Mamacita's Archive

The Kershner saga: 2026 update

A family history written from the archive, each fact traced to its source document.

2026 Update: What 52 New Documents Added to the Kershner Story

A second, much larger batch of scanned documents — 52 files, 4,155 pages, mostly Ruth and Stuart Kershner’s own working research files from the 1970s and early 1980s — has now been processed and folded into the archive. Most of it confirms and deepens the story already told in the main narrative above, rather than overturning it. A few things are worth adding to the record.

The immigrant generation is now on firmer footing. A formal, footnoted monograph in the new batch (Doc K-055) methodically establishes Johann Görg Kirschner and his wife Anna as the documented immigrant couple, cross-checking the 1731 ship Samuel passenger list against Pennsylvania and Maryland land and church records rather than relying on family tradition alone. A companion file (K-066) preserves hand-drawn charts from the German researcher Max Steinbaur tracing the Kirschner family in Langenselbold, Hesse, back through the 1600s — the same German thread mentioned in the original narrative, now with the researcher’s actual working papers on file rather than just Ruth and Mary’s letters about him.

A promising lead to Abraham Lincoln turned out to be a different family entirely. One of the largest single files in this batch (K-027, 203 pages) documents a years-long correspondence between Ruth and a Kentucky researcher, Margaret Karsner Murphy, chasing a family tradition that Margaret’s ancestor Casper Karsner was a great-uncle of President Lincoln, through his sister’s 1782 marriage to a Thomas Lincoln. The primary sources Margaret gathered — Revolutionary War pay records, an 18th-century Virginia chancery suit, a 1797 will — confirm the Karsner family’s own dramatic history (Casper and his wife were captured at the destruction of Ruddle’s Fort, Kentucky, in 1780) but also confirm this was a different Thomas Lincoln than the President’s father. It’s a good reminder of how much of this research is ruling things out, not just confirming them — and the “Karsner” spelling itself turns out to belong to an entirely separate family from the documented “Kershner” line, a name-collision risk flagged repeatedly throughout the archive.

The family’s own record-keeping habits are now visible on paper, not just described. Files like K-042 through K-052 are Ruth and Stuart’s actual working correspondence with fellow researchers — Verna Shingleton, Hilda Cushwa, Douglas Woodard, Jeffrey Wyand, and dozens of others — trading typed abstracts, photostats, and hand-drawn plats back and forth by mail through the 1970s. It’s the paper trail behind the more polished story told in the original letters between Ruth and Mary, and it shows the same patient, decade-long cross-referencing at a finer grain: catching two different men both named Martin Kershner, sorting out which of several same-named Jacob Kershners belongs to which county, and politely declining a cousin’s assumption in one case that “the Kershners owned all the land” between two towns — a claim Ruth’s own research quietly disproved.

A few items in the collection aren’t part of the family’s history at all. A handful of files kept alongside the genealogical material are unrelated: an old newspaper history of a nearby town founder, a Time magazine clipping, a used-book-dealer’s note about selling copies of the Kershner books, and an entire Rutherford/Graham/McGuire family card file that appears to have been acquired or traded with another researcher rather than documenting an actual Kershner ancestor. These are logged in the archive for completeness but are correctly kept out of the family story itself.