K-041: Letters: Wolgamot, 1973
Kershner Correspondence (Wolgamot and Kemp chancery case)Summary
K-041 Closing Summary
Source: Letters_Wolgamot_1973.pdf Pages: 34 of 34 transcribed
Verified date range
Correspondence January 1973 to January 1978; records from 1731.
Thread classification
Core Kershner, with a cross-reference to the Wolgamot (Wolgamott, Vulgamott) family.
What this document reveals
Papacito and Mamacita's correspondence with mill historian John W. McGrain of the Baltimore County Historical Society, trying to locate Martin Kershner Sr.'s and Jr.'s 18th-century mills on Conococheague Creek. The letters trace deeds, patents (Dutch Folly, Contentment, Conquest, Defense, Green Castle), tax lists and chancery suits linking the Kershners to the Swingle, Van Lear, Shultz, Witmer, Kemp and Wolgamot families. Late letters come from Stephen W. Kershner's home in Falls Church, Virginia.
Most significant facts and leads
- Martin Kershner Sr. gave a deposition on 14 December 1765 about his dam and sawmill and an armed crowd said to be marching on it.
- Includes the Wolgamot and Kemp chancery case.
- No mill location was ever confirmed.
Notes
Stephen W. Kershner, Papacito's brother, hosted them in Falls Church.
Closing summary written 2026-10-18 from the transcript and genealogical index.
People, places and dates
Show the genealogical index
K-041 — Letters_Wolgamot_1973.pdf — Index
Thread: Core Kershner. This document is a research correspondence file (1973–1978) built around the Washington County, Maryland Kershner family's colonial-era land and mill holdings on the Conococheague Creek. The core exchange is between Stuart & Ruth Kershner (Austin, TX; later staying with brother Stephen W. Kershner in Falls Church, VA) and John W. McGrain of the Baltimore County Historical Society, a mill historian. Two additional letters (from C. W. Vulgamott of Southgate, MI, and from researcher "Jeffrey Wyand") concern the separate but land-and-marriage-adjacent Wolgamot/Wolgamott/Vulgamott family, whom the Kershners were investigating as possible in-laws/neighbors rather than direct Mundine-line relatives. No Mundine content appears anywhere in this document. The dominant subject throughout is the Kershner family proper — its mills, patents, and 18th-century land transactions — so it is classified as core Kershner with an embedded Wolgamot family cross-reference.
People
- Martin Kershner (Kirshner/Kersner) Sr. — b. ca. 1715–1720 in Germany (arrived Philadelphia 1731, ship Samuel, under age 16, with parents), miller on the Conococheague, deposed 14 Dec 1765 re: his dam/saw-mill and an armed mob reportedly marching on Annapolis; will written 1769, proved shortly after; d. ca. 1769/70. Held Dutch Folly, Addition to Dutch Folly, Widow's Last Shift, One Shift More, The Contentment (1762, from Daniel Dulany), Walnut Bottom (1752). Father of Martin Jr., George (youngest, "bound to trade"), and daughter Elizabeth (m. George Shultz).
- Johan Gorg (George) Kirschner/Kersner — father of Martin Kershner Sr.; patented two Dutch Folly tracts 1739; d. 1748.
- Anna Kirschner — wife of Johan Gorg; after his death patented Widow's Last Shift and One Shift More.
- Martin Kershner Jr. (Kirshner) — 1743–1817; eldest son and executor of Martin Sr.; resurveyed family lands as "Defense" 1798; described himself as a miller; father of Andrew Kershner (b. after 1783, only son).
- George Kershner (Sr.) — brother of John Kershner; received Dutch Folly/Addition to Dutch Folly/Widow's Last Shift/One Shift More from Martin Sr.'s executors 1773; deceased intestate by 1807 per Martin Kirshner Jr. petition.
- George Kershner Jr. — married a daughter of Nicholas Swingle Sr.; living on/witnessing the Swingle sawmill tract (Dutch Folly) 1787; given power of attorney 1784; assessed 1784 for 386 ac. woods/47 ac. arable; ultimately transferred rights to Martin Kershner Jr. for £350; excluded from father-in-law Nicholas Swingle's estate ("shall not enjoy anything of my property").
- John Kershner — brother of George Kershner Sr.; b. ca. 1742, d. 1822 (Capt. John); boundary dispute with Ludwig Kemp ca. 1800, resolved by four deeds 1800; conveyed schoolhouse land to trustees John Wolgamott and David Newcomer.
- Jacob Kershner — b. 1751, tavern-keeper at Wilson's Store; owned Conquest tract; associated with "Kershner's Ford"; d. 1776 (per separate reference to his 1776 death and 1773 deed from Wolgamots).
- Andrew Kershner — grandson of Martin Kershner Sr. (son of Martin Jr.); operated carding machine and mill ca. 1812, six miles above Williamsport; legatee 1816 of father's dwelling house and mill race; property auctioned 1855 (bought by Jacob Funk, later to Elizabeth Kershner).
- Andrew Kershner Stake — grandson of Andrew Kershner.
- Elizabeth Kershner — daughter of Martin Kershner Sr., b. ca. 1741–1745; married George Shultz (Schultz/Scholtz), d. 1779; served as his executrix.
- George Shultz (Scholtz) — b. 1711 Germany, Schwenkfelder immigrant (ship Merchant, Phila. 1733); husband of Elizabeth Kershner; d. 1779; land purchases 1763–1773 including Little Friendship and Hazard alias Conquest.
- David Kershner — served in "Capt. Kershner's" militia company; father (with Elisabetha Ollinger) of an illegitimate son per Vulgamott family records; migrated to Augusta Co., VA by 1784, then Tennessee, then Christian Co., KY, d. 1816; deacon of Salem (Reformed) Congregation.
- Capt. Martin Kershner — commanded a militia company; Committee of Observation paid for whiskey for his company, 15 Feb 1777.
- Susannah/Susanna Kershner (Volgamet/Wolgamott) — daughter of Jacob Kershner (d. 1776); married David Wolgamott.
- Edward Kerschner — of Norristown, PA; great-grandson of Jacob Kershner (b. 1751); supplied a copy of the Brightwell's Choice patent.
- J.B. Kerschner — listed as a miller at Emmitsburg, Frederick County, in the 1887 Maryland State directory.
- Martin Kircher (no "n") — Maryland General Assembly member and attorney, ca. 41 years old in 1973, school acquaintance of John McGrain; speculated as a possibly related but unconfirmed family member.
- John Wolgamott — will 1774 (Frederick Co.), names sons John and Joseph, daughters Susanna and Mary, wife Mary and Joseph Wolgamot Jr. as executors.
- Joseph Wolgamot(t) (miller) — bought mill property 1745; will 1774 (proved 1775, separate from John's).
- Capt. John Wolgamott — served in Col. Bouquet's unit; witness/officer named in Chancery Records; children young at his death.
- John Wolgamot (nephew/defendant in Kemp suit) — deposed 1823, gave his age as 52 (implying b. ca. 1770/71); dispute over land boundary with uncle Ludwig Kemp; land adjoined John Kershner's.
- General Joseph Wolgamot (per Vulgamott family oral history) — Revolutionary War general, sold land/mill and converted proceeds to worthless Continental script; died age 97; widow died age 106 (dates/century not independently verified in this document).
- Jacob Wolgamot — father of John A. Vulgamott (b. 1821, Holmes County, OH, third of nine children).
- John A. Vulgamott — b. 1821, Holmes Co., OH; acquainted with Abraham Lincoln per 1905 newspaper interview; great-great-grandfather of C. W. Vulgamott.
- C. W. Vulgamott — of Southgate, MI; corresponded with Stuart Kershner Dec. 1977, researching Wolgamot Revolutionary War ancestry.
- Mary Wolgamott — 1783/1790/1803 tax lists, 386 acres Bachelor's Delight; will 1808/proved 1814; children Susan Orendorff, John Orendorff (son-in-law), Polly Schnebly, son David, son John (executor).
- Henry Wolgamott — 1783 Assessment, owned Second Tryal (87 acres).
- Nicholas Swingle (Swingley) Sr. — bought Wolgamott mill properties 1777; will 12 Nov 1784, devised grist mill/Dutch Folly to sons Benjamin and Philip, saw mill to son John George, and named daughter Mary Kershner (wife of George Kershner Jr., who is expressly excluded from inheriting).
- Matthew and William Van Lear — leased/purchased Swingle mill properties 1787–1788; associated with the "Red Mill" and "Irwin/Stone Mill."
- Jonathan Hager Sr. — brother-in-law and co-executor of Martin Kershner Sr.'s estate; d. 1775; married Elizabeth Kerschner 1740 (per ship-list/Bible-record note); patentee of Brightwell's Choice 1763.
- John W. McGrain — Baltimore County Historical Society researcher/mill historian, 34 Willow Avenue, Towson, MD; principal correspondent and source of deed/patent abstracts throughout 1973.
- Mrs. Hilda Cushwa — Washington County land-records researcher (tax assessor's office); traced Kershner deeds; cross-referenced elsewhere in the archive as a Cushwa-family source for Mary Maxwell.
- Jeffrey Wyand — genealogical researcher; authored the Chancery Court explanatory letter (page 1) regarding the Kershner/Wolgamot/Kemp lawsuit.
- William B. Marye — age 87 in 1973, longtime Maryland land-patent researcher consulted by McGrain.
- Barbara Kirchner — Maryland landscape/watercolor artist profiled in an enclosed 1970s newspaper clipping; explicitly noted by McGrain as "the same name, but different spelling," i.e., not confirmed as a relative.
Places
- Conococheague Creek, Washington County, MD — central geographic focus; site of numerous Kershner-, Wolgamot-, Swingle-, and Van Lear–associated mills and land patents (Dutch Folly, Addition to Dutch Folly, Widow's Last Shift, One Shift More, The Contentment, Walnut Bottom, Conquest, Hazard, Free Stone, Defense, Green Castle, Little Friendship, Mountain of Wales, etc.).
- Old Mill Tavern (formerly Kemp's/Wolgamott's Mill), Hagerstown vicinity — stone mill site, extensively researched as a possible original Kershner or Wolgamot mill location; visited in person by the Kershners; flooded by Hurricane Agnes (1972).
- Kershner's Ford / Wilson's Bridge (Route 40 bridge area) — historic Conococheague crossing near the Conquest tract.
- Witmer's (Witmers) Mill — large merchant mill 7 miles from Hagerstown; sold at trustee's sale 1851.
- Huyett's Mill / Huyett site — later an amusement park; traced through Jacob and David Huyett (1865) back to Green Castle/Little Friendship/Pleasant Meadow tracts.
- Upper Marlboro, Prince George's County, MD — 1791 deed, Martin Kershner purchase of town lot in "Hamburgh."
- Leonardtown, St. Mary's County, MD — quilt signed "Susan Kershner 1811" held by local historical society.
- Falls Church, Virginia — residence of Stephen W. Kershner, visited by Stuart & Ruth Kershner in 1973.
- Augusta County, Virginia; Christian County, Kentucky; Tennessee — migration path of David Kershner and family after 1784.
- Holmes County, Ohio — birthplace (1821) of John A. Vulgamott, Wolgamot family branch.
- Monongalia County, (West) Virginia — suggested location for further Wolgamot tax-list research.
- Annapolis, Maryland (Hall of Records) — repository of Chancery Court appellate records and colonial land patents used throughout.
Dates / Events
- 1731 — Johan Gorg Kirschner (Kershner) family arrives Philadelphia aboard ship Samuel; Martin Kershner Sr. under 16.
- 1736 — Heinrich, Abraham, and Joseph Wolgemuth arrive on ship Harle with Jonathan Hager.
- 1739 (2 July) — Multiple 100-acre "Dutch Folly" tracts patented on the same date to Thomas Wells, George Kersner ("Addition to Dutch Folly"), and Charles Higgenbotham.
- 1740 — Jonathan Hager marries Elizabeth Kerschner (Bible record).
- 1742 — Daniel Dulany has "The Contentment" surveyed (patent later dated 1762 after his death).
- 1745 — Joseph Wolgamot's Resurvey on Dutch Folly patented; also date of Joseph Chapline's "Free Stone" certificate referencing "Volgemore's Mill."
- 1748 — Death of Johan Gorg Kirschner; widow Anna patents Widow's Last Shift and One Shift More.
- 21 Nov–22 Nov 1765 — Maryland General Assembly bills concerning navigation obstruction by a dam/saw-mill on Conococheague Creek and a related water-mills act; both ultimately die/are rejected.
- 14 Dec 1765 — Martin Kirshner (Casner), miller of Conococheague, deposes before the Lower House regarding an armed mob reportedly gathering to march on Annapolis.
- 1769 — Martin Kershner Sr. writes his will; dies shortly after; estate proved and executors (Martin Jr. and Jonathan Hager Sr.) named. Also: George Kershner (Martin Sr.'s youngest son) too young to be apprenticed.
- 1771 — Baptism (Salem/Old Zion Reformed Congregation) of an Olinger child, described as a Dunkard-tradition family; only such record found.
- 1773 — George Kershner Sr. and brother John Kershner receive Dutch Folly-group deeds from Martin Sr.'s executors; Philip Olinger migrates to Augusta Co., VA.
- 1774 — Will of John Wolgamott (proved 18 July 1774), naming daughters Susanna and Mary and sons John and Joseph.
- 1775 — Will of Joseph Wolgamot (Aug. 1774) proved 12 Jan 1775; Jonathan Hager Sr. dies.
- 1777 (15 Feb) — Committee of Observation pays Capt. Martin Kershner's militia company for whiskey.
- 1777 (29 May) — Wolgamott estate executors sell mill properties to Nicholas Swingle.
- 1779 — Death of George Shultz (husband of Elizabeth Kershner); Elizabeth serves as executrix.
- 1783 — Tax Assessment records Martin Kershner (Jr.) with two mills and land in Mountain of Wales; also lists Wolgamotts Henry and Mary and Jacob Kershner's Conquest/Hazard holdings.
- 1784 — Nicholas Swingle Sr.'s will devises mill tracts to sons John George, Benjamin, and Philip, and daughter Mary Kershner, explicitly excluding son-in-law George Kershner Jr.
- 1787 — Swingles lease gristmill to Matthew and William Van Lear; George Kershner Jr. witnesses as tenant.
- 1788 — John George Swingle sells part of Dutch Folly to the Van Lears.
- 1790 — Baptism of Susanna (b. 1771) and Maria (b. 1773) Wohlgemuth as adults, "Old Zion" Reformed Congregation, Hagerstown.
- 1794 — Gabriel Friend conveys Green Castle/Mountain of Wales land to Jacob Kershner.
- 1798 — Martin Kershner Jr.'s "Defense" resurvey consolidates family holdings.
- 1800 (27 March) — Four deeds resolve the John Kershner–Ludwig Kemp boundary dispute.
- 1805 (24 Oct) — Federal Gazette advertises the former "Wolgamott's mill," late property of the deceased Nicholas Swingley.
- 1807 — Martin Kirshner Jr. petitions Washington County Court after George Kershner's intestate death; partition and conveyance to Henry Witmer.
- 1808 — Mary Wolgamot writes her will (proved 1814).
- 1812 — Andrew Kershner's carding machine/mill operating six miles above Williamsport; Old Mill Tavern's stone bridge on the National Turnpike built around this time.
- 1816 — Death of David Kershner in Christian Co., KY; Andrew Kershner named legatee of Martin Kershner Jr.'s dwelling house.
- 1816–17 — Samuel Sergeant Van Lear in control of the "Red Mill" per equity testimony.
- 1819 — Wilson's Bridge built, superseding "Kershner's Ford"; road-overseer record distinguishes Kerschner's Cross Roads from Wolgamott's.
- 1822 — Martin Kershner/Wolgamot v. Ludwig Kemp/Henry Kemp Chancery case proceeds on appeal (commission testimony 1822–1823); John Kershner dies (Capt. John, b. ca. 1742).
- 1823 (19 July) — John Wolgamot, age 52, answers final interrogatories in the Kemp chancery suit.
- 1842 — Jacob Kershner conveys land (adjoining Andrew Kershner and John Troupe) to Hoffman.
- 1850 — Abraham Leiter appears in manufacturers census in connection with a mill later linked to the Old Mill Tavern site.
- 1851 (6 Aug) — Trustee's sale notice for Witmer's Mill published in the Herald of Freedom and Torch Light.
- 1855 — Auction of Andrew Kershner's property; tract later deeded to Elizabeth Kershner via Jacob Funk.
- 1856 — Public sale notice (prior to 11 Nov 1856) for property once owned by Joseph Kretzer, adjoining Andrew Kershner and John Troupe.
- 1865 — Jacob and David Huyett acquire mill tract from the Sheriff.
- 1870 — William H. C. Kemp (son of David Kemp) purchases a mill.
- 1880 — U.S. Manufacturers Census records a Kershner/Kircher-named mill operator (transcribed variously as "A.V. Kicher") in Washington Co. District 4.
- 1887 — Maryland State directory lists J.B. Kerschner as a miller at Emmitsburg, Frederick County.
- 1905 — Newspaper interview with John A. Vulgamott recounts Wolgamot family oral history (Gen. Joseph Wolgamot).
- 1972 (Feb.) — Old Mill Tavern property conveyed to Urie, Hamilton, and Old Mill Inc.; Hurricane Agnes floods the site (summer 1972).
- 1973 (29 Jan–6 June) — Core Kershner/McGrain correspondence documenting the mill-location research described above.
- 1977 (26 Dec)–1978 (3 Jan) — Correspondence between C. W. Vulgamott and an unnamed Kershner-family researcher regarding Wolgamot/Vulgamott genealogy and possible connection to the Kershner mill research.
Open Questions
- Was Martin Kershner Sr.'s 1765/1769 mill located at the site later known as "Old Mill Tavern" (Kemp's/Wolgamott's Mill), or elsewhere on the Conococheague? The correspondents concede they cannot conclusively locate it despite extensive deed research.
- What is the relationship between Capt. John Wolgamott (d. young family) and Joseph Wolgamot the miller (d. same era, grown children) — father/son, brothers, or unrelated same-surname men?
- Was John Wolgamot (b. ca. 1770/71 per 1823 deposition) a twin of his sister Susanna, given their closely reported birth dates?
- Is Henry Wolgamott (1783 Assessment, Second Tryal) the same "Henrich" (age 29 in 1736 ship list) as brother to Joseph and Abraham Wolgemuth?
- Is the Prince George's County "Martin Kershner" who bought a Hamburgh town lot in 1791 the same Martin Kershner of Washington County, or an unrelated man of a common name?
- Does the 1770 Frederick County deed / Daniel Dulany land-title dispute have any real connection to the location of Martin Kershner's mill, or is it coincidental ("grasping at straws," per the correspondents' own words)?
- Is Martin Kircher (Baltimore attorney/legislator, no "n" in surname, ca. 1932 birth) a "lost member of the tribe," i.e., an unrecognized relative?
- Is the artist Barbara Kirchner (Harford County) related to the Kershner/Kirschner line, or purely a same-sounding-name coincidence as McGrain suggests?
- What was on the property that David Wolgamott sold for the unusually high sum of £2,000 in 1779 — was it another undocumented mill?
- Does "Martin Kershner of George" (1807 deed) establish a clear father/son chain distinguishing this George Kershner from George Kershner Jr. (Swingle's son-in-law)?
Summary
K-041 is a decade-spanning (1973, with a 1977–78 coda) packet of genealogical correspondence documenting an intensive land-title and mill-history investigation into the Kershner family of Washington County, Maryland, centered on efforts by Stuart and Ruth Kershner (Austin, TX) and Baltimore historian John W. McGrain to pinpoint the location of Martin Kershner Sr.'s and Jr.'s 18th-century mills on the Conococheague Creek. The letters trace overlapping deeds, patents (Dutch Folly, Contentment, Conquest, Defense, Green Castle, etc.), tax assessments, and equity/chancery suits connecting Kershners to the intermarried Swingle, Van Lear, Shultz, Witmer, Kemp, and Wolgamot/Wolgamott families, and include a separate but related exchange with a Wolgamot/Vulgamott descendant (C. W. Vulgamott) and researcher Jeffrey Wyand about a possibly parallel Wolgamot mill and family line. No definitive mill location is ever confirmed. Verified date range of content: 1731 (immigration) to 1978 (final letter), with the great bulk of documented events falling between 1739 and 1887, and the correspondence itself dated January 1973 to January 1978.
Full transcript
Typed from the scans, handwriting included. Unclear words are marked [?]. The original scans are kept in the family archive.
K-041 — Letters_Wolgamot_1973.pdf — Transcript
Source: pgpreview_batch3/K-041/page-01.jpg through page-34.jpg (34 pages)
Page 1
[Continuation of a letter, no letterhead visible on this page; margin has handwritten annotations "Mr. Hale of Records," "age 52," "I have only p. 26," and initials.]
"...of Washington County. The case concerning John Kershner, Ludwig Kemp, John Wolgamot et al. [illegible caption names] vs Henry Kemp. The exact cite is [illegible] Chancery B139. John Wolgamot's deposition being on page 25, as you [illegible]. Pardon me now if I digress into territory that [is old hat] to you. The courts of Maryland are and always have been divided into equity and law. In all the counties except Baltimore City there is no distinction in who is the judge, etc. There they have a special courtroom [for equity] in which there is never a jury for an equity [case]. The judge is called a chancellor [following] the origin of the court in England under Henry VIII whose first Lord Chancellor was St. Thomas More. Hence the name chancery. Equity acts via orders, injunctions, etc., although money damages can now be awarded in an equity court here, if that is the appropriate remedy even though circumstances suggest that the action originate in equity. That is if the remedy sought be an order or, in the alternative, damages, equity is the proper place to begin, since law courts don't ordinarily issue orders. Anyway, these land disputes were actions in equity. This case started out in Washington County in the March 1822 term of Court, if not earlier. From that March hearing or proceeding, there was filed a motion to dissolve an injunction. An appeal was taken, that is to say. In those days a separate appeals court existed for actions in equity called the Chancery Court. It went out of business sometime before mid-century (19th). What we have here is the appeal to the State court and that's why the records are in the Hall of Records (state records, not county). The normal practice was followed here. The Chancellor sent down an order to one John Price, Esq. (I'm rather certain he was the sheriff of Washington County) to convene a commission to take testimony concerning the controversy. I.e., the whole case was reviewed on appeal, but a new record was created. I have no idea why this procedure was followed, that's not how it is done today. The commission came down 12 Feb. 1822 (p.25). A commissioner had been appointed by 30 May 1823. Between that time and the adjournment following Wolgamot's and others' depositions nearly two months expired. The next meeting was on Saturday July 19 1823 at which time Wolgamot, presumably still 52 years of age, answered the last of the defendant's interrogatories. He had completed the complainant's and all but one of the defendant's in the previous meeting. (We wouldn't call those interrogatories anymore if we were speaking strictly.) So John must have been born about 1770 or 1771. Are you sure about Susanna's date of birth? Could they have been twins? (Last interrogatory at later session is on page 26).
Research time and writing took about 1½ hours for this report.
Sincerely yours,
Jeffrey Wyand"
Page 2
Letterhead-style personal correspondence, dated 3 January 1978, addressed "Dear Mr. Vulgamott:"
"We appreciate your outlining your field of interest with regard to your Vulgamott/Wolgamot research. Revolutionary War records are a field we leave to others, while we concentrate more on the land records and interpersonal relationships of the Colonial period.
We have nothing for sale and prefer to work on an exchange-of-information basis. I did ask that your name be placed on the Kershner Family Association's mailing list for the forthcoming volumes, but if you will be researching the Hall of Records or in Washington County, you will be able to use them at no cost by early summer. In any case, the Wolgamot records you might be interested in are all in Volume II, and we would much prefer that you did not order Vol. I even if you should want some of the Kershner material. There will be a very limited edition, and probably not enough for members of the family. Much of the Wolgamott data turned up as a by-product of research and was not germane to the Kershner books. It is only offered to you as a friendly act.
I am interested in knowing the religious affiliation of the Wolgamotts. In the period in which we specialized, there are only a few of the many church records which have survived. I have copies of the Salem baptismal records of Rev. Jacob Weimer, which he began on his appointment to the Conococheague area in 1770. These were translated by some unnamed person and are in the Maryland Historical Society at Baltimore, with photocopies of the hand-written records also available through the Mormon Library. I read them at Salt Lake City, but made complete photocopies of the typed ones at the Washington Co. Free Library. I understand that the original German records were lost in a fire after the Translation was made, but Rachel (Mrs. Frank) Schwartz, author of "Old Zion", saw them in the original, and is quoted as saying Pastor Weimer's German word, translated as "illegitimate", would have been more correctly translated as "un-ethical". At the time Weimer came to the Conococheague, the Church of the Brethren and other popular sects had made serious inroads into his Reformed Congregation, and he took stern measures to regain his lost sheep.
We have turned up many examples of refusal to recognize the ordinances of rival ministers. The Reformed and Lutheran pastors regarded with horror the unordained, uneducated Brethren, Moravians, etc., who, as a matter of principle, kept no records, and refused to support superstitious sacraments of the church.
It seems pretty sure that the Olingers, who probably migrated from York Co. Pa., were not either Reformed or Lutheran, and there is a tradition that they were Dunkards. Certainly their name never turned up again after that one baptismal ceremony in 1771. The Kershners were Reformed, and David Kershner subsequently served as a deacon of Salem Congregation, Apparently he made his peace with Pastor Weimer, for at the baptism of his next child, he and Elizabeth were labeled "both married". The Wolgamotts did not again appear in Salem records, and though I certainly did not expressly search for them in all records, the only other one I noticed was the baptism of Susanna and Maria, daughters of Joh. Wohlgemuth/on 14 Aug. 1790 ("Old Zion"--the Reformed Congregation at Hagerstown, p. 43, Wash. Co. Free Library). Susanna, born 15 July 1771, and Maria, born 15 February, 1773, were "baptised as grownups".
Susanna and Mary were named as daughters in the will of John Wolgamott, made 7 June 1774, proved 18 July 1774 (Frederick Co. Wills A-1:498), which you no doubt have. His sons, John and Joseph, under age, were to pay the legacies to the girls. His wife, Mary, and Joseph Wolgamot Jr., were named executors. Obviously, the executor, Joseph Jr., cannot be the son, who is not of age yet, and we suspect he is the heir and executor named by Joseph Wolgamot 2 Aug. 1774 (Frederick Co. Wills A-1:528, proved 12 Jan 1775)."
Page 3
"3 Jan 1978 p 2"
"The executors, Joseph, David, and Catherine Wolgamott, sold the mill properties mentioned in the will, 29 May 1777 (Wash. Co. Deeds A-29), to Nicholas Swingle, having come to terms with Thomas Ringgold over their conflicting claims to the 520 acres Resurvey on Freestone, across the Conococheague from the present "Old Kemp's Mill". We corresponded extensively with John W. McGrain on this: you will find a copy of his "Mills-ography of Maryland" in the Western Maryland Room at the Wash. Co. Library. Also, we obtained copies of the surveys and platted the ones relating to the Wolgamott's Mills. Nicholas Swingle's will, 12 Nov. 1784, devised to his sons Benjamin and Philip, the tract "with the grist mill, 112 acres, Dutch Folly and Resurvey on Dutch Folly", and this right of Thomas Ringgold which is signed over to me by Joseph and David Wolgamott". He had paid the Wolgamott heirs L 2500 for it in 1777.
We went into this so extensively because Johann Görg Kirschner patented a tract called Dutch Folly in 1739, also an adjacent one called Addition to Dutch Folly, and because we knew his son, Martin Kirshner (b. ca. 1720) was a miller. But the Wolgamott's Dutch Folly was patented originally to Thomas Wells, also in 1739. Joseph Wolgamote had the Resurvey on Dutch Folly patented 18 Feb. 1745. We used the surveyors' calls in the Wash. Co. Land Records Book 1 (Patents), but suggest you use the originals in the Hall of Records if at all possible. The abstracts we used are full of errors. However, I would be happy to lend you the plats: they are on the same scale, 600'=1", as the current Wash. Co. Tax Maps, and can be overlaid on those maps to get a good fix on the locations. It might save you some time.
Perhaps you are trying to connect your family records with public records, a really fascinating problem. Oral tradition tends to become compressed in time, and the characters get somewhat mixed up, but it is an excellent clue.
It does seem to me that the Wolgamott family of Washington Co., with the mills, has common elements with that of your ancestor, Joseph Wolgamot who sold his land and mill, although you do not mention dates. There was apparently a military tradition in the family, witness Capt. John Wolgamott and Sgt. David Wolgamott. David was unmarried at the time of his father's will, 1774, as was one sister. Three sisters were married, and probably the oldest child, Joseph, was too. Washington Co. Md. Deeds K:438, 1797, names as grantors "Joseph Wolgamot and wife Ulia": I take her name to be Julia, probably Julianna. I was fascinated by your mention of their divorce and would appreciate copies of your records. I think it wouldn't be necessary to get a divorce unless they were married. Joseph and "Ulia" were of Monongalia Co, Commonwealth of Virginia, in 1797, but I do not have the text or abstract of the cited deed.
Philip Olinger migrated to Augusta Co. Va. by 1773, followed by David Kershner and his wife Elizabeth about 1784. Philip Olinger devised to his grandson Jacob (b 1781) in his will of 1786, and David signed a permission for his son (under age) to marry there in 1801. That same year, David and Elizabeth and at least two younger children left for Tennessee, then went to Christian Co. Kentucky where David died in 1816, naming as executor his son Jonas (b 1783 and baptised at Salem), and devising to wife Elizabeth. Other Washington Co. residents migrated to Augusta Co. Va., including Capt. John Wolgamott's brother-in-law, Nicholas Shaver, by 1778. Enclosed carbon copy of deed is for you to keep.
Only two Wolgamotts are mentioned in the 1783 Assessments. Henry owned 87 acres, called Second Tryal, 5 horses and 6 cattle. This tract was north of and adjacent to Hookes Neglect and Black Oak Levels, owned by Jacob Kershner at his death in 1776, and west of Nicholas Shaver/Schaeffer's Long Stripe. John and Mary Wolgamot sold 31½ acres to this Jacob Kershner in 1773 (Fred Co Deeds S:73), part of Bachelor's Hope, Felty's Fortune and Felty's Addition. I have a fix on"
Page 4
"3 Jan 1978 p 3"
"the age of John and Mary's son John (underage in 1774), found in Chancery Records 139,5: in testimony taken 1823 with regard to a suit by his uncle, Ludwig Kemp, John Wolgamot stated he was age 52. The dispute was about boundaries of land adjoining John Kershner (Capt. John bc 1742, d 1822). I also enclose another carbon, a deed made by Capt John Kershner, conveying land for a schoolhouse to John Wolgamott and David Newcomer as trustees. I have not happened on any other record for Henry Wolgamott and don't know who he was.
The other Wolgamott in 1783 was Mary Wolgamott, 386 acres of Bachelor's Delight, 9 horses, 15 cattle, and two slaves. In the 1790 census, she was the only Wolgamott, her family consisting of one male above 16, one under 16, and three females, which seems to fit her known family rather well. (I should have mentioned that I have only the 1783 Assessments for Conococheague and Salisbury Hundreds, west of Hagerstown and including Clear Spring. There could have been additional Wolgamotts elsewhere in the county: the card index at the Hall of Records would give you a quick answer to this.) Mary Wolgamot made her will 18 July 1808 and it was proved 28 Feb. 1814 (Wash Co Wills B:282). She was careful to keep the principal out of the hands of her children, Susan Orendorff and John Orendorff her husband, and her daughter Polly Schnebly, and her son David. Her son John, executor, got all the rest of the estate.
The only other early extant tax list is that of 1803/1804. Mary Wolgamot still owned her part of Bachelor's Delight, but John Wolgamot now owned Second Tryal, both in Salisbury Hundred. I do not have Conococheague Hundred. There is a photocopy in the Maryland Room as well as at the Hall of Records, but no index at Hagerstown. In 1778, David Woulgemot was in John Cellars' list, along with other people who lived north of the Conococheague-Hagerstown Road, and Joseph Wolgamot was in John Barnes', who lived in the Clear Spring area.
The only mention of a Jacob Wolgamot that I have noted was a deed in Wash. Co., G:116, 1790, grantors Jacob Wolgamot and wife Magdalena. I also noted one (N:168, ca. 1801) John Wolgamot and wife Magdalena, grantors. We have found it very worthwhile to look up all deeds indexed to the surname we are searching, and to follow up all apparent connections and look up their deeds, too. We found these while looking for Susannah, Volgamet, daughter of Jacob Kershner d. 1776. Wash Co Deeds B:67, 14 June 1779, David Wolgamott, farmer, sold to Harmon Clapper 100 acres, Griffiths Purchase being part of tract Nazareth beginning at the original beginning of Nazareth... This was near or adjacent to the mill property. And the deed ended "then came Susannah Wolgamott wife to within named David Wolgamott and relinquished her dower etc"... He got L 2000 for the property, and I can't help wondering what was on it that was so valuable. Another mill? If you ever find out, let us know.
I noticed Heinrich, Abraham, and Joseph Wolgemuth on the ship Harle's list with Jonathan Hager in 1736. Hager married Elizabeth Kerschner in 1740, one of the very few Bible records that have survived.
If you could supply me with some dates, I'd be happy to watch for your Jacob Wolgamot. You probably have census records from Ohio. Probably your Wolgamots, like our Kershners, migrated early from Washington Co. Md., so our common interest is prior to 1800 there and probably in Virginia later. If you can manage to visit the Virginia State Archives, ask for the personal and real estate tax lists of Monongalia Co. These are originals, unpublished, and are in folders in big black boxes. They'll let you have only one box at a time, and they are not indexed, but within each county, each of the several tax assessors (or militia captains or whatever the title was) alphabetized his own list, so it doesn't take all that much time to search. Not all years since 1783 have survived, but we were successful in building up a series of lists that showed the name of each additional son as he became 22 and was added by name."
Page 5
"3 Jan. 1978 p 4"
"I am curious about the relationship of Capt. John Wolgamot to Joseph Wolgamot, miller. They died about the same time. Capt. John's children were very young when he died; Joseph's were all grown, and he had bought the mill property in 1745--30 years before his death. The Joseph on the ship Harle was 20 in 1736, and apparently had brothers Abraham, 22, and Henrich, 29. Was Henrich the Henry who owned Second Tryal in 1783, and did John inherit it by 1803? Or was John--Capt. John--an elder son who pre-deceased Joseph the miller? The indexes (with errors) are also available in Washington Co. courthouse, but all the records with the exception of the balance books have been transferred to Annapolis and they have not even any copies at Hagerstown. I have not been able to get a good fix on the age of Joseph Wolgamot Jr., son of the miller.
Should you become interested in tracing the history of the old mill, we suggest caution when you read the local newspaper features and the Cracker Barrel articles. They'd have you believe every stone was put there in 1740. We think parts of the building may date from the late Revolutionary period (it's been damaged by floods over and over), but the machinery is turbines--hardly a type that was used back then. You might consult Paula Stoner Dickey, who did a survey of Washington County Historical Sites last year. Her office was in the county office building, 33 West Washington St., Hagerstown, Md. 21740, and I think it would be forwarded to her if you send mail there. I notice she is an art historian and worked previously at the Museum of Fine Arts in Hagerstown.
John W. McGrain had little on the Swingle Mill before their ownership, but probably has more since we have been working together on it. He has excellent descriptions of the premises from newspaper notices at the times of the various later sales. Actually, there were at least three mills, and our research suggests that Wolgamott built his across the river--Conococheague Creek, rather--from the present site. I think he had at least two different ones. McGrain's address is 34 Willow Avenue, Towson, Md. 21204, phone 301-823-1849 (1649?). Someone told me McGrain is a pseudonym for literary purposes. I haven't asked him.
We wish you good hunting in 1978."
Page 6
Letter dated December 26, 1977, from 16714 Quarry, Apt. C1, Southgate, MI. 48195. Addressed to Mr. Stuart Kershner, 1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin, Texas 78746. Re: Vulgamott/Wolgamot Genealogy.
"Dear Mr. Kershner:
Thank you for your letter of December 18, 1977, concerning the Kershner and Wolgamot families.
We are aware that David served in Capt. Kershner's company and we have census information concerning Susannah in Ohio.
Our records show that David Kershner and Elisabetha Ollinger were the parents of an illegitimate son and that Joseph Wohlgmuth and Juliana Ollinger were the parents of an illegitimate daughter. We also show the divorce of Joseph and Juniana but no marriage of either couple.
We also have Orderly Book and other information about Capt. John Wolgamott in Col. Bouquet's unit.
From a 1905 newspaper interview with my great-great grandfather, John A. Vulgamott (who was well acquainted with Lincoln) we learned that while in Ohio he remembers his grandfather, Revolutionary War General Joseph Wolgamot who died at age 97 and his widow died at age 106. The General sold his land and mill and converted it into Continental script which was later worthless.
John A. was born 1821 in Holmes County, Ohio, the third child of nine to Jacob Wolgamot.
We have located the Wolgamot land and mill from the eighty pages of documents from the Hall of Records at Annapolis, Md. and in May, 1978, will be in that area again for further research and photographs.
Our primary interest at the moment is locating a Joseph who served as an officer for the American cause and had a son named Jacob. Would you please advise if your publication will help us in this area.
In any event, please describe briefly what you have and the cost.
Very truly yours,
C. W. Vulgamott"
Page 7
Handwritten note/card, addressed "John W. McGrain, 34 Willow Ave, Towson Md 21204" with heading "Re: Volgamotts Mill" — remainder of card is blank. Bottom edge marked "CLASS" (part of a "FIRST CLASS" mail indicia, image cropped).
Page 8
Envelope. Return address: "Baltimore County Historical Society, Inc., Agriculture Building, 9811 Van Buren Lane, Cockeysville, Maryland 21030" (address partly struck through), sender "J. McGrain, 34 Willow Avenue, Towson, Md. 21204." Postmarked Baltimore, MD, JUN 21, 1 PM 1973 (8-cent Eisenhower stamp). Addressed to "Mr. & Mrs. Stuart Kershner, 1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin Texas, 78746."
Page 9
Short note, ruled index-card stock:
"Dear Mr. & Mrs. K.,
Thank you for the gems from Frederick County Wills, etc. You certainly can find your way around in those Maryland records. Enclosed is a lady of the same name, but different spelling. Just throw it away if it isn't one of your tribe.
Yours truly, John McG. John McGrain"
Page 10
Newspaper clipping, "THE AEGIS, BEL AIR, MARYLAND." Column "ART TALK by Paul D. Gilbert — With News of Harford Artists." Feature headlined "MARYLAND ARTIST BARBARA KIRCHNER stands beside a display of some of her landscape paintings," subheading "Barbara Kirchner — Lovely Lady With A Touch Of Magic!" Article profiles artist Barbara Kirchner of Jarrettsville, a native of Carroll County, describing her studio, family (husband Charles, three sons Michael, Jeffrey [16], David [13], and daughter Myra [15]), her training under W. Reginald Watkins, F.R.S.A., and James G.A. Murphy in Baltimore, her memberships (National League of American Penwomen, Baltimore Watercolor Club, The Art Guild, Rehoboth Art League, Harford Artists' Association, Maryland Institute Alumni Association), exhibition history, and an award-winning painting "Antietam Station" (watercolor, Gold Medal) and "Outer Sanctum" (pastel) and "New Windsor Barn" (oil). Sidebar items: "Harford Artists' Notes" re Locks House Sketching and Million Dollar Mile painting competition; "Dubree In Nevada" — brief item on USAF Sgt. Steven T. Dubree of Aberdeen. [This clipping was enclosed by John McGrain per page 9's note, as "a lady of the same name [Kirchner/Kershner], but different spelling" — not directly part of the Kershner/Wolgamot line but kept with the correspondence.]
Page 11
Handwritten notes on lined paper, largely a research memo to self, partially [illegible]:
"Letter to McGrain — [illegible] 14 cop. — re Kemps Mill. re — Vanlears steam merchant mill Equity 10:489 — Irwin Mill [illegible] references — Brightwells Folly 1763 — also twin + Vanlear Manor"
Page 12
Letter, letterhead "34 Willow Avenue, Towson, Md. 21204," dated 24 May 1973. "Dear Mr. & Mrs. Kershner,"
"Thank you for the recent plat and the Xerox of part of Tax Map 48. That was your letter postmarked Nashville, May 1; it arrived here May 22. That isn't bad under the present postal service; that is about how long it took for a letter from my street corner to go 7 miles.
I found two Kershner crumbs without looking for them. (1) In Upper Marlboro, Prince George's County, there is a deed of 1791 wherein Martin Kershner bought Lot No. 142 in the town of Hamburgh; it was 80 x 230 ft (Liber JRM 1:31).
Then down in Leonardtown, St. Marys County, the historical society museum (the former jail on the courthouse lawn) has a large quilt with a corner block signed "Susan Kershner 1811."
I don't have the metes and bounds of Free Stone in the house. It looks as if Old Mill Tavern may wind up on that tract -- which will add to the mystery. I'm sure the existing structure is a reconstruction -- but of what year, I can't say.
The "Red Mill" I looked up is the one on Tax map No. 48 in the parcel marked "Darius Forsyth" on the west side of the old road that is now bypassed by Maryland 63. The mill is a little above the point where the Western Md. Railroad cuts across the old road. The stream there is called Semple Run, farther upstream on the Md. Geological Survey map. I was surprised to find it called red, because it has long been covered with shingles. The point where the railroad crossed the old road was the village of "Kemps."
There is nothing unusual about discrepancies in old surveys. I talk to Mr. William B. Marye every so often -- he is 87 and has been digging in Maryland patents for more than 50 years and he still can't resolve some questions. Even the big square or rectangular parcels would be intruded upon by later surveys. I keep declaring my mill book finished, but also keep squeezing in irresistible bits of data that turn up.
Very truly yours, John W. McGrain"
Page 13
Letter, dated 6 June 1973, from "% Stephen W. Kershner, 6667 Van Winkle Dr, Falls Church Va. 22044." Addressed "Mr. John W. McGrain, 34 Willow Ave, Towson Md, 21204." "Dear Mr. McGrain:"
"We spent a couple of days in Hagerstown on our way up here, and were delighted to find your note. Thank you for the Kershner crumbs -- I am so glad you are [tuned] in on Kershners.
We had half an hour in Upper Marlboro courthouse last summer and have been perishing with curiosity about those deeds. Besides JRM 1:31, there was another Jacob Funk to Martin Kershner indexed, AA:2, but the courthouse closed on us and we never did get to look them up. I don't find Hamburg on my trusty road map and have no idea what was going on in Prince George's Co in 1791 with Martin Kershner. Of course, it may have been a different man. It was a popular name, and Pennsylvania was full of Martins, Georges, and Jacobs at the time. The quilt-block reference is certainly a new one, and absolutely only the first reference of that kind I can put down!
Thanks for the Red Mill pin-pointing. We are hoping to get another day at Frederick or Hagerstown and can check the location.
We ran down the Walnut Bottom tract, BC & GS # 17, 368, 1752 patent to Martin Kershner, with the idea it might be the "place and mill on Bottomeck". Sold by his executors O:373, 1771, it has ever since been kept in one piece and is now owned by Ellis E Strite 320/690. The executors got L 150 for the 100 acres, and of course no mill is mentioned. Adam Piper, Blacksmith, added to it Tar Hill, 50 ac, kept it eight years, sold 1779 (A:518) for L 1760 to Martin Sidener (may have meant Snider). This seems a large increase in value. Martin Sidener or Snider conveyed it in 1786 (D:740) to John Rush, who conveyed it to Abraham Heabling 1793 (H:318). Snider lost money on it but still got L 770, and it was back to an average price in the next transaction. So if this was a mill there on the Conococheague in the bend next above Kemps, the blacksmith must have put a lot of work on it, which the next owners allowed to deteriorate. No mill was mentioned in any of the deeds, but the tract was bounded by the middle of Conococheague Creek, and on the east.
Prince George's index also had Y:249, Peter Bumgardner to Thomas Wells. Martin Kershner's [illegible] 1762 patent for The Contentment (Wash Co. 1:19) (not to be confused with his Contentment, Trouble with Contentment, etc.) mentioned Bumgarners Mill-Feltigraws road as its beginning. This tract apparently lies right across the present US 40/Md 63 intersection at Huyett. Felti-Grau or Groh adjoined Broadfording Road. Thomas Wells was patentee to the Dutch Folly of Wolgamotts Mill, 1739, said to have been born 1717, son of Robert 1693-1771 who owned Canneau Botham. Thomas Wells also owned Luberland: Andrew, son of Thomas' brother Robert b 1728, said he was born 1755 "two miles from the mouth of Conococheage Cr on Potomac in Maryland."
I wouldn't want to slow your book, but include another crumb. Maybe you have it."
Page 14
Handwritten note, letterhead "STUART G. & RUTH B. KERSHNER, 1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin, Texas 78746":
"Maryland Room, Washington Co. Free Library, Vertical File, Van Lear
Mrs. Nancy Findley Boyle writes: 'Matthew Van Lear built a house in the late 1700's... land originally granted to Hugo Parker 1750, known as Salisbury Tract... My great grandmother, Mary Irwin, 'sat under the trees and' nursed the twins born 1783... My father married 1861'
[Note that twins are here associated with Van Lears -- you mentioned an Irwin mill.]"
Page 15
Letter to Mr. John W. McGrain, 34 Willow Avenue, Towson, Md. 21204. "Dear Mr. McGrain:"
"Enclosed are some plats that may relate to the location of Thomas Wells' Dutch Folley. These are just tracings of some we did and are for you to keep. Also we have included a small section of the Washington Co. Assessment map that seems to include part of the area you indicated.
Our maps do not name Semple Run or the village of Kemps Mill, and we are unsure of the location of the Red Mill. But we located the Old Mill tavern, which is extremely visible, when we were in Hagerstown.
These plats are a sort of synthesis of three tracts or surveys, and all were copied from the Washington Co. Land Records, which in turn are typed abstracts of the original patents or surveys, apparently. We have discovered a number of errors in copying, and we may have added some errors ourselves, so sometimes these plats just do not come out. We have indicated the places there seem to be errors. I am sure later surveys would straighten these out, but these are all we have.
The interesting thing is that, once these three tracts fitted together pretty well, and we shuffled them around on the big map, the same thing happened as when we were trying to locate the Kershner Dutch Folly. Some lines jumped into focus, some existing property lines and two corners with the right courses for Thomas Wells Dutch Folly. So we thought you'd be interested.
This Dutch Folly begins on a tree in the east bank of the Conococheague, as does the Resurvey on Free Stone -- the same tree, and so does the Joseph Wolgamot Resurvey on Dutch Folly (1:27) which refers to a deed for 38 acres of the original. So it seems likely that these two tracts, or three tracts, fitted together in some way.
If this tentative location proves to be correct, it looks as though the stone mill was not on Dutch Folly, or I should say, is not now. I don't know where it was then. It looks as though it would be on the Resurvey on Free Stone. We don't have the original of Free Stone.
The 1804 Assessment charges Benjamin Swingley and Philip Swingley's heirs each with 67 acres of Dutch Folly. Benjamin and Philip inherited the grist mill, John George Swingley the saw mill. But Mathew Van Lear has Free Stone, 183 acres valued at 7/ per acre, and Hugh Hyland has part of Free Stone, 108 ac @ 17/. But how about Henry Stine, who has part of Dutch Folly, 1 acre, value 400/ ?
We'll keep an eye out for Henry Stine.
Sincerely,"
Page 16
Handwritten notes, headed "Old Mill" — "1804 Assessment":
"Hugh Hyland pt Salisbury 177 12/, pt Free Store 103 17/ } 195.15.0 Benj. Swingley pt Dutch Folly 67 32/ 106.14 Philip Swingley heirs " " 1 ac 400/ 20.0.0 HENRY STINE Mathew Van Lear Free Store 183 7/ 64.1.0 William " " Nazareth 93 32/ 148.16.0"
Page 17
Letter dated 26 April 1973, to Mr. John W. McGrain, 34 Willow Avenue, Towson, Md. 21204. "Dear Mr. McGrain:"
"We deeply appreciate the information you have sent us and the expertise and time you have applied to our problem of locating the mill of Martin Kershner Sr. on the Conococheague in 1765.
Thank you for checking the Fridinger tract out, and confirming our guess about location of George Kershner's 1739 Dutch Folly. Indeed it is not a tract near Thomas Wells' 1739 Dutch Folly which you have identified, and we are sure correctly, as the present Old Mill Tavern.
You can hardly mention a name in pre-Revolutionary records of that area that the Kershners were not intermarried with or otherwise involved intimately, including Kemps, Van Lears, Swingles, Wolgamots, Abraham Leiter, etc., so it will be easy for us to keep an eye out for transactions prior to Abraham Leiter's 1850 mill record back to the Van Lears.
The second Van Lear Mill called the Irwin Mill, your reference Y:234 Peter Newcomer to Samuel B. Clagget, and its location, Brightwells Choice, patented to Jonathan Hager 3/3/1763 (Wash Co I:138) 50 A., begins at lower end of a bottom on the west side of the Conococheague Creek opposite Joseph Irwins. This tract is identified by the descendants of Jacob Kershner b 1751 as a part of his Conquest farm, and is across the creek from the present-day bridge, now owned by Harold E. Snively. "Kershner's Ford", according to W. Norman Reed, here crossed the Conococheague before Wilson's Bridge was built in 1819, and Jacob Kershner had a tavern at Wilson's Store.
In the 1783 Assessments, Jacob Kershner is charged with part of "Conqt or Hazzerd, pt of Maidens Choice". We have not been able to find any resurveys on Conquest since the original patent to James Badeford 1/11/1739 (Wash. Co. I:10) 275 A, but there are resurveys on Hazard that we've sent for.
Enclosed is another one of our patchwork of plats, which fit together as indicated because of statements made in the deeds or patents. Superimposed on the modern assessment map, some of the lines coincide -- the road, part of Conquest outline, and general outline with relation to the creek. I have indicated the Joseph Irwin site for you.
Your suggestions on the old Huyett Mill seem quite pertinent, and you may expect a period of quiet from us while we work on them. The 1851 Trustee Sale of Witmers Mill really brought us up short, however."
Page 18
Continuation of the 26 April 1973 letter (page 2 of that letter, not separately numbered):
"'Witmers Mill,..on the Conococheague, distant 7 miles from Hagerstown, 4 miles from Williamsport' --this sounds all right--'on the Chesapeake and Ohio Canal'--this jars my sense of direction. Said my husband, 'There's no way the Route 40 bridge can be on the C&O Canal!' The ad continues, 'a few hundred yards from the Western Turnpike'.. If this means the mill has access to the C&O Canal, what about the dam across the Conococheague at Abraham Leiter's mill in 1850?
In any case, it seems a good idea to follow up on George Shultz. According to Washington Co. records, George Shultz is just another farmer, mentioned in Martin Kershner Sr's 1769 will--he is to be given a deed--and is husband of Martin Sr's daughter Elizabeth (D:31, F:392). See the enclosed plats for the tract deeded "adjoining where the late George Shultz lived." Elizabeth was probably born ca. 1745 or possibly as early as 1741. In 1770 she relinquished her dower to a tract acquired 1736 by George Schultz of Philadelphia, merchant, who had sold in 1757 this plot, "George Scholtze, late of the city of Philadelphia, merchant, now of Salisbury Hundred, Frederick Co. Maryland." (Genealogical Record of the Schwenkfelder Families, Samuel K. Brecht, 1923.)
Brecht relates, pp 88-91, that George Shultz was born 1711, his parents arrived on ship Merchant at Philadelphia 1733 (his parents George Scholtz and Anna (Hübner), brothers Melchior and David.) George Shultz came in 1731 to America; his twin brother left for India at the same time. The three brothers in America, David Shultz wrote in his almanac, were dealers in Saffron in 1731-1732. George Shultz died in 1779, Elizabeth (Kershner) was his executrix, and the first account shows she paid Martin Kershner (this would be Jr.) L 5779, balance due Exrx L 4617. This is hardly the simple farmer.
Brecht says Shultz bought, 1763 100 ac, pt of Little Friendship, from Joseph Chapline, Frederick Co. 1773, 33 ac, Hazerd alias Conquest from Peter Whitstone 1773, 25 ac, pt of Resurvey on Hartman's Place from Peter Whitstone
There is one other Martin Kershner Sr tract that seemed promising, Walnut Bottom, 1752 (BD & CS # 17, 368), 100 ac, begins on the side of a hill on the East side of Conegocheigue; this tract was sold by his executors 1771 (Fred Co O:373) to Adam Piper blacksmith. Nothing is said about any adjacent tract or landmark, no mill is mentioned, but it seems to fit rather neatly in the bend above the Old Mill where the USGS map is labeled Walnut Bottom. If we can get to Hagerstown, we are going to check Ellis E Strite, 320/690.
We do thank you for your generous help, and will advise you of the results of this search. We do not, however, wish to burden you with correspondence, so hope that this report doesn't make you feel you should make a courthouse tour for us! I think the only question we raised was about the C & O canal mention in the Witmer's Mill ad; unless this really does mean the Mill is not near the Route 40 bridge, no reply is requested. It's a rhetorical question.
Most gratefully,"
Page 19
Letter, letterhead "34 Willow Avenue, Towson, Md. 21204," dated 14 April 1973. "Dear Mr. and Mrs. Kershner,"
"I was in Hagerstown again, and think I have wound up my probing for the moment. I don't seem to have a clear link to Abraham Leiter from the Swingles for the Old Mill Tavern. On the other hand, the Shingle-covered Kemps mill traces back through the Van Lears and was known as the "Red Mill." The Red Mill was associated with the tracts "Let Justice Take Place" and "Poor Land." There was a complex suit recorded in Equity Record 2:225ff, on f. 249, a witness deposed that Samuel Sergeant Van Lear was in control of the Red Mill in 1816-17.
The Van Lears had a second mill, a steam merchant mill as it was in one place distinguished from the Red Mill. Possibly that is the "Stone Mill" shown on the plat in Equity 10:489. The second mill was also called Irwin Mill and traces back to Peter Newcomer deed to Samuel B. Clagett and others in 1812 (Y:234). This mill stood on part of Reserve Number Six. It would be on the same side of the Conococheague as the "Shingle" Kemps Mill -- I would think downstream.
Nicholas, Barbara, and Benjamin Swingle rented the gristmill on Conococheague Creek to Matthew and William Vanlear for 5 years ... where the said Barbara and Benjamin now dwell ... together with use of all water ... privilege of building a Milk House ... 26 February 1787 (S:267).
John George Swingle sold part of Dutch Folly to Matthew and William Van Lear ... 23 June 1788 .... and whereas a certain George Kershner is now in the actual tenure ... by virtue of lease ... of 1787 (f. 92) together with the sawmill (S:922).
There are for sale notices in Equity Records for Kemps Mill -- the shingle one in Equity 50:338, and for old mill tavern Kemps Mill, 50:336.
Going back to the tax map, I find that the "Fridinger" tract traces back in three jumps to IN 9:492 which shows that Jacob Funk deeded the tract to Elizabeth Kershner; he had bought it at the auction of Andrew Kershner's property in 1855.
The tract immediately north of this is across the line in District 13 and belongs to Edward Burkholder; his deed has a plat (251:27) which shows that it is composed of parts of Resurvey of David's Last Shift, Widows Last Shift, Resurvey on Contentment, Addition to Dutch Folly ...and references a deed from Henry S. Eavey to John Troup, 14 October 1858 in IN 13:540.
That deed (IN 13:540) references a spring branch and shows that Eavey and Michael Newcomer were trustees appointed to sell the real estate of Joseph Kretzer in Equity Cause No. 1393."
Page 20
Continuation of 14 April 1973 letter:
"Turning to Equity Records, Liber 7:290, we see that in Elizabeth Hoffman-vs-Michael Newcomer ... the late Joseph Krotzer ... owned land adjoining Andrew Kershner and John Troupe ... 189 acres ... barn, sawmill ... conveyed to Hoffman by Jacob Kershner in 1842.
You might be able to find a sale notice for this property in either the Hagerstown Mail, or in the Herald and Torch, within the three weeks before public sale of November 11, 1856.
I have some other misc. data, but I don't think it is particularly relevant. Let me know if you have any other interest in references to Red Mill and Old Mill Tavern.
Very truly yours, John W. McGrain
P.S. J.B Kerschner was listed under millers at Emmitsburg, Frederick County, in 1887 State directory."
Page 21
Letter, letterhead "34 Willow Avenue, Towson, Md. 21204," dated 6 April 1973, marked "corrected" at top. "Dear Mr. and Mrs. Kershner,"
"Thank you for your letter of March 23. If you want me to send back those plats, just let me know. I took your tracing of the plats and laid out Addition to Dutch Folly on my map. I was in Hagerstown yesterday and finally got to meet John Frye; after all day in two courthouses, I didn't have much energy for probing his collections.
- In the courthouse, I looked up one deed, and the very first one on the tax map proves that you are in the right area with "Addition to Dutch Folly," which is mentioned in the current deed (Liber 217:608), as well as the adjoining tracts Rocky Springs, and Hagers Delight.
That stream is not mentioned by survey map, 1877 atlas, or by the tax maps. John Frye thought it was a fairly feeble stream for a mill, but the old atlas shows a mill and distillery near its mouth -- that of John M. Miller -- east side of the old road (not the present Md. 63).
The saw mill of J. Troup was shown on east bank of that creek, north of U.S. 40 practically on the Addition to Dutch Folly tract or Dutch Folly, 1 mile NE of Pikeville (now village of Huyett).
- I traced the Old Mill Tavern property. It too is on a Dutch Folly tract, and on part of Free Stone. The references aren't clear before Abraham Leiter c. 1850; I already had Abr. Leiter on the 1850 manufacturers census. The chain isn't perfect back to the Van Lears.
Just recently (Feb. 1972), the place was conveyed by the Tedricks to Joseph P. Urie, Robert E. Hamilton, Jr. and Old Mill Inc. (537/835).
An ad in the Federal Gazette, Baltimore, October 24, 1805, advertised the valuable estate (known formerly as Wolgamott's mill) late the property of Nicholas Swingley, deceased ... 200 acres ... large stone merchant mill ..."
The 1795 Dennis Griffith map had shown Swingles Mill; the 1808 Charles Varle map showed a mill symbol.
- The old Huyett's Mill may not be a Kerschner mill, but just in case, I enclose a for-sale notice from the Hagerstown papers.
Very truly yours, John W. McGrain"
Page 22
Newspaper clipping transcription, headed "Herald of Freedom and Torch Light, Hagerstown, Md., August 6, 1851, p. 3:" with handwritten annotation top right "J.W. McGr[ain], 6 Apr 1973":
"... Trustees Sale ... No. 1068 Equity ... at Witmers Mill, near the Conococheague Bridge on the Western Turnpike ... A Farm, situated on the west side of the Conococheague Creek, above the Turnpike Bridge, adjoining the lands of Valentine Wachtel and John Stein, and containing 125 acres ... 100 cleared ... residue in wood ... log house ... barn ...
ALSO, That Large and Valuable Merchant Mill, known as Witmers Mill, situate on the Conococheague, distant 7 miles from Hagerstown, 4 miles from Williamsport, on the Chesapeake and Ohio Canal, and a few hundred yards from the Western Turnpike -- The building is Frame and weatherboarded -- 60 by 40 feet, 4 Stories High, capable of storing 20,000 bush. of wheat, with three run of New Burrs and one pair of Chopping Stones. The Machinery has recently been thoroughly repaired, and is capable of manufacturing 60 Barrells of Flour in 24 Hours ...50 or 60 acres ... With the mill will also be sold the Saw Mill, Millers House, Two Log Dwelling Houses, Store, Cooper-shop, and a good weather boarded Stable ... application to Mr. Henry B. Witmer, residing near the mill.
Possession of the mill can be had immediately
GEORGE SCHLEY, Trustee
(In the same issue, George and Oliver Zeller offered to sell the Broadfording Mill.)"
Page 23
Letter dated 5 April 1973, to Mr. John W. McGrain, 34 Willow Avenue, Towson, Md. 21204. "Dear Mr. McGrain:"
"This is to correct a careless letter: in mine of 23 March 1973, I misquoted Chancery Records 64:14 et seq. Would you please correct the last paragraph on page 2? It was not George Kershner Jr who was living on the Swingle's sawmill property: it was George Swingle. The record says "George" with no surname and George Kershner was a witness, but apparently it was John George Swingle who lived there, 1784.
This long case will bear some more study, and I hope there are not other errors in my report of it.
The many Contentments and George and Martin and Jacob Kershners are so confusing that I have almost given up trying to explain my understanding of them without plats. Finally I constructed a sort of chart to try to trace the development of this group of land records. Perhaps it will help as I try to ask a question.
You mentioned the 1770 deed for The Contentment, N:472, Fred. Co. We have a patent for the identical tract, which recites that Daniel Dulany had the tract surveyed in 1742, but before a patent could issue, he died, and in 1762 his executors transferred it to Martin Kershner. In Washington Co. Records and Hall of Records, the date of this patent is listed as 1742. The later date seems much more likely. Other patents, Defense, for example, are listed under the date of the grant, not the survey or warrant. Are there other records, such as a patent ledger or entry book, which supply official dates? Or is this an index error?
The second interesting thing is the 1770 deed in itself. It does not mention the prior patent. It does state that Martin Kershner has paid Walter Dulany L 100 plus the alienation fine paid to Will Murdock Beall. Martin Kershner's 1769 will says "also I order that shall be Setled with William Beall concerning a Tract of Land which will Shoo by the Books and recieds & Agreement..." Walter Dulany received the payment as acting executor: Daniel and Walter Dulany are executors. These dates suggest that the Daniel Dulany mentioned in the Assembly records, 1765, is the executor. He seems to be objecting to people building dams on the property of another. In other words, does this seeming land title problem have anything to do with the location of the mill? We really do grasp at straws, don't we.
We hope to be in Falls Church, Va., part of May and June, visiting our brother, Stephen W. Kershner, 6667 Van Winkle Drive, and will be going up to the Hall of Records and to Hagerstown. We get pretty good forwarding service from our postman, or can be contacted later at Falls Church. But do not feel under pressure to give instant opinions! We hope to investigate Little Friendship and other tracts you mentioned.
Sincerely,"
Page 24
Handwritten note, dated at top "To John W. McGrain 20 Mar 1973":
"copies of p 6 Martin K Jr's will West end of Defense w/ Shelter Robinson Dutch Folly-Coat. resurvey 1769 w/ John + George K division Defense Pat 3pp carbon Martin K to Otho Sellars tract on Defense West end"
Page 25
Letter dated 23 March 1973, to Mr. John W. McGrain, 34 Willow Avenue, Towson, Md. 21204. "Dear Mr. McGrain:"
"Your very excellent letter and material are already filling gaps and we are having some hope of locating Martin Kershner Sr.'s mill of 1769 in the Conococheague area.
Of course you are correct that there were other mills. There must have been mills from a very early period, and the area had been settled for at least 35 years, as I understand the history. I am not familiar with the background of the editor of the Maryland state records that I sent you, but those are quotes from him. In trying to piece together this history and geography, we grasp at very diverse sources, and they don't always agree.
Andrew Kershner's mill, which you mentioned in 1812, six miles above Williamsport, may or may not have been near where he lived, but his home place may have been on what is now known as the Fridinger property, near present Huyett. This is a place you had suggested. Mrs. Hilda Cushwa, who is quite knowledgeable on the local land records (she has worked in the tax assessor's office for years), at one time traced the deeds back at least as far as Andrew Kershner Stake, grandson of Andrew Kershner. Andrew himself was grandson to Martin Kershner Sr., so there are really several generations that had plenty of opportunities to move around.
However, in 1816, Andrew Kershner was legatee of Martin Kershner Jr., named to inherit his father's dwelling house, and the mill race was mentioned in the property description, though no mill was. I enclose a page which describes this tract. If there is anything worse than having to plat (endlessly!) it's having a tract impossible to plat, as this is.
It looks though your suggestion of the general area may work out. We now have a plat group pieced together in a long east-west strip 4.6 miles from Ridenour's Pond and Dutch Folly on the east to George Shultz' 50 acres on the west, Martin Kershner Jr's Defense, 1798, holding it together, and fortunately mentioned others it touched -- First Snow, Hagers Delight, Dutch Folly, Young's Folly, Black Oak Levils, Contentment, Little Friendship, Resurvey on Hartman's place, and Hazzard. The Contentment was a 1762 patent, but did not touch and was not included in his 1769 resurvey of the four original patents (Dutch Folly, Addition to Dutch Folly, and Widows Last Shift and One Shift More -- the first two patented to Martin Sr.'s father and the last two to his mother) which was then increased slightly in size and called Contentment.
The 1762 tract, 126 ac. The Contentment, is the one you noticed mentioned Bumgarners Mill. There is a deed in Prince George's Co., Y:249, Peter Bumgardner to Thomas Wells, we intend to look up when we get a chance. Thomas Wells also patented a Dutch Folly tract.
You quoted a number of Jacob Kershner deeds, for which we are very appreciative. This is apparently Jacob b. 1751, the tavern-keeper at"
Page 26
Continuation (marked "p c" i.e. p.2, of letter dated 23 March 1973):
"Wilson's Store. Mr. Edward Kerschner of Norristown, Pa., supplied us with a copy of the original patent for Brightwell's Choice, which says on its face that it was granted to Jonathan Hager in 1763, but the family says this is Conquest. Mr. Edward is a great-grandson of Jacob Kershner, I believe, his grandmother having been a daughter of the Jacob Brewer mentioned in your Huyetts Mill paragraph. Gerry Sword of Hagerstown says Brightwells Choice is across the Conococheague from Conquest, and it appears to us that this may be the other end of Kershner's Ford. The old stone bridge on the National Turnpike was built about 1812, and replaced the use of the ford which was several hundred yards downstream where the ground slopes gently. You can probably locate the old roads to it even on the U.S.G.S. map as dotted lines. The Conquest barn with the big name painted across the end still stands, but vines had almost overgrown it last year. We ran across a deed mentioning "Hazard, formerly Conquest", but do not have the Resurvey, 1-354 in Washington Co. Courthouse. There is also a 1739 patent on The Hazard to Evan Shelby and a 1749 one to Hugh Gillialnd, 1-10 and 1-37, and we hope to be able to work these out for Mr. Edward Kerschner.
The 1739 Conquest patent to James Badeford, 1-10, appears to be in the loop of the Conococheague where it is crossed by Highway 40, which is where it is today except that it is somewhat smaller. Mr. Harold Snively is the present owner, and his tract on the Assessment Map for 1971 has a line identical to the Hazard line mentioned in the 1787 Defense survey, line 50. As we laid our tracing paper drawings out on sheets 35, 36, and 37, our Dutch Folly tracts fall on a creek which has no name on any of our maps, and the added land seems to fall along this creek as well as over toward the bridge. We looked at this creek--if it's the same one--where it runs into the Conococheague a short distance above the Old Mill Tavern. I am no mill expert, but it looked entirely inadequate to power any sort of mill. Yet everything indicates that the waters were very important to them. I think the Young's Folly tract that you sent -- which we did not have -- was on that creek. We had the resurvey, which calls it Young Man's Folly as first granted. This was included in Martin Kershner's Trouble with Contentment, 1007 ac, 1763; Amendment on Trouble with Contentment, 1076 ac. in 1773 for his estate; and then in 1798, in Defense. Both Martin Kershners, father and son, described themselves as millers.
Apparently the Kershner who was associated with the Swingle Mill was George Kershner Jr, who married Nicholas Swingles daughter and is mentioned in his will, 1784. Chancery records 64/et seq detail the transfer of the mill property from heirs of Nicholas Swingle Sr. to the Van Lears; in 1787 when a saw mill was leased to Matthew Van Lear, George Kershner was then living on the place and was a witness; the tract was Dutch Folly. On 25th of April, 1784, George Kershner Jr. gave a power of attorney to Nicholas Swingle Senr. to receive the estate due from his father Martin Kershner deceased..."to settle with my brother Martin Kershner one of the executors by any means or suit at Law to compel the settlement or payment of any legacy." Then on 12 Nov, 1784, six months later, Nicholas Swingle Sr.'s will devises to eldest son John George the saw mill tract on part of Dutch Folly "Alley", and to sons Benjamin & Philip the tract where the grist mill stands, called Dutch Folly and Resurvey of Dutch Folly, 112 ac. (Chancery 64-14,15,16) He also devises to his daughter Mary Kershner and specifies that "George Kirshner Jr shall not enjoy anything of my property." It seems possible that George Kershner Jr. was apprenticed to Swingle, but we do not yet understand"
Page 27
Continuation (marked "p 3"), heading at top "Conococheague.":
"yet the ins and outs of all these various Dutch Folly tracts and mills. On the 1784 Tax List, George Kershner Jr. was assessed for 386 acres of woods and 47 acres arable lands; in spite of Nicholas Swingles assistance, he never did get a title, but finally transferred his rights to Martin Kershner Jr. for L 350.
George Kershner Sr. was more fortunate. He and his brother, John Kershner, in 1773 got deeds from the executors of Martin Sr., and divided the original four grants between them (Dutch Folly, Addition to Dutch Folly, the Widows Last Shift, One Shift More, resurveyed in 1768 with contiguous vacancies added). As eldest son of the grantees of these four tracts, Martin Sr. was heir. George Kershner Sr. and John Kershner are thought to be his younger brothers. So here we have another George Kershner with Dutch Folly land. The deeds to the brothers include a detailed agreement for the use of the waters of a spring, and their portions are divided along the course of this spring. Neither is to have more advantage than the other of the waters, and neither may divert the water for more than 24 hours without the permission of the other. (Fred. Co. Deeds T-188 and T-333). Course of the spring is S 80 W 25, N 77 W 41, and the remainder of the division line is S 51 W 88; if this line were extended 94 perches to the western boundary of Addition to Dutch Folly/eastern boundary of Young's Folly, it would come out 6 perches north of its beginning "on the East side of a spring branch that runs from George Carsner's to Conococheague."
The 1763 Resurvey on Youngs Folly now called Trouble with Contentment mentions (BC & GS # 22, 397-399) the 1753 Resurvey on Youngs Folly (BC & GS # 10, 607-608), which mentions Youngs Folly 1746. Neither of the resurveys mentions the creek or spring.
We note dealings between Kershners and Kemps much earlier than the 1870 purchase of the mill by William H. C. Kemp, son of David Kemp of Frederick Co. Chancery Records 139-25 give some of the background of a boundary dispute between the John Kershner above mentioned and Ludwig Kemp about 1800. This was apparently resolved by four deeds recorded 27 Mar 1800: M-365, Lodwick Kemp and Henry Kemp of Frederick to John Kershner, 3 5/8 ac, pt. of Batchelors Delight beginning on Resurvey on part of Contentment 1788; M-367, same to Henry Tice, touching resurvey on part of Contentment, 9 3/4 ac; M-370, Henry Tice (son-in-law of John Kershner) to Lod. Kemp of Frederick, 90 perches of land, part of Bakers Purchase; and M-372, John Kershner to Henry Tice, 8 1/4 ac., part of Resurvey on Part of Contentment resurveyed for John Kershner 7 Apr. 1788.
Ludwig Kemp was son-in-law to John Feltigrah who received patent 1742 on Feltigrahs Fortune; Henry Kemp got a resurvey on this 1793 (2:417). You mentioned Martin Kershner's 1770 deed mentioning the waggon road from Bumgarners Mill to Felta (?) Graus(?). The family is later mentioned as Craw or Grau, sometimes hyphenated to Felti-Graw. I notice a prominent GROH in several places currently in Washington Co., including Groh Realty. In following up this clue, we have Deeds C-95, estate settlement which mentions Ludwig Kemp, 1782; Elizabeth Craw's will, 1761, Wills A-198; patent on Felty's Fortune Recovered 1832, Harry Kemp, 1-417; and patent on Felty's Addition (not dated) 1-321. None of these mention mills, however.
Sorry this has gotten too long. Will keep you posted. Many thanks!"
Page 28
Letter, letterhead "34 Willow Avenue, Towson, Md. 21204," dated 13 March 1972 [year corrected in ink to 1973]. Addressed "Mrs. Ruth Kershner, 1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin, Texas." "Dear Mrs. Kershner,"
"I finally made it to Hagerstown yesterday and looked in the court records. First let me mention that Kershner's Mill was not the only [mill] on the Conococheague in 1765 as suggested in the Archives of Maryland; Joseph Chapline's certificate for The Free Stone, surveyed 27 April 1745, states that the beginning was "a bounded Hickory... lying on the west bank of Conococheague about forty perches above Volgemore's Mill and running thence N7W 24 perches ... etc." Patents BY+GS 1, p. 216.
Also, if Henry Zeller is a Kershner in-law, the 1783 tax list shows him in Salisbury and Conococheague Hundreds with the tract Adventure and 2 mills worth L 200. (I think that was the Broadfording Mill, well upstream from the U.S. 40 bridge.)
Yesterday, I started at the Huyett Mill which was replaced by an amusement park, east side of Conococheague, about 2 houses above the old national road. The parcel belongs to a Mr. Thomas L. Stenger; it traces back to Jacob and David Huyett, who acquired it from the Sheriff in 1865 (Liber IN 19:201). The tracts were parts of Pleasant Meadow Resurveyed, Little Friendship, Resurvey on Green Castle ... beginning in the center of a large spring on the west side of the Conococheague Creek a short distance before the Turnpike Bridge and running thence with the lines of a deed from Jacob Brewer to John Witmer for part of Resurvey on Green Castle ... to edge of the Conococheague Creek one half of a perch south of the abutment of the bridge thence running down the Creek S½W ... 123 acres ... rights appertaining to the mill on the premises hereby conveyed is granted to be held and used by them the said Jacob S. Huyett and David Huyett ... mill property hereby conveyed being the same which was heretofore conveyed by George Schley, Trustee, to John H. Huyette by deed 3 June 1856 ... recorded IN 11:258-260...
If you go back to the equity records when John (or was it Henry?) Witmer died, Equity Records, 5:579ff ... Witmer had owned a farm and gristmill on Conococheague Creek, and an order to survey the land, listed the tracts Conquest, Millers Peices, Res. on Hartmans Please, Amendment, Trouble with Contentment, Shipleys Mistake, Addition to Millers Peice, Little Friendship, Res. on Green Castle; these properties were advertised for public auction at Witmers Mill, published in Hagerstown Mail Herald & Torch, prior to sale of 16 Aug. 1851. (I haven't yet looked this up.)
Here is where I get lost in the maze:
The deed from Jacob Brewer to John Witmer, 21 May 1838, sells a parcel ... beginning at the center of spring... south side of bridge... waterways water courses... part of Res. on Green Castle (TT:44).
Also Liber GWI 1:511 ... 24 March 1843 ... John Witmer to John Witmer, Jr. ...$5000 ... parcels ... parts of Conquest, Millers Pieces, The Res. on Hartmans Place, the Amendment on Trouble with Contentment, Johns Fancy, Shipleys Mistake, Res. on Green Castle all lying contiguous ... now laid out ...358½ acres ... called Pleasant Meadows ... surveyed 1814 ... to intersect division line of Kershner and Witmer, adjoining Mountain of Wales ... all interest ... which John Wachtell deceased conveyed ... houses, buildings, mills ..."
Page 29
Continuation of the 13 March 1973 letter (marked "-2"):
"Also, Liber FF:783: June 13, 1822 ... John and Valentine and Jonathan Wachtell heirs of John Wachtell to John Witmer ... by Last Will and Testament ... date 1810 ... sell his land to best advantage ... beginning at 9th line of Little Friendship ... 43 acres ... water courses ... privileges ...
FF:785 ... John Witmer from John Wachtell ... confirmatory of above deed ... 14 June 1822
There is a link from a former Kershner property to John Witmer:
Liber NN:295: David G. Yost -to- John Witmer ... 18 May 1822 ... In 1830 Yost was appointed trustee to sell real estates of John Foltz ... Res. on the Mountain of Wales and Galaspies Bargain ... which was conveyed by a certain Gabriel Friend to Jacob Kershner ... 15 April 1794 ... that lies on the north side of the turnpike road leading from Hagerstown to Hancock Town... recorded GG:962
H:653 Gabriel Friend, executor of Richard Shipley ... to Jacob Kershner ... 15 April 1794/9 ... part of Resurvey on Green Castle, part of Gilespies Bargain and part of Mountain of Wales ... Beginning for the Resurvey of Green Castle in the center of a bigg spring on the edge of Conococheague ... adjoining Brightwells Choice ... 37½ acres ...
Notice the mention of the spring in H:653. I can't tell without endless drawing of plats who had the mill before Witmer, although the Wachtell deed looks like a mill site deed, although not clearly expressed as such.
The Conococheague takes a big loop above U.S. 40, and a mill symbol was shown on the north bank on Charle's Varle's map of 1808. I looked up the site, now property of a Mr. Englehart -- north side of Independence School Road. The tract names here are parts of Green Castle and Little Friendship ...and it traces back to a Samuel Bovey, executor of Michael Bovey, who sold in 1871 (MMcKK 4:67).
Michael Bovey purchased parts of Ravin Spring, Res. on Green Castle, Little Friendship, and Millers Pieces, from Jacob Knode, David and Christian Newcomer, 31 December 1822 (Liber GG:45). The Newcomers were prominent millers, although the deed isn't specific.
I suppose you saw the Frederick County Deed, 1770, from Daniel Dulany of Walter to Martin Kersner ... part of Contentment ... Beginning at the foot of the ridge about 30 perches from the waggon road that goes from Baumgarners Mill to Felta(?) Graus(?). (Frederick LR Liber N:472.)
There was also a deed in 1807 (Wash. LR Liber S:652) from Martin Kirshner, Jr. to Henry Witmer ... Whereas Martin Kirshner of George by his petition to Washington County Court hath set forth that George Kershner hath lately departed this life intestate ... (etc.) ... died seized of Contentment, David's First Shift ... partition (rec. Liber S, f. 2,3,4) ... for and in consideration of L 2000 confirm to Henry Witmer ... part of Contentment and part of David's First Shift ... adjoining Addn to Dutch Folly ...
Maybe you can make some sense of these disjointed notes. Perhaps Dutch Folly stretched farther upstream than you had supposed from the Kemp Mill area. Remember, Martin Kershner was on the 1783 tax list with parts of Mountain of Wales and 2 mills. Please let me know if you come to any conclusions.
Very truly Yours, John W. McGrain"
Page 30
Letter, letterhead "Baltimore County Historical Society, Inc., Agriculture Building, 9811 Van Buren Lane, Cockeysville, Maryland 21030," dated 9 February 1973. Addressed "Dear Mrs. Kerschner,"
"Thank you very much for your interesting letter of January 29 and the Xerox pages. The Archives of Md. mention of Kershner's Mill was new to me. I have considerably enlarged that Washington County chapter since I gave a copy to Mr. Frye, but hadn't come across any new data on Kershner. There was not much published data on Washington County, plus the data various people sent me after Mr. Frye ran a story in the Hagerstown papers, that I was able to make a rather full report without having to spend much time in the courthouse searching titles. In fact, I have only done two titles in that whole county.
I am fairly sure that the "Old Mill Tavern" was Vulgamotts/Wolgamutts Mill.
The History of Western Maryland, T.J. Scharf, states on p. 1174, in reference to the carding machine ..."at Kerschners Mill on the road from Hagerstown to Hancock and four miles from Hagerstown."
That road would have to be the present U.S. 40 at the village of Wilson or Conococheague. The mill shown there in the atlas of 1877 was D. Huyett. That is the mill that was replaced by an amusement park, and also the 1880 census and the 1887 State directory.
Also in History of Western Md., p. 25, is a list of roads and their overseers for 1819:
"No. 25. From Millers Mill on the Conococheague, by Kerschner's Cross Roads near the turnpike, until it intersects the roads at Long's from Miller's Mill to Ashfords, and from the forks of the Williamsport road near Wolgamott's, by Huffer's Mill until it intersects the road to Broad Ford. Distance 6 miles. Henry Garlock, Supervisor."
That might suggest that Wolgamott's Mill was distinct from Kershners. Of course, at that time, Major Kershner had been dead 2 years.
The Md. Historical Magazine had a mention of Kershner in No. 13:235, quoting an order of the Committee of Observation issued Feb. 15, 1777 for L 7-8-6 to pay for 33 gallons of whiskey furnished for the use of Captn. Martin Kershners Company of Militia.
That society's manuscript collection has three index cards on Kershner, all relating to the militia; one referenced a list of members of the company."
Page 31
Continuation of 9 February 1973 letter (marked "-2"):
"The 1880 census, which is in rather difficult handwriting, lists someone who may be of family interest.
In District 4, Washington County -- A.V. Kicher(?), Jr. -- mill with 7000capitalinvestment, 2employees, 2runofstones, 126bu/diemmaximumcapacity; doing759830).
That was in the Manufacturers Census, original book of returns in State Library, Annapolis.
I went to school with a Martin Kircher (no "N"). He is now an attorney and member of the Md. General Assembly. Office at 425 St. Paul Place, Baltimore, Md. 21202. He would be about 41 years old. Possibly a lost member of the tribe.
I'll look up the Huyett site on the tax map the next time I'm in Hagerstown and let you know if it traces back to your ancestor. Please let me know if there are any other points I can check for you while I'm on my rounds of archives.
Very truly yours, John W. McGrain"
Page 32
Letter dated 29 January, 1973, to Mr. John W. McGrain, 30 [sic, elsewhere given as 34] Willow Avenue, Towson, Md. 21204. "Dear Mr. McGrain:"
"Your very interesting monograph, Introduction to The Mills of Washington County, was handed to us by Mr. John Frye, curator of the Western Maryland Room of the Washington County Free Library. Since you were kind enough to invite comment, we thought you might be interested in some pre-Revolutionary mill clues we have accumulated during some research on the Kershner family.
You mention Jacob Dunn and Andrew Kerschner's carding machine on the Conococheague in 1812. Andrew was the fourth generation Kershner there, and one of his eight sisters married Jacob Dunn: their grandfather, Martin Kershner Senr., was described as a miller of the Conococheague in 1765. I enclose some copies of data relating to this.
Martin Kershner Senr. was under 16 in 1731 when he came to Philadelphia in the ship Samuel with his parents, Johan Gorg and Anna Kirschner. His father, Johan Gorg Kirschner (Kersner, Carsner), acquired in 1739 two of Daniel Dulany's Dutch Folly tracts, and his mother, Anna, after her husband's death in 1748, patented two adjacent tracts called the Widow's Last Shift and One Shift More. Martin Kershner (Kirshner) Senr. had accumulated a number of additional holdings by the time he wrote his own will in 1769. We think the will indicates he was in the midst of some complicated land deals, and it took about 30 years to settle the estate after it was proved a month later. His executors were his eldest son and heir, Martin Kershner Junr. (1743-1817), and his brother-in-law, Jonathan Hager Sr. who died 1775.
We have followed up on many of the clues contained in this will of Martin Kershner Senr. One provision was that "the land shall be prayst and if required shall be sold, the place and mill on Bottom eck." Another was that "my youngest son named George is bound to trad when Gebaubel to good Christian people." He directed that deeds be given to various individuals, mostly relatives, and we have obtained and platted many of these deeds, as well as the patents to Dutch Folly and adjacent tracts that Martin Kershner Senr. inherited from his parents, George and Anna Kersner.
Surely Martin Kirshner Senr had a mill on the Conococheague. But where?
Mr. Frye says there are no pre-Revolutionary plats or tax maps. We know that Philip Kershner's son Jacob, b. 1751, owned Conquest at one time, that Kershner's Ford is still to be seen near Conquest's still-standing barn a few hundred yards below Wilson's Bridge, now replaced by the Route 40 bridge on the road from Hagerstown to Clear Spring.
Kershners now living in Washington County think it likely that this early mill was on or near the site of Kemp's Mill, now "The Old Mill Tavern." They have done some research, and have supplied me with some notes and abstracts, and I enclose some copies. Please keep all these for your own research.
(more)"
Page 33
Continuation of 29 January 1973 letter (marked "2"):
"Mr. W. Norman Reed, Hagerstown historian (is this the W. Nathan Reed you quote?), seems to combine the data you give for the wooden Kemps Mill at the head of Semple Run, and for the other Kemps Mill, the stone one now called the Old Mill Tavern. At least, that is the impression I got in Hagerstown. The fact that the land was called Dutch Folly seemed persuasive to them, and the article in the Hagerstown Cracker Barrel, quoting the present owner of the stone mill, now the tavern, certainly states that it is the stone mill that was built on Dutch Folly, patented to Thomas Wells.
We find that at least three 100-acre tracts were patented as Dutch Folly on the same date, 2 July 1739. This one to Thomas Wells, one to George Kersner called Addition to Dutch Folly (this patent recites that the tract is adjacent to Dutch Folly patented to Charles Higgenbotham and sold to George Kersner), and the third which he apparently sold even before he got the patent, to Charles Higgenbotham. At least one more Dutch Folly, 32 acres to Jacob Haines, was patented in 1792. So the Dutch Folly location in itself actually proves nothing.
The present owners of the Old Mill Tavern -- it may now be called a Restaurant -- were kind enough to take us through the lower parts of the old structure last summer. The machinery and construction were very interesting to my husband, who is an engineer. He is of the opinion that the present structure, and certainly the machinery, is nothing like the age indicated. The location and the height of the dam would be suitable for an undershot wheel or turbine only, he thought. After we were there, we understand that Hurricane Agnes put the main floor several feet under water.
We live far away, and have no reason to try to prove that this particular mill was, or was not, an old Kershner mill. What we want to know is, where was Martin Kershner's mill in 1765 and 1769? The 1783 Assessment shows that Martin Kershner (Junr) owned two mills, four years before his only son Andrew was born.
So far, no deed has mentioned a mill, but clues do keep cropping up. A recent letter from Miss Edna Ridenour locates Ridenour's Pond, and if we have interpreted her correctly, our plats show that Martin Kershner Senr's 1742 survey on Contentment places it across the Conococheague with its northwestern boundary very near today's Old Mill Tavern. It also turns out that Martin Kershner Senr's youngest son George, the boy who in 1769 was too young to be apprenticed, later married Mary, daughter of Nicholas Swingle. We have requested copies of chancery records of the Nicholas Swingle cause, 1789, mentioning this, but the Hall of Records is having trouble finding them under the indexed number. Long distance research is very frustrating!
As you can see, we are actively seeking further information. We have a poor copy of Varle's 1808 map, and current assessment maps, scale 600'=1". We are making our plats of the old deeds and patents on the same scale. Anything you can add to our data would be much appreciated, and of course we will provide you with whatever we find in your field of interest.
Very truly yours,
Ruth and Stuart Kershner 1414 Red Bud Trail Austin, Texas 78746"
Page 34
Enclosure titled "MARTIN KERSHNER'S DAM ON THE CONOCOCHEAGUE" (typed research memo, apparently quoting/summarizing Archives of Maryland/Proceedings of the General Assembly):
"On November 21, 1765, a bill described in the introduction to the proceedings of the General Assembly of Maryland,1764-1765, as a fish conservation measure was passed by the Lower House and sent to the upper house. This bill "with the misleading title 'An Act to prevent the Navigation on Potomack River, Monokasy, and Conecocheague Creeks being obstructed'" was the subject of messages between the Lower and Upper Houses, and finally was allowed to die.
"From these messages it is learned that the Lower House passed the bill because a dam and saw-mill, stated to be the only one on Conechcheague Creek, had been so constructed that it obstructed navigation, and this 'by a trespasser on the property of another contrary to the laws of the Province & that under the bill submitted (by the Lower House) he was being very tenderly dealt with...in only being obliged to make a sufficient lock' to the dam. The Upper House felt, on the other hand, that anything that was already built on private property 'under the faith of the law', should not be affected by any subsequent act which would prove an injury to private property rights (p.68)."
"From what follows it seems certain that the purpose of this bill 'to prevent navigation being obstructed', was the conservation of fish in Conococheague Creek. One also wonders whether a certain Martin Kirshner, described as a miller of Conococheague Creek, Frederick County, who made a deposition in the Lower House on December 14, 1765, in regard to the armed mob reported to be collecting in Frederick County to march to Annapolis to enforce the passage of the Journal of Accounts (p.234), may not have been the owner of the dam on Conococheague Creek which gave rise to this Lower House Bill....
"...It is not clear just what was the significance...of still another bill introduced in the Upper House by Daniel Dulany on November 22, 1765, and passed in that house the next day, entitled 'An Act to repeal an act for the encouragement of such persons as will undertake to build water mills' (pp.55,174), but it is certain that soon after it reached the Lower House it was, without explanation, rejected, and returned to the Upper House (pp.61,185). Its purpose may well have been to do away with, or prevent the erection of, dams which interfered with movements of fish; it was almost certainly rejected by the Lower House because of features objectionable to that body, such as the disposition of fines imposed under it."
"Referring to the proceedings of the Lower House, we find on page 234 'The Deposition of Martin Casner of Conocheague in Frederick County made on the Holy Evangelists of Almighty God this 14th Day of Dec.r 1765'"
"This deposition, signed Martin Kirshner, is the one referred to above. "The said Depon.t saith that some Time the Week before last...one Scott...had come to this Depon.ts Mill and told him..." of a conversation with Col. Cresap. "This Depon.t saith that he left home last Tuesday morning...did not see any people collected armed..." The House then adjourned till Monday.
Some inferences can be drawn from the above statements. Martin Kirshner, a miller, had before November 21, 1765, constructed the only dam & saw-mill on Conococheague Creek on that date, that the dam obstructed navigation, and that it was built on property he did not own at the time. Laws then in effect encouraged building of dams and mills, and required that persons must actually settle on lands before they could acquire title. Daniel Dulany, a large non-resident land-owner of the area, unsuccessfully tried to impose fines instead of encouraging building of mills, causing Martin Kirshner to go to Annapolis."