Mamacita's Archive

The research journey: the wider network

A family history written from the archive, each fact traced to its source document.

Addendum: The Wider Correspondence Network

The original research-journey narrative was built from the letters between Ruth Kershner and Mary Maxwell alone. A much larger batch of documents since processed — Ruth and Stuart’s own working files — shows that the two cousins were really just the hub of a much bigger, informal network of researchers, all trading photostats and typed abstracts through the mail across the 1970s and 80s: Verna Shingleton in West Virginia, Hilda Cushwa in Hagerstown, Douglas Woodard working the LDS genealogical library in Salt Lake City, Jeffrey Wyand in Baltimore, and dozens of more distant cousins, each holding one small piece of the puzzle.

Not every lead panned out, and one of the largest files in the whole archive is really the story of a dead end, patiently and honestly run down. A Kentucky researcher named Margaret Karsner Murphy spent years corresponding with Ruth, chasing a family story that her ancestor Casper Karsner was related to Abraham Lincoln by marriage. The documents she gathered were genuinely impressive — Revolutionary War records, an 18th-century chancery suit, a will from 1797 — but they ultimately showed the Lincoln in question was a different man entirely, and that “Karsner” was a different family than “Kershner” in the first place, despite the similar name. Margaret and Ruth worked through that disappointment methodically, the same way they worked through every other question in this archive: by finding the actual record rather than settling for the appealing story.

It’s a useful reminder for anyone picking up this research today. The archive contains plenty of leads that were investigated and correctly ruled out, alongside the ones that panned out — and both kinds are worth keeping, clearly labeled, rather than quietly discarding the dead ends and remembering only the successes.