K-071: Letters: Elizabeth Eppley Mrsgeary College Park MD Flenner, 1974
Kershner Correspondence (Flenner family, Elizabeth Eppley)Summary
K-071 Closing Summary
Source: Letters_ElizabethEppleyMrsgearyCollegeParkMDFlenner_1974.pdf Pages: 6 of 6 transcribed
Verified date range
Letters dated from 22 March 1974; family history from the 1700s to 1832.
Thread classification
Allied line: the Flenner family.
What this document reveals
Correspondence between Mamacita and Mrs. Geary (Elizabeth "Libby") Eppley of College Park, Maryland, a Flenner descendant, on the Flenner family of Washington County, Maryland and Huntingdon County, Pennsylvania.
Most significant facts and leads
- Margaret Flenner (b. 1776) married George Kershner (b. about 1774) in 1799.
- Her mother, Magdalena Kershner, daughter of Martin Kershner Sr. (d. 1769), married first Jacob Baum and then Rudolph Flenner.
- The letters correct a 1956 published error that confused Magdalena with her sister Margaretha, who married Henry Zeller.
- Sources: Ernest O. Nay's "Genealogy of the Flenner Family" (1968) and Douglas Dutro Woodard's notes (K-035).
Closing summary written 2026-10-18 from the transcript and genealogical index.
The originals
The scanned document. Scroll inside the viewer to page through it, or open it full screen.
Open the scanned pages full screenPeople, places and dates
Show the genealogical index
K-071 Index
Source: Letters_ElizabethEppleyMrsgearyCollegeParkMDFlenner_1974.pdf (6 pages)
Thread: Research correspondence — the Flenner family of Washington Co., MD and Huntingdon Co., PA, connected to the Kershner line through Margaret Flenner (b. 1776), who married George Kershner (b. ca. 1774) in 1799, and whose mother, Magdalena Kershner, married twice: first Jacob Baum, then Rudolph Flenner. Correspondents: Ruth Kershner and Mrs. Geary ("Libby") Eppley of College Park, MD, a Flenner-family descendant and researcher.
People
- Mrs. Geary Eppley (Elizabeth "Libby" Eppley) — of College Park, MD; Flenner family descendant and researcher; corresponds with Ruth Kershner 1974 (pp. 1-5)
- Ruth Kershner — recipient/author of letters; researching Kershner-Flenner connections; of Austin, TX (planning travel to Wyoming) (pp. 2, 6)
- Mrs. Nay — contact via the Maryland Genealogical Society (M.G.S.) Bulletin; wife of Dr. (Ernest O.) Nay; of Terre Haute, IN (winter) and Sarasota (other times) (p. 2)
- Dr. Ernest O. Nay — author of Genealogy of the Flenner Family (1968), which included a supplement on the Altoona Flenner line and descendants of John Flenner of Huntingdon (pp. 3, 6)
- John Flenner (Elizabeth Eppley's great-grandfather), b. 25 Dec. 1809, Oneida Twp., Huntingdon Co. PA — starting point of Eppley's 25-years' Flenner research; married Eliza Rettew, 1833 (pp. 3, 5)
- John Flenner (elder, "settled near Philipsburg N.J. before 1700, d. 1723") — earliest ancestor on the "Altoona line" chart (p. 4)
- Philip Flenner Sr. — fled an Indian massacre with his wife; children Rachael, John (lost to family, served in Rev. War), Philip Jr. (settled Wilmore, PA); himself reportedly served in the Revolutionary War at advanced age, d. 1779 from wounds (unconfirmed) (p. 4)
- Adam Flenner (Bedford Co., ca. 1850), Daniel Flenner (buried Broad Top, PA, 1887), Margaretha Flenner, David Flenner, Martin Flenner — names Eppley found listed in Africa's History of Huntingdon (1837-1849), later determined not to be her direct ancestors, though she used the Margaretha Flenner line in her own genealogy (p. 5)
- George Kershner, b. ca. 1774, Washington Co. MD — married Margaret Flenner 23 Nov. 1799 at Hagerstown (p. 6)
- Margaret Flenner, b. 26 Feb. 1776, Washington Co. MD — married George Kershner; daughter of Rudolph Flenner and Magdalena Kershner (p. 6)
- Rudolph Flenner — father of Margaret Flenner; second husband of Magdalena Kershner; buried Old Flenner Cemetery, Butler Co., Ohio (p. 6)
- Magdalena Kershner — mother of Margaret Flenner; first married Jacob Baum (d. by 1769, leaving three sons under six), then married Rudolph Flenner; buried Old Flenner Cemetery, Butler Co. Ohio (p. 6)
- David, Parmelia, Joseph, and Samuel Kershner — children of George Kershner and Margaret Flenner, all associated with Butler Co., Ohio (p. 6)
- Jacob Baum, d. by 1769 — first husband of Magdalena Kershner; erroneously identified by Mary Palmer Phillips (1956) as having married "Susanna Margaretha Kershner, daughter of Martin Kershner and Margaretha" — a case of mistaken identity between two Kershner sisters (p. 6)
- Martin Kershner (d. 1769) — father of both Magdalena Kershner (m. Baum, then Flenner) and Margaretha Kershner (m. Henry Zeller); his daughters' identities were confused by an earlier published source (p. 6)
- Margaretha Kershner (daughter of Martin Kershner, d. 1769) — married Henry Zeller, not Jacob Baum, correcting Mary Palmer Phillips's 1956 account (p. 6)
- Henry Zeller — husband of Margaretha Kershner (p. 6)
- Mary Palmer Phillips — author (1956) of "From the Family Record of David Lehman Booker and his wife Elizabeth Mutts," which contained an error conflating Magdalena and Margaretha Kershner regarding the Baum marriage (p. 6)
- Douglas Dutro Woodard — of Salt Lake City, UT; high school history teacher; researched and loaned notes refuting Mary Palmer Phillips's error; his wife was of the Flenner line; submitted data used in Ruth's letter (p. 6)
- Stephen W. Kershner — Ruth's brother (referred to as "our brother"), of 8801 Van Winkle [St?], with a daughter living in Silver Spring, MD (p. 6)
Places / Dates-Events
See CSVs for structured data. Key locations: College Park, MD; Terre Haute, IN; Sarasota, FL; Huntingdon Co. PA (Oneida Twp., Altoona, Wilmore, Broad Top, Tyrone); Bedford Co. PA; Philipsburg, NJ; Washington Co. MD (Hagerstown, Salem Reformed Church); Butler Co., Ohio (Old Flenner Cemetery); Salt Lake City, UT; Falls Church, VA; Silver Spring, MD; Austin, TX / Wyoming (Ruth Kershner's residence/travel).
Open Questions
- Was the "lost John" Flenner (soldier of the Revolutionary War, per family tradition) actually the father of Elizabeth Eppley's ancestor John Flenner (b. 1809), given that the 1809 John's own census record stated his father was born in Maryland, not Pennsylvania — a discrepancy Eppley flags but resolves only tentatively ("accepted... maybe too hastily")? (pp. 4-5)
- Are Adam Flenner, Daniel Flenner, Margaretha Flenner, David Flenner, and Martin Flenner (from Africa's History of Huntingdon, 1837-1849) genuinely related to Eppley's Huntingdon Flenner ancestors, or is the resemblance coincidental — Eppley admits uncertainty but used the Margaretha Flenner line anyway "as it fitted in nicely"? (p. 5)
- Has Mary Palmer Phillips's 1956 published error (conflating Magdalena and Margaretha Kershner as the same person in the Baum marriage) been corrected in all subsequently published genealogies, or does it persist uncorrected elsewhere? (p. 6)
- Ruth Kershner asks Mrs. Eppley directly for advice on researching Pennsylvania land records long-distance (specifically Bedford, Lehigh, or Bucks Co. resources) to clarify Penn./Md. Kershner relationships prior to 1800 — no answer to this request appears in the transcribed pages. (p. 6)
- Did Douglas Dutro Woodard ever respond to further letters, given Ruth notes "he has not answered any letters" despite being helpful in person/by phone? (p. 6)
Summary
This is a 1974 correspondence between Ruth Kershner and fellow genealogist Mrs. Geary (Elizabeth) Eppley of College Park, Maryland, centered on the Flenner family of Washington Co., MD, and Huntingdon Co., PA. The connection to the Kershner line runs through Margaret Flenner (b. 1776), who married George Kershner (b. ca. 1774) in 1799, and whose mother, Magdalena Kershner — daughter of Martin Kershner (d. 1769) — had first married Jacob Baum before marrying Rudolph Flenner; the letters also work to correct a published 1956 genealogical error that had confused Magdalena with her sister Margaretha Kershner (who actually married Henry Zeller). The correspondence blends substantive genealogical detail (citing Ernest O. Nay's 1968 Genealogy of the Flenner Family and researcher Douglas Dutro Woodard's notes) with personal news and requests for research advice on Pennsylvania land records. Verified date range: 1700s (John Flenner's original settlement near Philipsburg, NJ) through 1799-1832 (Kershner-Flenner marriages and children); the correspondence itself is dated 22 March - 6 September 1974.
Full transcript
Typed from the scans, handwriting included. Unclear words are marked [?]. The original scans are kept in the family archive.
K-071 Transcript
Source: Letters_ElizabethEppleyMrsgearyCollegeParkMDFlenner_1974.pdf (6 pages)
Note: Correspondence between Ruth Kershner and Mrs. Geary (Elizabeth "Libby") Eppley of College Park, MD, concerning the Flenner family — connected to the Kershner line because Margaret Flenner (b. 1776, Washington Co. MD) married George Kershner (b. ca. 1774) in 1799, and because Margaret's mother, Magdalena Kershner, was herself a Kershner who married twice (first Jacob Baum, then Rudolph Flenner).
Page 1
[Return address corner, red ink: "Flenner"]
[Letterhead: MRS. GEARY EPPLEY, 4603 BEECHWOOD ROAD, COLLEGE PARK, MARYLAND 20740]
Sept 6, 1974
Dear Ruth,
I didn't write to you in Wyo- as I was in no hurry for the Broad Top publication. I was over here with little summer visitors- all is quiet again.
Hope you found something of value in the story - I have another 'True Stories of (Broad Top)' by David Foster Norton - 75 pages. If I come to Austin this spring, will bring it to you, if you are interested. I have only one copy.
Have another party wanting the publication I sent you, so you may send it back. Have some new leads- keep me busy. Libby E.
Page 2
[Letterhead: MRS. GEARY EPPLEY, 4603 BEECHWOOD ROAD, COLLEGE PARK, MARYLAND 20740]
Mar 22, 1974
Dear Mrs. Kershner,
I was delighted to make a contact in the M.G.S. Bulletin, as I had only recently joined. Mrs. Nay's winter address is probably one you didn't have - her home in [crossed out] 29 S. 20th St. Terre Haute Ind. 47803. I will send her your suggested data, in case you do not write to her. The Nays were a delightful couple - they stopped here once to see us. We also saw them at their place in Sarasota.
My family name is Flenner from Huntingdon & Tyrone
Page 3
Pa. When I could go back only to my Great Grandfather John Flenner of Huntingdon, born Oneida Twp. Dec 25 1809 - then I began my research, 25 years ago. The first Flenner names I found in the DAR Library - the Flenner family of Wash. Co. Md, but I could make no connection. Dr. Nay worked on it also when preparing his Flenner book. Thru a John Flenner in Altoona years ago I obtained a family line that we finally accepted (but I had reservations). Then recently I found a Fenner line that is proving interesting too. Dr. Nay published, in his book, as a supplement, the Altoona line plus the descendants of my ancestor John Flenner of Huntingdon.
[Marginal note: "Spent Easter '73 in Austin."]
Sincerely - Elizabeth Eppley
Page 4
[Handwritten notes, top right: "Flenner - Pa."]
[Letterhead: MRS. GEARY EPPLEY, 4603 BEECHWOOD ROAD, COLLEGE PARK, MARYLAND 20740]
Altoona line
John Flenner settled nr. Philipsburg N.J. before 1700. d. 1723
Philip Flenner Sr. fled from Indian Massacre with wife - He[?] belong[?]
c. Rachael - married Lancaster Co John - lost to family (Serve in Rev.) Philip Jr - settled Wilmore Pa Franklin 1772-1873 "
The above Philip Sr. at an advanced age gave service in Rev. War - (cannot prove this) d. 1779 from wounds.
After receiving this material in great length, I concluded that the lost John was the father of my ancestor John, b. 1809, even tho' he stated in Census that his father was b. Md.
Page 5
So I accepted the Altoona line purely as mine, maybe too hastily. Another point convinced me at the time - my ancestor John in write-up on his life said his father was a soldier of the Rev. but did not give his name. I could only find one John Flenner from Pa. who served in Rev. - so thought I had the right lead.
My Ancestor John m. Eliza Rettew 1833.
There are some question marks? Adam Flenner - Bedford Co. w1850w Daniel Flenner buried Broad Top. Pa 1887 Margaretha Flenner, Daniel, David and Martin Flenner - listed in Africa's book on Hist. of Huntingdon 1837-1849 - p.381, 382. [crossed-out word]
My ancestors in Huntingdon did not seem to be related to these people, tho' I did use the Margaretha Flenner line in my genealogy as it fitted in nicely!
Page 6
13 April, 1974
Dear Mrs. Eppley:
Your Flenner data is most interesting. I have really not attempted to look into this family much beyond what I wrote you.
In Salt Lake City, I leafed through the Kerschner/Kershner etc. family sheets, and came upon George Kershner, b about 1774, of Washington Co. Maryland, who married 23 Nov 1799, at Hagerstown, Margaret Flenner, b 26 Feb. 1776 in Wash Co Md. Margaret's father is listed as Rudolph Flenner and his mother as Magdalena Kershner: both buried in Old Flenner Cemetery, Butler Co. Ohio. I am giving these details because I am not sure of an opportunity to copy it for you, and you can fill out a family sheet from this. Children listed are David b c 1801 md 28 June 1827 Eliza Garver; Parmelia b c 1803, md ....Spragg [struck-through, illegible]; Joseph b c 1805, md 15 Sept 1830 Mary Hayse; Samuel b c 1807 md 15 Mar 1832, Phebe Hayse, all of Butler Co.
Sources: Marriage records of Wash Co Md & Butler Co; Margaret Flenner's birth record, Salem Ref Ch, Hagerstown; p 21-22, Genealogy of the Flenner Family, 1968, Ernest O. Nay. Data submitted by Douglas Dutro Woodard, Birchwood Haus, 1977 Yalecrest Ave, Salt Lake City, Utah 84108.
With this in hand, I phoned Mr. Woodard. He teaches history in a SLC high school. Told me he used to live in Wash D.C. where he had done a lot of research for Dr. Nay's book. His wife is of the Flenner line. I think his Duttros were in Wash Co. Md. He loaned me a lot of notes, which I copied, but he has not answered any letters. He likes research, but confessed he had not even been in the SLC library. His notes and conversation suggested that he had been principally interested in refuting an error by Mary Palmer Phillips, 1956, in a little volume called "From the Family Record of David Lehman Booker and his wife Elizabeth Mutts". A copy of this is in the Wash Co Free Library. In the Baum section, p 69-76, Mrs. Phillips said that Jacob Baum md Susanna Margaretha Kershner, daughter of Martin Kershner and Margaretha. To place this in perspective, Jacob Baum was first husband of Magdalena, not Margaretha, Kershner, who md. (2) Rudolph Flenner, and Jacob Baum had died by 1769, leaving three sons under six years of age.
I thought Mr. Woodard's proof was conclusive about which sister had md. (1) Jacob Baum (2) Rudolph Flenner, especially after our research showed that the daughter of Martin Kershner (d 1769) named Margaretha had md. Henry Zeller. Apparently Mrs. Phillips did not know of the death of this Jacob Baum, and she went on to give his further history, but I have administration records for Jacob Baum, Martin Kershner admr., and I think she has not separated out all the various Jacob Baums yet.
I will keep an eye out for Flenner records, and write if I find anything potentially helpful. I could surely use some advice from you on how to research Pennsylvania long-distance, especially land records. We are trying to clarify the Penn/Md Kershner relationships prior to 1800. Do you have a Bedford or Lehigh Co. resource? What about Bucks?
We hope to leave Texas during the hot weather, but our mail is forwarded, and I'll take my Kershner card file. Probably go to Wyoming. Last spring & summer we were at Falls Church! Our brother, Stephen W. Kershner, 8801 Van Winkle--and he has a dau lives in Silver Spring. How about that!