Mamacita's Archive

K-027: Letters Records: Margaret A Karshner Murphy KY Geo Kersner, 1752 to 1980

K-027 Type: Correspondence and research materials (Karsner line, Kentucky) Dates: Correspondence 1980-1982; records from 1752 Size: 203 pages and images Family line: Kershner

Summary

K-027 Closing Summary

Source: LettersRecords_MargaretAKarshnerMurphyKYGeoKersner_1752-1980.pdf Pages: 203 of 203 transcribed

Verified date range

Correspondence 1980 to 1982; source documents back to 1742.

Thread classification

A name-collision case: the Kentucky Karsner family, allied to the Kershners but never proven to be the same line.

What this document reveals

The research file of Margaret Alice Karsner Murphy of Owenton, Kentucky, who spent years trying to prove that her ancestor George Kersner (d. 1795 or 1796, Rockingham Co., Virginia) was the same man as Joh. George Kirschner (b. 1722, Berks Co., Pennsylvania), son of the immigrant Johannes Kirschner. Mamacita insisted throughout that the link was unproven, and the two women argued and reconciled over how to handle unproven claims responsibly in print.

Most significant facts and leads

  1. Margaret's line runs through Revolutionary War veteran Casper Karsner, captured at Ruddle's Fort in 1780, died Fayette Co., Kentucky, 1797.
  2. The main obstacle: a 1768 Berks County Orphans' Court record says George Kerchner "late of Windsor Twp." had died, which would rule him out as the Virginia land buyer of 1773.
  3. The family story that Elizabeth Kersner's 1782 marriage made a Thomas Lincoln a "great uncle" of President Abraham Lincoln does not hold: the marriage records show a different Thomas Lincoln.
  4. Includes the Rockingham Co. chancery suit "Margaret & Casper Kersner vs. Thomas Lincoln" and Casper's 1797 will.

Notes

The family's own spelling is overwhelmingly "Karsner." The file also gathers material on at least three unrelated Karsner and Kesner families.

Closing summary written 2026-10-18 from the transcript and genealogical index.

People, places and dates

Show the genealogical index

K-027 Index — "LettersRecords_MargaretAKarshnerMurphyKYGeoKersner_1752-1980" (203 pages)

Thread: Karshner/Karsner name-collision case — CONFIRMED. This document is the single largest and richest "name-collision verification file" in the archive. It is the correspondence (1980-1982) and research file of Mrs. Margaret Alice Karsner Murphy of Owenton (Owen Co.), Kentucky, who spent years trying to prove that her ancestor "George Kershner/Kersner/Casner" (d. 1795/96, Rockingham Co., Virginia) was the same man as "Joh. George Kirschner" (b. 1722, Berks Co., Pennsylvania, son of the documented immigrant Johannes Kirschner, b. 1693) — i.e., that her own Karsner line of Kentucky descends from the same Pennsylvania-German immigrant family documented in Ruth Bownds Kershner and Mary Kershner Maxwell's The Kershner Families of Maryland, 1731-1977. The family's own surname, as used by Margaret and her Kentucky relatives throughout, is overwhelmingly "Karsner" (with historical variants Kersner, Casner, Carsner, Kentner, Kearsner, Kisner) — not "Karshner" as in the archive's own filename. As Ruth herself insisted throughout the correspondence, this Pennsylvania-to-Virginia connection was never conclusively proven during the period covered by this file; it remains a strong circumstantial case with real evidentiary gaps (chiefly the 1768 Berks Co. Orphans' Court record stating "George Kerchner, late of Windsor Twp.," had died — which, if accurate and referring to the same man, would rule out his being alive to buy Virginia land in 1773).

People

Name Notes
Margaret Alice Karsner Murphy Correspondent/genealogist, Owenton (Owen Co.), KY; author of unpublished family history "The Karsners of Kentucky" / "Days of Immigration"; church historian; retired KY state accountant (Dept. of Transportation, Toll Facilities); direct descendant of Casper Karsner (Pages 1-3, 154, 168, 192-193, and throughout)
Ruth Bownds Kershner Co-author (with Mary Kershner Maxwell) of The Kershner Families of Maryland, 1731-1977, Austin, TX; Margaret's primary genealogical correspondent and mentor throughout the file (Pages 17-19, 24, 30, 60-61, 88-89, 119, 136, 166-167, 194-195, and throughout)
Mary Kershner Maxwell Co-author of The Kershner Families of Maryland, Vol. I; visited Margaret in Kentucky Oct. 1980; author of the German-immigration research chapters (Pages 7-9, 91-93, 150-151)
Peggy S. (Shomo) Joyner, C.G. Certified genealogist, Portsmouth, VA; conducted primary-source research on the Rockingham Co. VA chancery/probate records at Ruth's request (Pages 27, 31, 48-49, 54, 69-70, 93, 124, 128, 132)
George Kershner/Kersner/Casner (d. 1795/96) Virginia settler on Brock's Creek, Augusta/Rockingham Co.; central subject of the whole file; possibly = Joh. George Kirschner (b.1722, Berks Co. PA) — never conclusively proven (Pages 17, 41, 45, 52-53, 77, 126-127, 142, 174-175, 178-179, 203)
Margaret Kersner (wife of George) George's widow; appointed son Casper's attorney (Wm. Dunlap) to settle George's Virginia estate, 1796 (Pages 17, 143, 178-179)
Casper Karsner (Carsner, Kersner, Kentner) b. ca.1750/1761 PA, d. 1797 Fayette Co. KY; Revolutionary War soldier (militia pay 1785, Auditor's Acct. XXVIII-A p.267); captured with the Lail family at Ruddle's Fort, 22 June 1780; witnessed an Aug. 1775 Augusta Co. deed alongside George Ruddle; m. Eve Lail 1786/1789; Margaret Murphy's direct ancestor (Pages 17, 116-118, 143, 168-172, 181-184, 190, 203)
Eve Lail Karsner (Carsner) Dunlap b. 1766 PA, d. 1842 (age ~76); Casper's wife; captured as a girl (~age 14) at Ruddle's Fort with her parents and brothers Johnny and George; remarried William Dunlap 1797 after Casper's death (Pages 17, 143, 168-169, 184, 190-191)
Elizabeth Casner/Korson/Kershner (Lincoln) b. ca.1752-1765 (dates inconsistent across the file), d. 1832/1833; daughter of George; married Thomas Lincoln, 23 Sept. 1782, Rockingham Co. VA — a marriage the family believed made Thomas Lincoln a "great uncle" of President Abraham Lincoln (Pages 17, 32, 140, 143, 147)
Thomas Lincoln (m. Elizabeth Casner, 1782) Executor of George Kersner's Virginia estate; explicitly NOT the same man as President Lincoln's father (also named Thomas Lincoln, who married Nancy Hanks in 1806) — both appear on the same page of "Old Tenth Legion Marriages" (Page 140)
Jacob Karsner (Kisner, Casner) Son of George; resident of Washington Co., Tennessee, by 1796; appointed John Lincoln and John Berry as attorneys-in-fact to pursue his inheritance claim, Oct. 1796; possibly the "Jacob Kisner" listed alongside Casper on the 1792 Lexington church-lottery record (Pages 17, 27-28, 87, 122, 139, 190)
John Lincoln Attorney-in-fact for Jacob Karsner (1796); named defendant in the Rockingham chancery suit; relationship to Thomas Lincoln (brother? unrelated?) never resolved (Pages 120, 139, 141, 152)
Modelena (Shaffer) Rust & Philip Rust Modelena believed to be another daughter of George Kersner (deceased by the time of the suit); husband Philip Rust, a widower, named defendant (Pages 45-46, 85, 120, 152)
John, Nicholas, George, Henry & David Shaffer/Shaver Named defendants in the Rockingham chancery suit; concluded to be grandsons of George & Margaret (sons of a deceased daughter), not sons (Pages 43, 120, 152)
Catherine (Karsner) Bowman Believed to be another daughter of George, married a Bowman, non-resident of Virginia by 1803 (Pages 45, 82, 120, 143, 152)
Johannes Kirschner (b.1693) Documented immigrant ancestor (arrived 1733) of the core Maryland Kershner line (Ruth/Mary's own family); NOT proven to be Margaret's ancestor (Pages 59, 91-95, 106-113, 136, 166)
Joh. Georg Kirschner (b.1722) Son of Johannes (b.1693); central "candidate" for Margaret's immigrant ancestor; per Berks Co. tradition died 1768 age 47 — the core unresolved discrepancy of the whole file (Pages 60-61, 98, 106, 108-109, 113, 136, 142, 166-167, 194-195)
Rev. Johann Casper Kirchner Lutheran minister, York Co. PA / Baltimore / Winchester VA (cornerstone 1764); alternate "candidate" theory for Margaret's ancestor via a different Kershner brother, Johan Casper (b.1700); never confirmed connected (Pages 97, 114-115, 124, 134-135, 144, 194-195)
Douglas D. Woodard Salt Lake City researcher; obtained/confirmed the Berks Co. Orphans' Court microfilm records for Ruth (Pages 16, 23, 32)
Evelyn Rosemary Frantz Certified American Lineage Specialist, Lafayette, IN; researched the "Bowman problem" tied to the Rockingham chancery suit (Pages 66-70, 128)
Warren D. Faust Reading, PA correspondent with Kershner-family research background; unable to resolve Margaret's PA ancestry but confirmed general Kershner/Faust intermarriages (Pages 133, 166-167)
James E. Lincoln Grandson of the 1782 Thomas Lincoln/Elizabeth Casner marriage; his 1879/1885 letters state Dr. Lyman Draper erred in calling his grandmother "a Winter" — she was "a Korson or Kersner" (Pages 17-18, 32, 143, 148)

Places

Place What Happened
Owenton / Owen County, Kentucky Margaret Murphy's home; site of her church, historical society talks, and the 1980 Karsner family reunion (Pages 2, 9, 94, 137, 168)
Brock's Creek, Augusta/Rockingham Co., Virginia George Kersner's land, purchased 1773; site of an Aug. 1775 deed witnessed by Casper Karsner alongside George Ruddle (Pages 17, 100, 154, 167, 174, 203)
Berks County, Pennsylvania (Bern & Windsor Townships) Home of the immigrant Kirschner family; site of the 1768 Orphans' Court guardianship record central to the whole unresolved question (Pages 16, 20-22, 60-61, 96, 106-113, 136, 142, 166)
Langenselbold, Hesse, Germany Ancestral home village of the Kirschner family in Germany; site of the Lutheran parish whose baptismal records underlie the "Date Guide Lines" chronology (Pages 94-95, 97, 105-109, 123-124, 134-135)
Fayette County, Kentucky (Lexington) Casper Karsner's home; site of his 1797 will, the 1798 courthouse fire that destroyed it, the 1792 Dutch Presbyterian Society church-lot lottery, and Margaret's estate power-of-attorney record (Pages 87, 101-102, 116-118, 168-169, 178-179, 190)
Ruddle's (Hinkston's) Fort, Bourbon/Harrison Co., Kentucky Site of the 22 June 1780 British/Indian raid that captured Casper Karsner and the Lail family; visited by Margaret on the 200th anniversary, 1980 (Pages 137, 181-191)
Rockingham County, Virginia (Harrisonburg) Site of George Kersner's death (1795/96) and the ensuing "Margaret & Casper Kersner vs. Thomas Lincoln" chancery lawsuit (1801-1803) over his estate (Pages 40-53, 63-65, 76-86, 120-121, 152-153, 180)
Washington County, Tennessee Home of Jacob Karsner by 1796 (Pages 27-28, 87, 122, 139)

Dates / Events

Date Event
1722 Joh. Georg Kirschner born, Berks Co. PA (candidate identity for Margaret's ancestor "George Kershner")
1742 Immigrant Johannes Kirschner (b.1693) dies, Lancaster/Berks Co. PA; his will names sons Conrad and George
ca.1750 Casper Karsner born, Pennsylvania
1768 Berks Co. Orphans' Court: children of "George Kerchner, late of Windsor Twp., deceased" petition for guardians — the central unresolved discrepancy of this file
1773 George Kershner buys land on Brock's Creek, Augusta Co. (later Rockingham Co.), Virginia
1775-08-17 Casper Karsner (as "Caspar Karsnar") witnesses an Augusta Co. deed alongside George Ruddle
1780-06-22 Ruddle's Fort destroyed by Capt. Henry Bird's British/Indian force; Casper Karsner and the Lail family (including 14-year-old Eve Lail) captured
1782-09-23 Elizabeth Kersner (George's daughter) marries Thomas Lincoln, Rockingham Co. VA
1785-12-10 Casper Karsner paid £314.15.4 for militia service (Virginia Auditor's Accounts)
1786/1789 Casper Karsner marries Eve Lail
1792-12-15 Casper Karsner and Jacob Kisner among founders of the Dutch Presbyterian Society, Lexington, KY
1795/96 George Kersner dies, Rockingham Co. Virginia; Thomas Lincoln named executor
1796-08 Margaret Kersner (widow) and son Casper appoint William Dunlap attorney-in-fact to convey George's Virginia estate ("Burnt Records," Fayette Co. Vol. 8 p.207)
1796-10-20 Jacob Casner (Tennessee) appoints John Lincoln and John Berry attorneys-in-fact to prosecute his inheritance claim
1797 Casper Karsner dies, Fayette Co. KY (will dated 14 Apr., proved 10 July)
1798 (Sept.) Fayette Co. courthouse fire destroys Casper's original will
1801-05 to 1803-08 "Margaret & Casper Kersner vs. Thomas Lincoln et al." chancery suit proceeds in Rockingham Co., VA
1804-04-07 Margaret (Casper's daughter) marries Warren Wheeler, Fayette Co.
1807/1813 Casper's estate finally settled/land divided in Fayette Co. Court
1813-05 John Karsner (Casper's son) wounded at Dudley's Defeat, War of 1812
1842 Eve Lail Karsner Dunlap dies
1976-10-10 Margaret's first church history book released
1980-07-11 Margaret's first letters to Ruth Bownds Kershner and the Kershner Family Association
1980-09-27 First Karsner (of Kentucky) family reunion, ~230-240 attendees
1980-10-14 Mary Kershner Maxwell visits Margaret in Kentucky
1981-02 to 1981-04 Tension/near-rupture in the Murphy-Kershner correspondence over publication rights and quotation accuracy (resolved)
1981-05-31 Margaret retires from Kentucky state government
1982-01/1982-11 Correspondence continues into Margaret's retirement; final dated letters in file

Open Questions

  1. Central question of the entire file, never resolved: Is "George Kershner/Kersner" who died in Rockingham Co., Virginia (1795/96) the same man as "Joh. George Kirschner," born 1722 in Berks Co., Pennsylvania — and thus part of the documented Maryland/Pennsylvania Kershner immigrant family? The 1768 Berks Co. death record for a "George Kerchner" is the chief obstacle; no direct link was ever found. (Pages 60-61, 136, 142, 166-167, 194-195)
  2. Was the 1768 Berks Co. "George Kerchner, late of Windsor Twp." record accurate, or could it describe a different George (or be a clerical/reporting error), leaving the door open for "our" George to have moved to Virginia instead of dying? (Page 167)
  3. Is "Rev. Johann Casper Kirchner" (Lutheran minister, d. Baltimore, will 1770) the same man as the German "Joh. Kaspar Kirschner" (b.1700, Langenselbold) — and could he be a "fourth brother" relevant to Margaret's line? Never confirmed (Pages 97, 114-115, 134-135, 144, 194-195)
  4. Were the "Shaffer/Shaver" defendants (John, Nicholas, George, Henry, David) in the 1801-1803 chancery suit really grandsons of George & Margaret Kersner via a deceased daughter, as inferred, or could "John Nicholas" instead be a single individual's full name? (Pages 120, 128, 152)
  5. Is the "John Casner" who purchased land on Briery Branch from Jacob Gillaspy (Augusta Co., 1775) the same "John [Kersner]" named as a defendant in the Rockingham chancery suit, or a coincidentally-named different man? (Page 203)
  6. Was Elizabeth (Casner/Kersner), who married Thomas Lincoln in 1782, actually a different, younger daughter than the "Elizabeth" baptized in Berks Co. in 1745 (who would have been too old, per Ruth's own math, to be a bride in 1782 without needing a guardian in 1768)? (Page 167)
  7. Is the unrelated Karsner family of Florence, Alabama ("Karsner-Kennedy House," Benjamin Franklin Karsner, b. Maryland 1800) connected in any way to Margaret's Kentucky line, or to the separate Maryland/Delaware "Karsner Line" (Daniel Karsner, immigrant 1774) documented later in the file? Neither connection was established. (Pages 155-165)
  8. Is the Indiana "Kesner" family (Solomon Kesner, b. ca.1638 Hanover, through to Ephraim Kesner) connected to Margaret's Kentucky Karsner line, the Maryland/Delaware Karsner line, or the core Berks Co./Rockingham Kershner line? No connection was established or apparently even investigated within this file — it appears to have been collected purely as a same-surname curiosity. (Pages 198-201)

Summary

K-027 is a 203-page file of correspondence (1980-1982, with source documents dating back to 1742) documenting Margaret Alice Karsner Murphy's years-long, ultimately unresolved effort to prove that her own Kentucky "Karsner" family — descended from Revolutionary War veteran Casper Karsner (captured at Ruddle's Fort in 1780, died Fayette Co. KY 1797) and his father George Kersner (died Rockingham Co., VA, 1795/96) — descends from the same documented Pennsylvania-German immigrant Kirschner/Kershner family whose Maryland branch was chronicled by Ruth Bownds Kershner and Mary Kershner Maxwell in The Kershner Families of Maryland. The file contains extensive primary-source photocopies (Berks Co. Orphans' Court guardianship records, the Rockingham Co. chancery suit "Margaret & Casper Kersner vs. Thomas Lincoln," Casper's 1797 will, Revolutionary War pay records, and an Augusta Co. deed witnessed by Casper alongside George Ruddle) alongside warm, often anguished personal correspondence between Margaret and Ruth as they worked, argued, and reconciled over how to handle unproven family claims responsibly in print — including the family's oft-repeated (and separately, more carefully qualified) claim that Elizabeth Kersner's 1782 marriage to a Thomas Lincoln made him a "great uncle" of President Abraham Lincoln, which primary-source marriage records in the file confirm involved a different Thomas Lincoln than the President's father. The file also incidentally collects material on at least three entirely unrelated "Karsner"/"Kesner" families (Florence, Alabama; the Maryland/Delaware "Karsner Line"; and an Indiana "Kesner" family), underscoring the archive's broader name-collision theme. The verified date range spanned by content within the document is 1742 (earliest primary-source record, the will of immigrant Johannes Kirschner) to 1982 (latest dated correspondence) — close to, but somewhat narrower on the early end and later on the late end than, the filename's stated "1752-1980" span.

Full transcript

Typed from the scans, handwriting included. Unclear words are marked [?]. The original scans are kept in the family archive.

K-027 Transcript — "LettersRecords_MargaretAKarshnerMurphyKYGeoKersner_1752-1980" (203 pages)

Source: Correspondence (1980–1982) and genealogical research materials between Ruth Bownds Kershner (co-author of The Kershner Families of Maryland) and Margaret A. Karsner Murphy of Owenton, Kentucky (Owen Co.), a "Ky. Cousin" descended from Casper Karsner of Rockingham Co., Virginia/Kentucky. Also includes correspondence with researchers Douglas D. Woodard (Salt Lake City), Peggy S. Joyner, C.G. (certified genealogist, Portsmouth VA), and research notes from the Tennessee State Archives (Draper Papers). Central question of the file: whether "George Kerschner" (b. 1722, Berks Co., PA, father of Conrad and Anna Maria per 1768/69 Orphans' Court guardian records) is the same man as "George Kersner/Carsner" (d. 1795/96, Rockingham Co., VA) — father of Revolutionary soldier Casper Karsner, ancestor of the Kentucky Karsner family and, via Casper's daughter Elizabeth Casner's marriage to Thomas Lincoln, a purported (unproven) great-uncle-by-marriage connection to President Abraham Lincoln's family. NOTE: the family's own surname as used throughout this file is overwhelmingly "Karsner" (or period variants Kersner/Casner/Carsner), not "Karshner" as in the source filename — see Page 22's "Variations of Our Name" essay, which catalogs the extensive spelling drift.

Page 1

Handwritten letter, dated "Sept 17, 1981," marginal note top-left in different ink "29 Sept note, ? price of book." "Dear Ruth:" from Margaret — opens reminiscing about Ruth and "Mary K. Maxwell," thanks Ruth for trying to help connect with "the Pennsylvania Kershner," believes "there is a connection... I'll never be able to make a connection. To begin with, I'm not smart enough, very little income for expenses, and I'm sick." Reports losing sight in her left eye for about 10 days starting Sept 3rd; diagnosed with diabetes by her doctor on Sept 7th; on a sugarless diet; also has a cataract forming on left eye (continues Page 2).

Page 2

Continuation: "...but that wasn't the problem. It seems too much sugar in my blood caused it all. I'm taking a blood thinner now too, so maybe I'll get better soon. I had so looked forward to doing hand work during my retirement years, but that's out for now." States she retired May 31st; "my family history was completed and released at our Karsner Reunion August 22nd. Everyone has seemed pleased with it. So many were old and sick and wanted me to draw it to a close so they could read it, while they could." Notes it's nothing to compare with Ruth's Vols I, II & III, "ours is a story that has been handed down from one generation to another. Our genealogies are printed back to George and Margaret, Parents of Casper." "I tried to abide by your..." (continues Page 3).

Page 3

Continuation: "...wished about the German information. If you ever find out that our Jah. George was the son of Johannes please let me know, if I'm not living write my son, James Karsner Murphy, address same as mine. He would appreciate it and pass it on to others who are interested. I would like to keep in touch with you, I'll always remember how you tried to help me. As soon as I can see a little better I want to go to the Archives here for Mary [sic — likely "more"]. There is someone you mentioned one time that you wanted me to look for in our Ky. records I think. If you still need me to look please tell me again. I'll close for now and hope to hear from you." Signed "With Love, Margaret K. Murph[y]."

Page 4

Envelope: return address "Margaret K. Murphy, Rt 3 Box 186, Monterey, Owenton, Ky. 40359"; postmarked Lexington, KY, 21 SEP 1981; addressed to "Mrs. Ruth B. Kershner, 1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin, Texas 78746."

Page 5

Christmas/greeting card, "1982" written in red at top. Printed/handwritten message: "Wishing you all a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year. With Love, the tie that Binds. Cousin Margaret Murphy" — followed by a continuing handwritten line "I know you must have had a wonderful vacation" (message continues onto Page 6's verso presumably, though Page 6 itself is a separate enclosure).

Page 6

Illustrated family crest/coat-of-arms enclosure: banner reading "Karsner," shield with two facing stag heads over a central helmet, flanked by a small lion (left) and a dragon/griffin (right) on the lower shield panels. Caption below: "Karsners of Kentucky — Located in 1778." Letterhead visible faintly upside-down at top of page (design printed on reverse showing through): "Preston-Hopkinson Co., Appomattox, Va. 24522."

Page 7

Handwritten letter, dated "Oct. 26, 1981." "Dear Ruth:" — apologizes for delay answering, "having a terrible time staying on this diet." Glad Ruth is still working on "my George and Margaret," believes "with your connections it will be worked out. I was careful to remind people in my book that the connection had not been made." Explains she turned her manuscript over to "our Karsner Association" for publishing; price is $35.00 plus $1.75 tax = $36.75 ("I bought 8 books at that price"). Notes "Mary Maxwell picked up one when she and Glenn visited me on Oct 14th." (continues Page 8)

Page 8

Continuation: Describes the surprise visit — Linda Anderson from the Kentucky Historical Society called saying a woman from "Cal[ifornia] Springs" wanted to speak with Margaret, whom she immediately guessed was Mary [Maxwell]. Invited them to lunch; Glenn napped while they "looked and talked"; after lunch Glenn walked along the Ky. River taking pictures of the view while the women talked until 2:30. Margaret "hated to see them leave" but they promised to stay overnight next visit. Mary "seemed to like my book. The binding is beautiful, if I do say so myself." Can hardly wait for Ruth's 3rd volume — "several of the Karsners of Kentucky have ordered one."

Page 9

Continuation: Margaret is setting up a genealogical file for her church and community — they paid 800 + forafireprooffilecabinet, andtwotypewriters(800 each, with ball and correcting element) were being delivered that Wednesday for her to try. "It will take me all winter, hard labor, to get this project off the ground." Prays her eyes will hold out; notes a film/cataract growing over her left eye. "Nov. 16th I speak on our history at our Owen County Historical Society." Mentions Mary said they were all going on vacation soon.

Page 10

Continuation: Closing remarks — plans to send a picture of "my plaque," which Mary thought was nice. "I must close for now, may the Good Lord bless and keep you as the years go by! With Love, the tie that binds, Your Ky. Cousin, Margaret A. Karsner Murphy." Postscript: "If you still want a book, I will pay the postage and have it insured, sorry I can't just give you one."

Page 11

Handwritten letter dated "Jan 6, 1982." "Dear Ruth:" — thanks Ruth for remembering her with a Christmas card; has been re-reading old letters; notes Ruth's Sept 28th letter was still giving hope of a connection being found. States: "I know Casper's father was George and his mother Margaret. 'The History of the Kershner Family' by Geo. C. and Dr. Ammon G. Kershner sure blocked me. If this book is ever reprinted, I want one. I just can't help but believe there is a connection here, but where or how?" Reports receiving her first newsletter from "W.E. Kershner Jr." with a nice letter attached — he wants to buy her History but Mary Maxwell already paid for a copy for him; Margaret will check if he already received it.

Page 12

Continuation: Eyes gradually worsening; can't get her blood sugar down with diet alone, still fighting going on more pills or shots, "may have to give in soon." Upcoming D.A.R. meeting Saturday Jan 9th where she'll help serve; speaker is Kentucky Lt. Governor Martha Layne Collins; nervous about working in the kitchen. Reiterates cataract on left eye but doctor's main concern is sugar level. Enjoyed Mary and Glenn's visit, "their time spent here was just too short." Notes "The Lails of America" by Margaret Lail Hopkins has been released; received her copy the day before Christmas.

Page 13

Continuation: Per a form letter from Mary, Ruth's Vol. III won't be released until about February. Would love to keep in touch though she knows Ruth is busy. Still setting up the genealogical file at her church, and separately "making 'My Family Quilt,'" with family names, births, marriages and deaths worked onto it — hopes to have it finished to show at their next reunion. "Write when you can, With Love the tie that binds, Margaret Karsner Murphy."

Page 14

Envelope: return address "Margaret Murphy, Rt 3 Box 186, Monterey, Owenton, Ky. 40359"; postmarked Lexington, KY, 17 JAN 1982; addressed to "Mrs. Ruth Bownds Kershner, 1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin, Texas 78746."

Page 15

Verso of a pink/rose-colored envelope bearing a childlike pencil sketch of stacked cubes/blocks (some with small drawn symbols inside), and two purple ink stamp impressions reading "88" and "SV 6V." No genealogical content — appears to be a repurposed scrap/doodle page, possibly a child's drawing on recycled correspondence stock.

Page 16

Photocopied 18th-century handwritten court record with typed caption: "Berks Co. Pennsylvania, Orphan's Court Records, Vol 2 p 3. LDS Library, Salt Lake City, Film #5098, Pt. 3. Index lists as follows: '1769 Kerschner, Conrad et al, Guardian appointed for Vol 2 p 2.'" Original record text (paraphrased from cursive): "The Petition of Conrad Kerschner of the age of fourteen years and two months, and Anna Maria Kerschner of the age of sixteen years or thereabouts, two of the children of George Kerschner, late of Windsor Township in the County aforesaid, Yeoman, deceased, who died intestate, praying to be admitted to choose guardians... The Court do appoint Conrad Kerschner the Elder, of Windsor Township aforesaid, Yeoman, Guardian of the said Petitioner Conrad Kerschner, and Martin Kerschner of Bern Township, guardian of the said Anna Maria, according to the desire..." Typed note beneath: "(Not dated, but entry before and after are dated 12 Feb. 1768). Record contributed by Douglas D. Woodard, March 1981."

Page 17

Genealogy chart, printed letterhead "STUART G. & RUTH B. KERSHNER, 1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin, Texas 78746, 512/327-2020," dated "1980" in corner. Detailed handwritten pedigree chart tracing: George Kershner — 1772 [or 1773], bought land on Brock's Creek, Augusta Co. VA (now Rockingham Co.); 1783 bought 6½ acres more (Rockingham Co. Survey Book A:168); died before August 1796. Margaret [his wife] — per "Fayette Co. Ky 'Burned Records' V.B:207,1796": Margaret, with son Casper, appointed Wm. Dunlap attorney to convey estate of Geo. Kershner, dec'd, to sue for property or money due, etc. (Ack. Fayette Co. Ky, Aug. 1796; Deed Book 6:423, May 1801). Note: "Margaret & Caspar. Kershner vs. Thomas Lincoln, exr. of Geo. Kershner, his wife * Elizabeth, [and others]." Notation: "*John Nicholas George's Henry & David Shaver, his wife, Cath. Bowman and John Lincoln, defendant. John Nicholas George, Henry & David Shaffer, Philip Rust & Modelena, Philip Rust & Modelena, his wife's deft's, did not appear & were cited for contempt." Marginal note: "Order Book ? 'Modlena Late Shaffer.'" Casper Karsner (Carsner, Kershner) — b. in PA; 1775 witnessed deed near Brock's Creek to Fayette[?] Co.; 1780 captured by Indians; "Rev. soldier"; will (A:343 Fay. Co.) made 14 Apr 1797, proved 10 July 1797. Married (1) [blank]; married (2) Eve Lail, m. 7 Aug 1789, b. PA 1766, d. 1842; captured by Indians 1780, "Will P:257, 1 June 1841[?], Proved Jan[?] 1842." Their son Jacob Karsner (Wash. Co. TN, 1777, 1783, 1786) m. Katharine Dunlap (dau. of Wm. Dunlap, Sheriff of Fayette Co. Ky., and Sabra [surname, possibly "Robinson"]). Casper's daughter Elizabeth Casner (Korson, Kershner), b. 1763, d. 1833 age 70, married 23 Sept 1782 Thomas Lincoln — noted "as widow, lived with son George, buried near Liberty, Mo." Their children: Thomas Lincoln b. 22 Oct 1761, d. 11 Dec 1820, "b. 1787, to Fayette Co. Ky., Ag't Uncle of Abe Lincoln, Exec'r for Geo. Kershner. 21 Jan[?] 1795." Grandchildren listed: Betty (b. VA ca.1783?), Margaret (b. VA ca.1785?), Abram (b. Rockingham Co. VA ca.1787?), Catherine (b. KY ca.1789, m. in VA). At bottom right: James E. Lincoln, "wrote letters in 1871 & 1895 — 'Dr. Lyman Draper' was wrong holding that Thomas Lincoln married a Winter — my grandfather married a Korson or Kaesner.'" Also shown: Hannah (b. KY), David (b. ca.1802, d.1833 age 70, as widow lived with son George near Liberty MO), John (b. KY 1800?), George Lincoln b. Ky. 15 Apr 1792. Lower section: John George Jonathan Karsner (b. 11 Feb. 1789, d. young), Sallie Patterson (m. 20 Dec. 1814), Jonathan Karsner (b. 19 Jan. 1828, d. 9 Apr. 1874) — bracketed note "[Margaret Alice Karsner Murphy's line]." Data attributed "from her, 1980."

Page 18

Continuation/companion chart, same letterhead. Traces the Lincoln family back further: Mordecai Lincoln Sr. (=2, m. Sarah Jones (0)), b. 1657 Hingham, near Boston, d. 1727, "an ironmonger"; other children stayed in Mass. His son (by 2nd wife Mary) Mordecai Lincoln Jr. (1686–1736), "ca. 1717 to E. Jersey, Montmouth Co.; 1720-6, taxable in Chester Co. Pa. and Amity Twp (now Berks Co. Pa); 1726 bought A.J. land; 1732 bought 1000 ac. in Phila. Co. (now Berks Co Twp); 1732-3 Justice of Peace; 1736 Will." His children include John Lincoln (1711–1773, m. Rebecca Moore, "300 ac. in Jersey, 1765 sold it, went west to Rocking[ham] Co. Va."), Capt. Abraham Lincoln (1737–1784, "1782, to Ky.; 1784, killed by Indians" — father of Thomas Lincoln of Rockingham/Ky. and grandfather of President Lincoln), and other siblings (Isaac b.1691, Abraham b.1689 "ca.1717 to East Jersey," etc.) Right side: Thomas Lincoln (of Exeter Twp, Sheriff 1758–9) m. (2) Bathsheba Herring (dau. of Joseph Herring, "an aunt of Nancy Hanks on the maternal side"); their son Thomas Lincoln (1782–1857) m. (1) Nancy Hanks (dau. of Joseph, a Nancy Hanks was "a top aide on his uncle Lincoln's line") — parents of Pres. Abraham Lincoln (1809–1864). Marginal note by "* Zella Armstrong wrote that Thomas Lincoln (1778–1851) stopped in Tenn. and worked for his uncle" (referencing the Lookout, undated, MSS Div., Acc. #1211, Tenn. St. Archives), "also to Ken[tucky]y, near the Boone Archives, Montgomery, Hist. of Berks Co. Pa. The Kinlocks in Va., Wayland." annotated "the Kinlochs in Va, wayland."

Page 19

Near-duplicate/second copy of the Page 17 chart (same George Kershner/Casper Karsner/Lincoln pedigree), with an added typed line at the bottom: "CHART Jan 1981 by Ruth B. Kershner from data furnished by Margaret A. K. Murphy" — confirming both Ruth's authorship of the charts and Margaret as the source of the Karsner-line genealogical data.

Page 20

Title page: "Berks County, Pennsylvania. Orphans' Court Record From 1752 to 1792." Handwritten at top right: "For: Ruth B. Kershner." Body: "From the Historical Society of Berks County, 940 Centre Avenue, Reading, Pennsylvania 19601. Mrs. Aimee Devine Sanders, Consultant, Archives and Research Department. To: Margaret Karsner Murphy, Rt 3 Monterey, Owenton, Ky. 40359. Copied by B.F. Owen. Deposited with the Historical Society of Berks County May 7, 1910."

Page 21

Photocopied 18th-century handwritten Orphans' Court record page (Berks Co. PA), continuing the same record series. Entries include: petition re: estate of Henry Scheffer/Lindt (partially illegible, [illegible] names John Steiner, John Fisher, James Seely, Adam Schrager, Henry Vanderslice, etc.); "Orphans' Court, Feb. 11, 1768, before Jonas Seely, Henry [illegible], Peter Shryock, George Douglas & Thomas Ritter, Esqrs." — petition of George Stahl, administrator of Henry Lindt, deceased; "Orphans' Court, Feb. 12, 1768" — petition of Peter Stumph, intermarried with Catharina (late widow of Jacob Blantz), re: Blantz orphans, court appoints guardians Jacob Mechlenberg and Mathias Rhoads Sr. "Petition of Conrad Kerchner, age 14 years, 2 months, and Anna Maria Kerchner, age 16 years, two of the children of George Kerchner, late of Windsor [township], yeoman, deceased. Prays for guardians. — Selects Conrad Kerschner, Sr. of Windsor. Approved." [Same guardianship petition as Page 16, from the original record book.] Following entry: "Petition of Johannes Mecklein and Margaret his wife (late Margaret Rosenbacker, widow), Administrators of Abraham Rosenbacker, late of Windsor Township, yeoman, deceased" — lists Rosenbacker's ten children by age (Nicholas 23, Abraham 21, Martin 18, Mathias 15, Henry 8, Catharina 24, Margaret 22, Anna Maria 19, Maria Catharina 17, Maria Barbara 12) and references a land tract "in the New Indian Purchase, over the Blue Mountain."

Page 22

Typed essay titled "VARIATIONS OF OUR NAME," apparently composed by Margaret Murphy for her family history book. Explains that the Karsner surname has been spelled many ways through the centuries: during immigration, "Kirschner, Crisner, Kirshner, Kistner, Kesner, Kastner, Korschner, Cassner, and Casner" (per "Pennsylvania German Pioneers" by Strassburger and Hinke, Vols. I, II, III); in the "American Genealogical Biographical Index," also "Carsner, Casner, and Kershner." States the oldest known ancestral great-grandfather in Germany, "Peter Kerschner," appears in an 1637 baptismal book; the 1660 marriage record of Johann and Anna Elsa Ermoldt spells it "Kirschner"; their son Johan Conradt's 1669 baptism spells it "Kisher." Cites "The Chronicles of the Scotch-Irish Settlement in Virginia" by Lyman Chalkley, Vol. III p.547 — "our George" served as a witness ("teste") 17 June 1776, spelled "Kersner." When "our Joh. George and Margaretta" bought land in Virginia 17 August 1773, the deed spelled it "Kershner." From "The Original Court Records of Augusta County Virginia" by Lyman Chalkley — "our Caspar Karsnar" is a witness alongside George Ruddle in a land transfer, August 1775. When Casper served in the Revolution at Logan's Fort in Kentucky in 1779, he was called "Caspar Casener"; Virginia records the following year (22 June 1780, when captured by the British and Indians) call him "Casper Casner." In 1795, organizing a Lutheran church in Lexington, his name was spelled "Casper Kernsner," but in his will and estate settlement it appears as both "Carsner" and "Kersner." Casper's land grant, signed by Patrick Henry, 20 May 1785, reads "Casper Kasner"; his daughter Margaret's wedding bond to Warren Wheeler (7 April 1804) gives her last name as "Kesner." Concludes: "So who knows why the spelling of the name differs in so many places. I have typed this information for those who might doubt our connection with all the different spellings. It seems to me the person writing the name spelled it however it sounded to him that day." Also notes: when Casper's son John was selling his heired land 17 Aug. 1819, his surname appears as "Kisner"; a Virginia State Library record of Casper's Revolutionary military pay (1785) spells it "Casner"; by 1791 (six years before his death) he was signing his own name "Karsner."

Page 23

Typed letter, letterhead "1977 Yalecrest Ave., Salt Lake City, Utah 84108," dated "24 March 1981." "Dear Ruth:" from Douglas [Woodard] — encloses the Orphan's Court document, noting it is undated but the index lists it "1769 Kerschner, Conrad et al, Guardian Appointed for Vol 2 P.2" (film call number 5098, Pt.3, Vol.2 p.3); confirms the entry immediately before is dated 12 Feb. 1768, consistent with Conrad being 14 and Anna Maria 16. Reports he examined likely estate-paper entries for George Kerschner without success, offers to look further in summer if still needed. Personal/family news: second daughter's upcoming wedding, a European trip with his daughter Holly including Scotland and Paris; closes "Happy the German research is going well."

Page 24

Typed letter, dated "20 April 1981." "Dear Margaret:" from Ruth — sympathizes with the time pressure of finishing her book; notes research is slow and their relationship hasn't been proven despite the crash effort, "maybe in another three or four years we will have some answers." Reports recently writing to a person in Hawaii about a possible lead that "Anna Maria Kerschner (b. 1751) married Johannes Staudt, at Molltown"; a fellow researcher in Reading, PA, could Xerox Vol. II for a cost; a Salt Lake City researcher offered help once school lets out. Suggests Margaret, after retiring, go to Pennsylvania herself for local research. Recounts a long-distance call from a Nashville friend who searched the State Library for Dr. Lyman Draper's passage about Thomas Lincoln's wife Elizabeth — he had written she was "a Winter," but this appears wrong; she was "a Korson or Karsner" (the friend read through an entire handwritten Winters-family letter series on microfilm without finding anything about Thomas Lincoln). Mentions Mary Maxwell fell off a step-ladder and cracked ribs but "is 73 and wants to get it done"; "Bill Kershner has gotten some corrections and additions"; researcher Steinbaur found "Joh[ann] Casper Kirschner's" death in Germany at age 65. Comments on amateur genealogists networking via early home computers (Apple II). Closes with family/travel news (sons, sailing, a "Walkfest," proofreading a University of Texas alumni cookbook).

Page 25

Handwritten letter, dated "April 22, 1981." "Dear Ruth:" from Margaret — glad to hear from Ruth again, appreciates her efforts to help connect the families; is preparing her book's "closing remarks" and unsure what to say, feeling strongly there is a connection but finding it hard to admit defeat after feeling so close; asks how Ruth would word the closing remarks. Her publication deadline (May 1st) has been extended 10 days to May 10th. She retires from Kentucky state government May 31st — "I can hardly wait, I'm so tired." Notes Ruth's own History project is progressing and she'll be anxious to read it. (Continues Page 26.)

Page 26

Continuation: "...you and Mary. You have been such a help to me. My Immigration Chapter is very short since I took out all you told me. However I have a few things out of Mary's Vol I that I included with permission. Of course I stated it was unproven that we had a connection. I have encouraged some of our younger generation to pick up where I've left off. Hope all is well with you and your family. With Love, Margaret Murphy."

Page 27

Typed letter, dated "4 April 1981." "Dear, dear Peggy:" — from Ruth to Peggy [S. Joyner] — thanks her for help with "the George Kershner of Rockingham bit"; reports Margaret Murphy has been "practically in a panic," pressed by deadlines and a printer on one side and Ruth "dragging at the reins" trying to keep her from "muddying the research trail by publishing guesses as facts." Encloses a report on Berks Co.–Rockingham Co. Lincoln connections, "nothing definitive so far." Discusses new leads: a lawsuit defendant "Jacob Kershner/Casner," in Washington Co., Tennessee as early as 1783, an heir of "George Casner dec'd"; 1803 court minutes name "Modelena Rust, late Shaver," likely mother of "the five Shaver boys"; possible connections to a Nicholas Schaeffer, whose land deeds (1778, Washington Co. MD, then Augusta Co. VA) place Maryland Kershners as frequent witnesses. Discusses newspaper ad research: "the Martin Kirschner whose servant had run away in 1754 is the Martin selected by Anna Maria, George's daughter, as her guardian in 1768." Describes a complex, "hard to explain" family connection between Martin Kirschner (b.1703) and Johannes Kirschner (b.1693) in Germany — half-brothers, with Johannes's wife Elftrude 10 years older (b.1783 [sic, likely earlier], apparently divorced from Johann Schussert); Johannes Kirschner and Gertrude Dietrich m. 11 Feb 1717; younger half-brother Martin Kirschner (b.1703), later of Bern Twp., married 26 Nov. 1732 Anna Elizabeth Schussert (b.1711), "dau. of Johannes & Gertrude" — i.e., Martin apparently married his half-brother's stepdaughter. Mentions sending Margaret a letter from Elsie Lebo Stauffer, a descendant of Martin Kershner (b.1703), offering German/Huguenot data. On George Kershner's naturalization: Saucon Twp., Northampton Co. PA, 1761 (Ruth corrects an earlier misstatement of 1765); notes Margaret Murphy followed up and found George in the 1790 census "up Saucon, George Kirsener." George Kirshner (of Richland Twp., Bucks) made his will 3 Jan. 1793, proved 18 Apr. 1794 — devised his plantation in Upper Saucon Twp. to daughter Juliana, wife of George Kern, and her eldest son George Jacob Kern; "dau. Christina wf of Jacob Kepler" is executor — Ruth notes "dunno who he was" (i.e., a different, unrelated George). Thanks Peggy for Host Church records: Anna Barbara Kuerschner m.1743 Peter Laukks (Stoever) is "a handy age" for a "missing Barbara b.1727," found only on a ship's list with "our Joh. George b.1695 of Md." Mentions "A Lech" marrying into the family in Germany, and Margaret Laux as sponsor for a child of Martin K. b.1703, 1743.

Page 28

Handwritten letter, "Owenton, Ky., July 31, 1980." "Dear Ruth:" from Margaret — has just received listings from a friend in Washington D.C., possibly Mormon (LDS) records, unclear and hard to read; asks whether "Johannes Kershner born in 1693" could have had a wife named "Sarah" (corrected in her own handwriting above the line to "Anna Maria"). Can hardly wait to read Ruth's book, struggles making family connections even with materials in hand; hopes Ruth will have time to make corrections on a chart she sent. Plans to write Mary Maxwell the next day. Still has never heard back about "the guardianship" Ruth asked her to write about; the Washington County (TN) Court House never answered either, regarding Jacob Kershner. Signed "With Love, the tie that binds" (unsigned name, but marked "from Margaret K. Murphy" in a hand note at top).

Page 29

Handwritten letter, dated "Nov. 27, 1981." "Dear Ruth:" from Margaret — will send a copy of "Peggy's letter," as Peggy mentioned Ruth might like the information. "I'll always believe there is a connection for our family, but I may never live to see it. My hopes have been up and down so many times over George. I hope all is well with you and your history. With Love, the tie that binds, Margaret Murphy."

Page 30

Typed letter, dated "22 March 1981." "Dear Margaret," from Ruth — reports studying the Kersner material again and finding nothing new to resolve outstanding problems. Her letter to the Berks Co. Recorder of Deeds (asking about land transactions for "George Kersner/Kerschner/Kersoner/Casner/Carsner" between 1760–1775) was returned with a penciled note, "Nothing grantee or grantor" — no land changed hands under that name; speculates if George died before 1764 someone else may have sold land for the estate, or that "a George" never sold land before coming to Virginia. States there seems to be no way to resolve the death of "a George" in Berks Co. absent an undiscovered record, complicated by Rockingham Co. records having been partially burned ("a bad county in which to have to research... Virginia Germans are so hard to trace"). Notes the Virginia Lincolns were Baptists (Linville Creek Baptist Church, per Wayland's Virginia Valley Records); the nearest German church was Rader's Church near Timberville, records beginning only 1791, no Kersner mentioned, though a Jacob Kentner had children baptized there as early as 1778. Provides two possibly-unrelated records: "A Geo. Kershner of Saucon Twp., Northampton Co., Pa. was naturalized 6 Apr. 1761" (per Giuseppi, Naturalizations of Foreign Protestants); and "George Kerchner, last from Rotterdam, servant to Thomas Moore of Philadelphia and by him assigned to serve John Price of Lower Chichester, 5 Dec. 1772" (per Tepper, Emigrants to Pennsylvania) — Ruth notes this "seems too late to consider."

Page 31

Continuation of a typed letter from Peggy S. Joyner (letterhead not shown on this page). Explains "George Karsner could not write" and so was at the mercy of English clerks who spelled his name phonetically. Clarifies that "late" on the court record (referencing "p.345 of court document") — as in "Thomas Lincoln and Elizabeth his wife, late Elizabeth Kersner" — means "formerly" or "née" (maiden name); notes the relationships shown on that record need other documentation to clarify, since "it sounds like Modlena (Magdalena) had 5 sons by a former husband," though this is only conjecture; also flags "John Lincoln is a curiosity, too — was he a son of Thomas, or why would he be listed as a defendant?" States she is "at a loss to find more," has exhausted her sources, and wishes she could get to Berks Co. records; dislikes negative searches. Adds a few more records for future reference from Edward W. Hocker's "Genealogical Data Relating to the German Settlers of Pennsylvania and Adjacent Territory" (from PA/Germantown newspaper ads, 1743–1800): p.42 — "Martin Kirschner, Bern Township, Berks County, advertises that his servant ran away... Anna Margretha Muellerin, born Bambergerin, 34 years old" (1 Aug. 1754); p.192 — "Michael Christman, at Martin Kirschner's Mill, on the Conococheague, six miles from Hagerstown, Md., inquires for his brother Georg Christman, a shoemaker, who left the vicinity of Kaiserslautern... about twenty years ago" (23 Apr. 1793); p.168 — "Daniel Koerschner, Head of Elk, Maryland, is going to Germany. He is a native of Landau" (27 Jan. 1784). Signed "Good luck, Peggy — Peggy S. Joyner."

Page 32

Typed letter/report, dated "Apr. 3, 1981" (handwritten note: "cc to Peggy Joyner, Margaret Murphy"), titled "About GEORGE KERSCHNER b. 1722, of Berks Co. Pa." From Ruth — reports "no word from Reading," apparently no one knows what became of the original Orphans' Court records of Berks Co. Doug Woodard obtained a photocopy from the Mormon (LDS) Library microfilm of these records, which confirms George's daughter Anna Maria chose "Martin Kerschner of Bern Township" as her guardian, "confirming the reading of George C. Kershner (d.1966)"; notes Owens' 1910 abstract and Glen Schwalm's typed copy of it may contain inaccuracies (the original's "very plain Kerschner" came out "Kerchner" in a copy, which usually indicates a different family). Reports that Helen Andrews searched the Tennessee State Archives' Draper Papers microfilms for a Kershner–Lincoln connection in Berks Co. PA, using material Larry Palmer sent from the Rockingham Co. Library (Wayland's "The Lincolns in Virginia," 1946): an 1885 letter from James E. Lincoln to Hon. John Pennybacker of Linville Creek states Dr. Lyman Draper was wrong that his (James E. Lincoln's) grandfather married a "Winter" — James says Thomas Lincoln, his grandfather, married "a Korson or Karsner." Cites Thomas Lincoln's marriage bond, "Eliz. Casner, dau. of George," 23 Sept. 1782, and George's written permission quoted in Strickler's "Old Tenth Legion Marriages, Rockingham Co. Va." p.77 as "wholly written by Kensoner [sic], the father" (Ruth suggests more likely "Kersoner") — concluding this disproves the earlier assumption that George Kersner/Carsner was illiterate (his signature must match the rest of the document's handwriting). Reports Helen has not yet found any reference to a "Thomas Lincoln" or even "Winter" as a Lincoln spouse, but sent Lincoln charts. Summarizes Lincoln genealogy per Montgomery's "History of Berks Co. PA": in 1732, Mordecai Lincoln Jr. (1686–1736) bought 1000 acres in Amity Twp., Philadelphia Co. (now Exeter Twp., Berks Co.); his eldest son John Lincoln (1711–1773) received/inherited 300 acres in Jersey, sold in 1765, moving to Rockingham Co. VA; John's son Capt. Abraham Lincoln (1739–1784[sic, elsewhere 1786]) went to KY in 1782 and was killed by Indians, father of Thomas Lincoln (1778–1851) and grandfather of President Lincoln (1809–1864). Since "the Thomas Lincoln who married Elizabeth Carsner in 1782 is said to have been a great uncle of Pres. Lincoln, he must have been a brother of Capt. Abraham (1739–1784) and son of John (1711–1773)." Notes Mordecai Lincoln Sr. (1686–1736) had at least seven children by two wives; three sons with land in Amity Township: another Mordecai; Thomas Lincoln, sheriff of Exeter Twp. 1758-9; and Abraham (b.1736), county commissioner 1773-5 and Assembly member 1772-1786, said to have married Anne Boone (dau. of James, niece of Squire Boone). Concludes it must have been Thomas Lincoln the sheriff who in 1762 stood surety for Frederick Weiser, son of Conrad Weiser (d.1760) — "he would have been an uncle of the Thomas Lincoln who m. Elizabeth Carsner."

Page 33

Continuation: Dave Hollenbach sent a map showing Berks Co. Townships after the county was formed from parts of Lancaster Co. (west of the Schuylkill River) and Philadelphia Co. (east of the river); copies sent to both correspondents. Notes none of the Berks Co. Kershners lived especially near Conrad Weiser or the Lincolns, but Weiser (as a colonial official) had probated the 1742 will of George's father, Johannes Kirschner — George was named in the will, his brother Conrad was executor, and uncle Martin signed the inventory. Weiser was a colonial government representative from about 1729/1732, and a county official at times; Thomas Lincoln, Berks Co. sheriff 1758-9, would certainly have known Conrad Weiser before his 1760 death, and could have consented to serve as surety when Weiser's son Frederick was administering the estate. Concludes: "This is a very tenuous connection. All we have is the name of one person who knew George Kershner (b.1722) and also knew the uncle of a George Kershner's son-in-law in Rockingham Co. Va. It does not prove that George Kershner of Berks Co. did NOT die in 1768. It does NOT prove that George Kersner/Carsner (d.1795) of Rockingham came from Berks Co. Pa. All it does is make it seem barely possible that these things could have happened. We have a long way to go yet. Please forgive the carbons. I'm not delaying this long enough to visit the copy shop next week. Affectionately, Ruth B. Kershner."

Page 34

Typed research notes, headed "TENN. ARCHIVES, 25 March 1981 — DRAPER PAPERS." Three entries: Film 5QQ19, 26 Feb. 1780 (not examined) — index describes a Rev. War letter to Col. Wm. Preston re: troop movements, Lord Cornwallis/Gen. Clinton, land warrant claims. Film 6XX73, 18 Aug. 1883 — Will H. Jones (Lafayette, Ohio) letter to Lyman C. Draper re: Capt. John Winter, the Crawford and Stevenson families, and Gen. Benjamin Harrison's Ohio descendant — annotated "I read this and there was nothing about Winter family — name only mentioned." Film 12CC300, Kentucky index — reference to material in Draper Mss. relative to Abraham Lincoln, Tullis, Hugh Drennon, Mrs. Stagg, Wm. Hughey, and Cresap — annotated "I read this and it was just a list of these names as contributors to letters, accounts, etc. in the 12CC film."

Page 35

Blank pre-printed business form, letterhead "The Equitable Life Assurance Society of the United States, Residential Mortgage Department," with fields for "Dated At," "For," "Subject," and "Date" — entirely unfilled. Appears to be reused/scrap stationery with no genealogical content, likely inserted incidentally into the file.

Page 36

Newspaper/magazine clipping, "THE LOOKOUT — THE LINCOLNS — An Early Tennessee Family," by Zella Armstrong (stamped "MANUSCRIPT DIVISION... 1771" — likely a Tennessee State Archives/Draper Papers accession stamp). Discusses Lincoln family history in Tennessee: Isaac Lincoln, uncle of Thomas Lincoln (who married Nancy Hanks), born in Virginia, married Mary Ward; a great-granddaughter of Christian Carriger recounts family lore about Thomas Lincoln (Abraham's father) working as a farmhand for his uncle Isaac before continuing on to Kentucky; describes two marked graves in Watauga Valley, Carter Co., TN: Isaac Lincoln (d. 10 June 1816, age ~64) and Mary Lincoln (d. 27 Aug 1834, age ~76).

Page 37

Genealogy chart tracing the Whitman family intermarried with the Lincoln line: Deacon John Whitman Ruth (1602–1692) down through many generations (Whitman, Carr, Gregory, Wood, Lunn, McDaniel families) to "James Ewell McDaniel, 1961–." Includes, as a cross-reference branch, the core Lincoln pedigree: Mordecai Lincoln Sr. (1657–1727) m. (1) Sarah Jones, m.(2); Mordecai Lincoln Jr. (1686–1736) m. Hannah B. Salter; John Lincoln (1711–1773) m. Rebecca Moore; Capt. Abraham Lincoln (1739–1784) m. Bathsheba Herring; Thomas Lincoln (1778–1851) m. Nancy Hanks (1783–1818); President Abraham Lincoln (1809–1865). This chart documents the Whitman-line intermarriages parallel to, but distinct from, the "Thomas Lincoln m. Elizabeth Kersner" line described elsewhere in this file — confirming there were at least two different "Thomas Lincoln"s in the extended family (the President's father, who married Nancy Hanks, vs. a different, elder Thomas Lincoln of Rockingham Co. VA, who married Elizabeth Kersner/Casner in 1782 and was reportedly a great-uncle by marriage).

Page 38

Handwritten letter, dated "Feb 3, 1981." "Dear Ruth:" from Margaret — thanks Ruth for her help; Peggy Joyner's letter "is on its way"; sent Peggy a $20 check, telling her she was "desperate to prove George died ca. 1796," and offered to borrow money if Peggy found proof, "I'm going to have to borrow money for the book anyway." Encloses a picture of herself made the day her first book was released, Oct. 10, 1976. Reports she has written for records that "Mrs. Karl Kammann" told her about — "she is from Elizabeth and Thomas Lincoln," has ordered a book, and may come to the reunion in Aug. '81.

Page 39

Continuation: "I must close and write Mary a note. You both have been wonderful to me. I'll send you copies of anything I get. Your Kentucky Cousin, With Love the tie that binds, Margaret M[urphy]."

Page 40

Photocopied original Rockingham Co., VA court order book page (stamped "Virginia State Library," 1801 entries) — routine April/May 1801 court business (debts, sureties, adjournments); mentions "Michael Brews Plff vs Adam Paulos Deft" and other unrelated suits; establishes the physical source/context for the Kersner chancery suit documents that follow.

Page 41

Photocopied Rockingham Co., VA Chancery Court record, page 413, dated May 1801: "Margaret Kersner, Widow, Devisee & Legatee of George Kersner, dec'd, and Casper Kersner, Devisee & Legatee of said George Kersner, deceased, Complts, against Thomas Lincoln, acting Executor of said George Kersner & Elizabeth his wife, late Elizabeth Kersner, John, Nicholas, George, Henry, David Shaffer, Philip Rust & Modelena, his wife (late Modelena Shaffer), Jacob Kersner, Catharine Bowman, and John Lincoln, Defendants." Order states that defendants Elizabeth Lincoln (late Elizabeth Kersner), Jacob Kersner, and Catherine Bowman, "not having entered their appearance according to law," and it appearing they "are not inhabitants of this Commonwealth," are ordered to appear on "the third Tuesday in August next" to answer the bill; a copy of the order to be published in a newspaper for two months and posted at the courthouse door. This is the founding document of the "Margaret & Casper Kersner vs. Thomas Lincoln" chancery suit referenced in Ruth's genealogy chart (Page 17).

Page 42

Continuation of Rockingham Co. court order book, page 422, dated May 1801 (stamped "Virginia State Library, MAR 1981" — a modern research-request stamp): routine unrelated debt/estate business (Elias Byrd/Jared Sleigh, Henry Slaugh vs. Henry Coop & James Given, "in debt"); records the court adjourning and reconvening "the county of Rockingham the 21st day of May 1801."

Page 43

Continuation, page 423, May 1801: unrelated chancery matters (Jonathan Shipman vs. George Bell et al.). Then: "Margaret Kersner & Casper Kersner, Complts, against Thomas Lincoln, Executor of George [Kersner] & Elizabeth his wife, John, Nicholas, George, Henry & David Shaver, Philip Rust & Modelena his wife, Jacob Kersner, Catharine Bowman and John Lincoln, Defendants." Records that process of contempt had been executed on defendants "John, Nicholas, George, Henry & David Shaffer, Philip Rust & Madelena his wife," who, not appearing, are ordered that unless they appear by the next August court and answer the complainants' bill, it "shall be taken for confessed."

Page 44

Continuation, page 336, dated August 1803 (stamped "Virginia State Library, MAR 1981"): routine unrelated witness-fee orders (William Bryan, John McLaughlin, Joseph Hott, Ephraim Hopkins); records court adjournment, then opens "Thursday... the 18th day of August 1803," present "John Ewen, Joseph Baxter, Smith Lofton & Giles Tinsley, Gentlemen Justices."

Page 45

Continuation, page 345, dated August 1803: "Margaret Kersner, widow, devisee & legatee of George Kersner dec'd, and Casper Kersner, devisee & legatee of said George Kersner dec'd, [complainants] against Thomas Lincoln, acting executor of said George Kersner and Elizabeth his wife, late Elizabeth Kersner, John, Nicholas, George, Henry & David Shaffer, Philip Rust & Madelena his wife (late Madelena Shaffer), Jacob Kersner, Catharine Bowman and John Lincoln, Defts." By consent of the parties' attorneys, the court refers the accounts between them to "Master Commissioner Cravens," directed to examine, state, and settle the accounts and report to the next court.

Page 46

Continuation, page 153, dated September 1802 (same suit style repeated: "Margaret Kersner Widow... & Casper Kersner devisee & legatee of said George Kersner dec'd, Compl[ainan]ts against Thomas Lincoln acting Executor of said George Kersner & Elizabeth his wife late Elizabeth Kersner, John, Nicholas, George, Henry & David Shaffer, Philip Rust & Madelena his wife late Madelena Shaffer, Jacob Kersner, Catherine Bowman & John Lincoln, Defts."). By consent, a commission is awarded each party to take depositions of witnesses. Below, unrelated routine county business (settling the estate of "Huffman," wolf-scalp bounty payments, a poor-orphan apprenticeship binding).

Page 47

Continuation, page 150, September 1802: unrelated criminal trial record (a prisoner tried for breaking into William Hughes's house and stealing about thirty silver dollars; acquitted, "not guilty," discharged by the court, with Philip Grymes as defense counsel). Records court proceedings for "Tuesday... the 21st day of September 1802."

Page 48

Typed letter, letterhead "D.M. Joyner, 5008 Dogwood Trl, Portsmouth VA 23703," postmarked Norfolk, dated "25 Feb. 1981." "Dear Margaret," from Peggy [Joyner] — encloses "the findings to date," which "only prove that George Kersner did die in Rockingham Co., which you knew anyway. The Kentner and Kershner are the same [man]. I sure wish his will had not been destroyed." Still awaiting word from the Recorder of Deeds in Berks Co., not too hopeful. Suggests Margaret might find something additional studying the Lincoln family; notes she "was most interested to see a Thomas Lincoln in Berks Co." Lists enclosures: letters to/from Berks Co. Orphans' Court, letters to/from Rockingham Co., Executor Bond of George Kentner, Probate of George Kersner.

Page 49

Typed letter, letterhead "Peggy Shomo Joyner, C.G., 5008 Dogwood Trail, Portsmouth, Virginia 23703," dated "10 February 1981," addressed to "Berks County Court House, Orphan's Court, 33 N 6th, Reading, PA 19601." Requests copies of any papers on "GEORGE KERSHNER/CARSNER/KARCHNER": (1) the 12 Feb. 1768 petition of Conrad and Anna Maria Kershner (children of George) for guardians — asks for the original or most authentic source, since B.F. Owen's handwritten copy "seems to have omitted data"; also requests any Orphans' Court papers on the estate of "the George who died ca. 1764–8." (2) Asks whether there is an unrecorded/untranslated will for George Kershner between ca. 1764–1768, or estate administration papers. States: "Historians believe George Kershner did not die about 1768 in Berks County, but is the same George who bought land in 1773 in Rockingham County, Virginia." Offers immediate payment for copies. Handwritten reply note at bottom (from the Berks Co. office): "We haven't anything but enclosed is a card & you can write to them. You could also write to the other county. Sorry."

Page 50

Continuation of the Berks Co. reply card: lists records available at the courthouse (marriages from 1885, births/deaths 1894–1905) and directs pre-1885/1894 inquiries to "The Historical Society of Berks County, 940 Centre Ave., Reading, PA 19601" or, for city records, Reading City Hall.

Page 51

Small handwritten label/note (verso of a document): "Probate 27 [of] July 1795, George Kersner, Rockingham County Court, Minute Bk. No. 3, p. 50" — a citation tag for the following probate record.

Page 52

Photocopied Rockingham Co. VA court minute book page (Minute Book No. 3, p. 50, court held 27 July 1795): routine probate business (deeds acknowledged, estate appraisals ordered) followed by: "The Last Will and Testament of George Kersner, dec'd, was prov'd in Court and prov'd by the oaths of the witnesses thereto... and on motion of Thomas Lincoln, one of the exec[utor]s therein named, a certificate is granted him for obtaining a probate... he having with security entered into and acknowledged bond and made oath thereto as the law directs, and leave is reserved for the other executor therein named to join in the probate thereof." Names John Lincoln, Joseph Lair, Jacob Custard [or Custer] and John Kring (or similar) appointed to appraise the estate. Also appoints a guardian (Jacob Parrott) for the Painter orphans (unrelated family) in the same court session.

Page 53

Photocopied original executor's bond, Rockingham Co. VA, 1795: "Know all men by these presents, that we Thomas Lincoln, John Reeves & Jacob Carter [or Custard] are held and firmly bound to Benj[ami]n Harrison, Wm. Herring, Ez[ekie]l Harrison & John Ewing, Gent. Justices of the Court of Rockingham County... in the sum of Two Thousand Dollars... sealed with our seals the [blank] day of July, in the year of our Lord one thousand seven hundred and ninety-five." Condition: if Thomas Lincoln, executor of the last will and testament of "George Kentner," deceased [note: name here reads "Kentner," elsewhere on related pages "Kersner" — see Page 54/55], makes a true inventory and accounting of the estate and pays all legacies as directed, the bond is void. Signed "Thomas Lincoln," witnessed by "John Reeves" and "Jacob Carter." A later archival label affixed to this same sheet reads: "Executor Bonds 1778–1815, George Kentner, Rockingham Co., Va." — documenting that the original county index itself alternates between "Kentner" and "Kersner" for the same man.

Page 54

Typed letter, letterhead "Peggy Shomo Joyner," dated "25 Feb. 1981," to "Mrs. T.R. Cooley, 763 S. Mason St., Harrisonburg, VA 22801" — thanks Mrs. Cooley for sending "the Kersner documents" and for her comment that she felt the two spelling variations (Kersner/Kentner) "are the same man," noting "they certainly seem to be with the involvement of Thomas Lincoln." Encloses $4 for the documents and her help.

Page 55

Handwritten letter, dated "February 24, 1981," from "Marriett T. Cooley (Mrs. Talmage R.)" to "Peggy Shomo Joyner" — encloses the probate and executor's bond for "George Kersner – George Kentner," court held 27th day of July 1795; states "my feeling is these two men were the same, difference in spelling due to record being transcribed." Requests a $3.00 research charge.

Page 56

Handwritten letter, dated "Mar. 6, 1981." "Dear Ruth:" from Margaret — encloses more copies, "the same as we already have"; notes her last mailed material (sent Feb. 3rd) was delayed, having been misrouted to Owensboro, KY, before reaching her May 5th [sic, likely "March 5th"]. Feels better after reading Ruth's reassuring reply about their relationship, "I would rather forget the whole history than to have hard feelings." Reports feeling worse daily: circulation worsening, sugar up, doctor says her eyes are progressively worsening, new glasses (two weeks old) haven't helped much. Hopes and prays to finish the book and make the Pennsylvania connection; asks that if a connection is ever made, Ruth notify her son, "James Karsner Murphy (age 34)" at the same address (continues Page 57).

Page 57

Continuation: confirms "same address"; reports retiring May 31st, already signed up for Social Security, deeded her farm to her son the prior week ("he is my only child. The farm was just too much for me to take care of"); is now typing genealogies, dislikes it, but enjoyed the "background part." Praises Ruth as "a jewel" for trying to help her connect, noting much of the material she receives she doesn't understand, and appreciates Ruth's "special gift of understanding." Encloses a family photo (Page 58) "of my son & his family." Signs "With Love, the tie that binds, Margaret Karsner Murphy," with a postscript asking: "Do you all have a Coat-of-Arms? If so I would like to see a Xerox copy of it & what it says."

Page 58

Family photograph (color): a man and woman seated on a floral sofa with three children (a toddler, and two older girls) around a small table with a Christmas-style greenery centerpiece — identified by Page 57's text as Margaret's son James Karsner Murphy and his family.

Page 59

Typed genealogical report, "From: Ruth Bownds Kershner, August 1980. To: Margaret Alice Karsner Murphy. Re: The Kershner Families of Maryland, 1731-1977." States the Kershner Family Association has received reports of two additional individuals who may fit into the group of known Colonial German immigrants. Presents German church-record data from Langenselbold, Hesse: Johann Konrad Kerschner (b. 1669, d. 26 Apr 1746 age 77) m.(1) 23 Feb 1693 Maria (Kneiss) Schad (widow of Hans Bernhard Schad), with two sons: Johann (b. 26 Nov 1693, d. probably Sept 1742, Bern Twp., then Lancaster, now Berks Co. PA) and Joh. Georg (b. 9 May 1695, d. by 20 Mar 1748, then Prince George['s], now Washington Co. MD) — both marked as "known to have come to America." Johann Konrad m.(2) 16 Feb 1699 Margarete Keyser (1672–1722), with two more sons: Joh. Kaspar (b. 18 Sept 1700, m. 1721 Anna Magdalena Doell, with 5 children including Joh. Martin b.1725 and Joh. Conrad b. mid-Oct 1734 — noted as "known to have come to America") and Joh. Martin (b. 4 Nov 1703, m. 1732 Anna Elisabeth Schüssert, b.1711, dau. of Johannes dec'd & Gertrout, with 6 children including Joh. Conrad, mid-Oct 1734). Side note raises the question of whether Joh. Kaspar (b.1700) could be the same person as "Rev. Joh. Kasper Kirchner," a Lutheran pastor who immigrated to Berks Co. PA in 1754, traveled in PA/VA/MD, served in York Co. PA 1758-68, laid a cornerstone in Winchester VA in 1764, retired to Baltimore due to age in 1768, and died there 1770 (left a will, widow Christina, no mention of children) — unresolved whether this is the same "German brother" who stayed behind.

Page 60

Typed letter, "To: Dave Hollenbach," from Ruth — states she and Mary Maxwell "are in the last throes of getting out Vol. III of 'The Kershner Families of Maryland'" and urgently need a researcher to go to the courthouse in Reading, PA, at reasonable pay, to correct any Pennsylvania records before publication. States the central problem: "It seems very likely that a George Kershner who died in Rockingham Co. Va. in 1795 was the same person as Joh. George Kirschner, b. 1722 in Germany, son of Johannes Kirschner of Bern Twp. (d. 1742) and brother of Conrad Kershner I (b.1717-d.1791) of Windsor Twp." Quotes George C. Kershner's book, "The History of the Kershner Family": "Very little is known about George... the second son of Johannes and Gertrud Kirschner... It is not known where they lived... there is no tombstone, and no other record is found," and the 1768 Orphans' Court petition of Anna Maria (age 16) and Conrad (age 14), children of George Kirschner, choosing guardians Conrad Kershner the First (for Conrad) and Martin Kershner of Bern Twp. (for Anna Maria). Notes that in trying to verify this Orphans' Court record, the Historical Society of Berks Co. sent a 1910 transcription which differs somewhat: "Feb. 12 1768... Petition of Conrad Kerchner age 14 years 2 months & Anna Maria Kerchner age 16 years, two of the children of George Kerchner, late of Windsor, Yeoman, deceased, prays for Guardian... selects Conrad Kerschner, Sr. of Windsor. Approved" — and that this transcription omits any mention of Martin Kershner of Bern guarding Anna Maria, raising the question of where George C. Kershner (d.1966) got his information. Records that the two children stayed in Berks Co.: Conrad married Elizabeth Bertolet about 1780, and Anna Maria married Johannes Staudt in 1771; baptismal records show four children born to George Kershner and wife: Elizabeth (1745, Bern), Casper (1750, Bern), Anna Maria (1751, Dunkel's), Conrad (1754, Bern) — but George C. Kershner listed a fifth, John George, which Ruth suspects may be "a garbled copy" or "a child of" a different George. Notes Peggy S. Joyner had just replied that the Orphans' Court "had nothing on the record."

Page 61

Continuation (typed, follow-on page from Page 60's line of research, addressed generally as research notes to a helper — likely still to Dave Hollenbach or a researcher): lists urgent research questions: "What we need is a researcher to do as soon as possible: If the original Orphans' Court records are not at the courthouse, where are they? If they are, please get a copy or exact transcription of the original. Is there any other evidence that George Kershner/Kerschner/Kerchner/Kirschner (b. Va. 1773-d.1795) actually died [in Berks Co. by 1768]? (The Virginia George wasn't fussy about the spelling of his name, and usually signed with an X. Kershner/Kersner/Kerstner/Casner/Kersener/Carsner, and some of his descendants are Karsners.) His will was lost in a burned courthouse in Berks Co." Notes George Kershner [of PA] inherited 400 acres of woodland near Scull Hill in Bern Twp. in 1742 and patented 150 more acres there — asks if anyone sold it (e.g., for the benefit of Conrad b.1754 Kershner of Windsor, or Anna Maria/Johannes Staudt, or Conrad/Martin Kershner of Bern) between 1765-1788, or gave a power of attorney. Encloses "a chart on George Kershner of Virginia," noting his daughter married Thomas Lincoln (whose family was also from Berks Co.) and that his executor was his son-in-law, also Thomas Lincoln, "also of a Berks Co. family." Cites Owens' copy of another Orphans' Court item: "13 Aug 1762, Thomas Lincoln a surety for Frederick Weiser, s/o Conrad Weiser dec'd (Weiser d.1760)" — "This seems to place the Lincolns in Bern Twp. too."

Page 62

Small handwritten note fragment (likely a continuation/insert from Margaret): "I am willing to do anything you want me to do. I'll write York Co. Pa. but I hardly know what to ask. I've written to them before, but they never did answer. Pa. just brushes me off when I ask for information."

Page 63

Photocopied 18th-century Berks Co. Orphans' Court record (same page/content as Page 21 — a duplicate or second-generation photocopy), showing the estate appraisal orders (George Baxter, Benj. Henton, etc. for Francis Green dec'd) and, again, "The Last Will and Testament of George Kersner, dec'd, was prov'd in Court... on motion of Thomas Lincoln, one of the exec[utors] therein named, a certificate is granted him... John Lincoln, Joseph Lair, Jacob Custard & John Kring... appointed to appraise..." — same content as the Rockingham Co. probate seen on Page 52, here appearing as a second/clearer photocopy.

Page 64

Small handwritten citation label (duplicate of Page 51): "Probate 27 July 1795, George Kersner, Rockingham Co., Va., Minute Book No. 3, p. 50."

Page 65

Photocopied original executor's bond (clearer duplicate of Page 53): "Know all men by these presents, that we Thomas Lincoln, John Reeves & Jacob Carter are held and firmly bound to Benj. Harrison, Wm. Herring, Ez. Harrison, John Ewing, Gent. Justices of the Court of Rockingham County..." — same 1795 bond text as Page 53, with archival citation label affixed below: "Executor Bonds 1778–1815, George Kentner, Rockingham Co., Va." — again documenting the "Kentner"/"Kersner" name conflation directly in the county's own archival indexing.

Page 66

Typed letter, letterhead "Evelyn Rosemary Frantz, 7225 New Castle Road, Lafayette, Indiana 47905, Certified American Lineage Specialist," dated "Dec. 4, 1980" (marked in pen "Copy for Ruth"). "Dear Margaret" — responds to Margaret's genealogy queries (Q 23-6,7,&8 in the Dec. 6, 1980 Tri-State Trader newsletter) about Kershner/etc. spelling; encloses a red-lined copy of a paper attempting to solve a "Bowman problem" in Rockingham Co. VA; unsure if a Catharine Bowman is the wife of "Jacob Sr."; believes Catharine may be Jacob Sr.'s second wife, but cannot yet prove it.

Page 67

Typed research notes (continuation of the Bowman research, likely enclosure to Page 66's letter), headed with a note about "Judgement and Order Books 1802 [-]1809" — summarizes the same Rockingham Co. chancery suit style ("George Kershner Sr., Margaret Kershner widow; children Casper Kershner, John Kershner, Nicholas Kershner; children of deceased daughter — George, Henry and David Shaffer of Shavers; Philip Rust widower of Madelena, a daughter; non-residence Jacob Kershner, Catharine Bowman; John Lincoln [probably a grandchild or may be another son-in-law]; George Kirchner deceased, his widow Elizabeth married to Thomas Lincoln"), plus tax-list notes (1784 tax list "George Casner," 2 white souls, 1 building; 1788 "Geo Cashner," 1 tithable, 4 horses; 1789 tax list "George Casner" (43), landowner of 235 acres; 1792 list "Geo Casner and 1 negro" under Jacob Lincoln's household) and a footnote: "Thomas Lincoln married Elizabeth Casner, daughter of George, in 1782" (per the Tenth Legion Tithables). Continues with extensive unrelated Bowman-family court entries from Rockingham Co. Deed/Order Books (1798–1804) researching a separate "Jacob Bowman Sr. & wife Catharine" problem — concluding note: "spellings seem to be the problem — inconsistency."

Page 68

Continuation of the Bowman research report ("page 2"), Rockingham Co. VA Deed Book, 1802-1809: lists further Bowman-family deed transactions (Bowman to Bear, Bowman to Rife, Bowman to Branaman, etc.), notes a courthouse fire caused non-consecutive/cross-indexed record numbering; poses the open question "Jacob Bowman Sr. and wife Catharine — who is she???"; a second wife "Fanny," orphan of Jacob, married George Bright in 1803; records "Widow Catharine Bowman married Christian Fry" on 22 May 1804; additional Bowman vital/estate data (Benjamin Bowman b. 1 Nov 1754, d. 29 Sept 1829). Concludes: "Conclusion to date — just too many Bowmans... and each generation using the same given names." Signed "Oct. 6, 1980, Evelyn Rosemary Frantz."

Page 69

Typed letter, dated "25 Feb. 1981." "Dear Ruth," from Peggy [Joyner] — self-deprecating opening ("the Kershners are running out my ears... I am not so darned sharp after all!"). Discusses whether Margaret would pursue the Lincoln-Berks Co. connection; notes limited time for research generally; reports Berks Co. replied again that they have nothing on the Orphans' Court record, and speculates a local researcher is needed. Describes her own ongoing Berks Co. research for her "Shomo" family line. States: "Today I got a note from a lady in Rockingham Co. with copy of two documents... We now know that there was a will for George Kershner which was destroyed by the fire, I guess. Big help. Kershner and Kentner were the same man. A John Lincoln was ordered to appraise. George did die in Rock'ham Co. But how to find proof that he is the one who didn't die in Berks?! I can't see the forest for the trees in this one."

Page 70

Continuation: discusses a separate query about "A. Barbara Kuerschner m. to Peter Laucks" (probably Berks Co.); mentions ongoing work on a survey of VA/WV German church records for "The Report," a presentation to the Va. Genealogical Society in Richmond, and merchandising "the Roosen book." Personal/family news (son's MBA graduation, a toothache/root canal, upcoming social events, being called "a workaholic" by her husband Doug). Closes: "I do enjoy your letters and hope we can get together the next time you come this way... Love, Peggy."

Page 71

Typed letter, dated "21 Feb 1981." "Dear Peggy:" from Ruth — thanks her for "marvelous" Berks Co. records; flags a possible clue: the Orphans' Court record showing Thomas Lincoln as surety for Frederick Weiser (son of Conrad Weiser dec'd), 13 Aug. 1762 — asks if this could be the same Thomas Lincoln (or a close relative) who married Elizabeth Kersner in Rockingham Co. Identifies Conrad Weiser (d. 13 July 1760): famous Indian agent, Lt. Col., justice of the peace, born 1696 in Wuertemberg, settled Tulpehocken 1729, lived near Womelsdorf, Bern Twp.; probated Johann Kirschner's 1742 will and translated the inventory — "he undoubtedly knew the Kershners well, and lived only a few miles away." Reports Margaret Murphy is checking Lincoln-family book details on the Lincolns' move from Berks Co. Reports new German records from Langenselbold, difficulty with modern German handwriting; mentions "Steve Kershner" and a "Baussermann"/Bauserman connection in Augusta Co. Describes a lead from an "Aunt Nettie" letter (1899) regarding descendants of a different Michael Kershner (b.1806, migrated to Kansas/Indiana) and William Kershner (b.1810) of Union, Monroe Co. W.Va. — notes Jacob Kershner (d.1840) left 12 heirs. Also discusses Martin Karcher of Windsor (d.1787), owner of town lots in Hamburg, whose name appears as "Karcher alias Carter" — suspects his daughter Phillipena (b. Karcher) was the wife of Anthony Kershner (d.1809, per Bern gravestones), i.e., Karcher was not itself a Kershner but married in.

Page 72

Typed letter, dated "21 Feb 1981" [continuation, same date as Page 71 but addressed differently]. "Dear Margaret:" from Ruth — explains that the "abstract" Margaret received from the Rockingham Co. Historical Society is actually a photocopy of the original executor's bond (Thomas Lincoln and sureties John Reeves and Jacob Custner/Castner), a standard performance bond set at twice the estate's expected value; deduces "George Kershner (possibly written as 'Kerstner') probably died between three and six weeks prior to July 27, 1795" based on quarterly court sessions, and that "George Kershner left a will" (the original may be lost, but a copy should have gone to the state). Regarding the 1803 court record's phrase "late Elizabeth Kersner" and "late Modelena Shaffer": explains these mean the women's maiden/previous married names before marrying Thomas Lincoln and Philip Rust respectively; if Ruth can connect Abraham Bowman (of KY) and the Catherine named in the suit, that would support Catherine being a daughter of George. Thanks Margaret for forwarding Peggy's "excellent" research report. Flags another lead: the Orphans' Court record of 13 Aug. 1762 showing Thomas Lincoln as a surety for Frederick Weiser — "This is an administrator's bond just like the one you got from Rockingham, only with Thomas Lincoln the suretor, as Jacob C[a]stner was in Rockingham." Notes Conrad Weiser (d.13 July 1760), the famous Indian agent, translated Johannes Kirschner's 1742 will/inventory and was based near Womelsdorf, Bern Township — asks if Margaret has dates for the Thomas Lincoln who married Elizabeth Kersner, since "a Thomas who was old enough to be a surety in 1762" seems too old to have married Elizabeth later.

Page 73

Continuation of a typed letter "to Margaret Murphy, p.2," dated "23 Feb" [1981] — discusses whether a "George K's will in Northampton Co. PA" mentioned by Margaret could be the same George (probably not, unless it names Casper and Margaret as legatees); addresses a naturalization record for a "John George (or George) Kershner" in Northampton Co. that Ruth once thought might match but now believes is a different man, based on the 1790 census. The bulk of this letter is an extended, friendly explanation of U.S. copyright law (in response to what reads as a prior remark from Margaret about possibly being sued or having material used without credit) — explaining what copyright protects, how it affects scholarly quoting/research use, and stating that Ruth and Mary Maxwell hold copyright on "The Kershner Families of Maryland" and want to "work TOGETHER" with Margaret rather than have any conflict.

Page 74

Continuation: reassures Margaret there's no legal threat intended, states "personally, I think there is a chance that we can clear up the origins of your George Kershner, but we haven't yet. Peggy echoed my sentiment... she says, 'It is difficult to believe the record is in error.'" Mentions new German records still being deciphered by "our German researcher"; encloses copies of French & Indian War lists from Maryland on which "George Kisner and Conrad KIsner" appear among otherwise all-English names, hoping (without luck) to spot a Lincoln name on the same list. Closes with personal health news (her husband's anemia/tendinitis) and sign-off "Affectionately."

Page 75

Typed research note, dated "Feb 1981," "For Margaret Murphy: Re: guardianships" — general background (not specific to the Kershner family) explaining Colonial English-law guardianship procedure using two 1725 Somerset Co., MD examples (John Walton and William Walton, orphans of John Walton dec'd, choosing/being assigned guardians) to illustrate that guardianship existed "to safeguard the inheritance of the orphan until he came of age 21, or in the case of a girl, until she was married... if under 21" — general legal-context education for Margaret, not a Kershner-specific record.

Page 76

Typed letter, letterhead "Rockingham County Historical Society, P.O. Box 1141, Harrisonburg, Virginia 22801," to "Mrs Margaret Murphy" — "Here is the abstract. I hope it helps. Please send $1.00 for the copy. Sincerely, Dale Dawson." Margaret's handwritten reply note beneath: "The trouble with me, I don't understand half I get — what does this abstract mean?"

Page 77

Clearer photocopy duplicate of the 1795 executor's bond (same text as Pages 53/65): "Know all men by these presents, that we Thomas Lincoln, John Reeves & Jacob Cust[n]er are held and firmly bound to Benj. Harrison, Wm. Herring, Ez. Harrison & John Ewing, Gent. Justices of the Court of Rockingham County... condition... executor of the last will and testament of George Kerstner deceased... Signed Thomas Lincoln, witnessed John Reeves, Jacob Cust[n]er."

Page 78

Handwritten letter, dated "Feb. 16, 1981." "Dear Ruth:" from Margaret — reports having received a letter from the Register of Wills of Northampton County, Easton, PA (mailed a check); also an abstract from Rockingham County Historical Society she doesn't understand, enclosing a Xerox; encloses a copy of "Mrs. Joyner's letter." States: "I am not in any condition to write about your threats of suing me, I guess that's what it amounts to. First — I am not copy writing our history. It's been a joy to write it, until the last six months, I'm just not up to all the hassle it has caused. I will not enclose in the bound book the 'Date Guide Lines' before 1733, like you ask me [not] to do. I have told you and Mary all along I would print only what you wanted me to or approved."

Page 79

Continuation: "I can't imagine what has happened to you so sudden, unless some of your lawyer relatives have become disturbed, and think I'm not trustworthy. I am sorry this has all turned out so ugly. I am just going to try not to think about it any more. I'm home sick with flu so I called Frankfort and told the typesetter to hold up until I could get up there and mark out any information you have given me or that has [already] been printed... I am sorry, so sorry, you feel toward me the way you have stated in your letter. When[ever] I get any answers to these letters I have out, I'll send copies to you. I have sent Mary copies of all my chapters and told her to use anything she wants to. Lots of Luck on your Vol. III. As Ever, With Love, the tie that binds, Margaret Murphy." [This letter documents a serious, if apparently temporary, rift between Margaret and Ruth over publication rights/copyright concerns — compare Ruth's copyright-reassurance letter, Pages 73–74, and her editorial letter, Page 81, both dated around the same period.]

Page 80

Photocopied duplicate of the August 1803 Rockingham Co. chancery order (same text as Page 45/85), with Ruth's handwritten red-ink annotations added directly to the photocopy: "Ruth — according to this George's children were: Casper, Elizabeth, Modelena, Jacob, and Catherine. Is this right? I hope George's will is coming" and a marginal query "does this mean Eliz. is dead? and Modelena?"

Page 81

Typed letter, dated "7 Feb 1981." "Dear Margaret:" from Ruth — reports that the photocopies of "the Johannes Kercher, 1753 immigrant" prove he is definitely NOT part of their family (his own signature reads "Kirschar," with no "n" in the last syllable — ruling out any connection to "Rev. Joh. Casper Kirchner" as well). Expresses continued unease about Margaret publishing the German research before it's adequately verified, noting the German researcher Steinbaur's work is only "about 62% right" per cross-checking against known records. States plainly: "I certainly wouldn't publish these German records until they are better nailed down... In effect, you are pushing us to fit your deadline, while we have extended ours because this research is not yet satisfactory." Raises the copyright/priority concern directly: "Have you considered that you will be jumping the gun on Mary Maxwell and the Kershner Family Association, if you publish our research before we publish it? If you copyright your book... that makes the research yours and we have no right to print it or correct it? Unless we should choose to sue you for pirating the original work... That is a very ugly situation that none of us even want to think about." Suggests Margaret hold back the first two pages of her "Date Guide Lines" and begin the American records at 1731 or 1733 instead of the more speculative German material, since "readers are going to be a lot more interested in your Indian raids and local history."

Page 82

Continuation (marked "Saturday"): discusses Virginia State Archives photocopies — notes an illegible 1801 Order Book page should be re-requested; confirms names "John Kershner, Nicholas Kershner" are legible elsewhere. Identifies the "Shaffer boys" as sons of a deceased daughter, "Modelena Rust's (or Bust's), 'late Modelena Shaffer'"; notes Abraham Bowman signed Eve Karsner's executor bond in KY, and Catharine Bowman is "not an inhabitant of Virginia" per the 1803 order (implying she'd moved to KY). Notes the court assigned the estate dispute to Commissioner Cravens, reporting due at October 1803 court. Asks whether Margaret has ever found George Kersner's will; jokes about the profusion of misspellings: "Jacob 'Custer'! You get first prize for the worst misspellings... I thought I had it with Ann 'Caesner'... but you win with Kentner and Custer in the same document." Signed "Affectionately."

Page 83

Handwritten note/message form, "TO: Mrs. Margaret K. Murphy... FROM: Mrs. Karl Kammann, 12x31 Van Buren, Crown Point, Indiana 46307," dated "1/28/81" — shares a find from "Abstracts of Executor, Administrator and Guardian Bonds of Rockingham Co. Virginia 1778-1864," compiled by Marguerite B. Proctor of the Harrisonburg Historical Society: an entry under "Executor Bonds 1778-1815" reading "1795, Jul. 27 — Kentner, George — Ex'ctr Thomas Lincoln — Pounds 2,000 — Bondsman John Reeves, Jacob Custer" — again documenting the county abstract's use of "Kentner" for the same George Kersner. Signed "Cornelita."

Page 84

Photocopied duplicate of the May 1801 Rockingham Co. chancery order (same content as Page 41): defendants "Elizabeth Lincoln, late Elizabeth Kersner, Jacob Kersner & Catharine Bowman," not having entered appearance and not being inhabitants of the Commonwealth, ordered to appear by the next August court.

Page 85

Photocopied duplicate of the September 1802 Rockingham Co. chancery order (same content as Page 46): "Margaret Kersner Widow... & Casper Kersner... vs. Thomas Lincoln acting Executor of said George Kersner & Elizabeth his wife late Elizabeth Kersner, John, Nicholas, George, Henry & David Shaffer, Philip Rust & Madelena his wife late Madelena Shaffer, Jacob Kersner, Catherine Bowman & John Lincoln, Defts." — commission awarded to take depositions.

Page 86

Virginia State Library "Photocopy Order A-9" form, filled out by "Mrs. Margaret Alice Murphy," dated "January 24, 1981," ordering (and paying $11.00 for) exactly the four Rockingham Co. Judgements & Orders entries this file reproduces: Book 6 (1798-1801) pp. 406/413 (May 19, 1801, "Margaret Kersner and others vs. Thomas Lincoln and others"); pp. 422/423 (May 21, 1801, "Kersner vs. Lincoln"); Book 7 (1802-1804) pp. 150/153 (Sept. 21, 1802, "Kersner vs. Lincoln"); pp. 336/345 (Aug. 18, 1803, "Kersner and Lincoln") — confirming this order as the direct source of the chancery-suit photocopies appearing throughout the file.

Page 87

Photocopied excerpt from "Early Families of Eastern and Southeastern Kentucky" by William C. Kozee (1961), "Robinson Family of Carter County" — an unrelated Robinson/Robeson/Robertson family genealogy, annotated in Margaret's hand "Jan 1981 from Margaret K. Murphy." Of tangential interest: describes "Ezekiel Robinson, b. Virginia 1775, m. in Jonesboro, Washington County, Tennessee, Sabra Castner, b. Tennessee 1777, daughter of Jacob Castner, a Revolutionary War soldier" — connecting to the "Jacob Kershner/Casner" of Washington Co., TN mentioned elsewhere in this file as a son of George Kersner.

Page 88

Typed letter, dated "24 Jan 1981." "Dear Margaret:" from Ruth — detailed line-by-line editorial feedback on a draft Margaret sent (apparently the "Date Guide Lines" manuscript). Corrects terminology (the Langenselbold church should be called an "Evangelical Parish," not "Reformed" or "Lutheran"); cautions against overstating unproven claims (e.g., "I don't think you should say all four sons came to America. We don't know yet about Johan Caspar b.1700"); flags a mis-attributed baptismal record ("Scratch Joh. Georg K., bapt. 1756, completely. Geo. C.K. or his typist completely misquoted a baptismal record and inserted a different family"); discusses Chapline's 1756 French & Indian War militia list showing a George and Conrad Kisner who are "definitely NOT members of the Maryland Kershner group;" encourages Margaret to include locations along with dates.

Page 89

Continuation: discusses coordinating all German-record requests through "William E. Kershner Jr., 1449 Fox Run, Charlotte, NC 28212" to avoid overworking the Langenselbold church staff, and to prevent inadvertently disclosing the church's exact address/name to outside requesters (to protect the research relationship); mentions it "just occurred" to her to wonder how George Kershner funded his 1773 Virginia land purchase (from Pennsylvania land sale? rent? crop savings?); reiterates the need for the original 1768 Orphans' Court record rather than the 1910 transcription, since Conrad's stated age ("14 years 2 months" on 12 Feb 1768) seems slightly off for a birthdate of 16 Sept 1754; concludes: "So far, I would agree that your apparently overlapping George Kershner records are very hopeful. We'll work on it."

Page 90

Duplicate photocopy of the September 1802 Rockingham Co. chancery record (same as Pages 46 and 85).

Page 91

Typed manuscript page from Margaret's own book, headed "DAYS OF IMMIGRATION" (numbered "#1," annotated "For Ruth, Keep"). A narrative opening chapter: recounts the Mayflower/Pilgrims/Thanksgiving story as the author's earliest childhood impression of history, and Columbus's 1492 voyage, as scene-setting before turning to the family's own immigration story. States: "Now it appears that over in Germany, about this time, there was a young boy Peter Kirschner and a little girl Anna growing up, who would one day marry and possibly become our oldest ancestral Great Grandparents. However, this has not been proven." Recounts the Mayflower Compact, landing at Plymouth, the harsh first winter, and Squanto's aid leading to the first Thanksgiving, November 1621.

Page 92

Manuscript continuation ("#2"): describes the Puritans arriving ca.1630; the period 1620-1750 of English/German immigration to the British Colonies; states "From my childhood, we were always told our Kersner lineage first planted their roots in Pennsylvania, upon arriving in America, possibly around 1733," under the invitation of William Penn; describes Penn's 1681 land grant from King Charles II and his 1671/1677 recruiting trips to the Rhine Provinces of Germany; introduces Francis Daniel Pastorius, the Pennsylvania Quaker commissioned to purchase and survey land for German settlers, who founded Germantown in fall 1685.

Page 93

Manuscript continuation ("#3"): describes Germantown's growth (12 families/41 individuals at first, 40 families within a year), German farmers/mechanics/weavers, and the founding of Germantown's chapel in 1686; states that "from this background we find Kershners, with many variations of the spelling of their name, located in many states." Explicitly credits: "All genealogical data found in the chapter 'Days of Immigration' has been gleaned by me through correspondence with Mrs. Mary Kershner Maxwell... and Mrs. Stuart (Ruth Bownds) Kershner... They are Co-Authoress of 'The Kershner Families of Maryland' 1731-1977. Mary is given credit for Vol. I and Ruth for Vol. II. They have been an inspiration to me, and given me much courage to keep on keeping on. I have not factually been able to connect with the information I've received or read, about the known Colonial Immigrants from Germany. However I am printing here the 'Date Guide Lines' that has been collected from Ruth and Mary from time to time. They might help future historians of our family."

Page 94

Manuscript continuation, "DATE GUIDE LINES" begins (numbered "#4"): a chronological table of the German Kirschner ancestry, explicitly framed as "given to help others in research of our family history, and assist them in connecting the immigrant Kirschners with the Karsners of Kentucky. Much more research is needed." Entries: ca.1500s Peter Kirschner born, possibly our ancestor, Germany; ca.1607 Anna born, wife of Peter; 1637 Johann Kirschner baptized at Flensingen Vineyard, son of Peter and Anna; 1641 Anna Elizabeth Ermolt baptized, later wife of Johann Kirschner; 1643 Conrad baptized (younger brother of Johann); 1660 Johann Kirschner and Anna Elizabeth Ermolt married, 26 Jan., Langenselbold; 1665 Peter Kirschner died, 10 March, Langenselbold; 1669 Johan Conradt baptized, 14 Nov., only known son of Johann and Anna Elizabeth Ermolt; ca.1669 Maria Kneiss born (first wife of Johann Conradt Kurschner; her first husband was Hans Bernhard Schad, who died by 1693); 1672 Margareta Keyser born (2nd wife of Johann Conradt Kurschner); 1683 Gertrude Dietrich born (later wife of Johannes; immigrated with their two sons in 1733; age 50 on ship's list); 1683 Anna Elizabeth Ermolt Kirschner died, age 41½; 1690 Maria Kniess married Hans Bernhard Schad (he died by 1693, leaving a baby boy Joh. Peter, b.18 Feb 1691); 1693 Johann Conradt Kurschner married Maria (Kniess) Schad, his first wife, 23 Feb. (she died 21 Nov. 1697, age 28y9mo).

Page 95

"DATE GUIDE LINES" continuation ("#5"): 1693 Anna died, 25 Aug., wife of Peter, age 86, mother of Johann (bp.1637) and Conrad (bp.1643); 1693 Johannes Kershner ("Jo-hon-us" as called in America) baptized 26 Nov., son of Johann Conradt and Maria Kniess Kurschner — "the immigrant father who come to America in 1733. Later the husband of Gertrude Dietrich"; 1695 Johann Görg Kirschner baptized 9 May at Langenselbold, second and last son of Johann Conradt by Maria Kniess — "the first to come to America of the brothers. He come in 1731... Later married Anna Fischer. He is an ancestor of Mary Kershner Maxwell and Stuart Kershner, Cousin Ruth's husband"; 1697 Maria (Kneiss) Kurschner died, first wife of Johann Conradt (never came to America, though both her sons did); 1699 Johann Conradt Kurschner remarried, two years after Maria Kniess died, to Anna Margareta Keyser — sons Johann Casper (b.18 Sept 1700) and Johan Martin (b.1703); 1700 Johan Casper baptized 18 Sept., Germany, third son of Johann Conradt, first by Anna Margareta Keyser; 1703 Johan Martin baptized 4 Nov., last and youngest son of Johann Conradt by Anna Margareta Keyser; 1713 Johann Kirschner died 23 Apr., age 76, Langenselbold, only known son of Peter and Anna, husband of Anna Elizabeth Ermolt, father of Johan Conradt; ca.1716 Johannes Kirschner and Gertrude Dietrich married in Germany, later came to America 1733 with two sons; 1717 Johann Conrad born in Germany, 5 Sept., oldest son of Johannes and Gertrude, "a teenage boy" when he emigrated.

Page 96

Manuscript page (marginal apology: "Sorry, I am a miserable typist. I'm hazy on the Shelbys, but Evan Sr. was an immigrant from Wales who owned huge tracts on both sides of the Penna-Md line near the Maryland Kershners...") continuing under heading "Page #6": 1734 "Just for the record... Daniel Boone" [born, Berks Co. PA]; 1742 Johannes Kerschner (b.1693) died by Sept. 10, Bern Township, then Lancaster Co. PA — his youngest half-brother Martin Kirschner (b.1703) arrived in America 21 Sept. and signed Johannes's inventory; c.1744 (Johann) George Kerschner (b.1722) married (Maria) Margaretha — "In our family history, I refer to our immigrant great grandfather as George and grandmother as Margaret. These are striking similarities, but not yet proven they are the same couple"; 1745 Johan George Kerschner and Margaret's first child, Elizabeth, baptized at Bern Church — "at this time, we know nothing more about her"; c.1748 "our Jacob Karsner/Kisner was possibly born at this time. He was in Washington County, Tennessee, in 1796, when his father George's estate was being settled" (owner of 100 acres per the 1787 tax list); 1748 (Joh.) Georg Kirschner (b.1695) died near Hagerstown, then Prince George's Co. Maryland; 1749 Caspar baptized 16 Sept. at Bern Church, Berks Co., son of George Koerschner and wife, witnesses Martin and Elizabeth Kerschner [a different Casper from a different George]; c.1750 "Casper Carsner was born in Pennsylvania, son of George and Margaret Kersner, our ancestors"; 1751 Anna Maria, daughter of George Kirschner and wife, baptized in Nov. at Dunkel's Church, Berks Co. — she married Johannes Staudt, 1771; 1754 Conrad, son of George Kirschner and wife, baptized 16 Sept. — he married Elizabeth Bertolet, 1780, Berks Co.; 1757-1758 George and Conrad Kisner appear on French and Indian War rolls with Capt. Joseph Chapline — explicitly "They don't belong to the Maryland family group serving with Capt. Jonathan Hager, Sgts. John and Jacob Casner, and Pvt. George Case005ner, son-in-law and sons of George Kirschner (b.1695)"; 1760 George Kirschner and Maria Margareta are sponsors, 30 June, at the baptism of (Joh.) Georg, son of Conrad Kirshner of Windsor Twp., Berks Co. — "This is the only place the name of the wife of George Kirschner (b.1722) is given"; 1768 in Berks Co. Orphan's Court, 12 Feb., Conrad Kerchner (age 14y2mo) and Anna Maria Kerchner (age 16), described as "two of the children of George Kerchner, late of Windsor Township... deceased," petition for guardians; Conrad Kerschner Sr. of Windsor approved.

Page 97

Typed letter, dated "6 October 1980," addressed "William E. Kershner, 1449 Fox Run..." headed "Add to data on Rev Joh Casper Kirchner by Ruth B Kershner" — details contributed by Rev. Lester J. Karschner (descendant of Johannes Kerschner b.1693), a Lutheran minister of Hanover, York Co. PA who researched church records; a history of Old Zion Church in Baltimore prepared by Dr. Klaus Wust from church archives; and Baltimore Co. probate records. Reports that recently found records confirm the purchase of Rev. Joh. Casper Kirchner's "country estate" in 1767 and its sale after his death in 1772 — "Jasper Kirchner" and "Leonard Sower" of York Co. PA bought 114 acres for £100; "Sower" (whose German signature looks like "Leonhard Sauer") and "Christian" Kirchner (the widow, who signed with a mark) sold it in 1772. Cautions: "this may be a lot more than you need to include. Leave it out, but if you do, also leave out the next to last paragraph on p.22. In fact, leave out that paragraph anyhow! It gives a false impression." Notes a number of Kerschner families in the Philadelphia area remain unresearched by any of the authors. Adds a note asking Margaret/Bill to verify a possibly-matching ship's list entry: "Kerschner, Johann (signed his own name on oath list)... Ships List 1753... Foreigners imported in the Ship St. Michael, Thomas Ellis, Com. from Hamburg 8th Sept 1753" — flags confusion between different editions/volume-numbering of the Strassburger & Hinke reference work.

Page 98

"DATE GUIDE LINES" continuation ("#6" — a second page bearing this number, continuing the German-to-American chronology in more detail than Page 96's version): 1722 Johann George born, 15 May, in Germany — "He might be our lineage, but not proven" — arrived in America as a boy, ship's list states age 12; had a twin sister Anna, who died 25 Dec. 1722 age ca. 7 months; 1722 Anna Margarete Keyser died, 30 Nov., age 50, 2nd wife of Johann Conradt — she died the same year Johann George was born; 1728 Johann Conradt Kürschner died in Germany, having outlived both wives; his sons then began coming to America: Johann Görg in 1731, Johannes in 1733, Johann Casper by 1764, and Johann Martin in 1742; 1733 "JOHANN GEORGE (who might be our ancestor) COME TO AMERICA IN AUGUST 1733 WITH HIS PARENTS JOHANNES AND GERTRUDE DIETRICH KERSHNER AND BROTHER CONRAD"; 1734 "Just for the record... Daniel Boone was born in Berks County Pennsylvania"; 1742 Johannes Kirschner died in August in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, "just before his youngest half brother Martin arrived in America"; c.1744 "JOHANN (GEORGE) MARRIED MARIA (MARGARETA)" — again flagged as an unproven "striking similarity" to the family's own George-and-Margaret tradition; 1745 Johann George and Maria Margareta's first child, Elizabeth, born, "from Baptismal records. Nothing more has been found about her"; c.1748 "Jacob was possibly born at this time. He was in Washington County Tennessee in 1796, when his father George's estate was being settled" [marginal note in a different hand: "I believe he was near Casper's age & maybe stuck in Ky when Church" (partly illegible)]; 1748 Johann Görg Kirschner died in Prince George['s] Co. MD; c.1750 "Casper Carsner was born in Pennsylvania, son of George and Margaret"; 1751 Anna Maria born, daughter of Johann George and Maria Margareta; 1754 Conrad born, son of Johann George and Maria Margareta; 1756 John George born, son of Johann George and Maria Margareta.

Page 99

"DATE GUIDE LINES" continuation ("#7"): ca.1765 Elizabeth born, daughter of George and Margaret, "who married Thomas Lincoln. (It was a common practice in those days to use the same name twice in a family, especially if one had died) Which would be true in this case, should Elizabeth born in 1745 prove to be a sister to the one born in 1765"; 1766 Evalias Lail born in Pennsylvania — her first husband was Casper Casner, her second husband William Dunlap (marriage date 7 Aug. 1797); 1786 Evalias Lail's marriage to Casper was ca. this year, "because their first child was born in 1787, a girl Margaret"; 1787 Margaret Casner born, daughter of Casper and Eva; 1789 John Casner born, first son of Casper and Eva — "He come to Owen County, KY. in 1846[sic, birthdate] Feb. 11, 1789" [Lexington, KY marginal note]; 1791 George born, second son of Casper and Eva, "died young" [Kentucky marginal note]; 1794 Jonathan born, third son of Casper and Eva, born 13 Mar. [Lexington, Kentucky marginal note]. Concludes: "CASPER AND EVALIAS LAIL CASNER HAD FOUR CHILDREN: one daughter and three sons."

Page 100

"DATE GUIDE LINES" continuation ("#8"), shifting to general Kentucky-frontier historical dates interleaved with family dates: 1767 Daniel Boone led an expedition finding a practical route through the mountains (the Cumberland Gap); 1773 "George Kershner left Pennsylvania, and settled in Virginia. Bought land on Brocks Creek, neighbors to 'Virginia John Lincoln.' George lived here 23 years until his death 1796"; 1775 the Wilderness Trail was blazed by Daniel Boone with Michael Stoner, March 10-25; 1775 April 18, midnight ride of Paul Revere; 1775 Revolutionary War started April 19 (Casper ca. age 25, Eve ca. age 11[sic, elsewhere given as later-born]); 1778 permanent foundation of Louisville laid, October; 1779 Lexington, KY permanently settled, fort begun by Col. Robert Patterson and about 30 others from Harrodsburg, April 14-17; 1779 people began leaving stations to settle their own land, marking the real beginning of agriculture; 1779 Casper Carsner was in the Militia at Logan's Fort, KY (circa age 29); 1780 Fayette, Jefferson and Lincoln counties formed; 1780 Casper Carsner and the Lail family were captured at Ruddle's Fort by the Indians and British, June 22 (Casper age ~30); 1781 Revolutionary War ended Oct. 19, Cornwallis surrenders at Yorktown (Casper about age 30); 1790 "George and Margaret Kershner were listed in the first United States Census"; 1782 Daniel Boone enters 500 acres for Capt. Abraham Lincoln in Kentucky, Tom Lincoln's brother; 1782 "Elizabeth Kershner, (Casper's sister) married Tom Lincoln in Virginia. He was great uncle to Pres. Lincoln"; 1783 a grant (Warrant #486) was given to Casper Carsner, March 31st; 1784 400 acres surveyed May 21st for Casper (#2004); 1784 800 acres surveyed on Green River, KY, for Capt. Abram. Lincoln; 1785 Casper's land survey/grant was given Patrick Henry's seal, May 20th; 1785 Casper was paid 314 pounds, 15 shillings, and 4 pence for prior militia services from Virginia during the Revolutionary War.

Page 101

"DATE GUIDE LINES" continuation ("#9"): 1785 Casper bought a lot in Lexington, May 11th; circa 1786 Casper Carsner and Eve Lail probably married this year (Casper age 36, Eve age 20); 1786 Bourbon County created by Virginia out of Fayette County; 1787 Casper bought a tract of land bordering Ruddle's Station [marginal date "8/15/1793"]; 1787 Margaret, daughter, first child of Casper and Eve; 1788 Dec. 16, a deed was ordered recorded to George Lail from Joseph Mosby — "this 200 acres was where he lived in Bourbon County, Ky."; 1788 separation of Kentucky from Virginia passed by Virginia, Dec. 29th; 1789 the First Constitutional Convention of Kentucky was at Danville, April 2nd to April 19th [sic, likely 1792]; 1789 John, first son and second child of Casper and Eve, born Feb. 11th — "our lineage"; 1789 census shows George and Margaret Kershner owned 235 acres in the Shenandoah Valley, Virginia, then Augusta County, now Rockingham County; 1790 Tom and Elizabeth Kershner Lincoln left Virginia and came to Kentucky; 1790 Aug. 13, a land deed of 351 acres bordering Hinkston Settlement was claimed by George Lail, "father of Casper's wife, Eve Lail. They were originally from Pennsylvania, as were the Kershners. This land was in Bourbon County Kentucky, and was in dispute at the time of George Lail's death"; circa 1791 George, second son and third child of Casper and Eve, died young, "named after grandfathers George Lail and George Kershner"; 1792 Colonel Isaac Shelby was elected first Governor of Ky. in May; 1792 Kentucky officially admitted into the Federal Union, a fifteenth star added to the flag; 1792 Casper Carsner, with others, Dec. 15th, representative of the Dutch Presbyterian Society in and near Lexington, raised $500 to purchase a lot and erect a house of worship; 1792 Casper Carsner sold a lot in Lexington.

Page 102

"DATE GUIDE LINES" continuation ("#10"): 1793 William Dunlap was sheriff of Rockingham County — "Casper and mother made Dunlap their attorney, in regard to the settlement of George's estate in Virginia (from burnt records, Vol. 8 page 207)"; 1793 George Lail's will was written July 2, 1793; 1793 George Lail died sometime between July and August 1793; 1793 November Bourbon Court ordered appraisement of his estate; 1794 Jonathan #1, last child and third son of Casper and Eve, born [March 13, 1794] on the Versailles Pike, near Lexington Ky.; 1795 the organization of a German Lutheran Church was effected in Lexington Kentucky through efforts of several men, "Casper Kernsner's name was included and his brother Jacob Kisner['s]"; 1796 Casper bought some land in Green County Kentucky, as did Capt. Abraham Lincoln, Tom's brother; 1796 "George Kershner died in Virginia, Casper, Elizabeth and Jacob['s] father. around age 68. Casper's mother, Margaret came to Kentucky and lived with he and his wife Eve"; 1796 Jacob Kershner was living in Washington County, Tennessee; 1797 Casper Carsner's will was written April 14th, Fayette Co.; Casper Carsner's will was read in Court July 10th, 1797; Casper died between Apr. 14th and July 10th — "His daughter Margaret was age 10, John was age 8 and Jonathan was age 3"; 1797 Aug. 7th Eve married Wm. Dunlap in Bourbon County Ky.; 1798 September — sometime between 7/10/1797 and 9/25/1798 Casper's original will was destroyed by fire; Eve with her security proceeded to settle his estate; heirs were wife Eve and children, "Little George, named after his two grandfathers, had already died, leaving only Margaret, John, and Jonathan #1"; 1799 President Geo. Washington died Dec. 14, "2 years after Casper"; 1804 April 7, Margaret Carsner married Warren Wheeler in Fayette county — "Casper had been dead 7 years now and his wife Eve had remarried (William Dunlap). William Dunlap signed Margaret's bond as Step-father and guardian"; 1807 March Court of Fayette County was still trying to settle Casper's estate; 1813 March, Wills of Fayette County show division of Casper's land — "16 years after his death. Eve, his wife was referred to as Mrs. Dunlap in Court"; 1813 John Carsner was wounded at Dudley's Defeat, May 5th, during the War of 1812 — "My great great Grandfather"; 1814 John married Sallie Patterson, December 20th, daughter of Samuel Patterson — "She died after 2nd child was born, a little girl, who also died young. [First child, a boy,] was Jonathan #2 of my lineage, who married Nancy Eaton. They settled in [Owen] Co. Ky. About 2 miles from where I live today. My great grandfather."

Page 103

Manuscript narrative page (untitled section, German background): "In Germany our forefathers were tenants or servants under feudal lords to whom they had vowed homage. The Palatine was a feudal lord having sovereign power within his domains..." Credits "Kershner information in Germany was taken from Palatinate Society Records by Dr. Fritz Braun and Max Steinbaur, and Church Baptismal Records were taken from the Lutheran Parish of Langenselbold, by the church warden and Administrator, M. Strasser." Quotes an article by "Rev. W.J. Kershner of Bern County, Pennsylvania": "Such men you cannot enslave; you can put them in bondage, but their minds will ever remain unfettered." Describes Heidelberg Township, Berks County PA, named for a hometown in Germany; the War of the Palatinate (1688-1697) devastating Germany including the historic town of Heidelberg (taken from "History of St. John's (Hain's) Reformed Church," written by Rev. W.J. Kershner and Adam G. Lerch). Also covers general German historical background: the Kirschners "and others that lived during the period from 1546 to 1733 in Germany were a discontented people," due to the Thirty Years' War (1618-1648, ending with the Treaty of Westphalia); states Peter Kirschner (b. late 1500s) and wife Anna (b. ca.1607) lived during the Thirty Years' War, with sons Johann (bp.1637) and Conrad (bp. 25 Dec. 1643).

Page 104

Manuscript narrative continuation: "Our religious background reveals that the Kirschners of Germany were of the Lutheran faith, and continued to be so down through the line of descent to Casper Carsner of Kentucky and Jacob Kisner (thought to be Casper's brother). These men, along with others, proceeded to establish a Lutheran church in Lexington (Kentucky, Collins' 'History of Kentucky' states) on December 15, 1792." Extended background on the Protestant Reformation: John Wycliffe (14th c.), John Huss, and Martin Luther (1483-1546) — his 1517 Ninety-Five Theses, break with the Roman Catholic Church, rejection of clerical celibacy and most sacraments, 1520 burning of the papal letter, 1525 marriage to Katharine von Bora, and his German Bible translation and hymns (notably "A Mighty Fortress Is Our God").

Page 105

Manuscript narrative continuation: Luther died Feb. 18, 1546, at Eisleben, his birthplace; notes Peter Kirschner and wife Anna "must have lived during part of the Thirty Years' War." Includes a photograph captioned "A Lutheran Church at Langenselbold, Germany," noting the building had its 250th anniversary in 1958 (built 1708) — both Johannes (b.1693) and Johan Görg Kirschner (b.1695) "must have worshiped here and placed their faith in Christ"; describes the church's baptismal records for Johann Konrad Kerschner's four sons, and its history (founded by St. Laurentius in the 1st century; a monastery on the site from 1108 until torn down in the early 1700s by Graf Wolfgang Ernst, its stones reused for the current church); notes the interior was renovated and old pews removed in 1960; the old cemetery is now a city building site; the Rathaus (town hall) was built in the same era. Describes two World War I memorial plaques flanking the church door, listing (among others) two Kershners: "Jacob, killed 12 March 1915, and Karl killed 28 September 1914" [the transcript text shows "1814," evidently a typo for 1914].

Page 106

Manuscript continuation: notes records at Langenselbold before 1500 are deteriorated and discouraged from research, written in German requiring translation; "There is still 9 Kerschners in the phone book, and 2 Kirchners" [in modern Langenselbold]. Credits information from John W. Vollbrecht (given to his mother, another "Ruth Kershner" of Dayton, Ohio) who visited the town and locked church in Germany with his wife Kathy, was let in by the pastor, and took photographs — relayed to Margaret via Mary Kershner Maxwell. Cites George C. Kershner's "History of the Kershner Family" on the meaning of the name "John"/"Johannes." Begins retelling "the immigration story as simply as I can": Peter and Anna Kirschner's son Johann baptized 1637 (Flensinger Vineyard area), married Anna Elizabeth Ermolt (dau. of Hans Ermolt, bp.1641, d.1683 age 41½); another son Conrad baptized 25 Dec. 1643 (sponsor: Conrad Moll); their son Johan Conradt Kirschner (bp.14 Nov. 1669, "father of the four sons that immigrated to America") married twice: first Maria (Kniess) Schad (widow of Hans Bernhard Schad, who died leaving baby Joh. Peter b.1691) — married 23 Feb. 1693, she died 21 Nov. 1697 age 28, having borne Johannes (bp.26 Nov. 1693) and Johann Görg (bp.9 May 1695); second, 16 Feb. 1699, Anna Margarete Keyser (b. ca.1672, d.1722 age 50), bearing Johan Casper (bp.18 Sept. 1700) and Johann Martin (bp.4 Nov. 1703).

Page 107

Manuscript continuation: continues the lineage of "the four brothers" — Johannes Kirschner (bp.26 Nov. 1693) was not yet 4 years old (using his baptismal date) when his mother died 21 Nov. 1697; his baby brother Johann Görg (bp.9 May 1695) was only about 2 years 6 months old; assumes both were reared by a stepmother after their father remarried about a year and three months later; states all four sons stayed in Germany as long as their father, mother, and stepmother lived. Includes a quoted verse ("O Memory, thou choicest blessing..."). States Johannes (the oldest son) immigrated to America in 1733, while his brother Johann Görg came first, in 1731 — "Two years later Johannes followed." Notes: "Keep in mind this line of descent has not been proven to the Karsners of Kentucky, but hopefully someday soon it will be." Discusses the three types of colonial immigrant record lists (ship captains' lists, Oath of Allegiance lists, Oath of Abjuration signers) and their general incompleteness. Concludes: "It was the 27th August, 1733 when the Johannes Kirschner family arrived in America from their home in the Palatinate of Germany."

Page 108

Manuscript continuation ("#16"): documentary citations for the 1733 immigration — "Pennsylvania German Pioneers, by Strassburger" Vol. I, p.113, List A (Ship Elizabeth, Capt. Edward Lee, qualified 27 Aug. 1733): "Johannes Kernoser, age 40 (first on the lists)"; p.756 Appendix I List 30A, "Johannes Kesnoser, farmer, age 40"; p.766 women's/children's names: "Kertroudt Kesnoser age 50" and children "Conreet Kesnoser 14 and Johan Yerck Kesnoser 12." "Pennsylvania German Pioneers" Vol. II (Strassburger): "Johannes Kirschner, first on the list" — "the list with the names of the immigrants written in their own handwriting (or mark)... good writing." "Pennsylvania Archives, Series II, Vol. XVII" (Oath of Allegiance, Ship Elizabeth, 27 Aug. 1733): p.82-83 "Johnannes Kerschner age 40." Rupp's "30,000 Immigrants": p.87 "Johannes Kirschner (first on the list, as was the Maryland Johan Görg Kirschner, 1731)"; p.88 under sixteen: "Conrad Kirschner (first on the lists), Joh. Georg Kirschner." Notes the family were Palatines, making the women eligible for "Daughters of American Colonists" membership and Johannes's Oath-of-Allegiance signature relevant to "The National Society of the American Colonists" eligibility (if the connection to Casper Casner b. ca.1750 could be proven); credits this data as copied from Mary Kershner Maxwell's book Vol. I, "The Kershner Families of Maryland," p.351; offers Mary Louise Kershner Maxwell's own National Society membership number (25883) as a reference for future applicants "after we connect with the Kershners of Maryland."

Page 109

Manuscript continuation ("#17"): biographical narrative — Johannes as a boy lived with his parents in Selbold (now Langenselbold), about 15 mi. east of Frankfurt, Germany, District Wetterau, Hessen, members of the German Reformed Church there; married Gertrude Dietrich, "about 10 years older than Johannes" (estimated birth ca.1683, age 50 on the 1733 ship list); they married around 1715 or 1716, since their first child Conrad was born 5 Sept. 1717 (d.1791); Johannes and Gertrude had another son, Jon. George, b.15 May 1722 (listed as "Johan Yerck Kirschner" on the ship's list), twin to a little girl Anna who lived only 7 months (d.26 Dec. 1722); if Johannes and Gertrude had other children, they must have stayed in Germany; Johannes died 1742, "only lived about nine years after coming to America," survived by wife Gertrude and sons Conrad (age 25) and Joh. George (age 20). Introduces "the following is a copy of his will and inventory of his estate, given to me by Ruth Bownds Kershner": "Philadelphia Co., Pennsylvania, abstract of Wills, 791. Film 49640 Pt.4, P.293 Kirsher (Kerssoner) Johannes, Lancaster Co., Farmer. Children Connratt Executor and George brother of Conratt. Wit: John Reesar, Johannes Meyer, and Frederick Bickle. Proved at Tulpehocken 16 Feb. 1742. Recorded p.324."

Page 110

Full transcription (per Ruth Bownds Kershner's "The Kershner Families of Maryland," Vol. II, p.212) of "the will of John (Johannes) Kerssoner": citation details — "Philadelphia City and County, Office of the Register of Wills, 180 City Hall, Ground Floor, Western Entrance. Indexed No. 293, Will of John Kiershner, 1742 (Original): Recorded in Book F, p.324. On outside of folded Original Will, 'John Kirshner.'" Notes the original will appears to be in the handwriting of the first witness, John Reesar, the only person to sign in English script; "much faded and split at the folds," with the transcript showing in parentheses portions supplementing/differing from the original. Will text begins: "IN THE NAME OF GOD AMEN the Nineteenth of Aprill in the year of our Lord 1742 I, John Kerssoner of Barn [Bern] in the County of Lancaster & province of Pennsylvania farmer being very Sik and weak in body but of perfect mind and memory..." (continues Page 111).

Page 111

Continuation of the 1742 will: bequeaths his soul to God, wishes Christian burial; leaves his "well beloved Son Connrat Kerssoner" as sole executor, inheriting the 200-acre plantation (valued 150 pounds in the recorded copy); to son George, a 400-acre tract of woodland near "Gools [Golds] Hill," with the brothers' shares conditioned on an agreement (if George reaches age 21, Conrad is to pay him 30 pounds "to stay till" that age, or 20 pounds plus 34 bushels of wheat if paid a year early); Conrad is to support their mother in his house, giving her 40 pounds and 20 shillings yearly, plus flax, cows, wool, and Indian corn; if Conrad wants to leave "his place," he owes their mother 10 pounds yearly; the brothers are to divide household goods equally; Conrad to receive 15 pounds from debts owed by "the volks" [folks] who owe him for building a house on his land. Revokes all former wills. Signed with Johannes's mark ("his mark"), witnessed by John Reesar, Johannes Meyer, and Friderick Bickle (signature noted as "damaged by cracked fold").

Page 112

Continuation: records the will's proving at Tulpehocken, 10 Sept. 1742, before Conrad Weiser, with witnesses Johannes Meyer and Friderick Bickle swearing they saw Johannes Kirshner sign, seal, and declare the will while of sound mind; the executor (Conrad) is also sworn the same day before Weiser, acting "by authority from Peter Evans" (Register General); includes docket labels: "293, John Keirshner's Will," "Prob. 10 Sept. 1742, Inv. ret. to Sec. next and Per. paid," "Recorded"; and, from the end of the recorded will in Book F, p.325: formal certification that probate and letters testamentary were granted to "Conratt Kirshner sole executor," required to bring "a true and perfect inventory" to the Register General's office in Philadelphia by 10 Oct. 1742. Docket label for the accompanying inventory: "Invendarium of the Estate of John Kirshner, deceased. Exhibited 17 Nov. 1742." Note: "Within, all handwriting, including witnesses' signatures, is Weiser's" [i.e., Conrad Weiser wrote out this fair copy].

Page 113

The estate inventory: "Invendary of the goods, Rights & Credits of John Kirshner late of Lancaster County deced. made the 20th day of October Anno. 1742," itemizing: the plantation appraised at 150 pounds; five working horses (75 pounds 10 shillings); two mares and two colts; four cows; four heifers; eight young cattle; ten sheep; household goods; a wagon; a plantation wagon; wagon gear and tackling — total (excluding land value/specific legacies, per standard practice) 136 pounds 7 shillings; "Signed by Martin Kirshner and Caspar Melk [or Meth], truly translated from the German Original by Conrad Weiser." Lists a summary timeline: will made 19 Apr. 1742, proved 10 Sept. 1742 at Tulpehocken; Martin Kirshner arrived 21 Sept. 1742 on the ship Francis & Elizabeth; Conrad ordered to bring inventory to Philadelphia by 10 Oct. 1742; inventory made 30 Oct. 1742, signed by Martin Kirshner and Caspar Melk; inventory exhibited 17 Nov. 1742. Margaret's own analytical note follows: "It has been thought our connection would come through Joh. George b.15 May 1722, who had a son Casper baptized Sept. 1750, about the same time our Casper Casner was born. But there is a family history 'The History of the Kershner Family' which was compiled by George C. Kershner of Berne, Penn. now deceased and in collaboration with Ammon G. Kershner, M.D. Norristown, Penn. which says that Joh. George died in 1768" (citing the 1768 Berks Co. Orphans' Court petition of children Anna Maria and Conrad, guardians Conrad Kirschner of Windsor and Martin Kershner of Bern). "Of course our George didn't die until 1796. Much research needs to be done in Pennsylvania. Our George left Pennsylvania five years later, buying land in Virginia, on Brock Creek in Aug. 1773. I feel there might still be a connection here, but I don't have the time now to wait for the discrepancies to be untangled and finish our history this year, for you. Our connecting problem is in the state of Pennsylvania... Armchair research is not good, and very expensive. Someone needs to go there, to fill in the gaps."

Page 114

Manuscript section headed "JOHANN GÖRG KIRSCHNER": describes Johan Conradt and Maria Kniess's second son, Johann Görg (bp.9 May 1695), arriving in America with wife Anna Fischer and three children (Elizabeth, Martin, and Barbara — George also possibly a babe in arms) on the ship Samuel, 17 Aug. 1731, at the Port of Philadelphia — "Johann Görg & Anna Fischer are the immigrant ancestors of the Kershners of Maryland. This is the lineage of Stuart Kershner (Ruth's husband) and Mary Kershner Maxwell. This line has been completely traced." Second section headed "JOHANN CASPER KIRSCHNER": Johan Conradt's third son by 2nd wife Margarete Keyser, baptized 18 Sept. 1700; married 19 Dec. 1721 Anna Magdalena Doell; five children listed so far (Anna Elizabeth bp.1723, Anna Sabina bp.1724 d.1725, Joh. Martin bp.1725 m. Elizabeth Ruht 1751, Joh. Konrad bp.1728, Anna Margarete bp.1729); raises the unresolved question of whether this Johann Casper is the same man as "Rev. Johann Casper Kirchner," an American Lutheran minister who wrote (in Latin, 1763) to Muhlenberg complaining he had not been accepted as ordained clergy in America despite nine years there (which would place him in America by 1754) — but he is absent from the Strassburger & Hencke ship lists and Berks Co. tax/land records. Cites Ruth B. Kershner's research: this Rev. Casper served Schuster's Church in York Co. PA (1758), traveled to Baltimore to serve Zion Church, retired to Baltimore ca.1768 due to age/health, was called back to serve until his death; his will (written 1 Aug. 1770, proved 22 Aug. 1770) names wife Christiana as executrix, mentions no children, and inventories little beyond clothing; concludes "No where do the records of the German and American Joh. Caspers overlap, thus far."

Page 115

Photocopied excerpt, "Chapter XXXVI p.189-196," from "Shenandoah Valley Pioneers and Their Descendants," compiled by T.K. Cartmell, clerk of the Old County Court, Frederick County, Virginia (copied at the Filson Club, Louisville, KY): describes the early spread of Lutheranism west of the Blue Ridge, German Lutheran road-petition settlements, and the German Lutheran Church established in Shenandoah County ca.1776. Quotes the 1764 cornerstone inscription from the old Lutheran Church in Winchester, VA: "This Temple has been Consecrated to the Triune God and to the Evangelical Lutheran Religion alone... Drawn up in Winchester April 16th MDCCLXIIII (1764). John [Johann] Casper Kirchner, At that time Minister of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. Scribe Ludwig Adams, Anthony Ludi, School-Master in City." Notes efforts to determine Rev. Kirchner's exact relationship to the congregation (regular pastor vs. visiting minister) have found nothing beyond his cornerstone signature; cites "Dr. Gilbert," who states in a pamphlet on the "Fathers of the Church" that Rev. Kirchner was pastor of the first Lutheran Church in Baltimore in 1762 and died in 1773 [conflicting with the 1770 death date given in the Page 114 will record] — "the first Lutheran Minister to appear in the Shenandoah Valley."

Page 116

Photocopied (faded) original will, "Fayette Co. Will Bk. A, p.393": "I Casper Kersner of the county of Fayette & State of Kentucky contemplating the certainty of death do now being of sound mind and memory make and [publish] this my last will & testament revoking all former [wills]. I do... first, place I live to my wife Eve one third part of my real estate during her life (of dower) and one third part of my personal estate as the law provides and in addition to this I give to her all my bedding, bed clo[thes], her saddle, spinning wheels, forty bushels of wheat, and one hundred and fifty bushels of Corn. I do give to my mother Margaret during her life the room in the South West end of my house, one acre of land convenient to the house and free and unobstructed passage to spring water and privilege of taking wood for her fire all during her life only. The residue of my estate after payment of my debts and settlement of my accounts is to be divided equally among..." Marginal archival note: "Casper Karsner['s] Will, date Apr. 14, 1797. [He] was returned] into Court on July 10, 1797, His will (be) Recorded, Died some time within 3 months after making this Will."

Page 117

Continuation (p.394): "...my children the personal estate as they arrive of age or marry, and their respective proportions of the landed estate when the youngest child is of full age. I do appoint John Parker and Abraham Bowman Executors of this my last will and testament. In Testimony Whereof I hereto set my hand and affix my seal this 14th day of April 1797 and 5th year of the Commonwealth. Casper Kersner (Seal)." Witnesses: Levi Todd, Jonathan Ralston, Henry Kent, John Henry. "At a court held for the county of Fayette, on Monday the tenth of July One thousand seven hundred ninety seven[,] This last Will and Testament of Casper Kersner dec'd was this day produced in court by John Parker and Abraham Bowman the executors therein named and proved by the oaths of Levi Todd, Jonathan Ralston, Henry Kent & John Henry" (continues Page 118).

Page 118

Continuation: "...subscribing witnesses thereto and ordered to be recorded & on the motion of the said executors refusing to be qualified administrators with the will annexed, with the approbation of the court granted to Eve Kersner who made [oath] according to law; certificate is therefore granted in due form the giving security whereupon the said Eve Kersner together with John McConnell and Alexander Mak[a]n her security entered into and acknowledged bond in the penalty of £800 conditions as the law directs which is ordered to be recorded. In Testimony whereof I hereto set my hand and affix the seal of the said county this 25th day of September 1798 and 7th year of the Commonwealth. Teste, Levi Todd." Below: "Fayette County March court 1807. This attested copy of the last will and testament of Casper Kersner dec'd was produced in court and ordered to be recorded, the original with the record having been destroyed by fire. Teste, Levi Todd." [This record documents both Casper's estate settlement being delayed by his executors' refusal, granted instead to widow Eve, and the 1798 courthouse fire that destroyed the original will — explaining why only this 1807 attested copy survives.]

Page 119

Typed letter, dated "7 Jan 1981." "Dear Margaret Murphy:" from Ruth — advises on next steps for publishing: "Since you already have chapters to go to the printer, it is obvious you can't postpone your 'Days of Immigration' much longer. You must have page numbers for all the pages before you can complete the index. Never publish without an index!" Urges her not to give up hope on the Johann George Kershner (b.1722) connection but to publish an addendum later, as the Kershner Family Association plans to do; recommends pricing her book to recover at least 50-100% over printing/distribution costs. Lays out a rigorous standard for proving the Pennsylvania connection (absence of Berks Co. death/probate records for the years in question; documenting the gap 1760-1773 via Cumberland Co. deed/court records; cross-referencing witnesses to his deeds). States plainly: "So far, I think you have not done any real research, but I think you have pretty well established that no one else has done it, either. You will add a real chapter to the Kershner Histories, one that has never been done!" Raises a serious concern about Margaret's handling of quotations from the Rockingham chancery records: "You have all too frequently copied off what purported to be records, but inserted your own ideas into them without differentiating from the text of the record... When you insert these names into the typed copy as though they were written there, you are falsifying the original record. This destroys your credibility." Offers to draft a letter to Peggy Joyner on Margaret's behalf if she wants to spend research money.

Page 120

Typed document, apparently Margaret's own summary titled "IN CHANCERY," laying out the family relationships established by the Rockingham Co. lawsuit, annotated throughout with Ruth's red-ink editorial corrections: "Mother: Margaret Kersner & Son: Casper Kersner, Complainants, Against Thomas Lincoln (Executor of George Kersner); Elizabeth, wife of Thomas Lincoln and daughter of George Kersner; John (Kersner); Nicholas (Kersner); George, Henry, David — Shaver or Shaffer (Grandsons of George and Margaret) [Ruth's correction: "I don't see any indication they were Kershners. Either they were 5 Shaver boys, or one man, John Nicholas... I agree, they must have been grandsons (sons of a deceased daughter? who)"]; Modelena and husband Philip Rust (Modelena deceased — Philip was a widower); Jacob Kersner (now lived in Tennessee, Washington Co.); Catherine Bowman (another daughter), Defendants." Records the contempt order against non-appearing defendants. Notes: "John Lincoln was attorney-in-fact for Jacob — He lived in Tennessee at the time of the chancery suit (from John Wayland's book, 'The Lincolns of Virginia')" [Ruth's annotation: "An attorney-in-fact was not necessarily a lawyer. He had a 'power of attorney' which may be recorded in a deed book or court record"]. Concludes: "It seems they had children: three sons — Casper, John, and Jacob, also four daughters — Elizabeth, who married Thomas Lincoln, Modelena who married Philip Rust, and Catherine, who married a Bowman, and a daughter, who was the mother of the Shaffer grandsons." Ruth's closing red-ink note: "Margaret, dear, — it bothers me that you don't always put your opinions in parentheses, or indicate in some way that some of these transcriptions are partly from original records, but partly from other sources. See p.84, Vol. II KFM for Nicholas Shaver of Wash. Co. Md. who was a neighbor of the Kershners but had moved to Augusta Co. Va. by 1778."

Page 121

Damaged/partial photocopy of the May 1801 Rockingham Co. Judgement Order Book #6, p.423 (duplicate of content seen on Page 43): "Margaret Kersner & Casper Kersner, Compl[ainan]ts, against Thomas Lincoln, Executor of George [Kersner] & Elizabeth his wife, John, Nicholas, George, Henry & David Shaver, Philip Rust & Modelena his wife, Jacob Kersner, Catharine Bowman and John Lincoln, Defendants" — contempt order against non-appearing defendants.

Page 122

Typed letter, dated "28 Nov 1980." "Dear Margaret:" from Ruth — reports thoroughly investigating a "Jacob Nicholas" lead and ruling it out: their own William Kershner (b.1810, Augusta Co. VA) married Betsy, daughter of Henry Nicholas of Greenbrier Co. (W)VA; Jacob Nicholas was "pure German" and lived at the south end of Massanutten Mt., with documented baptismal records for his children; Henry Nicholas was a son of John Nicholas, a lawyer "probably English," who is documented suing his own son Henry over property in Greenbrier Co. — "so the proof is very clear. Jacob Nicholas did not marry any of our Kershner line." [Ruth's own marginal red-ink annotation adds: "The lawyer John Nicholas was an old man in 1810, but had a son John, also a lawyer."]

Page 123

Continuation: reports her husband's brother, Steve Kershner of Falls Church, VA, visited Langenselbold, Germany, arranging an extra day and a local researcher/driver from Frankfurt-on-Main to take him there while on business in Germany; delivered the family's accumulated donations to the Langenselbold archives, was welcomed by the Bürgermeister and officials — "we think our queries will be better received now." Describes coordinating all German-record requests through William E. Kershner Jr. of Charlotte, NC, to consolidate requests to their German researcher (reducing church-staff burden and duplicated efforts) and to correspond in German with researcher "Herr Max Steinbaur." Raises the open question of whether "Rev. Joh. Casper Kirchner of Baltimore" could be the same person as "Joh. Kaspar Kirchner b.1700 of Langenselbold" — German records of 1754 and later could be searched to see if the Langenselbold man is still there (if so, he obviously can't be the man in America). Notes Dr. I.J. Karschner of Hanover, PA, a retired Lutheran minister, has investigated Rev. Kirchner's church records for them and "is quite ready to accept Rev. Casper as the fourth brother, but has no more evidence than the rest of us."

Page 124

Continuation: further Rev. Casper Kirchner research — has a copy of his will (ordering the original from Annapolis); Dr. Karschner loaned her a book on Old Zion Church in Baltimore by Klaus O. Wust (a friend of Peggy S. Joyner of Portsmouth, VA, with whom Ruth has corresponded on the Augusta Co. Kershners — Peggy is a descendant of Philip Olinger, David Kershner's father-in-law, and of Peter Hanger, "but not of the Kershner lines," and is an accomplished genealogy teacher preparing, with the Pennsylvania German Society, a sequel to Strassburger & Hinke's ship-lists volumes); documents Rev. Casper's Baltimore Co. land dealings via deed abstracts (1767 purchase; 1772 sale by widow Christina and partner "Leonard Sower," both of York Co. PA, to "Jasper Kirchner" — "we assign all our right & title... Christain [mark] Kerchner"); Baltimore Co. probate records for "Kirchner, Jasper" (will 1770, inventory 1773). Notes plans to have the German researcher Steinbaur (with a Dr. Dahl in reserve, since Steinbaur has been ill) continue the work; corrects an earlier letter's reference to "Northampton Co. Virginia," clarifying it should read "Northampton Co. Pa.," east of Berks and now Lehigh Co. — several of Conrad K. I's (b.1717) children settled there.

Page 125

Handwritten letter, dated "Sept. 30, 1980" (with a later marginal addition: "In one of your letters you said I was mixing the Karsners from Penn. & Virginia. I didn't understand how I was mixing them up."). "Dear Cousin Ruth and Cousin Stuart:" from Margaret — recaps her family reunion held the previous Saturday, Sept. 27th, with 230-240 attendees, including visitors from Indianapolis, New Albany IN, California, Florida, and a returned foreign missionary from Africa; gave a roughly 15-minute summary of the family history during lunch hour, well received; one woman fainted and was taken to the hospital but insisted on returning "against her Doctor's wishes and her family," and did. Is mailing Ruth's book (Vol. I) back after enjoying it; notes attendees were surprised how many Karsners there are "here and there," and that both of Ruth/Mary's Vol. I and II histories were "handled a lot" that day; Mary Maxwell asked her to send in the Karsner lineage for possible inclusion in the forthcoming Vol. III. Reiterates her belief in "a concrete connection for the Karsners of Kentucky": that Casper (b.1750, son of George and Margaret) is her own ancestor Casper, who went to Virginia with his parents, later came to Kentucky, was captured by Indians, married Eve Lail, and left orphans in 1797 (Margaret age 10, John age 8, George already deceased, baby Jonathan age 3). Asks: "What other George could he be??? ...It seems to me I have more proof he didn't die, than the other family has that he did die. I told them all the credit goes to you and Mary for the Immigration information. Please hang in there with me until I can get over this hurdle of connecting, or I'll lose my sanity. Ha, Ha. Really some nights I can't sleep because of the uncertainty of the connecting link." Mentions she'll turn 62 on Dec. 29, 1980, and doesn't plan to retire until 65, after finishing her history.

Page 126

Typed letter, dated "Dear Peggy" (undated header visible, context places it late 1980) from Ruth — introduces Margaret Karsner Murphy as "a descendant of the George Kershner/Kersner who bought land on Brock's Creek in 1773. George Kershner's son Casper, a Revolutionary Soldier in Va. 1779, witnessed a deed about 1775 [Chalkley II], took his mother to Fayette Co. Ky. after his father died about 1795 in Rockingham Co." Notes Margaret is about ready to publish her family data "at the behest of some of her old relatives who want to see it before they die"; suggests Peggy help suggest Pennsylvania research resources. Discusses parallels between George Kershner/wife Margaret/son Casper and Joh. Georg Kirschner (b.1722, Berks Co. PA, younger son of immigrant Johannes Kirschner b.1693), noting Casper was old enough to witness an Augusta Co. deed in 1775, consistent with the Berks Co. Kershner's chronology. Discusses "Joh. Georg Kirschner and wife Margaret": checking Moselem baptismal records that were apparently misquoted in "History of the Kershner Family" by Geo. C. Kershner — the book said "Joh. George had a son Joh. Georg b.1756 who died young," but the actual record shows the parents as "Martin Kirshman and wife Agnesia Schwarts." Notes John George (b.1722, of the Kershner Families of Maryland Vol. I p.221) "had a wife, Maria Margareta, and a son Casper b.1750. So far, so good. About whom nothing is known." Flags the core problem: a Berks Co. Orphans' Court record (1768) says George C. Kershner "said he died at the age of 47 (KFM Vol II p.207) and I quoted him" — but Geo. C. buried at least one other Kershner prematurely, so it would be worthwhile to check Orphans' Court, other probate/administrator's bonds, petitions to sell land of decedent, deeds, and court minutes. Cites Dave Hollenbach and Warren Faust's indexing of Berks Co. tax lists (1752-1790): George Kershner (b.1722) was in Bern Twp. through 1760, inherited 400 acres of woodland on "Gool's Hill" [Ghoul's/Skull Hill, per Paul Millikin] in 1742, patented to old Johannes Kirschner; his children were baptized at Hain's Church in Bern Twp.: Elizabeth 1745, Casper 1750, Anna Maria b.1751 (who chose Martin K[e]rschner of Bern as her guardian), and Conrad b.1754 (who chose his uncle, Conrad Kerschner b.1717) — "these latter two lived and died in Berks Co., but George and Casper disap[peared]..." (continues Page 127).

Page 127

Continuation: "I don't know of any other George Kershner in Berks Co. until his nephew, b. 30 June 1760." Notes George and Maria Margaret were sponsors at the baptism of his nephew, Joh. George, son of Conrad, at Zion in Windsor Twp. — "I don't know of any other George Kershner [living] in Berks Co. till this nephew grew up. However, in scanning indexes, I noted a George Kershner naturalized 1761, Saucon Twp., Northampton Co., and a warrant for 150 ac. of land in Cumberland Co. Pa., surveyed 1765. It might be possible to develop a trail if the supposed death of George Kershner in 1768 looks shaky." Recommends Margaret Murphy get a copy of the marriage bond of Thomas Lincoln and Eliz. Casner, "Dau. of George," quoting a footnote (p.77) from "Old Tenth Legion Marriages, Rockingham Co. Va.": "wholly written by Kensoner, the father, as follows: 'Mr. Henry Youins please let the bearer Thomas Lincoln have Lisens to be mared to my dauter and in so doing you will oblige your friend George Kensoner'" (date given elsewhere as 23 Sept. 1782). Recommends ordering copies of Rockingham Order Book pp.153 (Sept. 1802) and 345 (Aug. 1803) naming children of George Kershner — the widow Margaret and son Casper had sued the other heirs; notes Margaret Murphy has a copy of Order Book 6 p.423 but should also get p.413 (May 1801). Closing personal note about her brother-in-law William E. Kershner (transferred from Snyder, NY to Charlotte, NC, a member of the KFA publication committee, coordinating German research) taking a set of "KFM" [Kershner Families of Maryland] to Langenselbold while on business in Germany.

Page 128

Handwritten letter, two dated entries. First, "Dec. 4th, 1980, Lunch hour": "Dear Ruth: You'll never know how happy I was to get your letter, dated Nov. 28th... I finally saw that I must give up the idea of Johannes being my line... I feel sure we are from one of the four brothers, and he must be the right one. Even before I ever knew you, we were always told 'three' brothers come from Germany" [marginal correction: "This was wrong also since there were four"]. Second entry, "Dec. 8th, 1980, At Home 8pm": reports three deaths within one week in her family (sister-in-law, first cousin, and third cousin all died within three days of each other); hosted 24 people for dinner after a funeral. States she wants to contribute money toward the research on "Joh. Caspar." Reports she is "fortunate to have a friend, Peggy S. Joyner," and that Peggy is a friend of Klaus Wust; advertised for help in the Tri-State Trader (Dec. 6, cost $27.00) and received several letters, enclosing some for Ruth's consideration, including one from "Evelyn Rosemary Frantz of Lafayette, Indiana" touching on the chancery suit — Frantz found "George Kershner SR. (there must be a Jr.) and wife Margaret['s]" children were Casper, John, Nicholas Kershner, also children of a deceased daughter (George, Henry and David Shaffer/Shavers), also deceased daughter Madelena (widower Philip Rust), and non-residents Jacob Kershner and Catharine Bowman — believes "this John Lincoln was the lawyer in the case to represent Jacob, who was now supposed to be in Washington Co. Tennessee in 1796. This George who is deceased must have been the Jr.??" Raises an alarming realization: "if this George, son of George Sr., [and his] widow married Thomas Lincoln, then my Lincoln connections are all wrong?? ... There is something bad wrong here. I know our Casper had a sister Elizabeth, who married a Lincoln, Thomas." Was about to send two chapters ("Early Kentucky" and "Our Lincoln Connections") to the printer but now hesitates; her Lincoln connection info came from John Wayland's "The Lincolns of Virginia" and Harry M. Strickler's "Old Tenth Legion Marriages"; wonders about getting a Xerox of pages 423 and 413 in Judgement and Order Book #6.

Page 129

Continuation (dated "Dec. 9th" in a circled note): "I must close this letter and get it on its way. I might call after you have had time to read this. With Love, the tie that Binds, Margaret Alice." Postscript: "What must I do next? Should I go on with my Lincoln connection and turn them it. I've got to get something released so they can be working on it. So many of my people are old and want to see it printed, they have no idea what I'm going through. If you have anything you can share with me about Joh. Caspar. At present, I would be thankful, however I [am] leaving 'Days of Immigration' until last. I had it about finished thinking it was Johannes, but stopped in my tracks when I realized I might be on [the] wrong trail. I now released 'Early Kentucky' without any problem also. I think I'm going to put the genealogies just like they have sent them in. To have them all printed alike, would take 6 more months."

Page 130

Typed letter, dated "November 10, 1980, Noontime at work." "Dear Ruth:" from Margaret — missed hearing from Ruth during her vacation; never took her own vacation this year, "I got so deep into this history"; wrote to her Virginia researcher about the defendants in the chancery case (forwarding his unhelpful reply); reports "W.D. Faust" also said he couldn't help untangle her Pennsylvania ancestors — "So I am getting no where." Is considering the possibility of "Johan Casper b.1700 and his wife Anna Elizabeth Doll," noting little has been said about him; asks whether Ruth has heard more from "Dr. John Dahl," and about the ship he came over on. States she's going ahead writing the Kentucky part of her history, hoping to finish the book by next summer. Frustrated that Pennsylvania county offices don't answer her letters or refer her to researchers who also don't respond. States: "I would bet my life that George is my immigrant Grandfather, but I may never know who his father was." Asks whether Ruth was going to the Mormon Genealogical Library on her vacation. Notes Casper's Revolutionary War back-pay record spells his name "Gasper"; recalls Ruth writing that "the pastor always spelled his name Kirchner, altho the indexes to the will and probate records in Baltimore spell his first name Jasper and Gasper" — asks if Ruth has copies of his will and probate record, since she's never contacted anyone in Maryland herself, trusting Ruth and Mary had already covered it. Asks why Ruth suggested checking "Cumberland County Pa." and why "Northampton County Virginia" [sic, presumably a slip for Pennsylvania], and where George was found there.

Page 131

Handwritten letter, letterhead "Harrisonburg-Rockingham Historical Society, P.O. Box 1141, 301 South Main Street, Harrisonburg, Virginia 22801," annotated "Murphy" and "Mailed Nov. 6, 1980." "Dear Margaret:" — "I'm at wit's end and at a dead end. I have scurried from one cubbyhole to another throughout the entire Court House and have been unable to turn up any info further to what I have already sent you. It should be here. I have taxed the staff and I have attempted all avenues open to my common sense and detective skills. Nothing! ... Please! Please! Do not feel obligated to remit any funds. This one is on me. I insist. I've put another inquiry in our newsletter. Who knows....? Best regards, Peter Slayer [signature reads 'Slayer']." Margaret's marginal reply note: "There is no use for me to worry any more, this woman ('Is there?') has really been nice to me."

Page 132

Typed letter, dated "1 Sept 1980." "Dear Margaret Murphy:" from Ruth — returns copied documents; has charted the data from Margaret's letters, raising research questions. Notes Wm. Dunlap acted as attorney-in-fact for Casper Kershner, then married Casper's widow less than a month after Casper's will was proved (10 July 1797) — asks whether Dunlap was still acting for Casper's estate as of the May 1801 Rockingham chancery record, and why it wasn't noted there that Casper had died. Deduces that since Thomas Lincoln is described as "executor" (not administrator), George Kersner must have left a will naming him, though Margaret hasn't mentioned finding it. Proposes that "John Nicholas" could be either one man or, more likely, a passage reading as five names — "John, Nicholas, George, Henry and David, of a Shaver, whose mother was George Kersner's daughter (Shaver=Schaeffer, etc.)" — expects Modelena Rust to be another daughter and Catherine Bowman a widowed daughter, "the Shaver boys' mother [being] dead, and they are her heirs." Suggests searching tax lists, guardian appointments, and land-division records for the various defendants named. Notes the record proves descent/marriage links but more could be found in the county records; will Xerox a research-methodology outline from the Maryland Genealogical Society Bulletin; recommends checking Cumberland Co. PA as a possible stopover between Berks/Northampton Co. and Virginia.

Page 133

Handwritten letter, letterhead partly cut off ("...Reading, [Pa.], 314 Raymond St., N.P."), dated "Aug 20 1980." "Dear Margaret:" from "W.D. Faust" — apologizes he cannot help untangle her Pennsylvania ancestors; notes the Faust and Kershner families came from the same area/church in Germany and immigrated on the same boat in 1733; his ancestor Philip Faust (b.1713) had a daughter who married Peter Kerschner (b.1749), a son of Conrad Kershner (b.1717); Jacob Faust (b.1729) had two daughters who married sons of Conrad Kershner (b.1717): Catharine to (John) George Kershner (b.1746, sic likely typo) and Magdalena to Mathias Kerschner. Cautions that most of his data is second-hand and he cannot vouch for its authenticity. Addresses Margaret's concern about "a John Geor[ge] Kershner" — confirms the John George who died 1768 is assumed to be a son of the 1733 immigrant Johannes Kershner, born ca.1721, died 1768 in Windsor Twp., Berks Co., and is further assumed to have had a son, John George, born 1756(?), "who seems to have been lost during the years." Observes that Margaret and her correspondent "Mrs. Kershner" may be discussing two different men named John/George Kershner who could actually be father and son, a generation apart. Notes he became familiar with the Kerschner name 65 years ago, recalling a "Kerschner's Ice Cream parlor" in Reading PA; states "The Penn. German pronunciation of the Kershner name is 'Karshner.'" Signed "W.D. Faust."

Page 134

Typed research page, headed "THE THIRD SON OF JOH. CONRAD KIRSCHNER AND THE FIRST SON BY HIS SECOND WIFE ANNA MARGARETE KEYSER — Joh. Kaspar Kershner": b. 18 Sept. 1700 (Lutheran Parish Record, Langenselbold); m. 19 Nov. 1721 Anna Magdalena Döll, dau. of Peter and Anna Elizabeth Döll. Children: Joh. George b.1722 (marginal note: "Maybe... no proof??????? I just added this name"); Anna Elizabeth b.1723; Anna Sabina b.1724 d.1725 age one year; Joh. Martin b.1725 (married 1751 Elizabeth Ruht); Joh. Konrad b.1728; Anna Margarete b.1729. Notes: "Joh. Kaspar Kershner may have come to America as a Lutheran Pastor, since there was one here in 1764." Their son Johann Martinus was baptized 10 Dec. 1725 "in their house," Lutheran Parish Record, Langenselbold, sponsored by "younger brother of his father, named Johann Martinus Kirschner." Copied from a letter of Ruth's: discusses the theory connecting through "Johann Casper Kirchner, Lutheran minister who left his name in the cornerstone of a church in Winchester, Frederick County Virginia 1764" — the similarity of names to the German baptismal "Joh. Casper" struck Ruth immediately, but no single common record has yet been found linking the German and American men, though they are of similar age/heritage; mentions Ruth employed "Dr. John Dahl, C.G., born in Germany, a Mormon who lives in Salt Lake City" to research German records, though Dahl reports none of the needed records have been published or filmed and he must look up emigration permits and church records in Hesse in person; Dahl has been ill (bleeding ulcer) and his reports are overdue. Margaret's marginal note: "I was just playing around with this idea. I noticed they had a child every year so I placed in Joh. George to see how it would stack up. Just speculating — I know this would have to come from Germany. Out of desperation. Ha Ha."

Page 135

Continuation: recaps Joh. Kaspar Kirschner's birth/marriage/children (Anna Sabina b.1724 d.1725; Anna Elisabeth b.1723; Joh. Martin b.1725, m.1751 Elisabeth Ruht dau. of Johann; Joh. Konrad b.1728; Anna Margarete b.1729); notes on 10 June 1739, "Johann Casspar Kirschner, the child's father's brother here" [i.e., a different Johann Casper] was sponsor at the baptism of another Johann Casspar Kirschner, son of Johann Martin and Elisabetha Kirschner at Langenselbold — identifies this sponsor as "Martin b.1703," who came to America and settled in Bern Twp. about a mile from Johannes (b.1693). States the lack of further dates doesn't mean none exist — someone simply hasn't gone through all the unnumbered, antique-German church record volumes stored in the church basement; they are trying to cultivate a better relationship with the pastor there. Discusses the American "Rev. Joh. Casper Kirchner": his 1763 Latin letter to Muhlenberg complaining of non-acceptance as ordained clergy despite nine years in America; not on the 1733 Strassburger & Hencke ship lists; said to have gone first to Berks Co., not on tax rolls or land records there; was an ordained pastor serving Schuster's Church, York Co. PA (1758), traveling to Baltimore to serve Zion Church six times a year, and other Virginia churches including Winchester; retired to Baltimore (bought a farm/country estate) at end of 1768 due to age/health, called back to serve Zion when it was between pastors, served until his death; wrote his will 1 Aug. 1770 (proved 22 Aug. 1770), naming wife Christiana executrix, no children mentioned, inventory showing little beyond a few clothing outfits; "he was a good man, strict but loving," with distinctive handwriting found in more than one parish baptismal record; concludes "No where do the records of the German and American individuals overlap, so far... In Germany, our Kirschners were farmers. All the immigrants were literate and apparently leaders of their groups, but there is nothing to suggest that our Joh. Casper b.1700 was a minister. We have to have more information."

Page 136

Typed letter, dated "23 Jan 1981." "Dear Margaret:" from Ruth — has finally obtained and studied the original 1910 Berks Co. Orphans' Court transcription (by B.F. Owen), comparing it against George C. Kershner's published quotation of the same record in "History of the Kershner Family" (by George C. Kershner of Bernville, d.7 Aug. 1966): the Owen 1910 copy reads "Petition of Conrad Kerchner, age 14 years 2 months & Anna Maria Kerchner age 16 years, two of the children of George Kerchner, late of Windsor, yeoman, deceased. Prays for guardians — selects Conrad Kerschner, Sr., of Windsor. Approved," while George C. Kershner's book states George "died in 1768" (age 47), invents that Anna Maria was "niece" and Conrad "nephew" of Conrad Kirschner the First, reverses which sibling petitioned first, and gives the date as Sept. 12 rather than Feb. 12. Ruth's pointed critique: "His apparent quotation of the Orphan's Court record is contaminated by extraneous material... He misquoted the record... Either George C. Kershner was careless, OR this 1910 copy is not correct OR there is an additional record (Sept. 12?) giving Martin as Anna Maria's guardian." Concludes: "I think I was right to be cautious about accepting George C.'s record as gospel. I'm glad he was careful about reporting George and Margaret's supposed burial place, but sorry the times he said 'nothing is known' or 'there is no trace' — he really meant he knew nothing more, and hadn't found any trace. Anna Maria's descendants have her marriage record in Molltown, just southeast of Windsor Twp.: looks like she met her mate near her uncle Conrad's rather than Martin's home. Just speculation, of course."

Page 137

Handwritten letter, "Owenton, Ky, July 25, 1980" (with a red marginal date "29 July" indicating reply/receipt). "Dear Ruth:" from Margaret — thanks for a letter and phone call; visited the KY Historical Society and looked at Ruth's books, "can hardly wait for Vol. III"; has made a chart of the lineage and asks Ruth to correct and return it before the Sept. 27th reunion of the Karsners of Kentucky. Is sending "a lot of papers" for Ruth to review and then discard; her DAR papers were sent to Washington the prior week; some Maryland material sent to her is of no use — "will it help you any? Just destroy it." States: "Casper's wife Eve Lail Carsner Dunlap died in 1842, here is her will. The book 'List of the Revolutionary Soldiers of Virginia' showing his Auditor's Accounts number in 1785, helps to prove he was in the Revolution. From the 'Lincolns of Virginia' by John Wayland shows Jacob's father was George Casner." Mentions writing about the story of Ruddle's Fort's destruction (bicentennial visit that summer); calls "the Burnt paper and the chancery suit" important evidence connecting a George in Virginia with wife Margaret and son Casper; notes Casper's will shows his mother Margaret lived with him in Kentucky; flags a discrepancy: "The 6½ acres George bought in Virginia in 1703, if it is 1703, 1783, lets me know he was in Virginia long before 1773????? Just got this from Virginia this week." Wonders if "Jacob Kisner might be Jacob Karsner," speculating the family "dropped the h in Karsner" after leaving Virginia. Mentions Kentucky contacts receiving letters from a "Beatrice Bayley" of uncertain reliability. Asks whether Ruth has copies of baptismal certificates to show at the reunion; states she's an accountant in the Dept. of Transportation, Division of Toll Facilities, in Frankfort, KY, 32 years, might retire after her book is finished.

Page 138

Continuation of the same letter (this page reproduced upside-down in the file — text reads bottom-to-top): "Yes, I would love to have a map of Brock Creek, or just anything you can share with me. I am sorry your books are all sold out. Do you expect to reprint at any time in the future? When Vol. III coming out. I I had gotten your books I was putting them in the Church Library, we are in the process of establishing a research center there. This is how I met the woman from Washington D.C., Mrs. Vivia Montsinger. She is so much. S he is a mormon and worked at the National Archives before she retired last January. I had always heard from a little girl, that our forefathers were related to the Lincolns, but we never knew how. I wrote the Historical Society I told you and you day I talked, the one you go to answer yet. No answer told me to write. I'll mail it on to you, if I get an answer. Was Maria the mother of Johannes and Johann Georg (this is the one your from)? Did you find out who the wife of Johannes was, if the Faust woman was wrong. Could I buy a picture from you of the little Church from your Germany book, I don't want to do any thing to take from your book. I will only print enough books to supply our family, if they have ordered in advance. I can't go into it in a big way like you all have. I have just written what I know down. I doubt there will be over a hundred orders if that many. We are just a small family here in Kentucky. I had always heard a little girl, that our forefathers were related to the Lincolns, but we never knew how related to the Lincolns, but we were related to..." [letter breaks off/repeats due to being photographed upside-down and partially duplicated]. Signed "With Love, the tie that binds, Mrs. Margaret Alice (Karsner) Murphy."

Page 139

Photocopied excerpt, "Lincoln Chronology," p.250, annotated "For Ruth" in red — a chronological abstract of Lincoln-family Rockingham/Augusta Co. VA records, 1793-1799: includes routine land-survey and court-fee entries for John Lincoln Jr., Capt. Jacob Lincoln, etc. Critically: "1796, Oct. 20, John Lincoln and John Berry appointed attorneys in fact by Jacob Casner of Washington County, Tenn., to prosecute his claim as legatee of his father George Casner, deceased" [underlined in the original] — direct documentary confirmation that Jacob Casner (Kersner/Kershner) was, by 1796, resident in Washington Co., Tennessee, and a legal heir of George Casner. Also: 1795, Aug. 12, Jacob Lincoln's son born on Linville Creek; 1795, Oct., fee paid for recording the appraisement of the personal estate of John Lincoln ("Virginia John") — confirming this "Virginia John Lincoln" (George Kershner's neighbor per the Date Guide Lines) had died by 1795.

Page 140

Photocopied page 77 of "Old Tenth Legion Marriages: Marriages in Rockingham County, Virginia, From 1778 to 1816" — the marriage list itself, annotated "Ruth," "George," and dated "Nov. 30, 1980" in the margins. Two entries of central importance appear on this single page: "82 – Lincoln, Tom. [married] Eliz. Casner [daughter of] Geo. [surety] Handle Wentz (Vance)" [marginal note: "and Casper's sister," and a footnote reference "22 Sept 1782"] — with footnote 15 (partially reproduced): "cn. wholly written by Kensoner, the father, as follows: 'Mr. Henry Youins, please let the bearer Thomas Lincoln have Lisens to be mared to my dauter and in so doing you will oblige your friend George Kensoner.' I have noticed the name spelled Lincheord [sic]." And separately, marked with an "X": "93 – Link, Nicholas... Lincoln, Thomas m. Nancy Hanks in Ky. Wash. Co. Sep 23, 1806, parents of the President." This single primary-source page thus documents, side by side, both the 1782 marriage of "Tom Lincoln" to "Eliz. Casner" (daughter of George Kensoner/Kersner) — the marriage central to the Karsner family's claimed Lincoln connection — and the entirely separate, later 1806 marriage of a different Thomas Lincoln to Nancy Hanks, explicitly identified here as "parents of the President," confirming these are two distinct men of the same name, consistent with the family tradition that the Casner-line Thomas Lincoln was a great-uncle (by marriage) rather than the direct paternal line to Abraham Lincoln.

Page 141

Duplicate photocopy of "Lincoln Chronology" p.250 (same content as Page 139), with an added marginal note in blue ink: "the John Lincoln — was a lawyer? Not a son of George — or as such?" — Margaret or Ruth questioning John Lincoln's exact relationship in the 1796 attorney-in-fact appointment for Jacob Casner.

Page 142

Typed research page, "(Continued)," analyzing "JOHANN KERSCHNER b.1693": married 11 Feb. 1717 Gertrude, daughter of Johann Dietrich, deceased, "of separated marriage with Johann Schussert" (ship's lists give her age as 50 in 1733 on arrival in Philadelphia). Six children listed: Joh. Konrad (b.17 Sept. 1717, d.1791 Windsor Twp. Berks Co. PA, m. Catherine Bek, 13 children); Joh. Peter (1719-1725); Anna (b.15 May 1722, d.26 Dec. 1722); Joh. Georg (Anna's twin), "said to have d.1768, 'late of Windsor Twp., Berks Co. Pa,'" married Maria Margaretha, 5 known children: Elisabetha (b.1745 Bern Twp.), Casper (b.1750 Bern Twp., Berks Co.), Anna Maria (b.1751, married there 1771 Johannes Staudt), Conrad (b.1754 Bern Twp., married ca.1780 Elisabeth Bertolet), John George (b.1756 Bern Twp.); also Anna Phillippine (1724-1725) and Anna Katharina (b.1727). Continues: "The above George Kerschner b.1722 was listed age 12 in 1733, and was left land in Bern Twp. in his father's will, 1742. He was in the Tax List of Berks Co. only until 1760. We think it was he — George Kisner — who served with Conrad Kisner 1757 in the French & Indian Wars in Md. A George Kershner was naturalized in Northumberland Co. Pa. 1761, and a John George Kershner got a warrant for 150 acres in Cumberland Co. Pa in 1765. But in 1768, two of the children of Joh. George Kerschner b.1722 are said to have petitioned the Orphan's (Probate) Court of Berks Co. for guardians: Anna Maria, 16, chose Martin Kershner of Bern Tp, and Conrad, 14, chose 'his uncle, Conrad Kerschner of Windsor Tp.' No will or estate records have been mentioned. Berks Co. researchers have assumed that Elisabeth, Casper, and John George died as children, since they did not petition for guardians. But did they? And was the death of Joh. George, b.1722, greatly exaggerated in 1768, like Mark Twain's?" A side-note (likely Ruth's) reads: "This sounds very much like the George Kershner/Kersner who d. in Rockingham Va. 1796 at age 74, hence born ca.1722. His wife was also Margaret, and he had a son Casper Karsner/Carsner, b. in Pa, old enough in 1775 to witness a deed in Augusta Co. Va. where George bought land in 1773. Casper was a Va. Rev. Soldier 1779, d.1797, m.1786 Eve Lail 1766-1842. Their descendants list other children of George Kersner who d.1796: Jacob, and Elizabeth who m. Thomas Lincoln in 1782." [This is one of the most direct statements in the entire file of the circumstantial case FOR the Pennsylvania-Virginia Kershner/Karsner connection, even though it stops short of declaring it proven.]

Page 143

Hand-drawn genealogy chart, letterhead "STUART G. & RUTH B. KERSHNER, 1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin, Texas 78746, 512/327-2020" printed vertically along the right edge — a clean summary pedigree: George Kersner (Kershner, Casner) = Margaret [notes: "bought land 1773, Brock's Creek, Augusta Co. Va (Bot 6½ ac, Survey Book A p.168)"; "d.1796 (by 1798) Rockingham Co. Va"; Margaret per "Fayette Co. Ky 'Burned Records' Vol.8 p.207, 1796 — w/son Casper, appointed Wm. Dunlap attny to convey estate of Geo. in Va., to sue for monies or [property] etc."; "Rock Co. Va Judgment Order Book #6 p.423, May 1801: Margaret & Casper Kersner vs. Thomas Lincoln & Eliz. his wife, John, Nicholas, George, Henry & David Shaver, Philip Rust (?) & wife Modelena, Jacob Kersner, Cath. Bowman and John Lincoln"] — their children: Casper Karsner (m. Eve Lail, 1766-1842, who m.(2) Wm. Dunlap 7 Aug. 1797) ["1775 witnessed deed Augusta Co."; "d. Apr. 1797/pr 10 Jy 1797"]; Jacob; Elizabeth Casner/Korson/Kershner (b.1763, d.1832 age 70, "widow, lived w/son George, buried near Liberty, Mo," m. 23 Sept. 1782 Thomas Lincoln, b.23 Oct. 1761, d.11 Dec. 1820, "by 1790/1787 to Fayette Co. Ky, gt.-uncle of Abraham Lincoln, exr. for Geo. Kershner"). Grandchildren listed under Thomas & Elizabeth: Betty (b. Va ca.1783?), Margaret (b. Va ca.1785?), Catherine (b. Ky ca.1787?, "m. Va, [Abraham?] (Bowman?), never returned to Ky"), Abram (b. Rock Co. Va, 1789?), George Lincoln (b.15 Apr. 1792, Ky), John (b.1794? Ky), David (b. May 1800, Ky), Hannah (b. Ky, 1802). Below George Lincoln: "James E. Lincoln, in letters of 1879, 1885: 'Dr. Lyman Draper was wrong, holding that Thomas Lincoln, my grandfather, married a Winter — she was a Korson or Kersner.'" Bottom label: "Augusta/Rockingham Co Va — Margaret Alice Karsner Murphy."

Page 144

Continuation of the 18 July 1980 letter to Margaret ("page 3," matching Pages 134-135's Joh. Kaspar Kirschner discussion — a duplicate/near-duplicate of that content): recaps Joh. Kaspar Kirschner's German baptismal children (Anna Sabina, Anna Elisabeth, Joh. Martin m.1751 Elisabeth Ruht, Joh. Konrad, Anna Margarete); the 1739 sponsor note distinguishing Martin (b.1703, who came to America, Bern Twp.) from other same-named relatives; the American "Rev. Joh. Casper Kirchner" biographical summary (Schuster's Church York Co. 1758, Zion Church Baltimore, retirement 1768, will 1770, wife Christiana, no children); concludes with the same "No where do the records... overlap" assessment as Page 135.

Page 145

Continuation, "You are cordially invited to join the search." Addresses a side question about "the three brothers, Johannes, Johann Georg, or Joh. Casper — 'Did they have a sister Rosina who married a Ridenour?'" — reports the German records don't mention any Rosina Kirschner, but Peter D. Ridenour's 1908 autobiography (p.271) states his ancestor Nicholas Reitenauer (immigrant, b.1695, took the oath of allegiance at Philadelphia age 44) had a wife whose maiden name was "Rosina Kershner" — notes church/deed/will records show the Kershner family was connected to branches of the Ridenour family across several generations, though a specific shared origin village (a "Rosenthal" in Alsace vs. one found in Hesse, ~40 mi. from Langenselbold) remains unconfirmed; mentions a cousin in West Virginia married to a Ridenour. Offers to lend Vol. II; mentions Ruth Moss Smith of Lexington KY (a Hager descendant) has concluded she and Ruth are "not of the same line," despite apocryphal information that Jonathan Hager's brother David also married a Kershner [cross-referencing the Hager/Kershner material discussed at length in document K-050]. Closes asking about Jonas Kershner (b.1783, son of David Kershner and Elizabeth Olinger), last seen on the 1810 census of Cumberland Co. KY next to Leonard (Cashner) Kershner, and on 1811/1816 Cumberland/Christian Co. KY tax lists — "Would appreciate anything you happen to pick up. Good hunting!"

Page 146

Envelope, postmarked Lexington, KY, 11 Jul 1980 ("Transylvania Bicentennial 1780-1980" commemorative postmark), from "Mrs. Margaret Alice Karsner Murphy, Rt. #3 Monterey, Owenton, Kentucky 40359" to "Ruth Bownds Kershner, 1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin TX 78746." [This envelope, dated July 11, 1980, corresponds to Margaret's first-contact letter reproduced later at Page 154 — the earliest-dated item of correspondence found in this file, marking the start of the Murphy-Kershner exchange.]

Page 147

Hand-drawn pedigree chart, headed "Casner, Augusta Co. Va. 1723 [sic, likely 1773]": George Casner = Margaret (d. by 1798); their children Jacob and "Thomas Lincoln = Elizabeth Casner/Kersner" (m. 23 Sept. 1782; Thomas b. 23 Oct. 1761, d. ca.1845, "from Rockingham Va. ca.1790 to Fayette Co. Ky. where d."; Elizabeth b. 1852-1860 [sic, clearly meant 1752-1760 or similar], "widow, w/son George, d. buried Liberty, Mo."). Their eight children numbered in birth order: John (b. Ky, #6, "1794?"), George Lincoln (#5, b.15 Apr. 1792 Ky), Abram (#4, b. Rock[ingham] Co. Va, "1789?"), David (#7, b. May 1800 Ky), Hannah (#8, b. Ky 1802), Betty (#1, b. Va "1783?"), Kitty/Catherine (#3, b. Ky, "m. Va, [to a] Bowman, never returned to Ky, 1787?"), Margaret (#2, b. Va "1785?"). Below George Lincoln: "James E. Lincoln, letter 1879, letter 1885, 'Dr. Lyman Draper wrong holding Thos. Lincoln my grandfather m. a Winter — she was a Korson or Kershner.'" At bottom: a separate note "George Kirschner of Bern b.1722, m. ca.1743, wife age 14, b.1729," with an age calculation "1768" [apparently checking whether the 1768 death date is consistent with a wife born 1729].

Page 148

Color photograph: an older woman in a blue dress holding a small book/plaque and a wooden commemorative plaque, standing near a framed display with an American flag and a wreath.

Page 149

Handwritten note (apparently the reverse/caption of Page 148's photograph): "Margaret Karsner Murphy, Oct. 10, 1976 in Church Library. The day my first Book was released. The church gave me the plaque as Church Historian. I was only age 58 then, now I'm 62+. I may retire on May 31st?? You can keep this — Rt. #3 Box 186 Monterey, Owenton, Ky. 40359. Phone # 502-484-3932."

Page 150

Typed letter ("-2-" mid-letter page), dated "Oct. 23, 1980," annotated "Copy to Ruth" and "P.S. — my letter to you dated 1/30/1980" [sic, likely 9/30]. "Dear Cousin Mary:" [Mary Kershner Maxwell] from Margaret — explains her reasoning for believing "George [and] Margretha" were her immigrant ancestors, developed independently before she'd read Mary's or Ruth's books; describes revising her estimate of Casper's birth year after reading Mary's history (initially guessed 18-20 at time of Revolutionary service, then aged it toward the 1760s based on wife Eve Lail's age — per Collins' "History of Kentucky," Eve was 14 when captured by Indians 22 June 1780, implying an ca.1766 birth) — "I think I had Casper's birth at first around the early 1760's. But after seeing your history I changed his estimated birth, and put circa before it, to show it wasn't factual." States firmly: "I know our family come from Pennsylvania first because we were always told that by our people. And that they lived in Virginia before coming to Kentucky." Confirms all three of George and Margaret's known children (Jacob, Casper, Elizabeth who married the Lincoln) came to Kentucky, along with widow Margaret after George's death in Virginia. Reports her Harrisonburg VA researcher is looking for George's will. Speculates that since "people frequently named a child for a dead sibling," the family's first child (Elizabeth b.1745, per the PA baptismal records) and last child (also Elizabeth, her own ancestral line) might reflect the first Elizabeth's early death — explicitly flagged as speculation. Notes Jacob was in Kentucky for a while, with his mother living with him at times, and was there when Casper was trying to buy a Lexington church lot — "only his last name then was spelled Kisner" (continues Page 151).

Page 151

Continuation ("-3-"): recounts that by the time of the chancery suit, Jacob was living in Washington Co., Tennessee, having secured lawyers to look after his part of father George's estate (1796); reflects on the length of Casper's own estate settlement (his 1797 death, will burned in a fire, executors' refusal to qualify, land division not finalized until 1813) and that Casper's son John didn't receive his inheritance until after being wounded at Dudley's Defeat in the War of 1812. Discusses her book's progress: over 100 copies pre-sold at $15.00 each ahead of the next summer's reunion; feels overwhelmed balancing scope against health (three heart pills and a thyroid pill daily); has an agreement with her printer to deliver material by chapter starting November 1st, planning to submit the Kentucky material first and the Immigration chapter later, "so as not to tread on anyone's toes," explicitly planning to "state that I stand to be corrected on any part I have written about the immigration days." Signs "With love, the tie that binds, Your Kentucky Cousin, Margaret Alice Kersner Murphy," noting a copy is also being sent to Ruth.

Page 152

Typed document, "=====IN CHANCERY=====," a cleaner early-stage version of Margaret's own family-relationship analysis of the lawsuit (compare Page 120's later, red-annotated version): "Margaret Kersner & Casper Kersner, Complainants, Against Thomas Lincoln, Executor of George Kersner; Elizabeth, wife of Thomas Lincoln and daughter of George Kersner; John, Nicholas, George, Henry, David [bracketed together as] 'Shaffer'; Modelena and husband Philip Rust; Jacob Kersner; Catherine Bowman, Defendants. John Lincoln was attorney in fact." Records the contempt order against non-appearing defendants. Below, Margaret's own working questions to Ruth: "The Shaffer children could have been George and Margaret's grandchildren, and their mother and father dead.? Modelena might have been a daughter? Catherine might have been a widowed daughter or divorced? Have you ever run across any of these names before, in your research? I have written back to Virginia to see if I can get any more information. Margaret."

Page 153

Duplicate photocopy of the May 1801 Rockingham Co. Judgement Order Book #6, pp.413/423 chancery record (same content as Pages 41/84/121) — "Margaret Kersner & Casper Kersner, compl'ts against Thomas Lincoln Executor of George Kersner & Elizabeth his wife, John, Nicholas, George, Henry & David Shaver, Philip Rust & Modelena his wife, Jacob Kersner, Catharine Bowman and John Lincoln, defts."

Page 154

Handwritten letter, "Owenton, Ky, July 11, 1980" — Margaret's introductory first-contact letter to Ruth: "Dear Ruth Bownds Kershner: I am trying to establish who my Immigrant Great Grandfather was and Ancestors. I feel sure we have the same Ancestors, if I can only connect. I would like to buy one of your books 'The Kershner Families of Maryland' 1731-1977 Vol. II. I am writing the history of 'The Karsners of Kentucky.' I have concrete proof back to George Kershner. My George Kershner came from Pennsylvania. His wife was Margaret ---- His children were born in Pennsylvania, Berks County I believe. His known children were Casper born circa 1761, Elizabeth born circa 1763 & she married Thomas Lincoln Sept. 23, 1782 in Augusta County Virginia. He also had another son, Jacob who settled as far south as Washington County Tennessee. Both sons served during the Revolution. I have made application to the D.A.R. under Casper Carsner. The last name is spelled so many different ways, its made research so difficult. George Kershner moved to Virginia and bought land on Brock creek, in Augusta County, deed dated August 17th, 1773. He was listed in the first U.S. Census in 1790 and even before that he was listed in the Augusta County Census 1784. Here he must have lived neighbors to the Lincoln family for his daughter Elizabeth married Thomas Lincoln, a Great Uncle and Great Aunt of President Lincoln. George Kershner died in Rockingham County Virginia in 1796 according to his settlement. I feel like he was a descendant of one of the 3 brothers: Johannes Kershner or Johan George Kershner or John Casper Kershner. Did they have a sister Rosina who married a Ridenour?? Would it be possible that you could help me connect to one of these men, or suggest some one who would help me. Let me know the cost of your book, I need one as soon as possible. Sincerely, Mrs. Margaret Alice (Karsner) Murphy, Rt. #3 Monterey, Owenton, Kentucky 40359." Postscript: "I would like to have your permission to use some of the information in your book. Let me know this, by return mail. Do you know Mary Kershner Maxwell of Vol. I of Kershner History??" [This letter is the origin point of the entire correspondence documented in K-027.]

Page 155

Newspaper clipping, "Florence Times — Tri-Cities Daily — Florence[, Alabama], Thursday Morning November 22, 1973," headlined "Karsner Restoration Color Selected By Owner," annotated "From Margaret Alice Karsner Murphy 1980" and "Ruth." Article by John Park describes public criticism of a "robin's egg blue-green" restoration color chosen for the historic "Karsner House" by the Florence [Alabama] Housing Authority; director Karl Tyree explains the color was authenticated by restoration expert Doug Fuller as the dwelling's original paint, and that "Karsner came to this area from Maryland in the 1820's" — identifying the house's namesake as "Benjamin F. Karsner," back in 1826. [This appears to be an unrelated/tangential Karsner family — of Florence, Alabama, with a stated Maryland origin — included in the file as a curiosity or possible further research lead rather than a documented connection to Margaret's own Kentucky Karsner line.]

Pages 156-160

A five-page cluster of correspondence, entirely about the unrelated Florence, Alabama "Karsner House" family introduced by the Page 155 clipping — collected by Margaret as a curiosity/comparison but explicitly a separate line. Page 156: "Service Engraving, Inc." message/reply form, Indianapolis, IN, dated 3/23/74 and 4/1/74 — "Mrs. Ernest [L.] Karsner" of Brownsburg, IN inquires of Karl T. Tyree (Florence Housing Authority) about the Benjamin Karsner family; Tyree replies the house was built 1828 as part of a Central Office, on the National Register of Historic Places; "Benjamin Franklin Karsner, born Maryland 1800 (or Virginia 1812) in Lauderdale County, Ala., married Sarah McCarter in 1827. They had 10 children but only four known to have lived to maturity: George W. (died [Tuscaloosa] 1912), Robert P. (unknown), Frank (moved to Tuscaloosa, Ala.), and Benjamin Jr., who was last known to be in Louisville, Ky. Are you connected?" Page 157: handwritten letter, "820 Jackson St. S.E., Decatur, Alabama 35601, April 3, 1974," from the restoration architect (name illegible, signs as project architect) to "Mrs. Ernest L. Karsner" — describes tracing the Karsner family via an abstract of title (B.F. Karsner owned/mortgaged the property when built), marriage records, and the 1850 census. Page 158 (marked "-2-"): continues — B.D. [sic] Karsner Sr. was a commission merchant in Florence for many years; son George W. married into the Ingram family of Lauderdale Co., with a granddaughter later found in South Carolina — "the only present relation we know of"; efforts to trace the Karsner name in Maryland and the McCarter name in Virginia have failed so far; speculates, based on excavated silver artifacts, that Sarah McCarter might be related to the Bigger(s) family of Baltimore; notes son Frank Karsner had "a rather brilliant Civil War record," traced to Tuscaloosa, Ala., marital status unknown. Page 159 (marked "-4-"): concludes the restoration is nearly finished; knows of no similar historic house in the family except "the Eden House in Brundidge, [Alabama? Tennessee?]"; lists the family's daughters per the 1850 census, all born in Alabama (Brundelia[?] 24, William 18, Ann Eliza 15, Sarah 12, Mary 10, John 8, Andrew 5, Charles 2; George, listed in another household, 23, born Alabama, merchant); signed "Douglas L. Fuller" [the restoration architect named in the Page 155 clipping]. Page 160: a small newsletter/clipping photo captioned "PRESERVING 'Karsner-Kennedy House'" — confirming the house's fuller historic name. [This five-page cluster documents a completely separate Karsner family of Alabama/Maryland with no established link to Margaret's Kentucky Karsner or the Berks Co./Rockingham Co. Kershner lines — likely retained in this file simply because Margaret, given her years of grappling with the surname's many spellings, collected every "Karsner" reference she came across as a potential lead.]

Pages 161-165

A five-page typed genealogy titled "THE KARSNER LINE," annotated "from Maryland Karsner" and "from Margaret Alice Karsner Murphy 1980" / "Ruth — Sent to me by [torn]" — documenting yet a third, separate Karsner family (this one of the Maryland Eastern Shore/Delaware/Philadelphia area), compiled from information provided by Eleanor Fulton Karsner and Joseph Reed Karsner (1960, Westtown, PA). Page 161 (numbered pages of this document restart at "-2-" through "-4-" after an introductory page not captured separately) begins the line with immigrant "Daniel Karsner," who came to America's Eastern Shore of Maryland in 1774 from the German Palatinate, wife Ann Barbara Esche (family later spelled "Ash"); Daniel returned to Germany for his patrimony and was lost at sea, ship never heard from again; children Daniel(2), Benjamin(3), Elizabeth(4). Daniel(2), a War of 1812 sergeant, married Eleanor Fulton Willock (1813), ten children (Charles, Emily, Mary Louise, Ann Elizabeth, Eleanor, George Henry, Eleanor II, David Fulton, William Clark, Cornelia). Benjamin(3) may be father of "George W. (known as Delaware George)"; mentions a Karsner brick house/homestead at McDonough, Newcastle Co., Delaware, later DuPont-connected, and a gravestone "G.W. Karsner, Co. K, 5th Del. Inf." at Old Drawyer's Cemetery, Odessa, DE; separately notes some Karsners went south to Tuscumbia, Alabama (one served as its Mayor), with descendants including an actress, "Jennie Karsner," who married hotel magnate Stafford (of Stafford Whitaker & Wright) and inherited the Hotel Imperial (NY) and Hotel Walton (Philadelphia) — [likely connected to, or the same family as, the "Karsner House" of Florence, AL documented in Pages 155-160]. Pages 162-165 continue several more generations of Daniel(2)'s descendants in detail: Charles Karsner (1814-1883), a Methodist Episcopal minister who later became a physician (Hahnemann Medical College), married Lavinia Rosalie Millichamp (granddaughter of Revolutionary War officer John Pettigrew of Virginia); his children Charles Waugh Karsner (physician, Philadelphia, US Navy Civil War veteran), George W. Karsner (Union Army cavalry, wounded at Antietam, dramatically found by his own physician father who had a premonition and rushed to the battlefield), Daniel Karsner Dr., James Henry Millichamp Karsner Dr. (Union cavalry, Oroville CA), and Lavinia Rosalie Karsner (m. Charles Tapley of Boston); also covers Emily Karsner (m. John Peach), David Fulton Karsner (1822-1881, seven children), William Clark Karsner (physician, Chesapeake City MD, Civil War Union Army), and Cornelia Karsner (m. Thomas J. Cleaver, Superintendent of the Chesapeake & Delaware Canal); concludes with George Henry Karsner (1843-1921, Cashier of the Baltimore "Sun," witnessed and helped save cash/records during the great Baltimore Fire of Feb. 7-9, 1904, arranging emergency printing in Washington D.C. so the paper never missed a publication day). [This entire five-page document concerns a wholly distinct Karsner family with no documented connection to either Margaret's own Kentucky Karsner/Casner line or the Berks Co. PA/Rockingham Co. VA Kershner line — another instance of the surname's collision risk that this file, as a whole, repeatedly confronts.]

Page 166

Typed letter, dated "20 Aug 1980." "Dear Margaret Murphy:" from Ruth — returns Margaret's draft with sympathetic but firm guidance ahead of her Sept. 27 reunion deadline. Explains in detail how Ruth and Mary's own research into the relationship between immigrant Johannes Kerschner (b.1693, arrived 1733) and his younger half-brother Martin Kerschner (arrived 1742) went through a similar process of over-eager theorizing and correction: a contributor "prepared her line... and stated positively that Martin was the oldest son, in spite of our care in advancing the theory. She insisted on having it printed that way, with her name on it, as an expert DAR membership chairman" — but new German records later proved Martin was actually the youngest half-brother, ten years younger than believed, forcing embarrassing corrections after Vol. I had already gone to the bookbinder. Draws the moral: "We are very glad that we were so cautious about advancing our theory about Martin, because we were wrong... Someone who checks out only her statement will get the wrong information." States firmly: "This is why I am trying to persuade you not to do a composite family sheet on the Pennsylvania George Kershner records together with the Virginia ones." Offers a two-column, two-page comparison report on the possible linkage (with her own name on it) for Margaret to use, "which will get you off the hook a little." Asks Margaret, once past her immediate deadline, to survey Cumberland and Todd Counties (KY) after 1820 for records of Katherine Townsend and Leonard Kershner, probably children of David Kershner (b.1750, d. Christian Co. KY 1816).

Page 167

Typed letter, dated "31 [illegible month] 1980" [context/handwriting suggests July or August 1980]. "Dear Margaret Murphy:" from Ruth — encloses marked Virginia highway maps showing the approximate location of Brock's Creek (a tributary of the North Fork of the Shenandoah River, "probably more backwoodsy today than it was in 1773"); notes she has seen no indication George Kersner was literate in English (unlike Rev. Joh. Casper Kirchner, literate in German/English/Latin), so places little weight on spelling variants as evidence either way. Recommends Margaret call Warren D. Faust after studying the enclosed pages, since "he does need to know the Kershner background in Berks Co. before you talk to anyone there" (he has published a book on the Fousts with Kershner connections across several generations); provides his address, 314 Raymond St., H.P., Reading, PA 19605. Explains her own material in Vol. II on the Maryland-Pennsylvania Kershner connections was "carefully designed not to tread on the toes of" George C. Kershner and Dr. Ammon G. Kershner's 1972 90-page Berks Co. family history, and has Xeroxed all references to George Kershner b.1722 found in that unindexed work. Suggests Margaret tell Warren Faust she raised the possibility that the lack of post-1760s records might mean George moved up the Valley of Virginia rather than dying, or that he simply couldn't write. Raises yet another doubt: "Elizabeth Kershner b.1745, daughter of Joh. George b.1722, would have been too old to be the bride of Thomas Lincoln in 1782, wouldn't she? She was already old enough to be married and thus not need a guardian, in 1768" — implicitly questioning whether the Elizabeth who married Lincoln could really be a different, younger daughter also named Elizabeth (per the family's practice of reusing names).

Page 168

Typed manuscript page (Margaret's own book, marked "5A," "Way it is [used] in Church History," "For Ruth"): quotes Spencer's "History of Kentucky Baptists": "However curious we may be to know more of the early settlers of our country, and the good old soldiers of the Cross, who first bore the tidings of salvation to this great valley, we shall never be gratified till we meet them in 'the house of many mansions.'" Then: "This writer's ancestral lineage from Gasper Carsner, for genealogical information of future generations, is as follows" (noting the spelling "Casper Karsner" was first seen in the obituary of Major Jonathan Karsner, d. Feb. 1, 1856): Gasper Carsner married Eva Lail (from Pennsylvania); children John (b.11 Feb. 1789, d.29 Oct. 1853, settled Owen Co., m.(1) Sallie Patterson 20 Dec. 1814, m.(2) Mary Polly Eaton 7 Jan. 1828, served War of 1812), George (died young), Jonathan #1 (a Major, fought at the Battle of River Raisin 1812, b.11 Mar. 1794, d.1 Feb. 1856, m. Janetta Creath 16 Oct. 1817, settled Fayette Co.), and Margaret (m. Warren Wheeler at Frankfort, settled Franklin Co.) — note: "After Gasper Carsner's death, Eva married William Dunlap at Frankfort." Continues Margaret's own direct line: John and Sallie Patterson Karsner's son Jonathan #2 (named for his father's brother, married Nancy D. Eaton 28 July 1838); their son Jonathan Albert (b.19 Sept. 1815 [sic, likely later], d.8 Apr. 1874, married Margaret Ann Clark 10-27-1873); their son James Henry (married Mattie Agnes Smith, 6-4-1902), "parents of Kenneth Claude Karsner and Margaret Alice Karsner Murphy" [Margaret's marginal note: "Me — From Casper"].

Page 169

Photocopied original will, "Will Book P, p.257," annotated "For Ruth" and "Children by 2nd Husband": the will of "Eve Dunlap" of Fayette Co., Kentucky (Casper Carsner's widow, remarried to William Dunlap) — "In the name of God Amen, I Eve Dunlap of the County of Fayette and State of Kentucky being of sound mind and memory do make and publish the following as and for my Last Will and Testament..." bequeaths household goods, silver, china, livestock to daughter "Catharine Martin" in consideration of her services, with provisions for equalizing shares among her children, naming son "W. Jefferson" and referencing "George W. Dunlap" and "Catharine Martin" — signed with her mark "Eve [X] Dunlap" (annotated in red "her — Lail Carsner"), witnessed by James P. Higbee, J.C. Richardson, and [Wm. Karsner, partly illegible], dated 1st day of June 1841; proved Fayette County Court, July 1842. Marginal note: "Eve Lail, Casper's Wife, son of George. Her 2nd marriage was to Wm. Dunlap."

Page 170

Photocopied title page, "List of the Revolutionary Soldiers of Virginia," Special Report of the Department of Archives and History for 1911, H.J. Eckenrode, Archivist (Richmond, 1912) — annotated "For Ruth," "Margaret Murphy," "Keep," "Copied from Book in Ky. State Historical Library at Old Capitol — Also this same book in Paris Ky. at the John Fox Jr. Library." Highlighted entry: "p.89 — Casner, Gasper. Aud. Acct. XXVIII-A, 267" — with Margaret's red-ink annotation: "Would this give me proof of his service record? Found his name and this No. on page 89 of this book. I've always been told he fought in the Revolution." [This documentary citation is the primary evidentiary basis for the family's claim that Casper Carsner/Karsner was a Revolutionary War veteran.]

Page 171

Virginia State Library "Photocopy Order A-9" form, filled by "Mrs. Margaret Karsner Murphy," dated "January 18, 1980" (one of the earliest-dated research requests in the file), ordering a photostat of "Auditor's Accounts XXVIIA (Oct.-Dec. 1785), Page 267, Entry for Dec. 10, 1785, showing warrant to Gasper Casner 'for militia service.'"

Page 172

Photocopied original Auditor's Accounts ledger page (p.267), "Saturday, 10th December 1785": itemizes various Revolutionary-War-era state payments (Indian Affairs expedition costs, minors' guardianship expenses, militia-related disbursements); the highlighted entry (marked with a red asterisk and arrow): "Do. to Gasper Casner for militia services... 314. 15. 4" — confirming, in the state's own original 1785 accounting ledger, the payment underlying the family's Revolutionary War service claim referenced on Page 170.

Page 173

Blank verso page bearing a "VIRGINIA STATE LIBRARY, FEB 1980" archival date stamp — confirms the timing of Margaret's Jan. 18, 1980 photocopy order (Page 171) being fulfilled in February 1980.

Page 174

Photocopied original Rockingham Co., VA Survey Book A, p.168 (annotated in red "Recd from Virginia this week"): "July the 28th 1795... Surveyed 6½ acres of Land in Rockingham County for George Casner, Assignee of John Thomas of William Russell['s] part of said Russell['s] Warrant for 1000 Acres No.10960 dated 13th Febr. 1703 [red annotation: 'Is this 1703? This means Geo. was in Virginia before 1773?']... Lying between the Lands and adjoining the lines of Peter Shoemaker and his own Land..." surveyed by "Ralph Loftus, Dep. Surveyor" and "Herring, S.R.C." Below, a second survey: "April the 3rd 1794 [sic]... Surveyed 6½ acres of Land in Rockingham County for Jacob Bare, Assignee of Henry Bare..." [an unrelated Bare-family survey using the same warrant series]. [This is the "6½ acres" land record discussed extensively in Margaret's letters — the puzzling early date on the original 1000-acre warrant (1703, apparently a clerical/transcription oddity since Rockingham Co. didn't exist under that name until 1778) fueled ongoing speculation, addressed elsewhere in the file, about whether George Casner might have arrived in Virginia earlier than the well-documented 1773 purchase.]

Page 175

Photocopied 1792 Rockingham Co. VA personal property tax list page (headed "Virginia Rockingham Historical Society"): a columnar list of taxpayers and their taxable property (slaves, horses, cattle, carriages, etc.), including an entry (marked with a red arrow and asterisk) for "Casner George" — taxed on 235 [acres, matching the "George and Margaret Kershner owned 235 acres" figure cited elsewhere in the Date Guide Lines] with associated livestock/property figures. Other taxpayers on the same page include Coffman, Cravens, Conrad, Elmer, Cande, Campbell, Elick, Custard, Crist, Chamgton, Crusman, and Brannaman families — general Rockingham Co. neighbors, none otherwise connected to the Kershner/Karsner research.

Page 176

Continuation of the same 1792 Rockingham Co. tax list, another page: repeats the "Casner George" entry (235 acres, matching Page 175) alongside further neighboring households (Clich Margaret, Coffman Jacob, Custard [Jacob], Crist Andrew, Cherrington William, Coffman David, Crusman George, Crumbaker Peter, Coring John, Custard Conrad, Cauce Paulin, City Peter/Christian, Crumbaker Abraham, Custard Richard, Caplinger Christian, Curtner Jacob, Custard Paul) — general tax-roll context, not independently significant beyond confirming George Casner's presence and acreage.

Page 177

Photocopied 1793 Rockingham Co. VA personal-property tax list ("Persons names chargeable with the Tax &c"): another year's entry for "Casner George" (marked with a red arrow/asterisk), listed with modest taxable property; near his entry, "Custard Jacob" bears a marginal red query "? Maybe son of Geo." — a research note wondering whether one of the Custard-surname neighbors (repeatedly seen alongside George Casner/Kersner throughout the Rockingham chancery records as executor's bond sureties) might actually be a relative rather than merely a neighbor.

Page 178

Photocopied original Fayette Co., KY "Burnt Records, Vol. 8, Page 207 (1796)" — the actual primary-source power of attorney referenced throughout Ruth's genealogy chart (Page 17) and Margaret's own account (Page 137): "...acknowledged by John Smith and Ma[ry] his wife, and the said Mary being first voluntarily relinquished her right of [dower]... Teste, Levi Todd, Cl[erk]." Then, the key document: "Know all men by these presents that we Margaret Kersner [annotated: 'Casper's [mother]'] and Casper Kersner [annotated: 'son'] of Fayette County, State of Kentucky, have constituted and appoint... William Dunlap Esquire our Attorney in fact for the purpose of transacting business for us in the Commonwealth of Virginia respecting the estate of George Kersner deceased [annotated: 'Geo's wife']" — particularly to convey, by sufficient deeds, land sold by Thomas Lincoln [annotated: "Casper's [sister] Elizabeth's husband"] the estate of the said decedent to the proper purchaser(s), collect and sue for and recover all monies or property due to them in Virginia, and give receipts — full power of attorney "as full and ample a manner as we ourselves might or could... Personally present declaring this..." Marginal note (blue ink): "This record is partly burned from a court house fire."

Page 179

Continuation (marked "2"): the document concludes with signatures "Margaret [X, her mark] and Casper Kersner," recorded "Fayette County August Court 1796. This Letter of Attorney was produced in Court, acknowledged by Margaret Kersner and Casper, parties thereto, & ordered to be Recorded. Teste, Fielding L. Turner." Marginal blue-ink note: "Found this in another place — they were separate 2 [pages] because of fire" [indicating the record had to be reconstructed from two separately-preserved fragments after courthouse fire damage]. Below, an unrelated routine entry begins concerning "Hugh Muldrough and [wife]... of Fayette Co... appoint... attorney..." [a different family's similarly-worded power of attorney, appearing immediately after in the record book].

Page 180

Duplicate photocopy of the May 1801 Rockingham Co. Judgement Order Book #6 p.423 chancery record (same content as Pages 41/84/121/153), annotated in red "Ruth" and "This is from the VA side of the 1st two pages" and "mother"/"son" labels added to "Margaret Kersner" and "Casper Kersner," and "daughter" added after "Elizabeth."

Pages 181-184

A four-page typed essay, "Ruddle's Fort Destruction," annotated "To Ruth" — Margaret's own composed narrative marking the 200th anniversary (June 22, 1980) of the event, compiled from Collins' "History of Kentucky" and Maude Ward Lafferty's "Destruction of Ruddle's and Martin's Forts in the Revolutionary War." Page 181: describes the June 22, 1780 destruction of Ruddle's (Hinkson's) Station by Capt. Henry Bird's British/Indian force (over 1,000 regulars, Canadians, Indians, and Tories, with the first cannon used against a Kentucky fort), capturing 470 settlers and marching them 600 miles to Detroit, some as far as Mackinac and Montreal — "one of the most shocking [episodes] in the pioneer period of Kentucky's history"; background on Hinkson's Settlement (built by Capt. John Hinkson, 1779) and Martin's Fort. Page 182: continues the Ruddle's Fort background (Capt. Isaac Ruddle's 1779 resettlement of the abandoned Hinkson site) and quotes an 1826 Kentucky Gazette account of Col. Bird's approach and Capt. Ruddle's forced surrender, with British/Indian prisoners divided among the Indians per treaty terms. Page 183 (marked "#3"): continues the Gazette account — separated families, the march to Martin's Station, the eventual retreat when advancing on Bryan's Station was judged infeasible; a first-hand account (letter of Alexander McKee to Major DePeyster, 8 July 1780) describing the six-pounder cannon that forced the fort's surrender; Governor Jere Morrow of Ohio's later account that "the picketts were cut down like cornstalks" and "twenty persons were tomahawked in cold blood." Page 184 (marked "#4"): concludes with Margaret's own reflections — "Casper Karsner and his wife Eve Lail are the Ancestors of the Karsners of Kentucky from Revolutionary War days... Eve was about age 14 when she was captured, along with her parents, George and Margaret Lail and her brother George, and maybe Peter. Little Johnny was born in Captivity." Describes the Lail children being taken to a Shawnee camp on the Mad River (near modern Springfield, Ohio); the Indians' adoption of two-year-old Johnny Lail after he didn't cry when rolled down a riverbank as a test, securing both his and his three-years-older brother George's adoption; the general prisoner exchange at Greenville, Ohio, Aug. 3, 1795; Johnny's return home while brother George remained with the Indians, married among them, later returned but was deserted by his Indian wife. States "Death claimed Casper in his early thirtys, 1797. Eve Lail Karsner lived a long life, dying in 1842, about age 76. They were parents of 4 children, John, George, Margaret and Jonathan." Signed "Compiled by Mrs. Margaret A. Karsner Murphy."

Page 185

Title page, "Kentucky in Retrospect: Noteworthy Personages and Events in Kentucky History, 1792-1967," Kentucky Historical Society, annotated "Country Doctor Poems" and "Kentucky Wilderness" — a general reference-book title page, likely the source for other Kentucky-history excerpts in the file, with a handwritten note about a copy going to "Margaret Murphy."

Page 186

Typed reference page, "RUDDLES (ALSO CALLED HINKSTON'S AND LICKING) FORT" — a roster of persons known to have resided at Ruddle's Fort when captured, 1780 (drawn from Collins' History and Draper manuscripts), including, highlighted with a marginal check mark: "Sarah (Ruddle) Davis, John Duncan wife and son, John Denton, and wife and Miss Denton, George Finley... Casper Casner (Karsner)" [named directly in this roster of fort residents] — followed by a separate list, "Captain Isaac Ruddle's Company (in 1779-80, at Ruddle's and Martin's Stations, between Paris and Cynthiana)," naming roughly 50 men including "George Lail" — confirming the Lail family's presence in the same company. Reference cited: "Collins History, Vol. I."

Page 187

Newspaper clipping, "Bloody site now peaceful memorial," by Elizabeth Smart, Enterprise Staff Writer — describes a visit to the Ruddle's Fort site (near Ruddles Mill, above the South Licking River) by "Mrs. Margaret A. Karsner Murphy and her cousin, Mrs. John Hawkins (both of Owenton, Kentucky)," commemorating the 200th anniversary of the massacre; recounts the same narrative as Pages 181-184 (Casper Karsner and Eve Lail's capture and eventual marriage, the fate of the Lail children); states "Mrs. Murphy is writing a book about them, 'The Karsners of Kentucky,' to go to press sometime in the fall." Captioned photo shows Mrs. Hawkins and Mrs. Murphy at the stone marker on the Ruddle's Fort site.

Page 188

Continuation of the same newspaper feature ("Enterprise," p.4, "Into the past"): photo of Margaret Murphy and Mrs. John Hawkins entering "the Lair family burial vault which is now the resting place of the 20 people murdered in the raid on Ruddles Fort in 1780. The bones of those involved in the massacre were moved there in 1845. 'Please do not disturb the remains of the sleeping dead' reads the inscription over the top of the tomb."

Page 189

Typed manuscript excerpt (Margaret's own church history, "copied from J.W. Spencer's History of Kentucky Baptists," annotated "Margaret," "From the other book, I compiled 1976, Published in 1976"): a history of Baptist religious life in early Kentucky (Squire Boone, Daniel Boone's family, Rev. Lewis Craig's 1781 "Traveling Church" migration of 600 souls from Spotsylvania Co. VA, Rev. Wm. Hickman, John Filson's 1784 "History of Kentucky").

Page 190

Continuation: recounts the tradition of the first Kentucky church constituted "under an Oak tree"; then Margaret's personal connection: "My fourth great grandfather, Gasper Carsner is mentioned in Collins['] History of Kentucky, page 182, Fayette County, as follows: 'The First Lottery authorized by law, was on Dec. 15th, 1792, to enable John Smith, Benedict Swope, Gasper Carsner, Marten Castle, and Jacob Kisner, representatives of the Dutch Presbyterian Society in and near Lexington, to raise $500.00 with which to purchase a lot of ground and erect thereon a house of worship.'" [Margaret's marginal note: "I think maybe this man was Casper's brother Jacob."] States: "The writer of this history is a direct descendant of Gasper Carsner and wife Eva Lail. They were from Pennsylvania and of German descent. They emigrated to Kentucky about 1780, locating and entering land in Fayette County." Recounts the Ruddle's Station capture narrative again (Eve age 14, brothers Johnny age 2 and George age 5). Margaret's marginal note: "I went to the area where Ruddles Fort once stood the day 6/22/1980 just 200 years from the day it was destroyed and Casper & Eve & her family were captured. They married after this."

Page 191

Continuation: concludes the adoption/exchange narrative (matching Pages 184/190); quotes an obituary from "The Kentucky Statesman" for Major Jonathan Karsner (Casper's son), describing Casper as "a descendant of that pioneer stock... justly entitled to... 'the first settlers of Kentucky.'" Footnotes: (1) John Lail's own biography (settled Harrison Co. KY, married Susan Williams, ten children, died 1869, per "The History of Pioneer Families in Missouri" by Wm. Bryan and Robert Rose, 1876); (2) citation to "The History of Fayette County, Kentucky" by Robert Peter, M.D., ed. William Henry Perrin; (3) clarifying note: "When she was [taken] prisoner this time [a second, later reference conflating two different captivities], Casper had died, and she was the wife of William Dunlap of Frankfort."

Page 192

Photocopied 1850 Census record (Owen Co., KY, Dist. #1, Family 543): "KARSNER, JOHN, age 61, m[ale], Laborer, [value] 375, b[orn] Penn[sylvania], No read or write; Joseph, age 20, [male,] b. Penn[sylvania]" — Margaret's marginal notes: "John's son, our Great Uncle Joe" and "The above John was my Great Great Grandfather. I know he was born in Fayette County Kentucky on Feb. 11, 1789. In the census record above he surely must be referring to his father or where his family was from" [i.e., explaining the discrepancy between John's actual Kentucky birthplace and the census's "born Pennsylvania" entry, attributing it to the family's oral tradition of Pennsylvania origin].

Page 193

Sketch/rubbing of a cemetery headstone (Kentucky), with Margaret's marginal annotations identifying: "John Karsner, Born Feb. 11, 1789, Died Oct. 29, 1853" [oldest son of Casper and Eve Lail]; "Mary [Polly Eaton] Karsner, Born Sept. 26, 1794"; "The Marriage of John Karsner and Mary his wife was the 8th [of] January 1829"; "Mary Karsner Senior died Oct. 12, 1846, age 52"; "Johnathan Karsner, Born September 1815, died April 8, 1874, age 59" [annotated "youngest son... named after John's brother Jonathan #1... half-brother to Uncle Joe... he was 14 when his father John remarried... children of John's 1st marriage to Sallie Patterson"]; "Mary Elizabeth Karsner was born October 10, 1820, departed this life in 1822, death age 2" [annotated "half-sister to Uncle Joe"].

Pages 194-195

Typed letter, dated "18 July 1980." "To: Mrs. Margaret Alice (Karsner) Murphy... From: Ruth Bownds Kershner" — one of the earliest and most substantive letters in the file. Confirms Ruth knows Mary Kershner Maxwell (corresponding since 1965) and has worked with her since 1972 on correcting prior family tradition (e.g., disproving that William Kershner of Monroe Co. VA was a Hessian soldier); describes how her own research into Maryland land records "got sort of out of hand," leading to founding the Kershner Family Association and publishing two volumes, now sold out (but available via 75 libraries, LDS microfilm, or a private film-to-book service, or a "floating copy" loan of Vol. II). Grants permission to use material from either volume but asks to see Margaret's draft first, since research has advanced since publication (citing the corrected discovery that Johannes Kershner's wife was "Gertrude Dietrich," not "Faust" as originally published, and Mary Maxwell's practice of circulating draft corrections before final printing to avoid errors). Confirms familiarity with the Augusta/Rockingham Co. George Kersner deed and chancery records, including Chalkley's abstracts showing "Casper Karsner a witness to Augusta Co. Deed 22:156 (both 1775) and John Casner purchaser from Jacob Gillespy in 21:167"; states "None of these individuals belong to our [Maryland Kershner] line" and identifies a separate, unrelated "David Kershner" (b. ca.1748 MD) whose son Jacob Casner (b. ca.1781) is "named in Philip Olinger's will as his grandson, 1786," married Peggy Gabbert 1801, and had 12 children — flagging yet another same-surname, non-connected Kershner/Casner individual active in the same Augusta Co. area at the same period. Lays out "two possibilities" for Margaret's Pennsylvania connection: First, that Margaret's line descends from Joh. Georg Kirschner (b.1722, son of immigrant Johannes b.1693) — details the four-German-brothers research, the 1768 guardianship petition (George "late of Windsor Twp.," died age 47), the tantalizing 1760 baptismal sponsorship linking Joh. George and wife Maria Margaretha to Conrad's family, and the full list of their five known children (Elizabeth b.1745, Casper b.1750, Anna Maria b.1751, Conrad b.1754, John George b.1756) — while noting the 1768 death date, if accurate, would seem to rule out this George being the same man who bought Virginia land in 1773. Second, the "Rev. Johann Casper Kirchner" possibility (discussed at length elsewhere in the file, e.g. Pages 114-115, 134-135, 144-145).

Page 196

Envelope, postmarked Lexington KY, 11 Jul 1980 (Transylvania Bicentennial postmark), from "Mrs. Margaret Alice (Karsner) Murphy, Rt 3 Monterey, Owenton, Ky 40359," marked "Please Forward," addressed to "The Kershner Family Association, 4603 El Salvador, Houston TX 77066" with a forwarding arrow to "1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin, Texas 78746" [i.e., forwarded on to Ruth].

Page 197

Handwritten letter, "Owenton, Ky, July 11, 1980" — Margaret's first-contact letter to the Kershner Family Association itself (companion to her same-day first letter to Ruth, Page 154): "Dear Sir: I am interested in the Kershner Family Association. I've just heard about it. Here in Kentucky we spell it Karsner. I am writing the History of the Karsners of Kentucky. I have just written to Mary Kershner Maxwell of Vol. I and Ruth Bownds Kershner of Vol. II, [and] to some one working on Vol. III. Do you apply for membership in this Kershner Association? Let me know more about it, please. Sincerely, Mrs. Margaret Alice (Karsner) Murphy."

Pages 198-200

A three-page typed manuscript excerpt (unrelated to Margaret's own line), headed "Solomon Kesner" and annotated "Mail to Ruth & Keep," "Copied at Filson Club, Louisville, Ky." — a fourth, entirely distinct "Kesner" family history (Indiana), attributed to information compiled by "my cousin Cecil Kesner... given to him by our grandfather Ephraim Kesner." Page 198: traces Solomon Kesner (b. ca.1638, Hanover, Germany, during the Thirty Years' War) through son Jacob Kesner (b. ca.1698, Hanover) to grandson Solomon Kesner (b. ca.1738, Hanover; emigrated to America/Virginia ca.1770; served under Washington through the Revolution including Valley Forge; settled in the Shenandoah Valley near Woodstock, VA; married Mary Hammond, eight children; later traded his Virginia land for Tennessee acreage, moved to Jonesboro area ca.1798, then mysteriously vanished while traveling back to Virginia to settle his estate, carrying about $2000 in saddlebags, "never seen or heard of again"). Page 199: continues with Christopher Kesner (b.1793, Woodstock VA, son of the vanished Solomon; illiterate; herded cattle in dangerous mountain terrain as a child; crossed into Indiana ca.1808; served under Gen. William Henry Harrison, fought at Tippecanoe). Page 200: Christopher's later life (two marriages, ten children including Ephraim Andrew Kesner b.1836) and the start of Ephraim Kesner's own biography (Ephraim's Civil War Home Guard service, farming, milling trades, multiple marriages, extensive travels to Texas/Kansas/Oklahoma/Missouri in his old age, death of pneumonia at his son John's house, March 1918). [This entire three-page cluster documents yet another same-surname family with no established connection to Margaret's own Kentucky Karsner line, the Berks/Rockingham Kershner line, the Alabama Karsner-Kennedy family, or the Maryland/Delaware Karsner Line documented earlier in the file — underscoring how frequently this surname's many spelling variants caused genuinely unrelated families to cross paths in genealogical research.]

Page 201

Continuation of the Ephraim Kesner biography (concluding the Page 198-200 manuscript): further Civil War Home Guard anecdotes (Company 127, Scott Township, Indiana, involvement in repelling "Morgan's Raid" river-crossing attempt); later life details (second and third marriages, extensive 1911-1915 travels to Texas, Kansas, Oklahoma, Missouri); death from pneumonia, March 1918, at son John's house. Closing line: "We are indebted to Mrs. Quist for the above manuscript."

Pages 202-203

Photocopied excerpts from "Abstracts of Wills of Augusta County, Virginia," Augusta County Court, Will Book No. 1 (a published Chalkley-type reference work) — annotated "Who would you contact about this or do you see any connection" and, on Page 203, "Caspar and Geo. Ruddle." Page 202: general early Augusta Co. will abstracts (Knox, Willson, Pickens, Martin families, 1745-1746) — general reference context, not directly relevant to the Kershner/Karsner line. Page 203 (the final page of the document): among a list of deed/patent abstracts from 1774-1786, the critical entry: "Page 156.—17th August, 1775. Philip () Nicholas, eldest son of Samuel Nicholas and John Thomas, executors of Samuel Nicholas to Jacob Brunk (of Frederick County, Maryland) on Brock's Creek, patented to William Rutledge, 20th August, 1745, and by him conveyed to Cornelius Ruddle. Teste: Caspar Karsnar, George Ruddle." — direct primary-source confirmation of Casper Karsner witnessing an August 1775 deed on Brock's Creek (the exact creek and year referenced throughout the file as where George Kersner/Casner had settled and where Casper would have been "old enough to witness a deed"), alongside George Ruddle, of the same family whose fort Casper and Eve Lail would be captured at five years later. Margaret's marginal annotation: "Casper must have been a friend of Geo. Ruddle — he was captured at their Fort in Ky[?]." Also on this page: "Page 167.—25th September, 1775. Jacob Gillaspy to John Casner, on Briery Branch, patented to Jacob Gillaspey, deceased, and by his decease vested in said Jacob Gillaspey (grantor) as eldest son and heir" — a second, separate deed record for a "John Casner" in the same county/period, with Margaret's marginal query noting she is "also referring to Chancery suit names" (i.e., cross-checking against the "John Kersner" named as a defendant in the Rockingham chancery suit) and asking whether this could be the same man or a coincidence.