K-080: Records: Susie Bownds, 1861 to 1971
Bownds Research packetSummary
K-080 Closing Summary
Source: Records_SusieBownds_1861-1971.pdf Pages: 25 of 25 transcribed
Verified date range
1861 (Susie's birth) to 1971 (Mamacita's finished packet). The family history inside reaches back to the 1600s in Virginia and, through a published 1899 genealogy, to pre-1066 Yorkshire.
Thread classification
Bounds/Bownds, through Mamacita's grandmother's Cleveland and Butcher families.
What this document reveals
Mamacita wrote this herself in 1970 and 1971, opening with "Our grandmother, Susie Bownds, was born in Independence Co., Ark., as Susan America Theodosia Cleveland." Susie taught at the Maple Springs school near Oil Trough, and L. D. Bownds signed her teaching contract for the school board shortly after their 1880 marriage. The packet traces Susie's father Joseph Cleveland, an Arkansas legislator, back through Col. Joseph Cleveland of Georgia and Jacob Cleveland of Culpeper County, Virginia, and includes her mother Elizabeth Butcher Cleveland's 1911 will.
Most significant facts and leads
- Susie Bownds, born 10 Jan 1861, died 22 Jan 1896 in Bandera County, Texas.
- Her father, Joseph Cleveland, died early 1887 at Newport, Arkansas, age 61.
- Her mother, Elizabeth Butcher Cleveland, died 17 Jul 1911 at Bald Knob, Arkansas; the will settles the year that other notes give as 1910.
- Col. Joseph Cleveland's own 1813 bounty-land application calls him a private, so "Colonel" was likely an honorary title.
- Open: the marriage date is 26 Nov 1880 in the narrative and 30 Nov 1880 on the charts.
Legibility
Clear. Page 8 is a draft chart Mamacita marked obsolete; page 7 is the corrected version.
The originals
The scanned document. Scroll inside the viewer to page through it, or open it full screen.
Open the scanned pages full screenPeople, places and dates
Show the genealogical index
K-080 Genealogical Index
Source: Records_SusieBownds_1861-1971.pdf (25 pages) — /home/claude/kershner_batch2/wave1/ Full transcript: /home/claude/kershner_batch2/transcripts/K-080_full_transcript.md
Classification
Family thread: BOUNDS/BOWNDS maternal line — CONFIRMED.
This document is a genealogy-research packet assembled chiefly by Ruth Bownds Kershner (signed and dated 1971, 1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin, TX), documenting the ancestry of her grandmother, Susie Bownds (née Susan America Theodosia Cleveland, 1861–1896), who married L. D. (Ludovico "Dov/Dolph") Bownds in 1880. The content is overwhelmingly about the Cleveland and Butcher families — Susie's birth (maternal, pre-marriage) surname lines — reached because Susie Bownds married into the Bownds family. The compiler's own surname, "Bownds Kershner," together with the explicit statement "Our grandmother, Susie Bownds..." (Page 1) and "Our grandfather, Ludovico (L.D.) Bownds" confirms this is Ruth Bownds Kershner's own direct maternal-line research, i.e., it documents the Bownds/Bownds-by-marriage line's Cleveland/Butcher ancestry. Given the Kershner surname of the compiler, this document is a direct ancestral record for the Kershner family researching this archive.
Confirmed from content:
- Page 1: "Our grandmother, Susie Bownds, was born in Independence Co., Ark., as SUSAN AMERICA THEODOSIA CLEVELAND."
- Page 1: "Our grandfather, Ludovico (L.D.) Bownds... signed her contract... shortly after they were married."
- Pages 2, 6: signed "Ruth Bownds Kershner, 1971."
- Page 9: Elizabeth Cleveland's 1911 will names "Susie Bounds heirs" as a legatee.
- Page 20: photos' originals "owned by John Bownds, Utopia Tex" — a Bownds-line descendant.
People
| Name | Birth | Death | Relationship to Susie Bownds | Key pages |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Susan America Theodosia Cleveland ("Susie Bownds") | 10 Jan 1861, Independence Co., Ark. | 22 Jan 1896, Bandera Co., TX (buried Jones Cemetery, Utopia, TX) | Subject | 1, 2, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 16 |
| L. D. "Dov/Dolph" (Ludovico) Bownds | 10 June 1857, Pleasant Plains, Independence Co., Ark. | not stated | Husband | 1, 7, 8, 9, 18, 20 |
| Mary J. Bumpass | — | before 1880 (L.D.'s first wife, deceased) | L.D. Bownds's first wife (predecessor to Susie) | 1 |
| Dr. Gabriel Bumpass | — | — | Father of Mary J. Bumpass | 1 |
| Joseph Cleveland (Susie's father) | ca. 1825–1828, Alabama | early 1887, Newport, Jackson Co., Ark., age 61 (per Goodspeed/compiler) or possibly 63 (per Centennial History, flagged as likely error) | Father | 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 23, 24 |
| Elizabeth "Maude" Butcher Cleveland | ca. 1829–1831, Georgia | 17 July 1911, Bald Knob, Ark., age 80 (will/probate), also reported as 1910 | Mother | 1, 6, 7, 8, 9, 19, 20 |
| Thomas J. Butcher | — | before 1860 | Maternal grandfather | 1, 6 |
| Col. Joseph Cleveland | ca. 1791, Franklin Co., Georgia | before 1865, Texas | Paternal grandfather | 1, 2, 6, 7 |
| Martha "Patsy" Meeks | 1792, S.C. | — | Paternal grandmother (wife of Col. Joseph Cleveland) | 1 |
| Rev. Littleton Meeks | 1763, — | 1853 | Great-great-grandfather (Patsy Meeks's father) | 1 |
| Elizabeth Ivey | 1768, Pendleton Co., S.C. | 1858, Habersham Co., GA | Great-great-grandmother (Patsy Meeks's mother) | 1 |
| Wiatt Cleveland | 25 Feb 1764, near Culpeper C.H., VA | 1824–1830, Franklin Co., GA | Great-great-grandfather | 2 |
| Temperance Freeman | before 1770 | after 1830 | Great-great-grandmother (Wiatt's wife) | 2 |
| Jacob Cleveland | ca. 1729, Culpeper Co., VA | 1791 | 3x-great-grandfather | 2 |
| Milly White | 20 Mar 1739, New York City | — | 3x-great-grandmother (Jacob's wife) | 2 |
| Rev. Col. Jeremiah White | — (Revolutionary-era) | — | Milly White's father | 2 |
| Rev. John White | — | — | Milly White's brother; Baptist missionary to the Cherokees, namesake tie to Vann's Creek Church | 2, 25 |
| Jeremiah Cleveland | 1700–1712 (born) | — | 4x-great-grandfather | 2 |
| Alexander Cleveland Jr. | 1659, England or VA | 1770, Orange Co., VA | 5x-great-grandfather | 2 |
| Milly Presley | 1667 | 1770 (reported age 103) | 5x-great-grandmother | 2 |
| Alexander Cleveland (Sr.) | before 1620, England | — | 6x-great-grandfather | 2 |
| Thorkil de Cliveland | — (pre-1066), Gisborough, Yorkshire, England | — | Earliest traced ancestor (per cited 1899 Cleveland genealogy) | 2 |
| Dr. Joseph Christopher Cleveland | 19 Nov 1852, Ind. Co., Ark. | after 1920 | Brother | 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 14, 23, 24 |
| Martha Elizabeth Cleveland | ca. 1850, Alabama | after 1890 (ca. 1888–1920) | Sister | 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 |
| J. W. Kennedy | — (age 30 at 1868 marriage) | — | Brother-in-law (m. Martha Elizabeth Cleveland, 29 Nov 1868) | 7, 8, 9, 10 |
| Henry P. Cleveland | 1855, Arkansas | between 1921–1940 | Brother; attorney, Judsonia, Ark. | 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 13 |
| Mary A. Cleveland | 1858, Arkansas | after 1940, Houston, TX | Sister | 4, 6, 7, 8, 9 |
| J. D. (J. B.) Cantrell | — | before 1921 | Brother-in-law (m. Mary A. Cleveland); of Chicago | 4, 6, 7, 9 |
| Thomas J. Cleveland | 1847, Alabama | 1850–1860 (child) | Brother (died young) | 6, 7, 8 |
| John Cleveland | ca. 1867/1868 | before 1889/1890 | Brother (died young) | 6, 7, 8 |
| James Franklin Cleveland | 1864 | between 1889–1911 (dates conflict in source) | Brother | 6, 7, 8, 9 |
| Charles Edgar Cleveland | ca. 1869 | after 1940 | Brother; MoPac RR engineer, Memphis/Little Rock | 6, 7, 8, 9 |
| Samuel David Cleveland | ca. 1872 | after 1940 | Brother; Van Buren, Ark. | 6, 7, 8, 9 |
| Edmund Littleton Cleveland | ca. 1874/1875 | after 1940 | Brother; North Little Rock (Argenta) | 6, 7, 8, 9 |
| Essie May Bownds | — | — married 1890 | Niece (?) — referenced only via marginal note tying Edmund L. Cleveland's age to her 1890 marriage; likely a daughter of Susie & L. D. Bownds — unconfirmed, see Open Questions | 7 |
| J. B. Sileck (Sibeck?) | — | — | Witness, Elizabeth Cleveland's 1911 will | 9 |
| Catherine Davis | — | — | Witness, Elizabeth Cleveland's 1911 will | 9 |
| Mrs. B. W. Gandrud | — | — | Cited local Tuscaloosa, AL historian/source for Cleveland records | 1 |
| Mr. Fred Cleveland | — | — | Cleveland cousin/contact, retired to family property near Elberton, GA; interviewed by compiler | 2 |
| Pearl Bownds Rainey | — | — | Cited source/contributor (Bownds-line relative) | 7 |
| Marlin Deric Bownds | — | — | Cited source/contributor (Bownds-line relative) | 7 |
| E. R. Wynn | — | — | Cashier, Bald Knob State Bank (1910 letter) — not family, contextual | 14 |
| T. J. Campbell | — | — | President, Bald Knob State Bank — not family, contextual | 14 |
Places
| Place | Significance |
|---|---|
| Oil Trough, Independence Co., Ark. | Susie's childhood home; father's farm, gin and mill; Susie taught school there 1878–1880 |
| Independence County, Ark. | Core family seat in Arkansas, 1851/52 onward |
| Pleasant Plains, Independence Co., Ark. | L. D. Bownds's birthplace |
| Newport, Jackson Co., Ark. | Family moved here; Joseph Cleveland died here 1887; Elizabeth Cleveland's 1911 will devises Newport town lots |
| Judsonia, Ark. | Home/office of Henry P. Cleveland, attorney |
| Bald Knob, Ark. | Home/practice of Dr. J. C. Cleveland; Bald Knob State Bank |
| Argenta (North Little Rock), Ark. | Home of Edmund Littleton Cleveland; Elizabeth Cleveland's residence/death documents reference it |
| Van Buren, Ark. | Home of Samuel David Cleveland |
| Memphis, Tenn. / Little Rock, Ark. | Homes of Charles Edgar Cleveland |
| Houston, Tex. | Home of Mary A. Cleveland (Cantrell) in later life |
| Bandera Co. / Utopia, Texas | Where Susie Bownds died (1896) and is buried (Jones Cemetery); originals of family photos held there by John Bownds as of 1971 |
| Tuscaloosa Co., Alabama | Joseph Cleveland & Elizabeth Butcher's marriage and early married life (ca. 1846–1851) |
| Washington Co., Georgia | Earlier Butcher family location (T. J. Butcher, 1820) |
| Hempstead Co., Ark. | T. J. Butcher's post-Civil-War relocation |
| Franklin Co., Georgia | Col. Joseph Cleveland's and Wiatt Cleveland's home area |
| Elbert Co., Georgia (near Ruckersville, ~20 mi east of Elberton) | Ancestral Cleveland land; Vann's Creek Baptist Church and family cemetery (Jacob Cleveland) |
| Culpeper Co., Virginia | Wiatt Cleveland's and Jacob Cleveland's birthplace |
| Prince William / Orange Co., Virginia | Alexander Cleveland Jr.'s home (Bull Run / Blue Run) |
| Gisborough, Cleveland, Yorkshire, England | Origin of the Cleveland surname (Thorkil de Cliveland, pre-1066) |
Dates / Events
| Date | Event | People | Pages |
|---|---|---|---|
| pre-1066 | Thorkil de Cliveland assumes surname "Cleveland," Yorkshire, England | Thorkil de Cliveland | 2 |
| before 1620 | Birth of Alexander Cleveland (Sr.), England | Alexander Cleveland | 2 |
| 1659 | Birth of Alexander Cleveland Jr. | Alexander Cleveland Jr. | 2 |
| 1700–1712 | Birth of Jeremiah Cleveland | Jeremiah Cleveland | 2 |
| 1729 | Birth of Jacob Cleveland, Culpeper Co., VA | Jacob Cleveland | 2 |
| 10 Oct 1756 | Marriage of Jacob Cleveland & Milly White | Jacob Cleveland, Milly White | 2 |
| 1764 | Birth of Wiatt Cleveland, near Culpeper C.H., VA | Wiatt Cleveland | 2 |
| 1782 | Jacob Cleveland migrates to Georgia | Jacob Cleveland | 2 |
| 1791 | Death of Jacob Cleveland; approx. birth of Col. Joseph Cleveland | Jacob Cleveland, Col. Joseph Cleveland | 1, 2 |
| 2 May 1809 | Marriage of Col. Joseph Cleveland & Martha "Patsy" Meeks, Franklin Co., GA | Col. Joseph Cleveland, Patsy Meeks | 1 |
| 1813 | Col. Joseph Cleveland's Seminole War bounty-land application (as private, Franklin Co. militia) | Col. Joseph Cleveland | 1 |
| 1824–1830 | Death of Wiatt Cleveland, Franklin Co., GA | Wiatt Cleveland | 2 |
| ca. 1825–1828 | Birth of Joseph Cleveland (Susie's father), Alabama | Joseph Cleveland | 1, 6, 7, 8 |
| ca. 1829–1831 | Birth of Elizabeth "Maude" Butcher, Georgia | Elizabeth Butcher | 1, 6, 7, 8 |
| ca. 1846–1851 | Marriage of Joseph Cleveland & Elizabeth Butcher, Tuscaloosa, Ala. | Joseph Cleveland, Elizabeth Butcher | 1, 6, 7, 8 |
| 1847 | Birth of Thomas J. Cleveland (eldest known child) | Thomas J. Cleveland | 6, 7 |
| 1850 census | Tuscaloosa Co., Ala. census shows Joseph C. & Elizabeth Cleveland with 2 children | Joseph Cleveland, Elizabeth Butcher Cleveland | 1 |
| ca. 1850 | Birth of Martha Elizabeth Cleveland | Martha Elizabeth Cleveland | 6, 7 |
| 1851–1852 | Cleveland family removes to Independence Co., Ark. (Oil Trough) | Joseph Cleveland family | 1, 5, 6, 7 |
| 10 June 1857 | Birth of L. D. Bownds, Pleasant Plains, Ind. Co., Ark. | L. D. Bownds | 1 |
| 1860 census | Hempstead Co., Ark. census records T. J. Butcher's family | T. J. Butcher family | 6 |
| 1861–1865 | Joseph Cleveland serves ~18 months–3 years in Confederate Army; POW at Fort Monroe; Battle of Shiloh | Joseph Cleveland | 1, 4, 5, 6, 23, 24 |
| 10 Jan 1861 | Birth of Susan America Theodosia Cleveland ("Susie") | Susie Cleveland | 1, 6, 7, 8, 16 |
| 29 Nov 1868 | Marriage of Martha Elizabeth Cleveland & J. W. Kennedy | Martha E. Cleveland, J. W. Kennedy | 7, 8, 9, 10 |
| 1873 (special session 1874) | Joseph Cleveland serves in Ark. 19th legislature (last Reconstruction legislature), Dist. 4 | Joseph Cleveland | 6 |
| 1874 | Brooks-Baxter War period legislative service | Joseph Cleveland | 5, 23 |
| 2 Nov 1875 | Marriage, Dr. J. C. Cleveland & Nancy Eleanor Vick | J. C. Cleveland, N. E. Vick | 4, 5, 7, 8 |
| 26 or 30 Nov 1880 | Marriage of Susie Cleveland & L. D. Bownds, Independence Co. (license issued Jackson Co.) — date conflict, see Discrepancies | Susie Cleveland, L. D. Bownds | 1, 7, 8 |
| 1878–1880 | Susie Cleveland teaches school, Independence Co. (Maple Springs) | Susie Cleveland | 1, 6 |
| 1883 | Confederate-vet father's Masonic/legislature years recede; receipt dated 2/3/1883 | L. D. Bownds, Elizabeth Cleveland | 18 |
| 1885 | Susie & L. D. Bownds move to Texas | Susie Bownds, L. D. Bownds | 1 |
| 1885 | Death of Nancy Eleanor Vick (Dr. J. C. Cleveland's first wife) | N. E. Vick | 4, 5, 7 |
| 1886 | Marriage, Dr. J. C. Cleveland & Nannie E. Goad | J. C. Cleveland, N. E. Goad | 4, 5, 7 |
| early 1887 | Death of Joseph Cleveland (Susie's father), Newport, Ark., age 61 (per Goodspeed) | Joseph Cleveland | 1, 4, 6, 7, 8 |
| 1888 | Dr. J. C. Cleveland graduates Missouri Medical College; opens practice, later Bald Knob | J. C. Cleveland | 4, 5, 23, 24 |
| 1889 | Publication of Goodspeed's History of Northeastern Arkansas (White Co. entries) | — | 3, 4, 21, 22 |
| 1890 | Essie May Bownds marries (per marginal note) | Essie May Bownds | 7 |
| 22 Jan 1896 | Death of Susie Bownds, Bandera Co., Texas; buried Jones Cemetery, Utopia, TX | Susie Bownds | 7, 8 |
| ca. 1901–1910 | Death of James Franklin Cleveland (date range uncertain) | James Franklin Cleveland | 6, 7, 8 |
| Jan 1908 | James F. Cleveland matter in Jackson Co. Court record | James Franklin Cleveland | 7 |
| Jan 2, 1908 | Postmark, H. P. Cleveland envelope to Jackson Co. Circuit Clerk | H. P. Cleveland | 11 |
| Sept. 7, 1907 | H. P. Cleveland letter re Osmon v. Parsons case | H. P. Cleveland | 13 |
| ~1919–1921 | Publication of Centennial History of Arkansas, Vol. II | — | 5, 23, 24 |
| Sept. 2, 1910 | Bald Knob State Bank letter re garnishment (Western Tie & T. Co. v. Eaton) | E. R. Wynn, J. C. Cleveland (bank officer) | 14 |
| 15 Mar 1911 | Elizabeth Cleveland signs her will, Argenta, Ark. | Elizabeth Cleveland | 9 |
| 17 July 1911 | Death of Elizabeth (Butcher) Cleveland, Bald Knob, Ark., age 80 — conflicts with "1910" reported elsewhere, see Discrepancies | Elizabeth Cleveland | 9, 20 |
| 2 Aug 1911 | Witnesses' probate statement for Elizabeth Cleveland's will | J. B. Sileck, Catherine Davis | 9 |
| 1912 (term) | Probate petition granted to erect monument to Elizabeth Cleveland | Charles Edgar Cleveland (executor) | 9 |
| Oct. 1970 | Compiler's primary on-site courthouse/cemetery/census research trip (Independence & Jackson Counties, Ark.; also Georgia Cleveland sites) | Ruth Bownds Kershner (and "SGK") | 2, 7, 8, 9, 10, 12 |
| 12 Oct 1970 | Site inspection, former Cleveland town lots in Newport (now apartments) | Ruth Bownds Kershner | 9 |
| 1971 | Compilation/copying of this document packet; narrative pages signed and dated | Ruth Bownds Kershner | 1, 2, 6, 20 |
Research Leads / Open Questions
- Marriage date conflict (Susie & L.D. Bownds): Page 1's narrative gives 26 Nov. 1880; the two genealogy charts (Pages 7, 8) both give 30 Nov. 1880, with the license issued in Jackson Co. Needs resolution against the original Jackson Co. marriage-license record.
- Joseph Cleveland's (Susie's father) birth year: variously 1825, 1826, 1827, or 1828 across Pages 1, 6, 7, 8. Likely irreconcilable without an original record; note which source gives which year if citing.
- Joseph Cleveland's death year/age — internal source conflict: Goodspeed (Pages 4/22) and the compiler's own charts (Pages 6, 7, 8) agree on early 1887, age 61. The Centennial History of Arkansas (Pages 5/23–24) instead prints "departed this life in 1867... at the age of sixty-three," which is almost certainly a typographical error for 1887 (the same paragraph describes his legislative service during the 1874 Brooks–Baxter War, which postdates 1867) — flagged in the original document itself by a contemporary marginal note: "date wrong, goodspeed says 1887, age 61." Treat "1867/age 63" in the Centennial History as erroneous.
- Elizabeth (Butcher) Cleveland's death year: the 1911 will and probate record (Page 9 — will dated 15 Mar 1911; witnesses attest 2 Aug 1911 that she died 17 July 1911) is a primary legal record and should be authoritative. However, the Centennial History (Pages 5/23–24) and the compiler's own handwritten note (Page 20) both say she died in 1910. Since the will itself is dated March 1911 (she could not have died in 1910 and signed a will in 1911), 1911 is almost certainly correct and the "1910" in the two secondary notes is the error — still worth flagging explicitly to future researchers.
- Elizabeth Butcher's birth year: 1829 (Pages 6, 20) vs. "1830 or 1831" (Pages 7, 8) — unresolved.
- Two competing genealogy-chart drafts (Pages 7 and 8): Page 8 is explicitly marked "first draft... obsolete" by the compiler; Page 7 is the corrected version and should be treated as authoritative where the two disagree (e.g., children's death-date ranges for Thomas J. and James Franklin Cleveland).
- Col. Joseph Cleveland's military rank: called "Colonel" throughout family tradition and both published county histories, but Page 1 notes his own 1813 bounty-land application stated he was a private in the Franklin County militia — the "Colonel" title is likely honorary or a later embellishment. Worth noting in any formal lineage write-up.
- Essie May Bownds (Page 7 marginal note, tied to Edmund L. Cleveland's age in 1890): identity and relationship unconfirmed. Given the Bownds surname and approximate timing, she may be a daughter of Susie & L. D. Bownds (which would make her a niece to Edmund L. Cleveland) — not corroborated elsewhere in this document. Recommend checking the Bownds family Bible (cited elsewhere as source "6") or Bandera/Utopia, TX records.
- "John Bownds" of Utopia, TX (Page 20, owner of original family photos as of 1971): relationship to Susie & L. D. Bownds not stated in this document — likely a son or grandson, given the Utopia/Bandera Co. TX connection to Susie's death and burial. Worth confirming against Bandera Co. records or the Bownds family Bible.
- Unidentified photographs: the tintype of a young woman (Page 15) and the uncaptioned portrait of an older woman (Page 17) are plausibly Susie Bownds (young) and Elizabeth Cleveland (duplicate/companion print to the captioned Page 19 portrait), respectively, based on their position in the sequence and visual similarity — but neither is explicitly captioned and both should be treated as unconfirmed identifications.
- Land title chain of custody (Page 12): the W½SW 14-13-1 / E½SE 15-13-1 chain-of-title notes (entries 1861–1899) are not tied to a named family member in the note itself. Likely relates to Cleveland family land near Oil Trough given its placement in the document, but this is not confirmed — worth checking against the Independence Co. land/deed records directly.
- "Robert Geddes Davies" entry (Page 24): a Hot Springs/Lake Village, Arkansas attorney's family (Davies/Gaines), with no apparent surname or geographic connection to the Cleveland/Butcher/Bownds line. Appears to be incidental content from the same printed book page rather than a deliberately included family record. Recommend excluding from the family tree unless a connection surfaces elsewhere.
- James Franklin Cleveland's exact death date: ranges conflict across Pages 6 ("1901–1910"), 7 ("between 1889–1911," overwritten "1889-1970"), and 8 ("1889-1970") — likely reflects the compiler's own uncertainty/work-in-progress rather than a resolvable discrepancy in sources; flag any future citation accordingly.
- Butcher family — Patrick H. Butcher: Page 6 shows a caret-inserted note tentatively adding "Patrick H. Butcher" as a possible additional child of T. J. Butcher (alongside Elizabeth, Thomas, and James W.), based on a Patrick H. Butcher, age 22, listed as a near neighbor in the 1860 Hempstead Co. census. Relationship not confirmed — could be a sibling or an unrelated same-surname neighbor.
- Mrs. B. W. Gandrud's Cleveland records / the cited 1899 three-volume Cleveland genealogy (Page 2): neither source is included in this packet; both would be valuable to locate directly to verify the pre-1800s Cleveland ancestry (Jacob, Wiatt, Col. Joseph, and the English generations back to Thorkil de Cliveland).
Summary
Verified date range: The filename's claimed span, 1861–1971, is accurate for the document's core subject frame: Susie Bownds's birth (10 Jan 1861) through the compiler Ruth Bownds Kershner's research/compilation activity, documented as ongoing in October 1970 and finalized/copied in 1971. Within that frame, the packet also includes discrete dated records spanning 1868 (earliest cited marriage record) through 1911 (Elizabeth Cleveland's will and probate) and 1907–1910 (business correspondence). Separately, the narrative genealogical content (Pages 1–2, 6–8) reaches back far earlier than 1861, tracing the Cleveland surname to pre-1066 Yorkshire, England, and specific ancestors from the 1600s–1700s in Virginia, South Carolina, and Georgia — this deep-ancestry material is historical background assembled by the 1970–71 research, not records contemporaneous with those earlier centuries, so it does not conflict with the filename's framing of the document's working range.
Thread classification: Confirmed Bounds/Bownds maternal line. The document centers on Susan America Theodosia Cleveland ("Susie Bownds," 1861–1896) and was compiled by her granddaughter, Ruth Bownds Kershner, in 1970–71.
Significance to the Bounds/Bownds line: This is one of the most substantive single documents likely to be found for this line: it supplies a sourced, multi-generation Cleveland/Butcher pedigree (Susie Bownds's birth family) running from Susie back through nine further generations to a pre-1066 English origin for the Cleveland surname, cross-referenced against two independent published county histories (Goodspeed 1889/90 and Centennial History of Arkansas ca. 1921), primary legal records (Elizabeth Cleveland's 1911 will and probate file), vital/cemetery records, family correspondence, and five photographs — all assembled first-hand by a direct descendant who did courthouse and cemetery fieldwork in Arkansas and Georgia in October 1970.
Most significant facts and leads:
- Susie Bownds's full birth name and parentage are established beyond doubt: Susan America Theodosia Cleveland, b. 10 Jan 1861, daughter of Joseph Cleveland and Elizabeth "Maude" Butcher Cleveland of Independence Co., Arkansas (Oil Trough).
- Her husband, L. D. "Dov/Dolph" Bownds (b. 10 June 1857, Pleasant Plains, Ark.), was a widower when he married Susie; his first wife was Mary J. Bumpass, daughter of Dr. Gabriel Bumpass — a previously undocumented prior marriage worth pursuing in Bumpass-family records.
- Susie died young (age 35) in Bandera Co., Texas in 1896 and is buried at Jones Cemetery, Utopia, TX — establishing the Texas branch of the family and a specific, locatable grave to verify/visit.
- Elizabeth Cleveland's 1911 will (transcribed in full, Page 9) is a primary legal document naming all surviving children, including "Susie Bounds heirs," and is strong direct evidence for the sibling set and for Susie's own descendants having inherited a share of Newport town-lot property.
- The Cleveland line is traced via a cited 1899 three-volume published Cleveland genealogy and a named Tuscaloosa-area historian (Mrs. B. W. Gandrud) back through Jacob Cleveland (GA, 1782), Alexander Cleveland Jr. and Sr. (colonial Virginia, 1600s), to Thorkil de Cliveland of Yorkshire, England before 1066 — an exceptional depth of lineage if independently verifiable, and a strong target for verification against the cited 1899 genealogy itself.
- A 1970 site visit corroborated the Georgia ancestral connection on the ground: the compiler met "Mr. Fred Cleveland" (a descendant still on the ancestral land near Elberton, GA) and photographed the Van's Creek Baptist Church historical marker (Page 25), which independently lists "John White" and "Milly White" as original 1785 church members — directly corroborating the Milly White/Rev. John White family story recounted in the narrative (Page 2).
- Dr. Joseph Christopher Cleveland (Susie's brother) is unusually well documented as a long-practicing Bald Knob, Arkansas physician (three marriages, Vice President of Bald Knob State Bank) via two independent published county histories plus original correspondence and a bank letter — useful for cross-referencing the wider Cleveland sibling set and in-laws (Vick, Goad, Webb, Cantrell, Kennedy families).
- Two competing, differently-dated handwritten genealogy-chart drafts (Pages 7–8) survive side by side, with the compiler's own "obsolete" label on the earlier one — a useful illustration of the research's evolution and a caution to always prefer Page 7's data over Page 8's where they conflict.
- Open identification questions remain for two family photographs (Pages 15, 17) and for several minor figures (Essie May Bownds, John Bownds of Utopia TX, Patrick H. Butcher) who are plausible but unconfirmed close relatives — worthwhile follow-up targets using the Bownds family Bible and Bandera/Utopia, Texas records, both cited elsewhere as sources but not included in this packet.
- The document itself flags its own two most important internal factual conflicts (Joseph Cleveland's death year/age, and the "1867" vs. "1887" typo in the Centennial History) with contemporary marginal annotations — the compiler's own corrections should be treated as authoritative guidance when discrepancies arise in future citation of this source.
Illegible pages: None of the 25 pages were fully illegible. A small number of individual words/names (noted in the transcript's closing list) were uncertain due to handwriting quality and are marked [?] or [illegible] at point of use; none affect the document's core genealogical conclusions.
Full transcript
Typed from the scans, handwriting included. Unclear words are marked [?]. The original scans are kept in the family archive.
K-080 Full Transcript
Source PDF: /home/claude/kershner_batch2/wave1/Records_SusieBownds_1861-1971.pdf Confirmed page count: 25 of 25 (matches source filename claim)
Page 1 — Typed narrative: "Cleveland" family background, by Ruth Bownds Kershner (1971)
Header (top right): "CLEVELAND"
Our grandmother, Susie Bownds, was born in Independence Co., Ark., as SUSAN AMERICA THEODOSIA CLEVELAND. She taught in the Maple Springs school near Oil Trough, a town named after a German explorer's description of its rich bottom lands as an "Oil Trove". Our grandfather, Ludovico (L.D.) Bownds, then called Dov or Dolph, signed her contract on behalf of the school board shortly after they were married. He was born at Pleasant Plains in Independence Co., 10 June 1857, and at age 23 was a widower, having lost his first wife, Mary J. Bumpass, daughter of Dr. Gabriel Bumpass. Susie and Dov were married 26 Nov. 1880. He bought the marriage license in Newport, Jackson Co., which was closer than Batesville, Independence Co. seat.
Let's leave the story of their life in Arkansas and the move to Texas in 1885, and look backward at Susie's family. She was born 10 Jan. 1861.
Her father was JOSEPH C. CLEVELAND, who was a farmer, justice of the peace, owned a steam cotton gin and mill near Oil Trough, and served in the Civil War. Oil Trough was a regular stop for boats plying the beautiful White River, and there is still a ferry across it there. Sue's mother, Elizabeth Butcher Cleveland, remembered from visits she made to Texas and pictures still in the family, was the daughter of Thomas J. Butcher. The Clevelands and Butchers lived in Tuscaloosa Co., Ala., at the time Joseph C, son of Col. JOSEPH CLEVELAND, and Elizabeth Butcher, were married.
Here end the family records we have found, and for further information we have to depend on family records of other Clevelands, on Public Records, on published histories and on other evidence.
Several hundred of the early marriage records of Tuscaloosa were on loose sheets and have been lost, but Joseph C. and Elizabeth Cleveland were probably married about 1846, the 1850 census of Tuscaloosa County, Ala., showing them with children Thomas J., 3, and a baby girl 2 months old, name not given. Joseph C. Cleveland said he was born about 1827 in Alabama and Elizabeth about 1829 in Georgia. They removed to Arkansas 1851 or 1852. Our Butcher research shows Thomas J. Butcher in Washington Co. Georgia in 1820, but all the records of that county were burned during the Civil War and much work will have to be done to trace them. Dr. J. C. Cleveland, Susie's brother, said T. J. Butcher removed to Hempstead Co. Ark. after the Civil War, and we have located a number of his other children there in 1870.
Fortunately, a local Tuscaloosa historian* has Cleveland records, and tells us Col. Joseph Cleveland, who was born about 1791 in Franklin Co., Georgia, was married there 2 May 1809 to Martha (nickname, Patsy) Meeks, born 1792 in S. C. She was daughter of Rev. Littleton Meeks, 1763-1853, who came with his brother, Nacy Meeks, to Virginia from England when quite young. Littleton Meeks' wife was Elizabeth Ivey, born in Pendleton Co. S.C. 1768, and died in 1858 in Habersham Co. Georgia from which Franklin Co. was formed. He is said to have been a Revolutionary soldier.
Col. Joseph Cleveland's military title may have been quite honorary, as his application for bounty land for service in the Seminole Wars of 1813 stated that he was a private in the militia of Franklin County.
*Mrs. B. W. Gandrud
Page 2 — Typed narrative continued; signed and dated by compiler
Header (top right): "Cleveland p 2"
Col. Joseph Cleveland's father was WIATT CLEVELAND, born 25 Feb. 1764 near Culpeper Courthouse, Culpeper Co., Va, and died between 1824 and 1830, in Franklin Co. Georgia. We have not yet searched Franklin Co. for history, but his wife was Temperance Freeman, born before 1770, who died after 1830. In his will, 1814, her brother, James Freeman, named her and three other sisters, Ann Simmons, Mary Wheeler, and Susannah Pressel.
Wiatt's father was JACOB CLEVELAND, who migrated to Georgia about 1782, having lived the previous three years in Abbeville District, S. C., just across the river. There are still Clevelands on this land in Elbert Co. Georgia, where there is still an old road to a ferry. We talked with Mr. Fred Cleveland, who has retired from Denver Colo. to the family property, and visited historic Vann's Creek Baptist Church and the old family cemetery on the farm. The area is about 20 miles east of Elberton, Georgia, at Ruckersville. Jacob Cleveland, (born about 1729 in Culpeper Co. Va, died 1791,) and his wife, Milly White, were married 10 Oct. 1756. Both are said to be buried in their family cemetery but we found no stones for them. However, another of their sons, Reuben, is buried there, his marker saying he was born 18 Aug. 1776 and died 1851. Milly White was born 20 March 1739 in New York City, the daughter of Revolutionary Col. Jeremiah White and granddaughter of Absolem Martin of Maryland. Her brother, Rev. John White, came to Georgia as a Baptist missionary to the Indians. A historic marker at the Vann's Creek church, the oldest in the state, says it was named for his convert, an Indian called Joseph Vann.
With Col. Joseph Cleveland, Wiatt Cleveland, his father, and Jacob Cleveland, his grandfather, we pick up the story in a three-volume Cleveland genealogy published in 1899.
Jacob Cleveland is said to have been the son of JEREMIAH CLEVELAND, born between 1700 and 1712. We do not have the name of his wife, but his father is said to have been
ALEXANDER CLEVELAND JR., born 1659 in England or Virginia, whose wife was Milly Presley, born 1667. They lived on Bull Run in Prince William County, Va., and died in 1770 on Blue Run in Orange Co. Va. They lived to be so extraordinarily old -- he 111, she 103 -- that records were made at the time.
Alexander Cleveland Jr.'s father was also ALEXANDER CLEVELAND, who was born in England before 1620, possibly some years before that. He is thought also to have immigrated to Prince William Co. Va. Alexander Cleveland was probably a brother or near relative of Moses Cleveland, the ancestor of the New England Clevelands, who lived at Ipswich, Suffolk, and sailed from London to Massachusetts in 1635.
The author of the Cleveland genealogy traces the line to THORKIL DE CLIVELAND, in Gisborough, Cleveland, County York, England, who prior to 1066 assumed the surname Cleveland from the name of the area.
- - - - - Ruth Bownds Kershner 1971
1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin Tx 78746
PLEASE, will everyone contribute additions and corrections! If you would like copies of the pages quoted from the Cleveland genealogy, write for directions.
Page 3 — Printed source: Goodspeed's History of Northeastern Arkansas, White County, p. 145
Handwritten top margin: "Good Speed , Northeastern 1880 Arkansas" [date as written; publication is generally cited 1889/1890 — see Open Questions]
Printed header: "WHITE COUNTY. 145"
[Left column] County, settling on a tract of railroad land, where the father died seven years later, September 17, 1874, his wife having died October 16, 1870. Their children are as follows: Mary Jane (who became the consort of L. D. Hendrickson, deceased, and is living in Kentucky with her five children), Millie C. (married Jasper Scott, and in 1856 moved to Illinois; her husband was killed at the battle of Nashville, in 1865, leaving her with six children), W. B. (was killed at Franklin, Ky., while a member of the Eighth Tennessee Regiment), Mary F. (was married to R. H. Ferguson, but died after having borne two children), John H. (residing in Texas, and by his wife, who was Miss Mary Ware, is the father of six children), Perlila C. (was wedded to John Hodges, and upon her death left two children), Pleasant T. (died at Jackson, Miss., while serving in the Confederate army), Arthur Smith (our subject), Thomas J. and Samuel B. Arthur Smith Claiborn was born in De Kalb County, Tenn., February 3, 1847, and was educated in the subscription schools of his native county, but it must be acknowledged that his advantages were very meager, and at the time he had attained his twenty-first birthday he had only received three months' schooling. He immediately began business for himself upon attaining his majority, and for two years raised crops of cotton and corn on shares, and at the end of this time was married to Miss Martha J. Hale, a native of Mississippi and daughter of Francis J. and Louisa (White) Hale, who were among the old settlers of Arkansas, having come to the State in 1859. Their marriage took place December 2, 1869, and of eight children born to their union seven are living: Elnora (born October 7, 1870), William B. (born August 20, 1872), James (born July 25, 1874), Mattie J. (born in September, 1876, and died in August, 1877), Annie (born October 16, 1878), Alcora (born March 28, 1882), Arthur S. (born February 27, 1885) and Aver A. (born February 26, 1886). After their marriage Mr. and Mrs. Claiborn settled on eighty acres of land belonging to the latter, and in 1876 Mr. Claiborn became able to purchase 116 acres of wild land, which he has improved and to which he has added
[Right column] eighty acres. He now has seventy-five acres under cultivation, a good frame house, good barns and one tenant house. He rented his land on shares until this year (1889) but now rents for cash. Mr. and Mrs. Claiborn and two of their children, Elnora and William, hold memberships in the Methodist Episcopal Church, South, and Mr. Claiborn is a Democrat in his political views. He has always been a liberal contributor to the advancement of religious, social and educational institutions, and has also given generously to all enterprises which he deemed worthy of support.
Green B. Clay is a well-to-do farmer and stock raiser of Cadron Township, and was the youngest in a family of ten children of John and Diallia (Morris) Clay. Mr. Clay was a native of North Carolina. His family consisted of the following children: Nancy, Harriet, Louisa, Jackson M., Emily, Sarah, Susan, William H., Martha and Green B. (our subject.) He was reared on a farm in Tennessee, where he was born in 1827, and started out in life when he was sixteen years of age. In 1851 he was married to Mary W. Mizzells, a daughter of Miles and Elizabeth (Rooks) Mizzells. In 1868 Mr. Clay bought a farm in Tennessee. He subsequently sold it and moved to Arkansas, settling in White County, where he bought a farm of 560 acres, clearing about seventy-three acres. Mrs. Clay was the mother of eighteen children, eight of whom are still living: John M., Joseph H., Zacariah M., Francis M., James N., George A., Charles C. and Albert A. He was married the second time to Nancy E. Burton (nee Neal), a widow. To them have been given five children: Walter L., Nathan B., Stephen M., Neoma Parlee and an infant which is not named. Mr. and Mrs. Clay are members of the Missionary Baptist Church. He is a strong Democrat and a member of the County Wheel. He is deeply interested in all work for the good of the church, school or any public enterprise.
J. C. Cleveland, M. D., was born in Independence County, November 19, 1852, and is the son of Joseph and Elizabeth (Butcher) Cleveland, natives of Georgia and Alabama, respectively. Mr.
[entry continues on Page 4]
Page 4 — Printed source: Goodspeed's History of Northeastern Arkansas, White County, p. 146 (concludes J. C. Cleveland, M.D. entry; names Susan A. T. Bownds)
Handwritten top margin: "Good Speed Northeastern 1880 White Co. Ark"
Printed header: "146 HISTORY OF ARKANSAS."
[Left column] Joseph Cleveland moved to Alabama when a young man, where he was married and in 1852, he removed to Independence County, Ark. He served his county a number of times in an official capacity, and in 1873 he represented his county in the legislature. He served eighteen months in the Confederate army, during which time he was taken prisoner and held at Fortress Monroe eight months before he was exchanged. He was with Gen. Price in his raid through Missouri and Kansas. He was a Republican and belonged to the Masonic fraternity, in which he had taken the Royal Arch degree. He died in the early part of the year 1887, at Newport, Ark., at the age of sixty-one. Mrs. Cleveland is still living and a resident of Newport, Ark., and is the mother of eleven children, nine of whom still survive: Martha E. (wife of J. W. Kennedy), J. C. (our subject), Henry P. (a lawyer by profession), Mary A. (wife of J. D. Cantrell), Susan A. T. (wife of L. D. Bownds), James F., Charles E., Samuel and Edward. Dr. J. C. Cleveland began his career as a school-teacher in his nineteenth year, following that profession till 1883, when he began the study of medicine. He graduated from the Missouri Medical College in 1888, first having taken lectures at the Kentucky School of Medicine, Louisville. Dr. Cleveland was married, November 7, 1875, to Miss Nancy E. Vick, a daughter of Dr. T. A. Vick. She died in 1885, having had three children, only one of whom survives, Lavina E., who is still living with her father. Dr. Cleveland was again married, in 1886, to Miss Nannie F. Goad, who is the mother of one daughter: Susan Estella. Mrs. Cleveland is a member of the Methodist Episcopal Church, South. The Doctor is a member of the Masonic fraternity and a strong Republican. He is now a resident of Bald Knob, where he has built up a large and successful practice, and is an enterprising and highly respected citizen.
John D. Coffey is a well-known citizen of White County and was born in Macon, Fayette County, Tenn., June 19, 1838. His father, David P. Coffey, was a Presbyterian clergyman, and first saw the light of this world in Tennessee in November,
[Right column] 1805. He was given all the advantages for an education to be had at that time, and applied himself so assiduously to his studies, that he became an accomplished and finely educated gentleman. He was married in his native State November 12, 1835, to Miss Mary C. Cogville, a daughter of Charlie and Pollie Cogville, and to their union fourteen children were born, of which John D. is the second child and the oldest son. Of that family seven are now living, six residing in this State. The Rev. Coffey immigrated from Tennessee, in 1854, and located near Searcy, where he died in 1883, his good wife surviving him but two years. He was a member of the Masonic lodge, and also a Royal Arch Mason, and was the originator of the first church that was ever organized in this township, where John D. Coffey now resides, derived its title from his father, in whose honor it was named. John D. served in the late war on the Confederate side, and enlisted in 1861, in Douglas County, in Brown's Tennessee Regiment. His first hard fight was at the battle of Shiloh, and he also engaged in numerous other engagements. He was captured at Port Edson, but was soon after paroled, and at once returned home to claim his promised bride, Miss Malicia G. Harris. After his marriage Mr. Coffey returned to the war and accompanied Price on his raid through Missouri, and received his final discharge from service in 1865. To Mr. and Mrs. Coffey have been born a family of eight children: John H., Mary, Josephus, Lucy E., Hugh, James S., Minnie C. Mr. Coffey has a good farm of forty acres, finely stocked, and with all the conveniences and modern improvements to make the home comfortable. Himself and wife are members of the Presbyterian Church, and highly respected by every one.
John Reed Coffey is a prominent farmer and miller of White County, Ark., and owes his nativity to the State of Tennessee, the date of his birth being December 19, 1856. His father, Wiley D. Coffey, was born in Bedford County, Tenn., October 6, 1827, where he received his education, and there married Narcissa A. Muse, August 5, 1850.
Page 5 — Printed source: Centennial History of Arkansas, Vol. II, pp. 263–264 (compressed scan of both pages on one image; full-resolution individual rescans appear at Pages 23–24)
Handwritten top margin (right): "pub after 1919 - prob 1921"
Printed header: "CENTENNIAL HISTORY OF ARKANSAS Vol II 263"
of books which he highly prizes. He is a member of the Methodist Episcopal church, South, and in his political views is a stanch democrat. His fellow citizens, recognizing his worth and ability, have called him to public office and he has served as alderman and city treasurer and for nine years was chairman of the school board, performing effective service for the public good in these various capacities. Fraternally he is identified with the Knights of Pythias. For thirty-four years Mr. McClure has been a resident of Russellville, arriving here with a cash capital of three dollars and a half and an indebtedness amounting to twenty-five dollars, while he now ranks with the most substantial business men of the town, which has greatly benefited through his progressive spirit and intelligently directed activities. His life has been one of unremitting industry and to him has come the crown of earnest effort and persistency of purpose—success and an honored name.
J. C. CLEVELAND, M. D.
Dr. J. C. Cleveland, a physician and surgeon for more than a third of a century, practices at Bald Knob, where his capability has again and again been demonstrated in his successful handling of important and involved medical cases. Dr. Cleveland is a native son of Arkansas, his birth having occurred in Independence county, November 19, 1852, his parents being Joseph and Elizabeth (Butcher) Cleveland, who were natives of Georgia and Alabama, respectively, their marriage being celebrated in Tuscaloosa, Alabama. The father was a son of Joseph Cleveland, a native of Georgia, who served with the rank of colonel in the Seminole war. In days of peace he engaged extensively in farming in Georgia, where he owned many slaves, and he also carried on merchandising there. Sustaining many losses on account of the ravages of war, he removed to Texas and there died ere the war had been brought to a termination. The maternal grandfather of Dr. Cleveland was T. J. Butcher, a native of Alabama, who carried on farming on a large scale. He removed to Hempstead county, Arkansas, after his son-in-law removed with his family to this state and his death there occurred.
It was in the year 1851 that Joseph Cleveland came with his family to Arkansas, settling in Independence county, having made the journey across the country with horse team and wagon. He purchased a preemption near Oil Trough and had to clear most of the land. For three years he served in the Confederate army and was captured while participating in the General Price raid in Missouri. He was sent to Fort Monroe, where he was incarcerated for ten months, and then being paroled, returned home, walking from Chattanooga, Tennessee, and crossing the Mississippi river on a raft, which he and his companions made. He had three brothers who were in the battle of Shiloh. Joseph Cleveland had his gun shot out of his hand, and his trousers were on one occasion pierced by bullets, but he escaped injury. With his return home he resumed farming and he also took an active interest in public affairs, serving as a member of the state legislature during the time of the Brooks-Baxter war. He was in the legislature during the extra session called by Governor Brooks and in various ways aided in shaping the destiny of the state during that momentous period. Returning to Independence county, he resumed farming and also operated a mill and steam cotton gin near Oil Trough. Later he retired and removed to Newport, where he departed this life in 1867 [sic — see marginal note below], at the age of sixty-three years. His widow long survived him, her death occurring in 1910 at the age of eighty years. In their family were eleven children, six of whom are living: J. C., H. P., an attorney of Judsonia; Mary, who is the widow of J. B. Cantrell of Chicago, Illinois; C. E. of Memphis, Tennessee; Samuel, living in Van Buren, Arkansas, and Edmund L. of North Little Rock. The parents were consistent members of the Methodist Episcopal church, South, and Mr. Cleveland was a Royal Arch Mason. His political endorsement was given to the republican party and he served for many years as justice of the peace and also filled the position of county commissioner in Independence county.
[Marginal annotation, handwritten, right margin:] "date wrong, goodspeed says 1887, age 61"
Dr. Cleveland pursued his education in the public schools of his native county and also through private instruction at home. He taught in the rural districts and in the town schools for several years, and afterward began reading medicine, while for a time he was employed in the drug business. He afterward attended the Kentucky School of Medicine and later the Louisville Medical College, while later he was graduated from the Missouri Medical College of St. Louis, winning the M. D. degree in 1888. Previous to this time he had practiced at Russell, Arkansas, and following his graduation he went to Newport, Arkansas, where he opened an office. In 1888 he came to Bald Knob, where he established an office and has since devoted his attention to medical and surgical practice. He has taken postgraduate work in the Chicago Polyclinic, and in 1919 he opened a private sanitarium, which he has since conducted. He devotes practically all
Printed header: "264 CENTENNIAL HISTORY OF ARKANSAS Vol II"
of his attention to his professional interests, which are of an important character, and his ability is demonstrated in the excellent results which follow his labors in the treatment of disease. For thirty-two consecutive years he has been local surgeon and dispenser of medicine for the Missouri Pacific Railroad Company. He belongs to the White County Medical Society, the Arkansas State and Southern Medical Societies, the American Medical Association and the Southern Railroad Medical Association. He enjoys the high respect and confidence of his colleagues and contemporaries in medical practice and his position has long been a creditable and enviable one.
Dr. Cleveland was married to Miss Eleanor Vick, and they had three children, two of whom died in infancy. The surviving daughter, Vina E., is the wife of C. E. Preston, a linotype operator on the paper of Memphis. For his second wife Dr. Cleveland chose Nannie E. Goad, and they became parents of three children: Estella, the wife of Perdy Spriggs of Cairo, Illinois; Hattie May, the wife of Dr. J. B. Crawford, a practicing physician of Benton, Arkansas, and one who died in infancy. For his third wife Dr. Cleveland chose Mrs. Dora (Winfield) Webb, and by a former marriage Mrs. Cleveland has a daughter, Cecile, who is the wife of B. J. Perham, a bookkeeper with the Fruit Exchange of Bald Knob.
Dr. Cleveland is an exemplary representative of Masonry, having taken the degrees of the Blue Lodge at Newport, the chapter and the council at Bald Knob, and he has served as high priest of the chapter. He also belongs to the Woodmen of the World, the Knights of Pythias, is examining physician of the former and passed through all of the chairs of the latter. His political endorsement has always been given to the republican party, and he has staunchly advocated its principles. His entire life has been passed in Arkansas and thus for almost seventy years he has been a witness of the growth, progress and development of the state. He served as a member of Baxter body guard during the Brooks-Baxter war, although but a boy in his teens at the time. Many events which are to others matters of history are to him matters of personal knowledge and experience, and his reminiscences concerning the early days in Arkansas are most interesting and instructive. All who know Dr. Cleveland, and he has a wide acquaintance, speak of him in terms of high regard by reason of his splendid professional attainments and, moreover, by reason of the sterling traits of his character.
[Page 5's compressed scan ends here; the continuation of p. 264 ("ROBERT GEDDES DAVIES") was cropped out of this image and is captured in full at Page 24.]
Page 6 — Typed: "Cleveland" family summary by Ruth Bownds Kershner (1971), incl. Butcher family
Header (top right): "CLEVELAND"
Col JOSEPH CLEVELAND, b ca 1791 Georgia; served in Seminole War; planter in Alabama; to Texas during Civil War where he died before 1865. Tuscaloosa Co Ala, (w/wife Patsy 1834 land records; w/wife Martha (b ca 1792,) 1850 census?) He was father of: Joseph Cleveland
JOSEPH CLEVELAND (s of Joseph), b ca 1827 Ala. where he md. ca 1846 in Tuscaloosa, Elizabeth Butcher. In 1851 or 1852, they moved to Independence Co., Ark., making the trip with horse and wagon and settling at Oil Trough. There he was a farmer and operated a steam oil mill and gin. He served as J.P. and as the representative from Dist. 4 (Independence and Van Buren Co.'s) in the 19th Ark. legislature (roster lists him as "Joe Cleveland") 1873, (special session 1874) which was the last Reconstruction legislature. He had served in the Confederate Army 18 months and had three brothers in the Battle of Shiloh. He was a Republican and Royal Arch Mason. When he retired, he moved to Newport, where he died early 1887 aged 61.
Children of Joseph Cleveland and Elizabeth Butcher (11):
Thomas J. b 1847 Ala, died 1850-1860
Martha E. b 1850 Ala, d 1890-1910, married J. W. Kennedy
Joseph Christopher Cleveland, M. D., b 1852, li 1922 Bald Knob Ark.
Henry P., b 1855, lawyer, li 1922 Judsonia Ark
Mary A., b 1858, married J. D. Cantrell, li 1922 Chicago Ill, d Houston Tex after 1940, 714 Arlington St.
Susan America Theodosia, b 1861, d 1896 Bandera Co Texas, married L. D. Bownds; taught school Ind. Co. 1878-1880.
James Franklin, b 1864, d 1901-1910
Charles Edgar, ca 1920 engineer for MoPac RR, Memphis Tenn; li Memphis Tenn 1921, 1414 W 4th St, Little Rock Ark 1940; b 1869
John, b ca 1867, d before 1890, prob. as child
Samuel David, li Van Buren Ark 1922 and 1940; b 1872
Edmund Littleton, li 1504 Short W 17th St, N Little Rock 1940, Argenta (earlier name for N. Little Rock) 1911; b 1874
BUTCHER
T. J. BUTCHER, moved from Ala. to Hempstead Co. Ark. after 1850 where he died before 1860. Father of: Elizabeth, prob Thomas and James W. Butcher, [caret-inserted: "Patrick H. Butcher"]
Maude Elizabeth Butcher, b 1829 Geo., md ca 1846 Joseph Cleveland. She died at Bald Knob Ark. 17 July 1911.
Thomas Butcher b 1825 Geo, 1850 census Tuscaloosa with Levina (Yerby) 20, b NC and Wm H 4/12 b Ala; in 1860 census Hempstead Co Ark, T. J. Butcher 35, b Geo. Lavinia P 29 b Ala, Wm H 10 b Ala, John T 6 b Ark, Benj F 4 and Mary F 3, all born Ark; also a housekeeper, Naomi Heher. Next door were: James W Butcher 27 b Geo, Margaret C b Tenn, and Patrick H Butcher 22 b Geo.
Ruth Bownds Kershner 1971
Page 7 — Handwritten genealogy chart "JOSEPH CLEVELAND, Page C 1" (dated Oct 1970 — appears to be the corrected/final draft)
Handwritten top right: "Oct 1970" Printed/typed header: "JOSEPH CLEVELAND" with "Page C 1" at top right margin
✓ Joseph Cleveland¹,² lived Oil Trough Indep Co in 1858 and in 1873; 1860, Christian Twp. b. 1828¹⁰ Ala. / 1825 or 1826, Georgia¹,² son Col Joseph B Cleveland d. early 1887 age 61, Newport, Jackson Co Ark m. before 1850, Tuscaloosa Ala, moved to Ind Co Ark 1851
✓ Maude³ Elizabeth Butcher, dau of T. J Butcher of Ala¹, lived Wash. Co, Geo, 1820 b. 1829⁶ʰ / 1830 or 1831, Ala. d. 17 July 1911, Bald Knob Ark. age 80¹ (White Co)
Children of Joseph Cleveland and Maude Elizabeth Butcher (Eleven, ~~order unknown~~):
2. Martha Elizabeth Cleveland⁴
b. ~1850 Ala. about 1850 d. after 1890
m. (age 18) 29 Nov 1868 J W Kennedy (age 30)⁵
3. Dr. Joseph Christopher Cleveland, lived after 1888 Bald Knob Ark
b. 19 Nov 1852, Ind. Co. Ark.² d. after 1920¹
m. (1) 2 Nov 1875 Nancy Eleanor Vick (21) dau Dr T A Vick, she died 1885²
m. (2) Nannie E. Goad 1886²
m. (3) Mrs. Dora Winfield Webb¹
1. Thomas J. Cleveland b. 1847 d. 1850-1860 [struck through: "before 1890, possibly unmarried"]⁴
John Cleveland 1868 [b. presumed]
James Franklin⁴ Cleveland² b. 1864 d. between 1889-1911 [overwritten: 1889-1970], in Jackson Co Court Record Jan 1908
✓ Susan America Theodosia Cleveland³,⁶,⁴
b. 10 Jan 1861⁶ prob Ind Co Ark
d. 22 Jan 1896 Bandera Co Texas, buried Jones Cemetery, Utopia Tex⁷
m. 30 Nov 1880 Ind Co Ark⁸ license issued Jackson Co.
L. D. Bownds
Henry P Cleveland¹⁰, attorney
b. 1855 Ark¹⁰ d. between 1921-1940
Mary A Cleveland¹,²,⁹
b. 1858 Ark¹⁰ d. after 1940 prob Houston Texas⁹
m. J B Cantrell⁹,¹ of Chicago² d before 1921, lived 714 Arlington St. Ho. Tx.
Charles Edgar Cleveland⁴,⁹,² lived Memphis Tenn 1921, Little Rock Ark 1940
d. after 1940, ca 1920 engineer for Mo.Pac. RR, 1414 W 4th St, no ch.
Samuel David Cleveland⁴,⁹,² lived Van Buren Ark 1940⁹
d. after 1940
Edmund Littleton Cleveland⁴,⁹,² lived 1504 Short W 17th St, North Little Rock⁹ (called Argenta 1911)⁷
b. about 1875 d. after 1940
[marginal note] "age 15 when Essie May Bownds married 1890"
References:
- Centennial History of Arkansas Vol II White Co pub about 1920 pp 263-4
- Goodspeed Northeastern Arkansas White Co pp145-146 pub 1890
- Pearl Bownds Rainey
- Will of Elizabeth Cleveland 1911
- Records, Independence Co. Ark.
- Bownds Family Bible
- Ruth Bownds Kershner
- Records Jackson Co Ark
- Records Marlin Deric Bownds
- 1860 census, Ind. Co. Ark / 1870 / 1850
Page 8 — Handwritten genealogy chart "JOSEPH CLEVELAND" (dated Oct 1970, marked "First draft" / "obsolete" — superseded by Page 7)
Handwritten top right: "Oct 1970, First draft" and "obsolete"
JOSEPH CLEVELAND
Joseph Cleveland b. 1825 or 1826 in Georgia d. early 1887, Newport, Jackson Co. Ark age 61 m. before 1851, Tuscaloosa, Ala.
Maude Elizabeth Butcher, dau of T. J. Butcher b 1830 or 1831 d 17 July 1911, Bald Knob, Ark. age 80
Children of Joseph Cleveland and Maude Elizabeth Butcher, 11:
2.(?) Dr. Joseph Christopher Cleveland b 19 Nov 1852, Ind. Co. Ark. Lived Russell Ark 1888, then Newport and later Bald Knob. m (1) Nancy Eleanor Vick (21)(dau Dr. T. A. Vick) 2 Nov 1875. She died 1885 (2) Nannie E. Goad 1886 (3) Mrs. Dora Winfield Webb
1.(?) Martha Eliz. Cleveland b about 1850 d 1888-1920 m (age 18) 29 Nov 1868 J. W. Kennedy (30)
? Thomas J. Cleveland d before 1889 [marginal note: "not named in will"]
? John Cleveland d before 1889 [marginal note: "not named in will"]
? (James F.?) Franklin Cleveland d 1889-1970
✓? Susan America Theodosia Cleveland b. 10 Jan 1861 prob Ind. Co. Ark d. 22 Jan 1896 Bandera Co. Texas, buried Jones Cemetery, Utopia, Tex m. 30 Nov 1880 Ind. Co. Ark (license issued Jackson Co.) L. D. Bownds
? Henry P. Cleveland, attorney, lived Judsonia Ark 1889 d 1921-1940
? Mary A Cleveland lived Houston Tex 1940 m. J. B. Cantrell
? Charles [caret-inserted: "David"] Edgar Cleveland li Memphis Tenn 1889, Little Rock Ark 1940 ? Samuel [caret-inserted: "Littleton"] Cleveland, Van Buren Ark 1940 ? Edmund L. Cleveland, North Little Rock Ark 1940 (Argenta in 1911)
[Note: the caret insertions "David" over Charles Edgar and "Littleton" over Samuel appear to be the compiler correcting/clarifying middle names — compare Page 7's "Charles Edgar" and "Samuel David" and "Edmund Littleton," suggesting some name-order confusion in this earlier draft that Page 7 resolves.]
Page 9 — Typed: Independence & Jackson Counties research notes; transcribed Will of Elizabeth Cleveland (1911)
Header: "Independence & Jackson Counties, Arkansas RBK SGK 12 Oct 1970 p"
Jackson Co Courthouse
King's Index to Court Papers
1228 Cleveland J F Box 357 Jan 1901 p 124, 125 (NO#) Bounds Thos, A C Harris et al 102 (New No) Record Book 33
Record of Admin Bonds & Letters B, C, & 1860-1878 No Cleveland or Bounds wills Book C Eliz Cleveland 396 Will 1911 15 Mar box 53 (Original will not in box 53, nor box 97 which some other indexed items referred to) Copy of will follows.
"Will of Elizabeth Cleveland
"Know all men by these presents that I Elizabeth Cleveland of the City of Argenta and State of Arkansas being of sound mind and memory and understanding but in failing health, do make and declare this to be my last will & testament in manner and form following,
"1st, I give, devise and bequeath unto my three sons, Charles Edgar, Samuel David, Edmund Littleton, Lots Ten (10) Block Nine (9) in Newport, Jackson Co., Arkansas, all of my personal effects, share and share alike.
"Second I give devise and bequeath unto my son Henry P. Cleveland, Dr. J. C. Cleveland and to my daughter Mary Cantrell, my son Franklin Cleveland Heirs, Martha Elizabeth Kennedy heirs, and Susie Bounds heirs, Lot Eleven (11) in Block Nine (9) of Newport, Jackson Co. Arkansas, each an equal share.
"Third I hereby [caret-inserted: "appoint"] my son Charles Edgar Cleveland executor of this my last will and testament.
"In witness whereof I have hereunto set my hand this the 15th day of March 1911. ELIZABETH CLEVELAND
"Signed sealed & acknowledged and declared by the said testator to be her last Will and Testament, in the presence of us and of each other at her request, who are witnesses thereto.
"J. B. Sileck (Sibeck?) Argenta Ark
"Catherine Davis Argenta Ark."
"State of Arkansas, County of Pulaski"....statement of above witnesses 2 Aug 1911 that the document they signed is her will and that she died on the 17th day of July 1911 at Bald Knob, Ark.
Jackson Co: document admitting will to probate. p 397
Jackson Co. Probate Docket p 186
Petition granted to executor to erect monument to Elizabeth Cleveland deceased out of the proceeds of her estate. p 168 1912 term.
Box 170 holds map of original town: Block 9 Lots 10 & 11 are at corner of Pine and Second, which as you go toward the river on Second are the corner next to the railroad on the left hand side between Pine & Oak Sts.
Inspection of this site on 12 Oct 1970 showed group of apartments now occupy this site. Old house is gone.
Page 10 — Handwritten: cemetery and Independence County marriage records
Header (top right): "RBK Oct 1970"
Maple Springs Cemetery, Ind Co Ark, near Oil Trough W T Cleveland 1 Aug 1847 — 11 May 1872
Indep Co Marriage records William T Cleveland 22 to Eliza McCollough 17, [age "23"?] 1870, by W H Palmer J P, Book C - p 484 James R Cleveland to Mrs Emma Herrington, 13 Oct 1874 Isaac T McConnell 31 to Eliza Cleveland, 31 Dec 1872 James S McLean (or McLane) 22 to Malinda J Cleveland, 25 Aug 1875 [bracketed together:] J W Kennedy 30 to Martha E Cleveland 18, 29 Nov 1868 [bracketed together:] W. S. Smotherman 20 to Mary Ann Cleveland 15, 1 July 1870
Surrounded Hill Cemetery — west of Newport Annie L wife of J L Cleveland, b 15 Mar 1894, d 13 Jan 1913
[Cemetery name illegible/uncertain — reads approximately "Chesbro" or "Charbro"] Cemetery — north of Newport James R Cleveland, 6 May 1845 — 18 Nov 1906
Page 11 — Envelope: H. P. Cleveland, Attorney-at-Law, Judsonia, Ark. (postmarked 1908)
Printed return address, upper left: "Return after 5 days to / H. P. CLEVELAND, / ATTORNEY-AT-LAW, / Lock Box C / JUDSONIA, ARKANSAS."
Postmark (upper right, over 2-cent stamp): "JUDSONIA / JAN 2 / 7 PM / 1908 / ARK."
Addressed in cursive: "Clerk of Circuit Court, / New-Port, / Arkansas."
[Envelope only, as scanned; no enclosed letter content visible on this page.]
Page 12 — Handwritten: land title chain-of-title notes
Header (top right): "RBK Oct 1970"
W 1/2 SW 14-13-1 E 1/2 SE 15-13-1
W 1/2 SW Entered 1861, W.C. Crutcher[?] Patented to same 1-8-1862 Entered 4-1-1872 by McAnally[?] Patented to same 1-10-1873 McAnally to Barton WD 6-5-73 Barton to Waggoner WD 12-10-74 [or "76"?] Waggoner to Everett WD 6-11-77 Everett to Haynes WD 12-13-79 Haynes to Allen QC 6-19-1880 To state for tax, 1871[?] State to Woodruff Do 3-30-98 Woodruff to [illegible] WD 2-18-99
[No surname in this note is explicitly tied to the Cleveland/Bownds/Butcher family; relevance to the family land near Oil Trough is inferred from placement in the document but not confirmed by name — see Open Questions.]
Page 13 — Letter: H. P. Cleveland (attorney) to Stucky & Stucky, Sept. 7, 1907
Printed letterhead: "H. P. CLEVELAND, / Attorney-at-Law. / Real Estate. Fire and Life Insurance. / Notary Public in Office. / Practice in all Courts of the State, including Federal and Supreme Courts. / Solicitor in Chancery. Collections a Specialty." and "Solicits for Claimants before Secretary of Treasury, Courts of Claims, Department of the Interior, and all Bureaus thereof." / "vs." / "Judsonia, Ark., Sept. 7th. 1907."
Stucky & Stucky, (Attys.) New-Port Arkansas.
Dear Sirs. In matter of E.E.Osmon Vs. L.A.Parsons appealed from Esqr. J.M.Mordis J.P.Court. Please set for Wednesday or Thursday of next week say 18, or 19 of Sept. 1907 and notify me as soon as you set it what day you set it for trial so I can work to fit the time, we wish to try the case without fail this term and get through with it. Thanking you for past favors.
I am yours Very Truly.
H. P. Cleveland [signed, purple ink]
Page 14 — Letter: Bald Knob State Bank (E. R. Wynn, Cashier) to W. T. Parish, Sept. 2, 1910
Printed letterhead: "Bald Knob State Bank / CAPITAL $20,000.00 / T. J. CAMPBELL, PRESIDENT. J. C. CLEVELAND, VICE PRES'T. E. R. WYNN, CASHIER." / "DIRECTORS: GEO. C. GRIFFITH, GEO. B. COLEMAN, J. C. CLEVELAND, E. R. WYNN, T. J. CAMPBELL, W. H. DAVISON, J. W. COOMBE" / "Bald Knob, Ark., Sept. 2nd, 1910."
Mr. W.T.Parish, Asst. Cashr., Newport, Ark.
Dear Sir:- Relative to the garnishment Western Tie & T.Co. vs V.Eaton, this writ was served on us about May 7th, last Eaton has NO BALANCE with us & hasent had during considerable time prior to this service, Eaton owes us, now I do not know what will be necessary, but I will thank you very much if you will have Mr.Stuckey file an answer if it can be done & save me the trip. Mrs. Wynn is very sick to-day & if still indisposed later I will forward a certificate from our Physician which will excuse me from attandance, but Mr.Stuckey can file our answer just the same. Thanking you, I am
Yours truly,
E.R.Wynn [signed]
Cashr.
[Confirms Dr. J. C. Cleveland (Susie Bownds's brother) was Vice President of Bald Knob State Bank, 1910.]
Page 15 — Photograph: unidentified young woman (tintype)
Tintype portrait, seated young woman, dark hair parted center, wearing a dark dress with light ruffled/bow collar and a chain or fob at the waist. Image shows surface wear/creasing and a punched hole in the upper left corner (apparent album-mounting hole). No name, date, or inscription visible on this scan. Positioned in sequence between a 1910 bank letter (Page 14) and a page captioned "Susan America Theodosia Cleveland" (Page 16) — plausibly a photo of Susie Bownds as a young woman, but unconfirmed (see Open Questions).
Page 16 — Caption page (no photo present on this scan): "Susan America Theodosia Cleveland, 10 Jan 1861"
Blank/plain stock page. Handwritten caption, lower portion of page:
"Susan America Theodosia / Cleveland b. 10 Jan 1861"
[No photograph appears on this particular page as scanned; it was likely originally mounted facing or backing a photograph — possibly the tintype on Page 15 — in a photo album, now separated from its image.]
Page 17 — Photograph: unidentified older woman (no caption on this page)
Studio portrait, older woman, hair pulled back and center-parted, wearing a dark Victorian-era dress with ruffled/ruched trim at the neck and bodice, three-quarter view. No inscription or caption visible on this scan. Closely resembles the pose/dress of the explicitly captioned portrait on Page 19 ("Elizabeth Cleveland. Grandmother.") — possibly a duplicate print or companion image of the same subject; unconfirmed (see Open Questions).
Page 18 — Handwritten receipt: Elizabeth Cleveland to L. D. Bownds, 1883
Lined paper, stained/water-marked.
"Newport Ark 2/3/1883 Received of L. D. Bownds Sixty Dollars in full of all demands to date. Elizabeth Cleveland."
[Financial document between Susie Bownds's husband, L. D. Bownds, and her mother, Elizabeth Cleveland, dated within the Bownds' Arkansas years, before their 1885 move to Texas.]
Page 19 — Photograph, captioned: "Elizabeth Cleveland. Grandmother."
Studio portrait of an older woman (same general pose and dress style as Page 17), with a handwritten caption below the image:
"Elizabeth Cleveland. / Grandmother."
[Confirmed portrait of Elizabeth (Butcher) Cleveland — Susie Bownds's mother, and the compiler Ruth Bownds Kershner's grandmother.]
Page 20 — Caption page: photo provenance and Maude Elizabeth Butcher summary
Blank/plain stock page, handwritten notes:
"Original owned by John Bownds, Utopia Tex Copy 1971
Maude Elizabeth Butcher b. Geo. 1829 d. Bald Knob 1910
married about 1847 Tuscaloosa Co Ala Joseph Cleveland
- to Indep. Co Ark 1951-52 [sic — almost certainly intended "1851-52," consistent with every other source in this document; apparent slip of the pen]"
[Confirms the family photographs in this packet were originally held by John Bownds of Utopia, Texas — the same Bandera-County-area town where Susie Bownds died and was buried — and were copied in 1971, consistent with the rest of the packet's 1970–1971 compilation date.]
Page 21 — DUPLICATE SCAN of Page 3 (Goodspeed, White County, p. 145)
Same handwritten top-margin annotation as Page 3: "Good Speed, Northeastern 1880 Arkansas." Printed content is identical to Page 3 (Claiborn family; Clay family; opening of the J. C. Cleveland, M.D. entry). Full verbatim text is given once, under Page 3, to avoid redundancy; see that entry.
Page 22 — DUPLICATE SCAN of Page 4 (Goodspeed, White County, p. 146)
Same handwritten top-margin annotation as Page 4: "Good Speed Northeastern 1880 White Co. Ark." Printed content is identical to Page 4 (conclusion of the J. C. Cleveland, M.D. entry, including the explicit listing "Susan A. T. (wife of L. D. Bownds)"; John D. Coffey and John Reed Coffey entries). Full verbatim text is given once, under Page 4; see that entry.
Page 23 — DUPLICATE SCAN of the p. 263 portion of Page 5 (Centennial History of Arkansas, Vol. II) — full-resolution individual rescan
Same handwritten top-margin annotation as Page 5: "pub after 1919 - prob 1921." Printed content matches the p. 263 portion transcribed under Page 5 (conclusion of an unrelated "McClure" entry, then the full J. C. Cleveland, M.D. biographical entry through "...also filled the position of county commissioner in Independence county," including the marginal note "date wrong, goodspeed says 1887, age 61"). Full verbatim text is given once, under Page 5; see that entry.
Page 24 — Full-resolution individual rescan of p. 264 (Centennial History of Arkansas, Vol. II) — includes additional content not visible in Page 5's compressed view
Printed header: "264 CENTENNIAL HISTORY OF ARKANSAS Vol II"
Text through "...sterling traits of his character" matches the p. 264 portion transcribed under Page 5; see that entry. This full-resolution scan additionally captures the following printed text, which was cropped out of Page 5's compressed two-page image:
ROBERT GEDDES DAVIES.
Robert Geddes Davies, a prominent representative of the bar of Hot Springs, practicing with a large clientele that has connected him with much important litigation heard in the courts of the state, was born in Lake Village, Arkansas, a son of Anthony H. Davies, who was a native of Milford, Connecticut, and became one of the first settlers of Chicot county, Arkansas, arriving there in 1829. From Connecticut he went first to New York and removed from the Empire state to Arkansas. He had been dependent upon his own resources from the age of twelve years, at which time, in 1812, he began working in a store. He was with the American soldiers for a period during his youth and then went to St. Louis, where he entered the employ of Choteau, the fur trader and merchant. Mr. Davies began trading among the Indians, and he gave to him the name of Rising Sun. He took up his work of this character on the Platte River and also traded with the Indians in Dakota. Coming to Little Rock, he established the first bank of Arkansas, and acted as attorney for the institution, the bank being conducted under the name of the Real Estate Bank of Arkansas. This was in 1829. He also purchased a plantation of two thousand acres located opposite the present site of Lake Village. He was likewise engaged in the commission business in New Orleans while developing his Arkansas interests, and he was a large slave owner, owning one hundred and sixty negroes, his home being on the Lake Hall plantation. He contributed much to the material development and progress of this section and was also prominent in connection with public affairs, serving as judge of the county and probate court for many years. He was likewise a member of the constitutional convention of the state and fraternally he was connected with the Masons. He died in April, 1861, at the age of sixty-three years. His wife, who bore the maiden name of Mildred H. Gaines, was born in Kentucky at Gaines Cross Roads, a place settled by her father William H. Gaines in 1798. He was the father of Major William H. Gaines. The daughter, Mrs. Davies, died in 1900, at the advanced age of eighty-six years. In the family of this worthy couple were the following named sons and daughters: Harpin, who served throughout the Civil War and is now living in Montana; Fanny, the wife of Charles W. Fry of Hot Springs; Walter, who is living on the old homestead; Robert G., of this review; Joseph, who also occupies the old plantation, and Mildred, who died at the age of twelve years.
Note: the Davies family has no apparent name or geographic overlap with the Cleveland/Butcher/Bownds line documented elsewhere in this packet. It most likely appears here only because it is the next biographical entry printed on the same book page. See Open Questions.
Page 25 — Photograph: Van's Creek Baptist Church historical marker, Georgia
Photograph of a brick church building with a steep gabled roof, trees at left, and a Georgia Historical Marker standing in front. Marker text, transcribed from the photo:
"GEORGIA 1776 [state seal] / VAN'S CREEK BAPTIST CHURCH. / Van's Creek Baptist Church, established early in 1785 by Rev. Dozier Thornton, Revolutionary soldier and Virginian, was famed for an Indian convert, David Vann, famed Chief of the Cherokees. Though the 6th Baptist church organized in Georgia, it is the oldest in continuous service. Rev. Thornton was its pastor for 43 years. Original members were Rev. Dozier Thornton, his wife Lucy Elizabeth Thornton, Elizabeth Thornton, William Arnold, first Deacon and Clerk, Susan Arnold, Nathan Morgan, Elizabeth Morgan, Thomas Gilbert, John White, Milly White."
No separate handwritten caption elsewhere on the page. This photograph corroborates the research-trip account on Page 2 ("we... visited historic Vann's Creek Baptist Church and the old family cemetery on the farm... about 20 miles east of Elberton, Georgia, at Ruckersville"), and the marker's listed original members "John White" and "Milly White" directly match the Milly White (wife of Jacob Cleveland, b. 1739 NYC) and her brother, the Rev. John White ("Baptist missionary to the Indians"), described on Page 2 — strong corroborating evidence tying this specific church to the documented Cleveland ancestral line.
Illegible / uncertain items noted during transcription:
- Page 7: witness/reference superscript markers are faint in places; all have been rendered as best interpreted.
- Page 9: witness surname "Sileck" is uncertain, possibly "Sibeck" — marked [?] in source.
- Page 10: cemetery name "Chesbro(?) Cemetery" is uncertain due to handwriting; marked [illegible/uncertain].
- Page 12: several surnames in the land chain-of-title (e.g., "W.C. Crutcher," "McAnally") are uncertain due to handwriting quality; marked [?].
- Page 17: no caption present; subject identity inferred only by visual similarity to Page 19, not confirmed.
- No page in this document was fully illegible; all 25 pages yielded readable content.