Mamacita's Archive

K-087: Letters: Cleveland Corres Ala Ga, 1968 to 1992

K-087 Type: Correspondence (researcher-to-researcher) Dates: 1968-1992 Size: 53 pages and images Family line: Bownds

Summary

K-087 — Closing Summary

Source file: Letters_ClevelandCorresAlaGa_1968-1992.pdf (Box 01, invoice 5) Pages processed: 53 of 53 (confirmed via pdfinfo and individually rendered/verified page by page)

Verified date range

September 1968 – July 1992 (confirmed from content, not the filename — which gives the same outer bound, "1968-1992," and is accurate as an outer range, though the correspondence is not continuous across those 24 years; see clusters below).

The filename's label "ClevelandCorresAlaGa" (Cleveland correspondence, Alabama/Georgia) is also accurate as far as it goes, but undersells the collection: a substantial portion of the file (roughly a third of the pages) concerns the Bownds family of Arkansas, not just Cleveland-in-Alabama-and-Georgia material.

Three distinct clusters of activity appear:

  • Sept. 1968 – Feb. 1969: Intensive exchange among Alenia McCord (Vandalia, IL), Webster Cleveland, Jr. (Booneville, MS), and Mrs. B. W. Gandrud (Tuscaloosa, AL) working out the Cleveland/Clark descent for a D.A.R. application.
  • 1971–1973: Ruth (Bownds) Kershner's own active research correspondence with Gandrud, James Logan Morgan (Newport, AR), Webster Cleveland Jr., and "Sue" (Mrs. Barney Reid, San Diego), conducted while Ruth was traveling extensively (Alabama, South Carolina, Georgia; mail forwarded to Delaware in fall 1973).
  • 1974–1975 and July 1992: Later, more occasional letters from Sue (San Diego) and a final (1992) round of Ruth's own Cleveland D.A.R.-claim correspondence.

Thread classification

Married-in/maternal-side line — Cleveland/Bownds — not the Kershner surname line. The compiler, Ruth Bownds Kershner, researched her own Bownds ancestry (Arkansas) and its Cleveland in-laws (Georgia/Alabama); a second Cleveland line (Daniel Madison Clark's wife Elizabeth Cleveland, pursued by Alenia McCord for Mrs. Elizabeth Miller Greer's D.A.R. application) also appears but is explicitly a different family's research, shared with Ruth as a professional/collegial exchange, not her own direct line. See the genealogical index for full detail and the reasoning behind this classification.

What this document reveals about the broader family history

  • It documents, across two generations of researchers (the 1968–69 Vandalia/Tuscaloosa/Booneville circle, and Ruth Kershner from 1971 onward), a sustained, collaborative effort to trace the Cleveland family from Culpeper Co., Virginia → Elbert Co., Georgia → Franklin Co., Georgia → Tuscaloosa/Franklin Co., Alabama, with the ultimate goal (for at least two different descendant lines) of proving Revolutionary War service for admission to the D.A.R.
  • It establishes the Bownds family's Arkansas roots in Independence and Jackson Counties (Oil Trough, Maple Springs, Newport, Utopia), anchored by the 1880 marriage of L. D. Bownds to schoolteacher Susan A. T. Cleveland, and by the Civil War-era deaths of several Bownds men (Dr. Thomas J. Bownds, Thaddeus Bownds, and son-in-law Mathew Price).
  • It shows a family archive actively being assembled and dispersed during Ruth's lifetime: she describes sorting her "massive collection of records" in 1992, storing the "L. D. Bownds papers" commercially in Houston, and distributing "Cleveland Sheet" charts to relatives by name (Page 21) — i.e., this file itself is a snapshot of an archive-in-formation, which is directly relevant to understanding how the broader Kershner/Bownds/Cleveland family papers ended up distributed the way they did.
  • It documents at least two significant unresolved family traditions — Joseph Cleveland's mysterious disappearance (presumed murdered) en route to Montgomery after selling "Dogwood Flats," and the ambiguous parentage of Martha "Patsy" Meeks — that the correspondents themselves could not settle with available records.

Working relationships among correspondents

  • Ruth (Bownds) Kershner is the hub of her own cluster: she initiates and drives research requests to Gandrud, Morgan, and the Cleveland descendants, and maintains a long personal correspondence with her relative "Sue" (Mrs. Barney Reid) that mixes genealogy with family news (health, travel, real estate) over at least 1971–1975.
  • Alenia McCord, Webster Cleveland Jr. (and his wife), and Mrs. B. W. Gandrud form a separate, earlier (1968–69) three-way working relationship: McCord acts as the requester (on behalf of client/friend Mrs. Greer), Webster Cleveland Jr. as the family-tradition source, and Gandrud as the Alabama records specialist who can access Tuscaloosa Probate Court and Alabama Dept. of Archives & History material. Their tone is courteous, patient, and methodical, repeatedly emphasizing the need for documentary proof over tradition for D.A.R. purposes.
  • Gandrud also appears to be Ruth Kershner's main Alabama contact in 1971, independent of (though covering some of the same Cleveland ground as) the McCord/Greer line — the two research threads overlap in subject matter (both work on Joseph Cleveland's family) but are not shown to be in direct contact with each other in this file.
  • Sue (San Diego) and Ruth have a warm, familiar, decades-long relationship (signing "Love, Sue"), trading family photographs, health updates, and genealogical finds about their shared Bownds/Cleveland ancestors.

Ten most significant facts / leads found

  1. Ruth Bownds Kershner (married name) is the collection's central figure and was herself born a Bownds — this file is Bownds/Cleveland in-law material, not Kershner-line genealogy.
  2. L. D. Bownds married schoolteacher Susan A. T. Cleveland on 30 Nov. 1880 in Jackson Co., Arkansas (banns 26 Nov., recorded 2 Dec.); her 1878–1880 Independence Co. teaching licenses and contracts survive in family papers (Pages 49, 53).
  3. Joseph Cleveland of Franklin Co., GA / Tuscaloosa Co., AL sold his plantation "Dogwood Flats" and disappeared en route to Montgomery to bank the proceeds — family tradition holds he was murdered; his death date and burial are unknown (Pages 26, 36, 39).
  4. Thomas Bownds's estate (Independence/Jackson Co., AR) deeded 40 acres (Sec. 25, T12N, R5W) to wife Elizabeth for life, remainder to son L. D. ("Ludovico") Bownds, two weeks before his death; sons Dr. Thomas J. Bownds and Thaddeus Bownds and son-in-law Mathew Price reportedly died in the Civil War (Page 47).
  5. Two separate researcher groups, a generation apart (1968–69 and 1971–92), independently pursued Cleveland Revolutionary War service (via Jacob Cleveland and/or his son Wyatt Cleveland) for D.A.R. applications on behalf of two different living descendants (Mrs. Elizabeth Miller Greer and, later, "Betty Sue") — the earlier effort found no supporting Virginia or Georgia D.A.R. record for either man; the 1992 letter claims new, "convincing" documentation. Whether these represent the same unresolved claim revisited, or two different sufficiently-distinct claims, is an open question.
  6. Martha ("Patsy") Meeks's parentage (Rev. Littleton Meeks vs. brother Nacy Meeks) and Elizabeth Cleveland's proof of descent from Joseph & Martha Cleveland were both explicitly unresolved by the correspondents as of 1969 — flagged, not solved, in this file.
  7. The L. D. Bownds family papers were, as of July 1992, stored commercially in Houston, Texas (Farren & Long Co. Commercial Record Centers), managed by a relative named "Tom," and described by Ruth as not practically available to researchers there — directly relevant to locating any surviving original Bownds materials today.
  8. At least three different women named "Elizabeth Cleveland" appear to be discussed across this file with partially conflicting vital data (see genealogical index, Open Question 3) — a significant discrepancy for any researcher using this file's Cleveland/Clark data.
  9. The collection documents a specific physical-archiving practice: "Cleveland Sheet" genealogy charts were hand-distributed by Ruth to named relatives in 1971–72 (Marlin & Helen, Sue Reid, John Bownds, Betty Sue, Joe Patton & Mildred, Dave Kelley, etc.) — a list that may help locate other surviving copies of family charts in descendants' hands.
  10. Mrs. B. W. (Pauline Jones) Gandrud, a published Alabama genealogical records compiler, was a direct, named documentary source for this family's research (her Tuscaloosa, Greene, Bibb, and Marengo County marriage-record volumes), providing a concrete, citable published source other researchers can still consult.

Pages too illegible to fully trust

None of the 53 pages were illegible enough to withhold transcription, but confidence is lower than usual on: the "Helpers checked" research log (Page 22, several words/numbers illegible or overwritten); isolated words throughout the cursive letters marked [illegible] or [word?] in the transcript; and the exact spelling of several surnames appearing only once in cursive (e.g., "Boumer," "Rochard," "Taplan Boland," "Bo[u]ltinghouse"). These are flagged individually at point of use in the full transcript rather than omitted.

The originals

The scanned document. Scroll inside the viewer to page through it, or open it full screen.

Open the scanned pages full screen

People, places and dates

Show the genealogical index

K-087 — Genealogical Index

Thread classification

This document belongs to a married-in/maternal-side line, not the Kershner surname line directly.

The collection's principal compiler and recipient of most of this correspondence is Ruth Bownds Kershner (also "Ruth B. Kershner," "Mrs. Stuart G. Kershner") — she married into the Kershner surname (her husband was Stuart G. Kershner) but was herself born a Bownds, as confirmed by her own printed bookplate ("Ruth Bownds Kershner," Page 1) and her signature on Page 45/47 ("Ruth Bownds Kershner"). Every letter in this collection concerns her mother's and/or her own maternal-side research into the Cleveland family of Franklin Co., Georgia and Tuscaloosa/Franklin Co., Alabama, who married into the Bownds family of Independence/Jackson Co., Arkansas (Ruth's own branch) — specifically the marriage of L. D. Bownds to Susan A. T. "Sue" Cleveland in 1880 (Pages 49, 53). A second, separate Cleveland line (descending through Daniel Madison Clark's wife Elizabeth Cleveland, researched by Alenia McCord of Vandalia, IL on behalf of Mrs. Elizabeth Miller Greer for a D.A.R. application) also runs through this document and is NOT part of Ruth's own direct ancestry — it is a correspondence file Ruth exchanged research with, concerning a different Cleveland descendant.

In short: this is Cleveland/Bownds in-law material on Ruth (Bownds) Kershner's side of the family, not Kershner surname genealogy.


People

Name Role / relationship
Ruth Bownds Kershner ("Ruth B. Kershner," "Mrs. Stuart G. Kershner") Principal researcher/compiler; born Bownds; married Stuart G. Kershner; lived 1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin TX (early 1970s) and later 4100 Jackson Ave #223, Austin TX (1992); correspondent with Gandrud, Morgan, "Sue"/Betty Sue, "Gail," and the Cleveland family researchers
Stuart G. Kershner Ruth's husband (named on envelopes, Pages 2, 14)
"Betty Sue" (Page 1) Addressee of the July 21, 1992 letter from (apparently) Ruth; likely the same "Betty Sue Bownds" named on Pages 21 and 50 — see Open Questions on the surname discrepancy ("Bo[u]ltinghouse" vs. "Bownds")
"Gail" (Page 3) Addressee of Ruth's July 20, 1992 letter; relationship not stated
Sue Reid / Mrs. Barney M. Reid ("Sue") San Diego correspondent (2443 Erie St., San Diego, CA); signs "Love, Sue"; granddaughter (or close relative) of L. D. Bownds and Susan A. T. Cleveland Bownds ("Grandpa L.D."); writes to Ruth 1971–1975 (Pages 10–13, 15–16, 50–53); husband Barney M. Reid; mother-in-law age 92 in late 1974
L. D. Bownds Ruth's (and Sue's) grandfather or great-grandfather; married Susan A. T. Cleveland ("Sue"/"S.A.T. Cleveland") 1880, Jackson Co., Arkansas (Pages 49, 53); kept a journal (Page 12); school board member, Oil Trough/Maple Springs, Independence Co. AR (Page 53); raised "Cousin Essie" among other children (Page 11)
Susan A. T. "Sue" Cleveland Bownds ("S.A.T. Cleveland") L. D. Bownds's wife; teacher, Independence Co. AR, licensed 1878–1880; teaching contracts 1880 Oil Trough and Maple Springs, AR (Page 53); subject of a photograph showing her "kneeling on a cushion instead of sitting in a chair" (Page 51/52)
Thomas Bownds Earlier Bownds ancestor in Independence Co./Jackson Co., Arkansas; first wife Sarah Allen; estate settled via Arkansas deeds (land in Sec. 25, T12N, R5W) two weeks before his death, to wife Elizabeth for life then to "Ludovico" (L. D. Bownds); sons/son-in-law said killed in Civil War: Dr. Thomas J. Bownds, Thaddeus Bownds, Mathew Price (son-in-law) (Page 47)
Elizabeth (Bownds) Thomas Bownds's wife named in the estate deed (Page 47) — relationship to Sarah Allen (his "first wife" per the same letter) not reconciled; see Open Questions
Dr. Sterling Allen Brother of Sarah Allen (Thomas Bownds's first wife) (Page 47)
James W. St. John, M.D. Married Mary Floyd, Thomas Bownds's step-daughter by Margarett Price (Page 47)
Dr. James Porter Father of Parilee Willie Porter, wife of John Price Bownds (Page 47)
Cousin Essie (m. Charlie Harper) One of the children L. D. Bownds raised (Page 11); daughter Emma m. Clayton Wentworth (Ruth's/Sue's father's cousin, who became his sister-in-law by this marriage) (Pages 50–51)
Emma (Harper) Wentworth Daughter of Cousin Essie & Charlie Harper; m. Uncle Clayton Wentworth; lived in Austin; children Chester, Harold, Essie Mae (Pages 11, 51)
Marquish L. Bownds Grandfather of Emma (Harper) Wentworth per Page 50 — note possible confusion/overlap with "L. D. Bownds" below; see Open Questions
Jack Bownds Contractor for a new Royal Inns Motel in La Jolla, CA (ca. 1971) (Page 52)
John Bownds Named on the "Cleveland Sheet — To" mailing list (Page 21)
Joseph Cleveland ("Col. Joseph Cleveland") b. Georgia ca. 1791 (per 1850 census, age 59); served as Lt., 208th District Co. militia, Franklin Co. GA, 1812–14; also credited (per family tradition reported by Alenia McCord) with Creek War service 1813–14 and the rank "Colonel" in a "Seminole War" — see Open Questions on conflating two service records; m. (1) Patsy/Martha "Patsey" Meeks, 2 May 1809, Franklin Co. GA; moved to Tuscaloosa Co., AL; owned plantation "Dogwood Flats"; disappeared/presumed murdered while traveling to Montgomery to bank money from its sale, date unknown, likely late 1850s
Martha "Patsy/Patsey" Meeks Cleveland Wife of Joseph Cleveland; parentage disputed — one source names her father as Rev. Littleton Meeks (& wife Elizabeth Ivy), another as his brother Nacy/Nace Meeks (per Goodspeed's Memoirs of Mississippi)
Wyatt (Wiatt) Cleveland Father of Joseph Cleveland; b. 25 Feb. 1764 (per Page 1) or "ca. 1766" (per Page 43) — see Open Questions; Culpeper Co., VA; m. Temperance Freeman, Elbert Co., GA; Revolutionary War service claimed (per Page 1) but later letters (Pages 30, 43) report no Virginia or Georgia D.A.R. record found for him; land transactions in Franklin Co., GA, 1790–1820 (Page 43); children: Joseph (to Tuscaloosa Co., AL, then Miss. Territory per one source) and Annie Cleveland (m. Robert Lane)
Jacob Cleveland Father of Wyatt Cleveland; Revolutionary soldier (per family tradition; "Jacob Cleveland, R.S." in McIntosh's Elbert Co. history) b. 1729, d. Elbert Co., GA 1791; m. Milly White (b. 1739, d. 1806), daughter of Rev. Col. Jeremiah White; will proved 1791, naming wife, daughter Elizabeth, sons Reuben, Daniel, and Jeremiah
Thomas Anderson Cleveland b. 26 July 1818, d. 6 Oct. 1873, Ebenezer Cemetery, Franklin Co., AL; m.(1) Emaline/Evaline Sullenger; m.(2) Rhodie Holland (b. 13 Dec. 1836, d. 5 Apr. 1908); many children (full issue on Page 32); described by his grandson Webster Cleveland, Jr. as the "great grandfather" (Page 28) — his relationship to Joseph Cleveland of Tuscaloosa Co. is treated in this correspondence as "brother" (per Pages 26/23, citing Webster Cleveland Jr.'s letter)
Elizabeth (Cleveland) Clark Boland b. Tuscaloosa Co., AL 28 Oct. 1824, d. 5 Apr. 1897, Salem, IL; daughter of Joseph & Martha (Meeks) Cleveland (per family tradition, unproven in this correspondence); m.(1) Daniel Madison Clark (b. 1 Jan. 1820 S.C., d. 1 July 1859, captain, AL militia, killed on maneuvers); m.(2) Taplan Boland of Tuscaloosa; fled to Illinois 1863 as anti-slavery refugees; this is likely also the "Elizabeth Cleveland" photographed on Page 24/25 ("Newport Ark. (Jackson Co.) b ca 1829 d 1910 dau of T.J. Butcher Tuscaloosa Ala") — see Open Questions: two different "Elizabeth Cleveland" identities with conflicting birth years/death dates/parentage appear to be in tension in this file
Daniel Madison Clark See above; children with Elizabeth Cleveland: Amanda Ellen (b.1850), Joseph Cleveland Clark (b.1852, d. infant), Martha Caroline (b.1853), Daniel Madison Jr. (b.1855), Nancy Jane (b.1856), Tena (b.1858), Permelia Eveline Elizabeth Roxanna (b./d. 1859–1860)
Amanda Ellen (Clark) McMackin Daughter of Daniel M. Clark & Elizabeth Cleveland, b. 4 Dec. 1850, Tuscaloosa Co.; grandmother of Mrs. Elizabeth Miller Greer
Mrs. Elizabeth Miller Greer Great-great-granddaughter of Joseph Cleveland; seeking D.A.R. membership for herself, her daughter, and nieces via the Cleveland/Clark line; client of Alenia McCord
(Miss) Alenia B. McCord Researcher/correspondent, Vandalia, IL (716 West Jackson); friend of Mrs. Greer; corresponds with Mrs. B. W. Gandrud 1968–1969 on the Cleveland/Clark D.A.R. application
Mrs. B. W. Gandrud (Pauline Jones Gandrud) Professional/avocational genealogist, 311 Caplewood Terrace, Tuscaloosa, AL; compiler and publisher of Alabama county marriage-record volumes (Marengo, Greene, Bibb, Tuscaloosa Counties, 1968–1970, via The Milestone Press, Memphis); transcribed ca. 15 feet of records at the Alabama Dept. of Archives & History; primary Alabama-records correspondent for both Ruth Kershner and Alenia McCord
Webster Cleveland, Jr. Booneville, Mississippi (misdated by himself once as "Mo." — see Page 17 note); descendant of Thomas Anderson Cleveland (great-grandfather) and Thomas Cooley Cleveland (grandfather); his wife is referred to as "Mrs. W. Cleveland, Jr." / possibly "Neola C." in some signatures; father Webster Cleveland, Sr., b. 27 Jan. 1890; corresponds with both Ruth Kershner (1972) and Mrs. Gandrud (1968–69)
Thomas Cooley Cleveland b. 10 July 1855, d. 5 Aug. 1924, Liberty Cemetery, Itawamba Co., MS; son of Thomas Anderson Cleveland & Rhodie Holland; m. Martha Catherine Johnson (b. 4 Aug. 1853, d. 17 Mar. 1929), 7 Nov. 1874; father of Webster Cleveland (Sr.)
James Logan Morgan Newport, Arkansas (314 Vine); genealogist/correspondent; Northeast Arkansas Genealogical Assn.; corresponds with Ruth 1971–1973; supplied service records for Joseph Cleveland and Thomas Bounds/Bownds; "grew up in Oil Trough," Arkansas
Mrs. Sallie Harrison Genealogist, 4715 Canal St., Houston, TX; researches the Meeks family; her ancestor is Nacy Meeks
Dorothy Newby Cleveland Long Island City, NY; placed a 1969 query in Footprints re Cleveland—Franklin Co. GA, Tuscaloosa Co. AL, and Mississippi; suggested by Morgan as a contact for Ruth (not confirmed as contacted)
Annalee Burns Author of "Gone Are the Days"; cousin of Sue (the San Diego correspondent); sister Lucile

Places

  • Franklin Co., Georgia — Wyatt Cleveland's and Joseph Cleveland's home before the move to Alabama; Cleveland land on Freeman's Creek, 1790–1820; Joseph Cleveland's 1809 marriage to Patsy Meeks
  • Elbert Co., Georgia (county seat Elberton; Ruckersville nearby, near the S.C. line) — Jacob Cleveland's home and burial place (Cleveland family cemetery); Wyatt Cleveland's brother's grave (b. 1776, d. 1815)
  • Tuscaloosa Co., Alabama — Joseph Cleveland's plantation ("Dogwood Flats"); 1850/1860 census and marriage records for multiple Cleveland families; Daniel M. Clark/Elizabeth Cleveland family
  • Franklin Co., Alabama (incl. "Old Burleson," near Red Bay; Ebenezer Cemetery) — Thomas Anderson Cleveland's home, death, and burial
  • Itawamba Co., Mississippi (Liberty Cemetery) — Rhodie Holland Cleveland's and Thomas Cooley Cleveland's burial place
  • Booneville, Mississippi — home of Webster Cleveland, Jr. (self-addressed once, in error, as "Mo." instead of "Miss." — see Page 17)
  • Independence Co. and Jackson Co., Arkansas (Oil Trough, Maple Springs, Newport, Batesville) — L. D. Bownds/Susan Cleveland Bownds's home; Susan's teaching career 1878–1880; their 1880 marriage; Thomas Bownds estate lands; James Logan Morgan's home and research base
  • Utopia, Texas — Bownds family cluster; S.A.T. Cleveland (Susan) Bownds buried there; D.A.R. chapter activity; several family photographs taken there
  • Austin, Texas — Ruth Kershner's home address (1414 Red Bud Trail, then 4100 Jackson Ave #223); Emma Wentworth's home; Jack Bownds's base
  • San Diego, California (2443 Erie St.) — home of Sue Reid (Mrs. Barney M. Reid); cabin/property at "Crest," CA
  • Vandalia, Illinois (716 West Jackson) — home of Alenia B. McCord, researcher for Mrs. Elizabeth Miller Greer's D.A.R. application
  • Tuscaloosa, Alabama (311 Caplewood Terrace) — home of Mrs. B. W. (Pauline Jones) Gandrud
  • Salem, Illinois — death place of Elizabeth (Cleveland) Clark Boland, 1897
  • Houston, Texas — Farren & Long Co. Commercial Record Centers (storage location for L. D. Bownds papers, managed by "Tom"); also home of Mrs. Sallie Harrison, Meeks researcher

Dates / Events

Date Event Pages
2 May 1809 Joseph Cleveland m. Patsy (Martha) Meeks, Franklin Co., GA 3, 27, 31, 34
1 Sept. 1813 – 10 Mar. 1814 Joseph Cleveland's Creek War militia service, Capt. Sandridge's Co., Col. Walton Harris's GA Regt. 33
1791 Death of Jacob Cleveland, Elbert Co., GA; will proved 1, 30, 43
ca. 1818–1824 Birth of Thomas Anderson Cleveland (1818) and Elizabeth Cleveland (1824, per McCord's account) 32, 37
25 Dec. 1838 Castleton L. Cleveland m. Rebecca Wallis, Tuscaloosa Co. 27, 39
10 Dec. 1838 Thomas A. Cleveland m. Eboline/Evaline Sullinger, Tuscaloosa Co. 27
26 Oct. 1840 John Cleveland m. Emily Pugh 27, 40
1 Jan. 1820 – 1 July 1859 Daniel Madison Clark's life (b. S.C., d. killed on AL militia maneuvers) 37
1850s (late, undated) Joseph Cleveland sells "Dogwood Flats," disappears en route to Montgomery; presumed murdered 26, 36, 39
1863 Daniel M. Clark's family flees Tuscaloosa for Illinois (anti-slavery refugees); separately, "Amanda" recalls fleeing Tuscaloosa and losing everything 37, 39
6 Oct. 1873 Death of Thomas Anderson Cleveland, Franklin Co., AL 28, 32
1874 Various family-location notes recorded (Castleton back in Tuscaloosa; Jackson's orphans with Sullinger grandparents; Thomas A. in Pleasanton, MS) 27, 38–40
1878–1880 S.A.T. (Susan) Cleveland's Arkansas teaching licenses and contracts, Independence Co. 50, 53
26/30 Nov. – 2 Dec. 1880 L. D. Bownds m. Susan A. T. Cleveland, Jackson Co., AR (banns 26 Nov., ceremony 30 Nov., recorded 2 Dec.) 49, 53
1902 "Mother" (Sue/San Diego correspondent's mother) apparently in Newport, AR — newspaper item found by J. L. Morgan 8, 10
1904(?) St. Louis World's Fair trip (family tradition) 10
28 Feb. 1906 Marriage of "Mother" (age 24) 10, 11
1920–1921 Family group photographs taken 53
Sept. 1968 – Feb. 1969 Core run of Alenia McCord / Webster Cleveland Jr. / Gandrud correspondence on the Cleveland–Clark D.A.R. research 28–37, 43, 45
1971 Ruth Kershner's intensive Cleveland/Bownds research correspondence (Gandrud, Morgan, Sue/San Diego) while traveling (Alabama, South Carolina, Georgia) 23, 26, 45, 47–53
1972–1973 Correspondence with Webster Cleveland, Jr. (slides, Cleveland family data); Ruth's mail forwarded Austin → Dover, DE (fall 1973) 17–20
1974–1975 Sue Reid (San Diego) correspondence: Mormon/Salt Lake City research trip by Ruth; Barney Reid family news 10–16
13–21 July 1992 Final, latest-dated correspondence in file: Ruth's Cleveland D.A.R.-claim letter and related envelope 1–2
20 July 1992 Ruth's letter to "Gail" re Cleveland/Bownds notebook and Georgia Land Lottery research 3

Research Leads / Open Questions

  1. "Betty Sue" identity and surname. Page 1 is addressed "Dear Betty Sue" and appears (by handwriting, content, and the "Ruth Bownds Kershner" bookplate on the same sheet) to be written by Ruth, but carries no visible signature. Page 21's gift-list spells the name "Betty Sue Bo[u]ltinghouse[?]," while Page 50 refers to "Betty Sue Bownds." Is this the same person under a married name (Bo[u]ltinghouse) in one record and maiden name (Bownds) in another, or are these two different "Betty Sue"s? Flagged, not resolved.

  2. Date vs. postmark discrepancy, Pages 1–2. The Page 1 letter is dated "July 21 1992," but the envelope on Page 2 (which appears, by its Farren & Long Co. letterhead matching the letter's content, to belong with it) is postmarked July 13, 1992 — nine days before the letter's dateline. Either the envelope does not actually belong with this letter, or one of the two dates was misread/miswritten. Flagged, not resolved.

  3. Two "Elizabeth Cleveland" profiles in tension. Page 25 (photo caption) gives an "Elizabeth Cleveland, Newport Ark. (Jackson Co.), b ca 1829 d 1910, dau of T.J. Butcher, Tuscaloosa Ala." Pages 37/38 and 47 describe a different "Elizabeth (Butcher) Cleveland" as Joseph Cleveland's wife (not daughter), and a separate "Elizabeth Cleveland" (b. 28 Oct. 1824, Tuscaloosa Co., d. 5 Apr. 1897, Salem, IL) as Joseph & Martha's daughter, who married Daniel M. Clark then Taplan Boland. The photographed woman's "Newport Ark." association and 1829–1910 dates do not match either of these two Tuscaloosa-based women cleanly. This may be three distinct women named Elizabeth Cleveland conflated across the file — flagged for untangling, not resolved here.

  4. Wyatt Cleveland's birth year: "25 Feb. 1764" (Page 1) vs. "b. ca. 1766" (Page 43, from the same researcher's later letter). Flagged, not resolved.

  5. Wyatt Cleveland's Revolutionary War service claim. Page 1 (1992) asserts a documented Revolututionary record justifying a D.A.R. claim and cites a Georgia D.A.R. roster page reference. But the 1968–1969 correspondence (Pages 30, 43) reports that the Virginia State Library found no record of a Jacob Cleveland of Culpeper Co., VA with Revolutionary service, and that no D.A.R. application had ever been filed for Wyatt Cleveland. The 1992 letter treats the case as newly "convincing," suggesting either new evidence surfaced over the intervening 20+ years or the two research threads (Wyatt's claim vs. Jacob's) are being conflated. Flagged for follow-up — what changed between 1969 and 1992?

  6. Joseph Cleveland's "Colonel" / "Seminole War" record vs. his documented "Lieutenant" / Creek War record. Page 26 (1971) quotes a Centennial History of Arkansas passage describing "Joseph Cleveland, a native of Georgia, who served with the rank of Colonel in the Seminole War." But Pages 27 and 33 document an actual bounty-land / militia record for a Joseph Cleveland as a private, then shown receiving a warrant, serving as a Lieutenant, 208th District Co. militia (1812–14) and in the Creek War (1813–14) — different conflict, different rank. Page 26 itself flags this source as "a little confused about Georgia and Ala." Flagged, not resolved — these may be two different Josephs, or a garbled family tradition.

  7. Martha/Patsy Meeks's parentage: Littleton Meeks vs. Nacy Meeks. Multiple letters (Pages 26, 31, 34, 40) explicitly debate and never resolve whether Martha ("Patsy") Meeks, wife of Joseph Cleveland, was the daughter of Rev. Littleton Meeks or of his brother Nacy/Nace Meeks. Explicitly flagged as unresolved by the correspondents themselves.

  8. Eliz. (Cleveland) Clark's parentage unproven. The McCord/Gandrud correspondence (Pages 37, 42) repeatedly states that Elizabeth Cleveland's descent from Joseph Cleveland & Martha Meeks is family tradition only, with no documentary proof found (no marriage record, no will, no deed naming her as his daughter) as of Feb. 1969. Status at the end of this file: unresolved; whether the D.A.R. application succeeded is not recorded here.

  9. "Marquish L. Bownds" vs. "L. D. Bownds." Page 50 names "Marquish L. Bownds" as grandfather of Emma (Harper) Wentworth, while elsewhere "L. D. Bownds" is the figure who married Susan Cleveland in 1880 and kept a journal. Is "Marquish L." the same person as "L. D." under a fuller/different name, or a different Bownds relative? Flagged, not resolved.

  10. Out-of-sequence leaves in two separate letters. (a) Pages 15–16 are undated fragments of what appears to be a single letter from Sue, but Page 16's content (describing events that read as earlier) logically precedes Page 15's content (which closes "Our best to you... in 1975"); they are not adjacent in the PDF and no page connecting them was captured. (b) The four leaves of the March 25, 1971 Sue letter (Pages 50–53) are scanned in an order (50, 51, 52, 53) that does not match the sentences' internal continuity; the likely original order is 50 → 53 → 51 → 52 (see note on Page 50). Both noted in the transcript; original physical page order was not altered.

  11. Webster Cleveland, Jr.'s return address: "Booneville, Mo. 38829." ZIP 38829 is a Mississippi ZIP code (Booneville, MS), and the letters' content concerns Franklin Co., AL / Itawamba Co., MS families — but the writer himself twice wrote "Mo." instead of "Miss." (Pages 17, 19, 28, 29, 31, 33). Treated here as the writer's own slip, reproduced as written, not silently corrected.

  12. Thomas Bownds's wives: Sarah Allen vs. "Elizabeth." Page 47 states Thomas Bownds's "first wife" was Sarah Allen (sister of Dr. Sterling Allen) but also states he deeded land "to his wife Elizabeth" two weeks before his death. Whether Elizabeth was a second wife, or Sarah Allen's full name was Sarah Elizabeth Allen, is not clarified in this file. Flagged, not resolved.

  13. Possible research follow-ups explicitly proposed within the letters themselves (left open in this file): Georgia Land Lottery records for the Cleveland/Jeremiah line (Page 3); indexed Civil War participant records at Batesville, AR for Dr. Thomas J. Bownds, Thaddeus Bownds, and Mathew Price (Page 47); Clevelands at the Battle of Shiloh, to cross-check against the Alabama Clevelands (Page 47); Greene Co., AL marriage and census records for Daniel M. Clark/Elizabeth Cleveland (Pages 40, 42); contacting Dorothy Newby Cleveland of Long Island City, NY (Page 48); and identifying who deeded land next after Thomas A. Cleveland's 1857 Tuscaloosa deed (Sec. 18, Twp. 19, Range 7 West, Deed Book 4 p.372), to bracket Joseph Cleveland's death date (Page 45).

Full transcript

Typed from the scans, handwriting included. Unclear words are marked [?]. The original scans are kept in the family archive.

K-087 — Full Transcript

Source: Letters_ClevelandCorresAlaGa_1968-1992.pdf (Box 01, invoice 5) Pages: 53 (all transcribed below, in PDF page order) Note on physical format: The collection is a mix of typed and handwritten letters, envelopes, research notes, and one excerpt from a published genealogy ("Old Families of the Valley" / "Happy Valley"). Several letters run several PDF pages; page breaks in the original letter are noted. Uncertain readings are marked [word?]; truly unreadable text is marked [illegible].


Page 1 — July 21, 1992; "Dear Betty Sue" (unsigned on this leaf)

Recto:

July 21 1992

Dear Betty Sue:

Recently I had a call from a man in Houston who is researching Andrew Jackson Cleveland, born 1825 in Alabama, a brother of Joseph C. Cleveland b. 1827 — S.A.T.'s father.

In the course of getting records together for him, I found enough documentation that I think we could make a convincing claim for a Cleveland D.A.R. claim.

I have photocopies and references. The final proof necessary is of Joseph C's father Wyatt Cleveland's Revolutionary record. He was born 25 Feb. 1764 in Culpeper Co. VA and married Temperance Freeman in Elbert Co. GA.

The Georgia Society D.A.R. published a "Roster of Revolutionary Soldiers in Georgia" (Genealogical [Society?] Publishing Co, 1968) (reprint - original 1941). I have Xerox copies.

Page 242 "Rev. Soldiers found in Records, Dept. of Archives (not published)": "Wiatt Cleveland." Also his father, Jacob:

Page 4 "Graves of Revolutionary Soldiers in Georgia located by the Society": Jacob Cleveland, Elbert Co.

We saw, in Elbert Co. GA, the grave of Wiatt's brother, b. 13 Aug 1776 d. 1815, who was named in the 1790 will of their father Jacob in Elbert Co.

I would like to get this together for you, and get you to send it in. I know the D.A.R. is very picky about their applications, which I don't know how to do. I did write to them, and no records had been filed for Wyatt Cleveland. It's such an unusual name that it should be convincing.

(Over)

Verso (same sheet, right side of scan): Printed/engraved bookplate reading "Ruth Bownds Kershner" (shown upside-down relative to the handwritten text, i.e. the letter was written on the back of a used bookplate sheet), followed by:

As I find time, I am sorting through my massive collection of records, and considering where I can find homes for them. We thought of a safety deposit box in a bank, you may remember, but it seemed impractical. The L.D. Bownds papers are in Houston where Tom is managing Farren & Long's Records Service Center. They are safe there, but not really available for researchers.

The Bownds collection would go into one 4-drawer legal-size file cabinet. In Historical Societies/Libraries, this kind of material is called "Vertical Files."

[No signature appears on this leaf; handwriting and content (ownership of "the L.D. Bownds papers," "my massive collection," and the "Ruth Bownds Kershner" bookplate on the same sheet) strongly indicate the author is Ruth Bownds Kershner. See genealogical index for discussion.]


Page 2 — Envelope, postmarked July 13, 1992

Printed return corner: "Farren & Long Co., Commercial Record Centers, 5603 South Rice Avenue, Houston, TX 77081-2189."

Postmark: HOUSTON TX, PM, 13 JUL[?] 1992.

Addressed to: MRS STUART G KERSHNER, 4100 JACKSON AVE #223, AUSTIN TX 78731.

[This envelope is addressed to Ruth B. Kershner (Mrs. Stuart G. Kershner) and bears the Farren & Long Co. business name mentioned in the Page 1 letter ("Tom is managing Farren & Long's Records Service Center"). The postmark date (July 13) precedes the dateline on the Page 1 letter (July 21); see genealogical index for this discrepancy.]


Page 3 — July 20, 1992; Ruth B. Kershner to "Gail"

Printed/typed letterhead: "Ruth B. Kershner, 4100 Jackson #223, Austin TX 78731, Phone (512) 459-4890"

Handwritten note at top, apparently added later: "(See Cleveland notebook (Lavender Cover) w/Johnson etc. in box)"

JUL 20 1992

Dear Gail —

[Letter discusses sending copies from the Cleveland notebook; mentions Bownds cousins living in Utopia, TX, active in a local D.A.R. chapter; documentation on Joseph Bownds; notes that S.A.T. Cleveland Bownds is buried in the Utopia cemetery; observes that the published Cleveland genealogy does not mention Albemarle Co., VA records (Albemarle being adjacent to Orange Co., near Charlottesville; by 1774 many other counties had been created from it); cites Albemarle deeds giving Jeremiah's wife as Mary in 1788, and that Reubin died in 1792; suggests trying Georgia Land Lottery records next.]

Signed: RBK


Page 4 — Printed excerpt, "Old Families of the Valley," p. 7 (Cleveland biographical sketch, part 1)

Handwritten note at top: "Contributed by Rudelle Mills[?] Davis — Johnson researcher"

OLD FAMILIES OF THE VALLEY — 7

  1. BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCHES

CLEVELAND

Benjamin Cleveland came from Orange County, Virginia, with his wife, Mary Graves, and her father and his family, about 1769, and settled near the foot of the Blue Ridge, on the waters of Roaring River, a northern tributary of the Yadkin, in what was then Rowan, afterwards Surry, and a few years later, Wilkes County. Here Cleveland, with the aid of Mr Graves' servants, opened a farm, raised stock, and devoted much of his time to hunting. At some subsequent period, he, according to Draper's "King's Mountain and its Heroes" located on the noted tract, on the northern bank of the Yadkin, known as the Round About—taking its name from the horse-shoe shape of the land, nearly surrounded by the river.

From Daniel Boone, who was among the earliest of the pioneers of the Yadkin Valley, Cleveland learned of the Kentucky country, its wild charms, rich lands, and teeming game. In the summer of about 1772, in company with Jesse Bond, Jesse Walton, Edward Rice, and William Hightower, he set out on a trip of hunting and exploration, in quest of this beautiful land of Kentucky. But upon reaching Cumberland Gap they were unexpectedly met and plundered by a party of Cherokees, of all their guns and horses, and ordered to leave the Indian hunting grounds. They had no alternative but to return to their settlements. After undergoing great hardships they arrived back home in a nearly famished condition. Several months afterwards, in a thrilling adventure with a chosen party of friends, Cleveland recovered his horses from the noted Cherokee chief, Big Bear.

But Cleveland's hunting days were about to end. The story of Colonial taxation by the King and Parliament reached the Yadkin Valley, and Cleveland was among the first to resent the threatened tyranny. During 1775, when his neighbors and friends of the Upper Yadkin Valley had occasion to go to Cross Creek (now the city of Fayetteville) to dispose of their surplus productions, and purchase their supplies of iron, sugar, salt, and other necessaries, they were compelled, before they were permitted to buy or sell, to take the oath of allegiance to the King. When Cleveland heard of these tyrannical acts, and attempts to forestall the politics of the people, he swore roundly that he would like nothing better than to dislodge those scoundrels at Cross Creek; whereupon he marched down from the mountains with a party of volunteer riflemen and captured a number of outlaws.

When the Cherokees were inveigled by the British into hostilities, Captain Cleveland, in the summer of 1776, served a tour of duty in scouting on the western frontier of the State. In the fall of 1776, when General Rutherford led a strong force against the Cherokees, Cleveland and his company went on the campaign, in the Surry regiment, under Col Joseph Williams and Maj Joseph Winston. Wm Lenoir, who was Cleveland's lieutenant, was accustomed, in after years, to recount the hardships and privations the troops had to suffer on that service—often destitute of provisions, without tents, with but few blankets, dressed in clothing made of crude materials, derived from hemp, tow, and the wild nettle. Though often harassed on their march by parties in ambush, there was no general engagement—Capt Cleveland sharing in the skirmishes and bushwhackings of the campaign. The villages and settlements of the hostile Cherokees were laid waste, their crops and provisions destroyed, and they were compelled to sue for peace.

In the autumn of 1777, Capt Cleveland attended the legislature—not as a member, but to use his influence for the division of Surry, and the formation of a new county, for the better convenience of the Upper Yadkin settlements. Wilkes County, thus formed, was named in honor of John Wilkes, noted for his steady opposition in Parliament to the American [continues on p. 8]


Page 5 — Printed excerpt, "Happy Valley," p. 8 (Cleveland biographical sketch, part 2)

Marginal handwritten note (running up the left margin): "See additions and corrections in front of book"

HAPPY VALLEY — 8

war. In March, 1778, when the new county was organized, Cleveland was placed at the head of the commission of Justices, and was made Colonel of the militia. In 1778, he was chosen to represent Wilkes County in the House of Commons, and was regarded as one of the popular leaders of the mountain section of the State.

On many occasions he was engaged in suppressing the Tories, capturing and hanging some of their notorious leaders and outlaws. Then followed his King's Mountain campaign—the great service of his life. His whole career during the war goes to show that he was severe in his treatment of the Tories—perhaps not unjustly so, considering the times and circumstances of an exposed frontier, when the execution of civil law was so infrequent and uncertain. It was during these times that Cleveland ordered three Tory outlaws to be hung from an oak tree that still stands near the court house at Wilkesboro. All admitted that although the execution was summary, it was nevertheless just. Cleveland was active at this period in sending out strong scouting parties to scour the mountain regions, and if possible, utterly break up the Tory bands still infesting the frontiers. His Wilkes riflemen had, by this time, acquired a reputation of which they were justly proud. They were generally known as Cleveland's Heroes, sometimes as Cleveland's Bull Dogs; while the Tories called them Cleveland's Devils.

One of these detachments caught Zachariah Wells, a Tory desperado, and brought him to Hughes' Bottom, about a mile below Col Cleveland's Round About residence, near the mouth of Hughes' Creek. Here (Draper's "King's Mountain and its Heroes," page 445), young James Gwyn (Table 21), a youth of thirteen, with a colored boy, was at work in the corn field, when Col Cleveland, who had joined those having the prisoner in charge, of whom Lieut Elisha Reynolds, Cleveland's two sons and his brother, formed a part, took the plow lines from the horse, with which to hang Wells to a tree on the river bank.

Young Gwyn, who knew little of the stern realities of war, was shocked at the thought of so summary an execution. Intimately acquainted with Col Cleveland, he begged the Colonel not to hang the poor fellow, who looked so pitiful, and was suffering from his former wound, greatly exciting his sympathies. "Jimmie, my son," said Cleveland tenderly, "he is a bad man; we must hang [a]ll such dan[ger and] misery"; while Capt Bob Cle[v]eland, who was present, was cursing the [adva]ncing Tory at a vigorous rate. With tears coursing down his cheeks, the Colonel adjusted the rope, regretting the necessity for hanging the trembling culprit—remembering vividly the rough treatment he had so recently received at the hands of Wells at the Old Fields place (on New River); and firmly convinced that the lives of the patriots of the Yadkin Valley would be safer, and their slumbers all the more peaceful, when their suffering country was rid of all such vile desperadoes. Such was Cleveland's philosophy, and such was his patriotism. Wells soon dangled from a convenient tree, and his body was buried in the same sand and loam on the bank of the Yadkin.

Col Cleveland on seeing a very weedy corn patch, said to a man standing near, named Bishop, "Are you a tory or a patriot?" He replied, "Sir, I am just a plain farmer." "Well, that being the case," said Cleveland, "the next time I find so many weeds in this corn, you will be given 39 lashes!" From that time on, this was the cleanest and best cultivated corn field to be seen anywhere!

At the close of the war, Cleveland having lost his fine Round About plantation by a better title, now turned his attention to the fine region of the Tugaloo, on the western borders of South Carolina—a country that had greatly attracted him, when, many years before, he returned from the Cherokee Nation with the horses [continues on p. 9]


Page 6 — Printed excerpt, "Old Families of the Valley," p. 9 (Cleveland conclusion; Allen; Reynolds sketches)

Marginal handwritten note (right margin): "See additions and corrections in front of book"

OLD FAMILIES OF THE VALLEY — 9

he had reclaimed from their plundering warriers. In 1785, he moved to his new home in the forks of Tugaloo River and Chauga Creek, in the present County of Oconee, accompanied by not a few of his kinsmen and old companions in arms. Col Cleveland served many years as a Judge of the Court of old Pendleton County, with General Pickens and Col Robert Anderson as his associates; Col Cleveland "frequently taking a snooze on the bench," says Gover[nor] Perry, "while the lawyers were makin' long, prosy speeches"; if he snored too loudly, his judicial associates would give him a nudge, and wake him up. He nevertheless administered justice promptly and fairly. For several years before his death, he became so unwieldy in size that he could not mount his favorite saddle horse, and leave his home.

He was survived by two sons and a daughter, whose descendants are numerous and respectable—many of them becoming prominent. His wife preceded him to the grave some half dozen years. In the prime of life, Col Cleveland was a little short of six feet, finely proportioned, possessing a pleasing and intelligent countenance.

North Carolina deservedly commemorated the services of this noble hero of King's Mountain by naming a County and town after him. With a limited education but a naturally vigorous intellect, he exerted a commanding influence among a frontier people; and though despotic in his nature, and severe on the Tories, his patriotic activity did much in preserving the western portion of the Carolinas from British and Tory ascendancy. Much has deservedly been written to preserve the memory of Ben Cleveland—to all Tories the terror of terrors, and to others, the jolly "Old Round About" of the Yadkin.

Prominent mention should be made of Benjamin Cleveland's brothers: (1) Capt Robert Cleveland (1744-1812) of King's Mt fame; (2) Lt Larkin Cleveland (King's Mt) who moved to Tenn; (3) Rev John Cleveland, pastor of Brier Creek church.

ALLEN

Richard Allen (1741-1832) was born in Maryland. He came to Wilkes Co., in 1770; served on the Cross Creek expedition in 1776; early in 1780, he commanded a company for the relief of Charleston; then went in pursuit of Bryan's Tories; and led his company on the King's Mountain campaign. He served a tour of duty early in 1781 under Genl Greene. He was the first Sheriff of Wilkes County, and a member of the House of Commons in 1793. He attained to the rank of Colonel in the militia.

Richard Allen Jr was, like his father, connected with the early and heroic history of Wilkes Co. He was also elected sheriff and rated one of the leading and influential citizens. He m. 1st Sarah Hampton; 2nd Margaret (Peggy) Hampton; both were daughters of Henry Hampton of Hamptonville. Child of the 1st marriage: Sarah (Allen) Asbury. Children of the 2nd marriage: (I) Lodemia Allen m. Prof John Stacy, children; (1) Charles, (2) Edgar, (3) Cora; (II) Addie Allen (Miss Add)—a striking personality—who lived and died (1919, age 90) at the old home about three miles north of Ronda, the last of the name in Wilkes. There were two sons by the 1st or 2nd marriage, one of whom was Thos H. Allen, Memphis, Tenn, owner of large cotton plantation on the Mississippi.

REYNOLDS

Elisha Reynolds (1755-1836) was born in what became Wilkes County. He served on Rutherford's campaign against the Tories; with Cleveland at King's Mountain; and shortly after Col Cleveland's capture by the Tories early in 1781, he went with Capt Johnson and others, and broke up the Tory gang who captured him. He was a lieutenant in the latter part of the war, and rendered his country good service.


Page 7 — September 26, 1973; James Logan Morgan to Ruth Kershner (typed)

Typed heading: "KERSHNER, Ruth B. / 1414 Red Bud Trail / Austin TX 78746" with date "9/26/73"

It was nice to hear from you. Right after I mailed you service records of Joseph Cleveland and Thomas Bounds, I got back a letter I had mailed 7/7. It had [strikethrough: "has"] been forwarded to Sault St. Marie, Mich., and they sent it back 9/11.

We can send the ARKANSAS GENEALOGICAL REGISTER by first class mail for $1.00 per year above the subscription cost.

Signed: James Logan Morgan, 314 Vine, Newport AR 72112


Page 8 — January 5, 1975; "Dear Ruth" (page 1 of 2)

Marginal note at top left: "Haswell journal filed addition typed[?]"

Jan. 5, 1975

Dear Ruth,

[Letter thanks Ruth for material sent; recounts that J.L. Morgan found an item in the 1902 Newport Weekly Independent about "my mother"; mentions Baylor Univ. pictures; sister "E." (Elizabeth) says mother went to normal school in Little Rock; mother born Jan 7, 1882, married "Dad" Feb. 28, 1906; mother taught school a few terms in the Utopia area. Continues with family recollections of Aunt Pearl's family; Jack Rainey called to say his mother had died; mentions hearing from a woman named "Willie" or "Wills"...] [continues on Page 9]


Page 9 — continuation (page 2 of the January 5, 1975 letter)

Willie! I had seen her in 1923 on our visit to Texas but never thought of her as an aunt — or even as a part of the family but I guess she and Aunt Pearl had visited & kept in touch. I always sent Aunt Pearl a card & letter at Christmas and sometimes she would write a note on her card so I've kept up with the boys a little. But we got the strangest letter from Jack later on — rambling on as if he were dreaming. I've never heard from James, but during the Korean war Tom & I corresponded and kept in touch until he moved to Long Beach. When I started urging him to visit us, he stopped writing. Said he didn't have much free time and kept pretty busy.

We know Bob & Polly — They and the Logans got to be good friends when Bob was stationed out here. The Logans often visit them on their yearly trips to Alabama — have seen them twice in Utopia. When Bob entered the Navy, I was staying with Gene and Keifer in Yuma & teaching in the high school. He came over on leave, in uniform of course, and we went to the show one night. As usual, there were lots of the high school kids there and they made much ado about my being with a sailor. And Bob, with the Bownds' sense of humor, thoroughly enjoyed the situation.

I haven't seen Bob & Polly for 22-23 years but will surely write to him about his Dad's journal. I [continues; remainder of this letter was not captured as a separate leaf in this document]


Page 10 — October 21, 1974; "Dear Ruth," San Diego (page 1 of 4)

2443 Erie St. San Diego, Cal. Oct. 21, 1974

Dear Ruth,

You must be having fun in Salt Lake City with all those microfilm records — I assume you are using the Mormon files? Wish I could concentrate on one hobby at a time, but seem to be continually diverted.

The news item about mother was interesting — and totally surprising since I never heard of any Butcher cousins and I had not thought of her traveling — except for a trip to the St. Louis World Fair in 1904(?) where she took many pictures. In our album were also pictures of Baylor Univ. and of your Dad so I assumed she had also attended Baylor. Elizabeth says mother went to a "normal" school in Little Rock, Ark. so that's what she was doing in Newport. Perhaps she stayed with relatives there? I think Gene has that old album and I'll check those pictures since some may be of her normal school — and 1902 would be right [continues on Page 11]


Page 11 — continuation (page 2 of the Oct. 21, 1974 letter)

as she would be 20 years old. (She was born Jan. 7, 1882 so the census was correct in listing her as 0-5). She taught two terms in the Utopia area (I don't have those papers right now) and married Feb. 28, 1906 at age of 24 so that all checks. Elizabeth said she and a friend had gone thru Little Rock about 1935 and had seen the old normal school. There could have been a school in Newport, also, but the towns are quite close. I showed her listened more carefully and asked Dad more questions about his and Mother's early lives — I know practically nothing.

Have you ever tried to talk to Emma Wentworth (she married my Uncle Clayton) who lives in Austin? She is the daughter of "Cousin Essie & Cousin Charlie Harper" of Utopia and Cousin Essie was one of the children L.D Bownds raised. If she has any of her mother's letters or papers, she might be able to fill in some gaps. We have never corresponded with Aunt Emma [continues on Page 12]


Page 12 — continuation (page 3 of the Oct. 21, 1974 letter)

but I think she definitely lives in the past and wanted to be the kind to save old things.

If you want additional copies of any papers I have, I'll send them to you — or anyone interested. Is James Logan Morgan a 'shirt tail' relative or just a contact?

You spoke of L.D. and a journal he kept — That's interesting and I'd love to see it. Keeping records and diaries seems to run in our family, but I thought it was Dad's influence.

Barney has finally finished our cabin and is hoping now to sell most of his common [land?], move all of the others to our cabin site at Crest, and maybe we can take a small trip to Arizona in November. We would surely like to see you, tho, so if you can come via San Diego, let us know about when and we'll plan to be here. We even have a "Camperland" about two miles from our house — on Mission Bay — Our yard isn't open for vehicles [continues on Page 13]


Page 13 — continuation (page 4, end; "Love, Sue")

and we can't leave mobile homes on the street, but we have room otherwise. We'll go thru the old pictures to see if you can recognize any of them — after seeing what others have shown you — and if you want copies of them.

I called a Rev. Butcher a few weeks ago and am going to contact his father (aged about 80+) when the latter returns to San Diego. The Rev. thought his folks were from Indiana or Wisconsin but really wanted me to talk to his Dad — there are other local Butchers I haven't yet contacted. It is a much more common name than Bownds or Wentworth.

Even tho your S.L.C. address was for thru Oct 15 — hope this reaches you.

Thanks again for keeping me posted.

Love, Sue


Page 14 — Envelope, postmarked October–November 1974

Return address: "Mrs. Barney M. Reid, 2443 Erie St., San Diego, Cal. 92110. In 10 days if not delivered please return to above address."

Postmarks: Salt Lake City Postal Service Center, PM, 21 OCT 1974 (two overlapping postmark circles).

Addressed to: Mrs. Stuart Kershner, Gen. Del., Salt Lake City, Utah 8401 [crossed out], Page Ariz 86040 [added in different ink].

Forwarding stamps: NOV 3 1974; NOV 1[1?] 1974.

[This envelope confirms "Sue," author of the four-page Oct. 21, 1974 letter (Pages 10–13) and of the undated fragments on Pages 15–16 and the March 25, 1971 letter (Pages 50–53), is Mrs. Barney M. Reid of San Diego. See genealogical index.]


Page 15 — undated continuation, "...Love, Sue" (fragment, apparently a different, later letter than the Oct. 21, 1974 one)

Barney was in San Francisco the first three weeks of Dec. His older brother was ill and died the 13th. Barney is executor so we're going up again the 17th of this month to see the lawyer. Since Julia lives in Palo Alto, we will be able to visit with her on the way.

Barney's mother at 92 is getting rather feeble so I'll probably be spending more time with her. She lives alone, does her own laundry, cooking, housework but does let me take her to the store for groceries and do other errands. She has such a dread of becoming dependent or mentally incapable of managing her affairs. She still keeps up with the news, reads books on all kinds of subjects, and watches travel pictures on T.V. She's very interested in nutrition and is evidently doing the right things since she never goes to a doctor and rarely takes anything stronger than Alka Seltzer. Hope I can do as well if I live that long!

I'll write a note to your mother — in her Christmas card — Barney was a little late in making them but I'm much later in sending them.

Our best to you and your family in 1975!

Love, Sue

[This page does not carry its own dateline; content (Barney's brother's death in December, plans to visit "the 17th," Christmas cards, "Our best to you... in 1975") places it in December 1974/early January 1975 — i.e., a different, later letter than the Oct. 21, 1974 four-page letter on Pages 10–13, not a continuation of it. See genealogical index.]


Page 16 — undated continuation (fragment, apparently precedes Page 15 in the same undated letter)

am surprised that Mary let him have any of the family things. L.D. was always so obviously the fair haired boy and Bob's only chance of getting ahead was to leave home. I understand that L.D. hasn't done so well with all his opportunities — he is — or was — a doctor, in Louisiana.

My cousin Irene (Harper) Boumer who lives in Hemet (about 60 mi N of San Diego) and I have decided to get together and go thru our old, old pictures. As long as I can remember, we've carefully stored an old picnic hamper of pictures — many carefully wrapped but many not identified. She has donated some old Civil War letters and pictures to a museum in San Antonio — where the Murray clan holds its annual gathering.

Tom Patton called Elizabeth Christmas Day while we were having dinner, and I had a good visit with him, too. He writes to some of us about once a year and sometimes calls just to talk. The other boys' wives have written the letters, but Tom was in the Navy here for some time so we got acquainted. All the boys seem to be in good health except Tom, who has had a heart attack & diabetes. Evidently Virginia isn't too well, either.

Someone wrote to Elizabeth that Margaret, Uncle Tommy's older girl, and her husband have returned to Utopia to live, and to start a nursery.

[No signature or dateline appears on this leaf. Content (L.D. as "the fair haired boy," a doctor in Louisiana; cousin Irene Harper Boumer; Tom Patton's Christmas-Day call) reads as an earlier portion of the same undated "Sue" letter that continues on Page 15 — i.e., the physical pages appear to be out of their original order in this archive. See genealogical index.]


Page 17 — March 20, 1972; Webster Cleveland, Jr. to "Mrs. Kershner"

Booneville, Mo. 38829 Mar. 20, 1972

Dear Mrs. Kershner,

I am returning the slides today. Thanks a lot for sending them. My mom and dad were over Sunday and I showed them. He was very interested and appreciative. I hope someday to be there and visit that part of the country.

I was glad to get the notes on your family. I did not intend for the sheet I sent to be complete but mainly a list of the children of Joseph and Martha Cleveland.

If any new Cleveland information turns up, I will let you know.

Kindest regards,

Webster Cleveland, Jr.

[Note: "Booneville, Mo. 38829" — 38829 is a Mississippi ZIP code (Booneville, MS), not Missouri; the writer elsewhere (Page 28) gives the same return address and the letter content concerns Franklin Co., Alabama / Itawamba Co., Mississippi families, consistent with Booneville, Mississippi. Likely a slip of the pen by the author, reproduced here as written. See genealogical index.]


Page 18 — Greeting card (no text correspondence)

Decorative wildlife card: "Bighorn Sheep," part of an "American Wildlife Ecology Cards" series, published by Current, Inc., Colorado Springs, Colo. No handwritten message visible on the photographed face of the card.


Page 19 — September 1, 1972; Webster Cleveland, Jr. to "Mrs. Kershner," with envelope fragment

Booneville, Mo. 38829 Sept. 1, 1972

Dear Mrs. Kershner,

[Letter thanks Ruth for Cleveland information sent; states he made a copy for his father (age 82), whose grandfather Thomas Anderson Cleveland was a brother of Joseph Cleveland; expresses hope to find Martha (Meeks?) Cleveland's parents.]

Signed: Webster Cleveland, Jr.

Attached/photographed with the letter, a torn envelope fragment: "W. Cleveland, Jr., [Wildwood?] Drive, Booneville, Mo 38829." Postmark: Booneville M[S], SEP 2 1972.


Page 20 — Envelope, postmarked October 1973 (forwarded)

Return address: J. L. Morgan, 314 Vine, Newport AR 72112.

Postmark: U.S. POSTAL SERVICE, AR 720, 1PM, 3 OCT 1973.

Forwarding stamp: OCT 25 1973.

Addressed to: Ruth B. Kershner [surname struck through], 1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin TX 78746 [address struck through], forwarded in different hand to: "Gen Del, Dover, Del 19901."

[This envelope confirms Ruth B. Kershner was traveling in the fall of 1973 (mail forwarded from Austin to general delivery in Dover, Delaware), consistent with other references in this collection to her moving around the country during these research years.]


Page 21 — "Cleveland Sheet — To" (gift/mailing list, dated entries 1971–1972)

Handwritten list, two columns:

Cleveland Sheet - To

Marlin + Helen — Christmas 1971 Sue Reid — " Derie[?] + Marilyn — " Jack Rainy[?] John Bownds Betty Sue Bo[u]ltinghouse[?] Joe Patton + Mildred — 16 Feb 1972 Dave Kelley

[This tracking sheet records who received copies of a "Cleveland Sheet" (genealogy chart). It independently corroborates several names found elsewhere in this document: Sue Reid, John Bownds, Betty Sue (here with a married surname, "Bo[u]ltinghouse," possibly differing from "Bownds" in other pages — see genealogical index), Jack Rainey.]


Page 22 — "Helpers checked" (research log)

Helpers checked

1960 [illegible, partly erased line] 1964 [illegible] Dec 1963 June, Dec, p 5[?] Skinner, p 71 c/maps — Write US Geo[logical] Survey Wash DC 2[0?] for index state Topo. 1964 - Mar. part of "[illegible]" [illegible] - June?; Dec[,] Pickens Co Ala Hist p 283 index no B- [illegible] Census 1965 Mar c/p 17 Skinner

[A research checklist/log, apparently tracking which years of a periodical or index ("Skinner") and which census/history volumes had been checked, with a reminder to write to the U.S. Geological Survey for state topographic index maps.]


Page 23 — April 30, 1971; Mrs. B. W. Gandrud to "Mrs. Kershner" (typed)

311 Caplewood Terrace Tuscaloosa, Ala. 35401 Apr. 30, 1971

Dear Mrs. Kershner,

Just a hurried note, as if you won't get my letter unless I mail it immediately. I won't have time to answer all your questions, but feel I should let you know something, since you are moving around.

The last line of the the letter from Webster Cleveland was: "C.L.Cleveland was in Arkansas in 1860. Thomas Anderson Cleveland's son James Edward Cleveland moved to Smith Co. Tex."

I am leaving in a few hours for Birmingham to play in a Bridge Tournament, and will be back Mon. I was in Pensacola last week end, for same. I leave Thur. May 6 to visit my son in N.Y. and will be home again May 14. Will try to answer your new questions after that, or will look for new info.

Sincerely,

[signed:] Pauline Jones Gandrud Mrs. B W Gandrud


Page 24 — Photograph (portrait, undated)

Formal studio portrait, head-and-shoulders, of an older woman in dark Victorian-style dress with lace/fringe trim at the collar, hair parted center and pulled back. No caption on the front.


Page 25 — Back of the Page 24 photograph

Printed studio stamp: "Photo By Ruth Kershner, 1414 Red Bud Trail, Austin, Texas 78746"

Handwritten caption below:

Elizabeth Cleveland Newport Ark. (Jackson Co.) b ca 1829 d 1910 dau of T. J. [Butcher?], Tuscaloosa Ala

[This identifies the Page 24 portrait as Elizabeth (Butcher) Cleveland, who other pages (e.g., Page 42, Page 49) identify as the wife of Joseph Cleveland and daughter of a Tuscaloosa-area Butcher family. The "Newport Ark. (Jackson Co.)" caption appears to record a later residence/association rather than birthplace, given her stated birth ca. 1829 as daughter of a Tuscaloosa, Alabama father.]


Page 26 — April 25, 1971; Ruth Kershner to Mrs. Gandrud (typed carbon/draft)

25 April 1971

Mrs. B. W. Gandrud 311 Caplewood Terrace Tuscaloosa Ala 35401

Dear Mrs. Gandrud:

Your big packet of materials caught up with us at Florida City and I'm delighted.

The material on the Clevelands is very interesting and I thank you for sending copies of letters. I may have studied them too hastily, but let me make some comments.

Re CLEVELAND

I'm quite sure you've found the right Clevelands. In the various public records I noticed Oliver C. Cleveland several times, about the age of Joseph, son of Col. Joseph, but didn't see him mentioned in the letters. I will chart them as soon as possible and maybe he'll show up.

There seems to be a disagreement on the father of Martha Meeks, wife of Joseph. One source says "Rev. Littleton Meeks", the other notes that Littleton and Nace or Nacy were brothers and only Martha they'd found was dau of Nacy (Goodspeed, Miss). Do you have any later information?

Mrs. McCord of Vandalia, the first source, tells an interesting story of Col. Joseph's disappearance after the sale of his plantation, "Dogwood Flats". Quoting Dr. Joseph C. Cleveland, son of Joseph, g'son Col. Joseph, in Centennial History of Arkansas, Vol II, p 263, "Dr. Cleveland..born 19 November 1852, Independence Co...his parents being Joseph and Elizabeth (Butcher) Cleveland, who were natives of Georgia and Alabama, respectively, their marriage being celebrated in Tuscaloosa. The father was a son of Joseph Cleveland, a native of Georgia, who served with the rank of Colonel in the Seminole War. In days of peace he engaged extensively in farming in Georgia, where he owned many slaves, and he also carried on merchandising there. Sustaining many losses on account of the ravages of war, he removed to Texas and there died ere the war had been brought to a termination..." He is a little confused about Georgia and Ala, it turns out.

Thinking the Col. might have joined children in Texas, I looked up the 13 Clevelands indexed in the 1850 census. Many were from Vermont etc. In Smith County, D. B. Cleaveland 28 b Ga, a lawyer, was living with Stephen Reeves 33 and Georia A M L 24 both b Ga. In Polk Co, L. C. Cleveland 30 b Ala, alone but next to John M Alexander and wife Drusilla 28 b Ala; C Tedwell and wife Eleanor 29 b Ala, with Wm McGee b Ala; and Jesse McGee 33 and Delinda 34 both b Ala. If the Col. left during the War and died before it was over, he would not appear in a census. My results were inconclusive. Working through the unindexed 1860 Texas census is something that might take a long time unless I have a place clue.

On page 3 of Webster Cleveland Jr's letter of Dec 15 1968, a note at the bottom of the page says "C L Cleveland was in Arkansas in 1860" and part of a line referring to Smith Co. Texas which didn't all come out in the copy. Could you quote the rest of the reference for me? It might help.


Page 27 — "CLEVELAND, JOSEPH 1812 TUSCALOOSA CO" (handwritten research notes)

CLEVELAND, JOSEPH 1812 TUSCALOOSA CO

Served in Ga militia as there was a card in Ga archives indexed: Cleveland, Joseph, Lt 208th Dist Co. (Franklin Co) GM Feb 22, 1812 (Dec 12, 1814) apr 5, 1813, no- [illegible]

Joseph Cleveland was married in Franklin Co Ga on 5-2-1809 to Patsy Meeks by Nacy Meeks.

He was son of Wyatt Cleveland & Temperance Freeman. 1830 census Franklin Co. Ga — Temperance Cleveland, 1 female 60-70.

1850 Census Tuscaloosa Co Ala, District 1, #293 Cleaveland, Joseph — 59, Ga, farmer, $500[?] Martha — 58, S.C.[?]

#546 [C]astleton — S/L 36 Ala Rebecca — 30, S.C. Littleton M — 10, Ala Mary J — 7 Flavius J — 3 Priscilla A — 1

#550 Cleaveland, Joseph — 23, Ala Eliz — 20 Thos — 3, Ala unknown (f) — 2/12

Tuscaloosa Co marriages: Cleveland, Castleton L — Rebecca Wallis, 25 Dec 1838 (27th) by Sam'l Hendrix, JP " Thos A — Eboline Sullinger, 10 Dec 1838 (13th) by Sam'l Hendrix, JP " John — Emily Pugh, 26 Oct 1840 (5th[?]) by A M Mills, JP

1850 Census Franklin Co Ala, District 6, #436 Cleaveland, Thos — 31, Ga | Sarah — 6, Ala Emaline — 2[8?], Tenn | Jane — 4 Wm — 10, Ala | Joseph — 2


Page 28 — April 25, 1968; "Dear Mrs. Gandrud" ($15 fee noted; Thomas Anderson Cleveland family)

Booneville, Miss. April 25, 1968 — "$15" [written at top, apparently a fee/payment note]

Dear Mrs. Gandrud,

I have enjoyed working on my wife's lines with her, and thought that perhaps you can help me, too.

My Great Grandfather was Thomas Anderson Cleveland, born July 26, 1818 and died Oct. 6, 1873, and is buried in Franklin Co, Ala in the Ebenezer Cemetery. His first wife was Emaline Sullenger and second Rhodie Holland.

I have him in 1850 Franklin Co. Ala Census: Cleaveland, Thomas 31, Georgia; Emaline [28], Tenn. Children William 9, Sarah 6, Jane 4, Joseph 2, all born in Ala.

In 1860 he is married to Rhoda and gives his birthplace as Ala. I did not find him or the Sullenger family in 1840 Franklin Co. Ala. census.

I did find Emaline Sullenger's parents in 1850 there: James Sullenger 52, b NC; Elizabeth Sullenger 51, b Ky; and children.

I have not been able to locate Thomas Anderson Cleveland prior to 1850 and I do not have any Sullenger information prior to this census record. I thought you might have either Cleveland or Sullenger information.

(Over)


Page 29 — December 15, 1968; "Dear Mrs. Gandrud" (Franklin/Fentress heading; double cousins)

Franklin [or] Fentress [heading, uncertain]

Booneville, Miss. 38829 Dec. 15, 1968

Dear Mrs. Gandrud,

We appreciated your Christmas card, and were thrilled to get some additional information on Joseph Cleveland. I would like to see this line established in the D.A.R. and hope you all [are] able to help Mrs. Greer. I think I have told you almost all I know but will write a bit in case I might add a clue. I had hoped to locate another Cleveland descendant who was interested in this line. You have certainly been a big help.

I believe that Thomas Anderson Cleveland's first wife was Evaline, because of the deeds. The only place we have found Emaline is in the 1850 census record. The clerk must have written Eboline instead of Evaline due to similar sound[,] on marriage record.

Also Joseph Sullenger Cleveland named his daughter Easter Evaline Cleveland.

My grandfather, Thomas Cooley Cleveland, had a double cousin, Dee Cleveland, who moved to Oklahoma and lived around Carney, Okla. He had a son, Andrew. Now if they were double cousins, that means Thomas A. Cleveland and Evaline Sullenger married brothers and sisters. This must be[en] Jackson Cleveland and Easter Sullinger. (Charles Anderson Cleveland named his son, Thomas Dee Cleveland after the above Dee — see genealogy enclosed on children of Thomas Anderson Cleveland.)

1850 Franklin Co. Ala — family #426: Jackson Cleaveland 25 m Ala; Easter Cleveland 25 f Ala; Aron 2 f Ala; Elizabeth 1 f Ala.

I think that #499 James Sullenger in listing the names of her children just listed them all — including Evaline and Easter who were married.


Page 30 — continuation (Thomas Anderson Cleveland's second wife, Rhodie Holland; Elbert Co., Ga.)

Thomas Anderson Cleveland's second wife was Rhodie Holland. She was born Dec 13 1836 and died Apr 5 1908 and is buried in the Liberty Cemetery, Itawamba Co., Miss, at the old Cleveland homeplace. The post office was Eastman[?], Miss.

1850 Census Franklin Co. Ala: Holland, Edward — 40, Tenn Mary Ann (?) — 32, Ala Nancy — 22, Ala Sarah — 18 Rhody — 14 [underlined] Susan — 8 Henry — 11 Thomas — 7 Easter — 4 Erwin — 3 Lewis — 9/12 Holland, James — 78, S.C.

The 1830 Franklin Co. Ga census shows Cleveland, Temperance, 1 F 60-70. This must be the widow of Wyatt (Wiatt) Cleveland. He is, I have been told on the jury list there until about 1824.

The Official History of Elbert Co. 1790-1935 by John Hames McIntosh, 1940, on page 402 shows (the father of Wyatt Cleveland) Jacob Cleveland, R.S. b. 1729; d. 1791, m. Milly White b. 1739; d. 1806; daughter of Revolutionary Colonel Jeremiah White and Miss Martin who was the daughter of Absalom Martin of Maryland.

I wrote to Virginia State Library, and they said that they did not list a Jacob Cleveland of Culpeper Co., Va. as having Revolutionary service.

Also in same publication by McIntosh, page 209: Will of Jacob Cleveland. Ex. apr 4, 1790. Rec. may 16, 1791. Wife (not named). Daughter — Elizabeth. Sons Reuben, Daniel, ...son Jeremiah. Witnesses: Reuben White, John White, &c. Wife Mill[y], Will Kidd and Jeremiah Cleveland [as executors/witnesses, order uncertain].


Page 31 — continuation (Joseph Cleveland/Patsy Meeks marriage; Meeks family; 1860 census; Jacob Cleveland/Milly White)

Joseph Cleveland and Patsy Meeks were married 1809 in Franklin Co., Ga by Nacy Meeks.

Littleton Meeks and Nace or Nacy Meeks were brothers.

Littleton Meeks married Elizabeth Ivy. I believe he was a Rev[olutionary] Soldier so the Meeks family folder in Archives in Atlanta lists 2 daughters. I believe Mrs. Harrison says they were Susan, who married Russell Holcombe Jan. 26, 1823 and Elizabeth.

The only Martha (Meeks) we have found is the one listed in Goodspeed's Memoirs of Miss. as a daughter of Nacy Meeks.

1860 Franklin Co, Ala. Census: Cleveland, T. A. — 40, Ala Rhoda — 25, Ala Martha — 18, Ala Sarah — 16, Ala Francis — 9, Ala W. L. — 7, Ala John — 8, Ala Lela — 1, Ala (Thomas Cooley Cleveland, born 1855, was not listed.)

Jacob Cleveland and Milly White married Oct. 10, 1756 [sic — likely a transcription/typo for a later year, given Milly White's birth year of 1739 given elsewhere, and Jacob's documented 1790/91 will] in Culpeper Co. Va. They are both buried in the Cleveland Family Cemetery near Ruckersville, Ga. [marginal note:] "Ruckersville is in Elbert Co near S. Car. line; Co seat Elberton."

Sincerely,

Webster Cleveland, Jr.

[Bottom of page, continuing a different research note, likely keyed to census/deed abstracts below:] 876[?] Smith Co. Texas. 328-P.46 — Josephus Cleveland 24 Ala; Rebecca 25 Ala; Josephine 3 Ark; James 2 Ark. "Thomas Anderson Cleveland's son James Edward Cleveland moved to Smith Co., Texas." "C.L. Cleveland was in Arkansas in 1860[.] [illegible] moved to Smith Co. Texas[?]"


Page 32 — "THOMAS ANDERSON CLEVELAND" (typed genealogy sheet, prepared by Webster Cleveland, Jr., Dec. 15, 1968)

THOMAS ANDERSON CLEVELAND Born: July 26, 1818. Died: October 6, 1873. Ebinezer Cemetery, Franklin Co., Alabama. South of Red Bay. He lived at least part of the time at Old Burleson, Franklin Co., Ala. and Married first Emaline Sullenger.

Issue: John D. Cleveland — Moved to Kemper, Texas. William — Killed in War between the States [marginal note: "not in order of births"] Sarah Jane Joe Sullenger Cleveland married 1. Hettie Ann Grey. 2. Nancy Jane Lewallen. 3. Willie Ann Brasel. Issue: (1.) Easter Emaline Cleveland, Mary Ann, William Thomas, Sarah Jane Frances, Arlando Sabastin, Mary Elmina, Oscar Alcanady. (2.) Nancy Jane, Willie Ann. (3.) Texas Leighton, Lou Cora, Anderson Veto, Willie Arvilla, John Thomas, Ezekiel Candler. Francis Cleveland, married Daniel Stanphill, whose first wife was her sister. Martha Cleveland married Mr. Crump, and lived near Baldwyn, Miss. Thomas Cooley Cleveland married Martha Catherine Johnson.

Thomas Anderson married secondly Rhodie Holland, b. Dec. 13, 1836. d. Apr. 5, 1908. [marginal note:] Buried Liberty Cemetery, Itawamba Co., Miss. Issue: Ben A. Cleveland married Sally Pearson. Charles (Charlie) Anderson Cleveland married Sarah Johnson, sister of Martha Catherine Johnson, and had issue: Jim, Ben, Thomas Dee, Frances, Rhodie, Lou. Daniel Cleveland married Zona Wilson. Lived at Jackson, Miss. Melvina Cleveland married Mr. Burns and lived at Columbus, Miss. James Edward Cleveland married Martha Funderburk. Lived in Texas. [Had] some other children.

THOMAS COOLEY CLEVELAND b. July 10, 1855. d. Aug. 5, 1924. Liberty Cemetery, Itawamba Co., Miss. Married Martha Catherine Johnson, b. Aug. 4, 1853. d. Mar. 17, 1929. [marginal note:] Married Nov. 7, 1874, Itawamba Co., Miss. Issue: John Anderson Cleveland married Elizabeth Martin. Arthur Thomas Cleveland married Effie Eulalia Senter. William Henry Cleveland married 1. Mabel Compton. 2. Hattie [Letitia?] Edwards. Mary Leigh Cleveland Sarah Cleveland married ___ Stockton. Annie Bell Cleveland married Fred Johnson. Easter (Esther) Jane Cleveland married Van B. Hill. Daniel Richmond Cleveland married Ida Moses. James Edward Cleveland married Fannie May Whisenant. Webster Cleveland married Mary Evie Harris.

This was taken from what my father, Webster Cleveland, born Jan. 27, 1890, told me, and the dates from the tombstones.

W. C. Cleveland, Jr. Dec. 15, 1968


Page 33 — September 21, 1968; Mrs. W. Cleveland, Jr. to Mrs. Gandrud (bounty land warrant for Joseph Cleveland)

Booneville, Miss. 38829 Sept. 21, 1968

Dear Mrs. Gandrud,

Well, I finally received a reply on the Bounty Land Warrant for JOSEPH CLEVELAND, and he DID receive one.

On this 14th day of March A. D., 1855, personally appeared....Joseph Cleveland of the County of Tuskaloosa and State of Ala........declares that he is the identical Joseph Cleveland who was a private in Captain Sandridge's Company, in Col Harris Regiment of Georgia Volunteers in the War with The Creek Indians. Was at the battles of "Camp Defiance" and "Ottersee". That he has received an 80-acre Warrant under Act Sep[t] 1850. No. 264.

That he actually served in said War for about Six Months from about 26th day of August 1813 until the 26th day of February A. D. 1814.......

Sworn to before....A. P. Walker, JP

In his certificate of Identity and Oath of Service in the Co. of Tuskaloosa dated on the fifteenth day of October 1850, Joseph Cleveland states that he was a Pvt. in the Company commanded by Capt. Garret S. Sandridge in the Georgia Regt. of Volunteers commanded by Col. Walton Harris and that he volunteered at Carnesville, Franklin County, Georgia on the first day of Sept., 1813 for the term of 6 months... and was honorably discharged at Miledgeville, Ga. on or about the 10th (?) day of March, 1814.

So this helps confirm that the Joseph Cleveland there in Tuscaloosa Co. is the same as the one from Franklin Co., Ga.

I have had two very nice letters from Mrs. W. R. Harrison in Houston, Texas. She is very interested in the Meeks Family.

So far I have not been able to locate Joseph and Martha Cleveland after 1856.

I thought you would like to have this information to add to your Cleveland file. Needless to say, we were very pleased to get it.

Sincerely,

[signed, indistinctly: "Neola C.[?]"] Mrs. W. Cleveland, Jr.


Page 34 — October 2, 1968; Mrs. Sallie Harrison (genealogist) to Mrs. Gandrud (two "Martha Meeks")

Mrs. Sallie Harrison, genealogist 4715 Canal St Houston, Texas

Oct. 2. 1968

Dear Mrs Gandrud.

"Martha Meeks" — There were two Martha Meeks in Franklin Co. marriages —

One married Joseph Cleveland 1809 one married Joseph Brantley — Brantly 1816.

Mr. Cleveland thinks the one who married Cleveland was daughter of Littleton Meeks. If so the other would be the daughter of Nacy Meeks. (Nacy is Mrs Harrison's ancestor.)

I think she could have come to Ala along with the Clevelands.

Martha Meeks m. Joseph A. Brantley Nov. 23, 1816 by [T]enon Patterson.

Patsey Meeks m. Joseph Cleveland May 2 1809. Married by Nacy Meeks.

Patsey is nick name for Martha. It is "Martha" [in] 1850 Tuscaloosa Co Ala.

Memoirs of Miss. say[s] Nacy Meeks had: Mary — Martha — Nancy & Jane. We have not [continues]


Page 35 — November 3, 1968; Mrs. (W. Cleveland, Jr.) to Clerk of Probate Court, Tuscaloosa (research request, page 1)

716 West Jackson Vandalia, Ill. 62471 Nov. 3, 1968

Clerk of Probate Court Court House Tuscaloosa, Alabama

Dear Sir:

I need some information, and I hope that you can help me. Is there anyone who checks the records in your office for a fee? I'd be glad to pay someone to look for the four things I need. If there is noone, and you are able to find any or all of these, please let me know the cost as I'll send for copies immediately.

  1. Is there a personal property deed 1848-1850 from Joseph Cleveland to Daniel Madison Clark? This should be for cattle. There also should be 5 or 6 deeds before this for slaves from Joseph Cleveland to his other children.

  2. Do you have a will or record [of] an intestate estate for a Thomas [continues on Page 36]


Page 36 — continuation (page 2 of the Nov. 3, 1968 letter to the Clerk of Probate Court; signed Alenia B. McCord)

Clark or Clarke, who died in Tuscaloosa in 1859. He was a Revolutionary soldier.

  1. Do you have a will or record of an intestate estate for Cornelius Clark, son of the above. He was alive in 1860, aged 76 years.

I want to thank you in advance for anything you can do for me.

Yours very truly, (Miss) Alenia B. McCord

Also, do you have a deed, 1859 or 1860, by which Joseph Cleveland sold his plantation "Dogwood Flats"? This would give a clue to his death date. He disappeared on his way to Montgomery to put the money in a bank, thought to have been murdered.

[This identifies "Mrs. McCord of Vandalia" (referenced in Page 26) by full name/title as "(Miss) Alenia B. McCord" of Vandalia, Illinois, a correspondent/researcher of Mrs. Gandrud's, writing on behalf of her friend Mrs. (Elizabeth) Miller Greer — see Page 37.]


Page 37 — November 20, 1968; Alenia McCord to Mrs. Gandrud (relationship to Mrs. Greer; Joseph Cleveland/Elizabeth; Daniel Madison Clark family)

716 West Jackson Vandalia, Ill. 62471 Nov. 20, 1968

Dear Mrs. Gandrud,

Your most welcome letter came yesterday. I just feel that we have found the one who will find what we have been looking for. Joseph Cleveland was not my ancestor, but the great-great grandfather of my friend Mrs. [Elizabeth] Miller Greer. She and her daughter and nieces would like to join D.A.R.

I think that I can explain the relationship and what we need. Would you be good enough to send the name and address of the other person working on Joseph Cleveland? It has to be a relative of Elizabeth's (Mrs. Greer).

Her grandmother was Amanda Ellen (Clark) McMackin, who was born in Tuscaloosa County 4 Dec. 1850. Her parents were Daniel Madison Clark, born 1 Jan. 1820 in South Carolina, died 1 July, 1859. He was a captain in the Alabama militia and was killed on maneuvers. He had been a captain in the militia for 17 years. Mother was Elizabeth Cleveland, born Tuscaloosa County, 28 Oct., 1824, died 5 April, 1897 at Salem, Illinois. She married (2) Taplan Boland of Tuscaloosa. They were anti-slavery and fled from Alabama to Illinois, 1863. Mr. Boland died soon after as did the one child by Boland.

What is known about the family is what Mrs. Greer's grandmother used to tell her grandchildren. Mrs. G's older brother, an attorney, has a wonderful memory and can remember everything he ever heard. Another cousin wrote down quite a bit. She is now dead.

Eliz. Cleveland was daughter of Joseph Cleveland & Martha Meeks. We need proof of this, for we have only what Amanda told her grandchildren. We have his bounty land record from Creek War & marriage record in Franklin County, Ga. According to his granddaughter he lived on a [continues on Page 38]


Page 38 — continuation (marked "②" in a circle, top right; Daniel M. Clark/Elizabeth Cleveland biography, continued)

died 1 July, 1859. He was a captain in the Alabama militia and was killed on maneuvers. He had been a captain in the militia for 17 years. Mother was Elizabeth Cleveland, born Tuscaloosa County, 28 Oct., 1824, died 5 April, 1897 at Salem, Illinois. She married (2) Taplan Boland of Tuscaloosa. They were anti-slavery and fled from Alabama to Illinois, 1863. Mr. Boland died soon after as did the one child by Boland.

What is known about the family is what Mrs. Greer's grandmother used to tell her grandchildren. Mrs. G's older brother, an attorney, has a wonderful memory and can remember everything he ever heard. Another cousin wrote down quite a bit. She is now dead.

Eliz. Cleveland was daughter of Joseph Cleveland & Martha Meeks. We need proof of this, for we have only what Amanda told her grandchildren. We have his bounty land record from Creek War & marriage record in Franklin County, Ga. According to his granddaughter he lived on a [continues on Page 39]

[This page repeats, nearly verbatim, the sentence that closes Page 37 ("He had been a captain...Amanda told her grandchildren...he lived on a") — i.e., the writer appears to have copied over the last lines of the previous enclosure page before continuing, or this is a second, slightly fuller draft of the same paragraph. Both are transcribed exactly as written.]


Page 39 — continuation (marked "③" in a circle, top right; Joseph Cleveland's "Dogwood Flats" plantation and disappearance; children of Joseph & Elizabeth)

plantation called Dogwood Flats. One plantation was on the Black Warrior river or "the big road between Huntsville and Tuscaloosa," but I'm not sure whose. Sometime before the Civil War Joseph Cleveland sold his plantation and started to Montgomery with his body servant to put the money in the bank. He was never heard from again. The family had a report that a man of his description (He weighed over 300 lbs.) was seen with a negro on the bank of a river. They thought the negro had killed him. (Thus — no estate)

The granddaughter said that as each child married, Joseph made a gift of a slave or slaves. Daniel M. Clark was opposed to slavery, and he was given cattle. I hope there will be a personal property deed for the cattle or something.

Children of Joseph & Elizabeth Castleton [sic — "Castleton" is itself one of the children's names, mis-filed as a heading here] + Cleveland:

Castleton [L.] Cleveland, age 36 in 1850, b. Ala. m. Rebecca Wallis 25 Dec 1838. Children (1850): Littleton M, Mary J, Flavius J, Priscilla. (Amanda said he had an Albert.) His brother said in 1874 that he moved back to Tuscaloosa.


Page 40 — continuation (marked "④" in a circle, top right; numbered list of Joseph Cleveland's children, continued; "Clark" section)

  1. George — no info

  2. Joseph, age 33 in 1850, wf. Elizabeth. His brother Thomas said that he had not heard from him since before C.W. [Civil War]

  3. Jackson — m. Sullinger. He was in army in C.W., died, left widow and five children. In 1874 the two youngest children were living in Tuscaloosa with Sullinger grandparents.

  4. Elizabeth — m. (1) Daniel M. Clark, (2) Taplan Boland

  5. Evaline — no info.

  6. John — m. Emily Pugh 26 Oct. 1840. He was in Mississippi at the end of Civil War.

  7. Thomas A. — m. (1) Eboline Sullinger, (2) Rhoda — In 1874 he lived at Hayes P.O., Miss, Pleasanton.

Clark

One grandchild of Amanda's said that Daniel M. Clark's father was named Cornelius. Mrs. Greer's brother says — probably Cornelius. There was a Cornelius Clark, cooper, aged 76, in Tuscaloosa County, 1860 — not there in 1850. No 1271[,] [n]ext door, 1272, was an Ishpam[?] Clark aged 30 farmer, b. S.C. (Eastern Dist.)


Page 41 — continuation (marked "⑤" in a circle, top right; Amanda's children; children of Daniel M. Clark & Elizabeth Cleveland)

Amanda gave her children as:

  1. Nancy
  2. George
  3. Thomas (lived near Hayes P.O.) had Jim, Joseph, Geo. & Margaret
  4. Jim
  5. Daniel Madison

One more thing might give a clue; Amanda said that in 1863 they had to flee from Tuscaloosa, lost everything. They thought they would be safe if they got to Uncle Tom's (don't know whether it was Clark or Cleveland), which was on the other side of Bear Mt. or Black Mt.

The children of Daniel M. Clark & Eliz. Cleveland were: Amanda Ellen Clark, b. 1850; Joseph Cleveland Clark, b. 1852 (d. at 8 mos.); Martha Caroline Clark, b. 1853; Daniel Madison Clark, Jr., b. 1855; Nancy Jane Clark, b. 1856; Tena[?] [Ten]a Clark, b. 1858; Permelia Eveline Elizabeth Roxanna Clark (posthumous) b. 10/25/1859, d. 12/6/1860.


Page 42 — "According to the Cleveland genealogy..." (marked "⑥" in a circle, top right; Wyatt Cleveland/Jacob Cleveland; Eliz. Clark not in 1860 census)

According to the Cleveland genealogy, Joseph Cleveland's father was Wyatt Cleveland, b. 1764(?). From another source, his mother was (can send) Temperance Freeman. Wyatt's father was Jacob Cleveland, Revolutionary soldier, d. Elbert County, Ga. 1791. His wife was Milly White.

Martha (Meeks) Cleveland's father just had to be Rev Littleton Meeks & wf. Elizabeth Ivy. So far we haven't proved it, but he's the only one who fits the bill. She (Eliz[.]/Martha, with "Eliz" struck through) was born ca 1792 in S.C.

Eliz. (Cleveland) Clark & children were not in Tuscaloosa County census, 1860. I have sent for Greene County, but have not received it. Thomas Clarke (Rev soldier) was listed as a voter in New Prospect (then Greene Co.) in 1853. However, he applied for bounty land in 1856, in Tuscaloosa. He was not in Tuscaloosa County 1850 census.

We have not found the marriage record of Daniel M. Clark and Elizabeth Cleveland — could it be in Greene Co.?

[Pages 38–42 (circled ②–⑥) form a continuous enclosure — evidently accompanying, or part of, Alenia McCord's Nov. 20, 1968 letter (Page 37) — describing the family of Daniel Madison Clark and his wife Elizabeth Cleveland, a daughter of Joseph & Martha (Meeks) Cleveland, for the D.A.R. application of Mrs. (Elizabeth) Miller Greer. See genealogical index.]


Page 43 — Land deed abstracts, Wyatt (Wiatt) Cleveland, Franklin Co., Ga., 1790–1820

Marginal note (running down the left margin, sideways): "[illegible word] Lane + [illegible] Cleveland, Nov 20 1817"

1820 Apr. 17. John Ivy to Wiatt Cleveland for $220 on Freeman's Creek, originally granted to James Freeman. 138 acres. wit. Britton J. Smith, Ann Lane, Robert Lane. [Bk. B p. 222]

1819[,] Apr 1818. Benjamin Baker to Wiatt Cleveland for $20 N. side of Grove River, Franklin Co (Lewis [Ams?], Wm. Legg, Murdock adjoining & Baker) originally granted to Fannin[gs?]. 60 acres. wit. R. J. Lane, Wm. Legg, Jo[s]. J. Scott. Bk. B. Vol. 1 p.14a

1790 Sept. 20. James Freeman of Wilkes Co. to Wiatt Cleveland, same [creek], for 50 pounds. Freeman's Creek, Franklin County, waters of Broad River. 200 acres. wit. Ezekiel Thomas, Samuel Hunter. Vol C p.120A (1785-1792)


Page 44 — continuation; signed "Alenia McCord" (close of a letter on D.A.R. documentation)

Anything you can do to help will be much appreciated. I think (hope, rather) that the D.A.R. will accept what we have, if we can get proof that Eliz. was Joseph Cleveland's daughter. We would need the last date he & wife Martha were known to be alive. However, we'd certainly like anything you can find on Clark.

Sincerely,

Alenia McCord


Page 45 — February 26, 1969; "(Mrs. W. C. Cleveland, Jr.?)" — typed — Jacob Cleveland D.A.R. strategy; deeds; Clark family background (typed, 2pp, page 1)

716 West Jackson Vandalia, Ill. 62471 Feb. 26, 1969

Mrs. B. W. Gandrud 311 Caplewood Terrace Tuscaloosa, Ala. 35401

Dear Mrs. Gandrud:

First I must apologize to you for taking so long to answer your letter and tell you what else we need. When your letter came, my mother had taken ill. With work, doing the housework and caring for her, I just could not get anything else done. I had a woman to stay with her, but she could not do anything except be with her. Mother died on Feb. 4. Now, I'm beginning to get caught up with things. We need some documents, and some advice.

Mrs. Greer's best bet to go into the D. A. R. is on Jacob Cleveland, who died in Elbert County, Ga. in 1791. We may have a little trouble. In his will Jacob Cleveland mentioned only his oldest son, who was executor and the two youngest who got some property. Apparently, he had given property to the others. However, Jacob Cleveland lived in the part of Georgia, which was being rapidly divided up into counties, and so far we haven't found the deeds. If the D. A. R. will take the Cleveland genealogy as evidence, we can get it through. If not, we'll have to look [before] some more.

Jacob Cleveland's son, Wyatt Cleveland, b. ca. 1766, married Temperance Freeman. He moved from Elbert to Franklin County, Ga. He had two children, Joseph, who married Martha Meeks and moved to Tuscaloosa County, and Annie Cleveland, who married Robert Lane. She is not mentioned in the genealogy, just that Wyatt had a daughter. However, the genealogy mentions that Wyatt had a son Joseph, who went to Miss. It was Miss. Territory when he went there.

If the D. A. R. will take this much, and I think they will, our only job is to get some proof from Tuscaloosa, and get copies of what we have here in Illinois. We have a copy of a letter, which I hope they will take. It is from the gr. gr. grandfather of the Dr. Cleveland you were helping, and it mentions all the brothers [n]o sisters — so I suspect that Elizabeth was the only one. Much of what we know is from tradition. If we can find a deed from Joseph to any of his children which mentions the person as his son, or if Joseph had any real estate after his death, which was sold by a son, we may be able to prove it. [They] had Castleton, George, Joseph, Jackson, Elizabeth, Evaline(?) and John. Jackson died in the Civil War, leaving five children. John was in Miss. at the close of the Civil War, nothing more known of him. Castleton moved back to Tuscaloosa after war. Whereabouts of Joseph were unknown.

Do you have a list of the deeds you sent me? If you do I won't copy them off. A copy of any deed (photostat) which mentions any son as his child would do. From what you sent, the last mention of Joseph is in 1857 when Thomas A. deeded the land in Sec. 18, Twp. 19, randge 7 West, Deed Book 4, page 372. This might have been Joseph Jr., or it might not. Would it be possible for you to find who made deed to this land next? That would give us an approximate date for his death.

If you will do this and let me know how much, Mrs. Greer will pay you for it. I'll put on the next page what we know about the Clarks. I wish we could find some descendants in Alabama. I really think that Thomas was Daniel M. Clark's grandfather.


Page 46 — Printed flyer: "Alabama Genealogical Records Compiled by Pauline Jones Gandrud"

ALABAMA GENEALOGICAL RECORDS COMPILED BY PAULINE JONES GANDRUD

THE MARRIAGE RECORDS OF MARENGO COUNTY, ALABAMA, 1818-1860 162 pages - Mimeographed - Paper Cover Published December 1970. Price: $13.50, postpaid. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 71-127789


THE MARRIAGE RECORDS OF GREENE COUNTY, ALABAMA, 1823-1860 194 pages - Mimeographed - Paper Cover Published October 1969. Price: $15.00, postpaid. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 71-93899


THE MARRIAGE RECORDS OF BIBB COUNTY, ALABAMA, 1820-1860 149 pages - Mimeographed - Paper Cover Published March 1969. Price: $12.50, postpaid. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 77-76181


THE MARRIAGE RECORDS OF TUSCALOOSA COUNTY, ALABAMA, 1823-1860 192 pages - Mimeographed - Paper Cover Published August 1968. Price: $15.00, postpaid. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 68-6369

The grooms are arranged alphabetically in each volume, and the brides, ministers, parents, guardians and others are indexed. Each volume also contains notes of census and other data for many of the persons named in the marriage records.


CENSUS RECORD FORMS

Pages prepared for copying census records 8½ x 11 inch pages - mimeographed - 35 for $1.00, postpaid. Nine different forms for: 1790 - 1800 or 1810 - 1820 - 1830 - 1840 - 1850 - 1860 - 1870 - 1880 Be sure to specify year!


Order from: The Milestone Press Post Office Box 12502 Memphis, Tennessee 38112

Marriage Records of: Marengo County - $13.50 ___ / Greene County - $15.00 ___ / Bibb County - $12.50 ___ / Tuscaloosa County - $15.00 ___ / Census Forms for ___ ___

Name ___________________________ Street ___________________________ City ____________________ State ____________ Zip Code __________


Page 47 — April 8, 1971; Ruth Bownds Kershner to James Logan Morgan (typed; Thomas Bownds estate, Arkansas)

Aiken S C, 8 April 1971

James Logan Morgan 314 Vine Newport, Arkansas 72112

Dear James:

Your letter caught up with us in Alabama and at a time when I was looking up Clevelands. Have a reference from the Alabama Dept. of History to Mrs. B. W. Gandrud, 311 Caplewood Terrace, Tuscaloosa, Ala, who has transcribed about 15 feet of books in their library. There are many Clevelands in her Tuscaloosa records and I am writing for help in untangling them. For her, I have redone your Joseph Cleveland sheet with additional information and enclose a copy for you. I pirated your style. Imitation is the sincerest, etc.

Since you grew up in Oil Trough, I thought you might be interested in the location of some of Thomas Bownds property. Please save these carbons for me as I haven't had an opportunity to make copies yet. They are verbatim copies of deeds, all made to settle Thomas Bownds' estate. Two weeks before his death, he deeded the 40-acre lot in Section 25, T 12 N, R 5W, to his wife Elizabeth during her lifetime and to Ludovico after her death. They both moved to Texas and disposed of the property.

You offered to look up something at Batesville. Are there records (indexed, that is) of the local participants in the Civil War? I would like to know something of the fate of Dr. Thomas J. Bownds, Thaddeus Bownds, and Mathew Price, sons and son-in-law of Thomas Bownds, all said to have been killed in the war. And the names of Clevelands in the Battle of Shiloh so I can check against Clevelands in Alabama.

I have proved my suspicion that Dr. Sterling Allen was the brother of Thomas Bownds first wife, Sarah Allen, and also found that James W. St. John, who married Mary Floyd, Thomas step-daughter by Margarett Price, was also a doctor. Then there was Dr. James Porter, father of John Price Bownds wife, Parilee Willie Porter. The place was rich in doctors!

Will check with the Cleveland you sent me as soon as I can sort out these here. Many thanks!

Sincerely

Ruth Bownds Kershner 1414 Red Bud Trail Austin Texas 78746

P.S. Don't waste your time insisting that Thomas Bownds' name be spelled with a w!


Page 48 — March 18, 1971; James Logan Morgan to Ruth B. Kershner (typed; Dorothy Newby Cleveland)

March 18, 1971

Ruth B. Kershner: 1414 Red Bud Trail Austin, Texas 78746

Dear Ruth:

Have you ever been in touch with

Dorothy Newby Cleveland 47-14 11th Street Long Island City, N. Y. 11101

?

I noticed her query in FOOTPRINTS, May 1969, seeking information on CLEVELAND--Franklin Co., Ga., Tuscaloosa Co., Ala., and Miss.

I'm making regular trips to Batesville now. If there's anything I can look up for you, let me know.

Thanks for your membership in the Northeast Arkansas Genealogical Association.

Sincerely yours,

James Logan Morgan 314 Vine Newport, Arkansas 72112


Page 49 — April 8, 1971; Mrs. Stuart G. Kershner to Mrs. Gandrud (typed; Joseph & Elizabeth Butcher Cleveland; enclosing $10 check)

Aiken S. Carolina 8 April 1971

Mrs. B. W. Gandrud 311 Caplewood Terrace Tuscaloosa, Ala. [handwritten: "205-758-7331"]

Dear Mrs. Gandrud:

Could you please help me sort out Clevelands of Tuscaloosa Co. prior to the 1850's? Mrs. Cobb at the Alabama Department of History thought you might. I have thoroughly explored her indexed resources including your excellent volumes, and have copied many records, but my family records don't go that far back.

Enclosed is a sheet on Joseph and Elizabeth Butcher Cleveland, who moved from Tuscaloosa Co. to Arkansas about 1851-52. In your 1840 census there seem to be Joseph Cleavland and Joseph Cleveland, each 40-50, and land records show a Joseph with wife Patsy and one with wife Martha. On the grounds that Joseph and Elizabeth named their first daughter Martha, I suspect that Joseph was the son of the Joseph and Martha Cleveland listed in the 1850 Tuscaloosa Co. census. I notice that John M and Emily Cleveland did the same.

I am seeking information on Col. Joseph Cleveland and wife and on their other children. Where did they come from in Georgia and when? I have found many Cleveland/Cleavland marriage records but none on Joseph and Elizabeth Butcher Cleveland. I would like similar information on Elizabeth's parents. I find a likely Thomas Butcher in Washington Co. Ga. 1820 — Elizabeth said she was born in Georgia 1829 — and we have the impression they came there from South Carolina.

Although I am not trying to prove out this line formally at this time, I do want it right, and I like documentation. I am more interested in tracing migration and family history than in merely having a list of names, so I am trying to make photographs in the areas where the families lived and am mapping land holdings where records are available.

My husband and I are in South Carolina now but are thinking of spending some of next week in Georgia before returning to the Carolinas for photos. If this works out, I may phone you for Georgia suggestions, and to arrange with you for a mailing address. In any case, please don't mail to my Texas address at this time.

I enclose a check for $10. Let's see what we turn up before authorizing any really detailed search.

Sincerely,

Mrs. Stuart G. Kershner 1414 Red Bud Trail Austin Texas 78746


Page 50 — March 25, 1971; "Dear Ruth" (San Diego; "Sue"; leaf 1 of 4 — see note on reading order)

Marginal note at top, written sideways in the left margin: "PS. How did you get the copy of the tin type you sent? I've never had copies of old pictures made."

Marginal note at top center: "Ans 6 April 1970[?] from Aiken S.C." [reply date noted by recipient; see genealogical index on the apparent year discrepancy]

March 25, 1971

Dear Ruth,

When your letter came in February, I was having some inner ear complications which destroy my sense of balance. By the time I recovered, I supposed you had already started on the three months fishing trip you mentioned. So I was doubly delighted to receive your latest — but I've been so busy trying to read everything that there was no time to write! What fun!

I think the picture you sent was S.A.T. (Sue) Cleveland and we may have one like it. We have a wicker hamper full of old photos — some of whom we can't identify. When Elizabeth has time, we'll go over them. I know there are some of Grandpa (L.D.) and his dogs, and one old picture taken by a tent. I'll let you know what we find.

In the old papers I mentioned, there are three teacher's licenses for S.A.T. Cleveland 1878, 1879, 1880. Issued by Dept. of Public Instruction, State of Arkansas, for Independence Co. Then there are two hand written teaching contracts. One is dated Jan. 31, 1880 in Oil Trough, Ark. The [continues — see note below]

[This four-page letter's leaves were scanned in an order that does not match the sentences' internal continuity. Leaf 1 (this page) ends "...Oil Trough, Ark. The ___," which is completed by the opening words of Leaf 4 (Page 53, "board members are W. H. Hill..."). Page 53 in turn ends "...new entry on your tree," after which Leaf 2 (Page 51, "I've really enjoyed reading Annalee Burns'...") reads as a natural new-paragraph continuation, and Page 51 ends "With the names Thomas and John appear-", which is completed by Page 52's opening "-ing so frequently..." through the "Love, Sue" close. The likely original leaf order is therefore Page 50 → Page 53 → Page 51 → Page 52; each page is transcribed below in its actual PDF page-number order, per the one-section-per-page instruction. See genealogical index.]


Page 51 — continuation (leaf 2 of 4; Annalee Burns' book; Betty Sue Bownds; Marquish L. Bownds; San Diego Library)

I've really enjoyed reading Annalee Burns' newest book. Elizabeth has a copy of her "Gone are the Days". You know she is my cousin — but we've never corresponded (long ago). I used to write to her sister, Lucile, and also to Betty Sue Bownds but haven't had any letters for several years.

Just a little side light — "Cousin" Essie (we always called her) who married Charlie Harper had a daughter, Emma, who married Clayton Wentworth. So my Dad's cousin by marriage became his sister-in-law. They had three children Chester, Harold, and Essie Mae and lived in Austin. Uncle Clayton died years ago but Aunt Emma may still be living and might have some old papers of her grandfather, Marquish L. Bownds. Annalee probably would have her address.

The San Diego Library doesn't have the Cleveland genealogy books you mentioned. I'll check with my Mormon friend & see what she suggests. The Los Angeles Library might. They are supposed to have a very fine collection of books about Texas, too.

With the names Thomas and John appear- [continues on Page 52]


Page 52 — continuation (leaf 3 of 4; family naming patterns; Jack Bownds; S.A.T. Cleveland photo; "Love, Sue")

-ing so frequently in the family, I'm not yet able to get people in place — especially with all the marriages. Evidently it was almost necessary to marry again in those days so the family unit could function.

I read that Jack Bownds was the contractor for a new Royal Inns Motel being built in La Jolla & I'll try to contact him — Sounds like another John.

Did you notice anything unusual about the picture of S.A.T. Cleveland you sent? She seems to be kneeling on a cushion instead of sitting in a chair.

I've been curious — you said you sold your house and bought a trailer. What did you do with all your collections? We may be faced with moving some day & I can't imagine disposing of all the things we've been accumulating — we're all pack rats —

Enough for now.

Love, Sue

P.S. Give my best to your mother — I haven't written her for a long time.


Page 53 — continuation (leaf 4 of 4; teaching contracts; L.D. Bownds/Susan "Sue" Cleveland marriage license; family photos)

board members are W. H. Hill and G. W. Scoggin. The other is dated Dec. 14, 1880 at Ma[ple] Springs and signed by board members L. D. Bownds and George W. Speed and teacher Susan Bownds.

The marriage license is from Jackson Co., Arkansas — L.D. + Sue — on [circled: 2] Nov 1880 — recorded on p.172 of Book B of Marriage Records. Recorded 2 Dec. 1880, R.W. Bandy clerk & recorder, by Geo. A. [Rochard?], (D.C.) [circled:] This is a mistake since the Banns of Matrimony were issued the 26th of Nov. & the ceremony performed Nov. 30. Grace says she will run off copies of these documents since her library has good facilities.

We have very few pictures of our mother but I'll see about one for you. As a rule, the ones we have were taken in Utopia since she was in bed all the time we were in Tucson. We do have a few family groups, taken about 1920-21.

I'm getting all the low-down on our family to send to you — I sent a sheet to Gene, Howard, + Elizabeth so as to have accurate dates on their children's wedding dates. Before long you should have a new entry on your tree.

[END OF DOCUMENT — all 53 pages transcribed]